Suped

Summary

Incorporating GIFs into email campaigns can dramatically enhance engagement, making messages more dynamic and appealing. This can lead to improved open and click-through rates. However, their impact on deliverability is primarily indirect, stemming from user experience. Large GIF file sizes can cause slow loading times, frustrating recipients and leading them to abandon emails, which negatively affects engagement metrics and subsequently, sender reputation. Additionally, compatibility issues with older email clients, which often display only the first frame of a GIF, necessitate careful design to ensure the core message is always conveyed. While GIFs themselves are generally not direct triggers for spam filters, ensuring optimization for size, clear first frames, and a balanced image-to-text ratio is crucial for maintaining a positive user experience and supporting overall email program health.

Key findings

  • Enhanced Engagement: GIFs can significantly boost email engagement, increasing open rates, click-through rates, and overall visual appeal by conveying dynamic content and complex ideas efficiently.
  • Indirect Deliverability Impact: GIFs do not directly trigger spam filters or harm deliverability. However, their impact on user experience, primarily due to slow loading times from large file sizes, can indirectly affect engagement metrics and sender reputation, which are crucial for inbox placement.
  • Negative User Experience: Slow loading GIFs frustrate recipients, causing them to abandon the email, potentially leading to lower reported open and click rates. This poor experience can indirectly signal low engagement to ISPs.
  • Client Compatibility Issues: Many older email clients, notably specific versions of Outlook, do not support animated GIFs and will only display the first static frame. If the first frame is not informative, the message may be lost.
  • Potential for Metric Skew: Extremely heavy GIFs might interfere with the loading of tracking pixels, potentially leading to an inaccurate measurement of actual open and click rates.

Key considerations

  • Optimize File Size: Keep GIF file sizes small, ideally under 1MB, to ensure fast loading times across devices and network conditions. Excessive file sizes are the primary cause of negative user experiences.
  • Prioritize First Frame: Design your GIFs so that the first frame conveys the essential message. This is crucial for older email clients, like Outlook 2007-2016, which only display the initial static image.
  • Monitor Load Times: Actively monitor how long your GIFs take to load. Load times exceeding 4 seconds are generally considered excessive and can lead recipients to abandon the email, impacting engagement metrics.
  • Balance Image-to-Text Ratio: While GIFs themselves rarely trigger spam filters, an email composed primarily of images with minimal text, especially with heavy GIFs, could increase the risk of being flagged.
  • Check GIF Host URL: Verify that the host URL for your GIFs is not blacklisted, as this could prevent tracking pixels from loading, leading to inaccurate open and click rate reporting.

What email marketers say

11 marketer opinions

GIFs are powerful tools for boosting email engagement, injecting dynamic visuals and personality that can significantly improve open and click-through rates. However, their influence on deliverability is largely indirect, stemming from the recipient's overall experience. The primary concern revolves around large file sizes leading to slow load times, which can frustrate subscribers and cause them to abandon emails. This negative user experience, coupled with potential issues like tracking pixel interference from heavy files, can result in lower engagement metrics. Such reduced engagement indirectly signals to Internet Service Providers that your content is less valuable, potentially impacting sender reputation over time. Additionally, ensuring a strong, informative first frame is crucial due to varying email client support, as some will only display the static initial image. While GIFs themselves rarely trigger spam filters, an imbalanced image-to-text ratio with overly heavy GIFs could, in rare instances, contribute to filtering.

Key opinions

  • Significant Engagement Boost: GIFs can substantially enhance email engagement, making messages more dynamic and eye-catching. This often translates to higher open rates, improved click-through rates, and better communication of complex ideas.
  • Indirect Deliverability Impact: GIFs do not directly trigger spam filters or block deliverability. Their influence on deliverability is primarily indirect, tied to the user experience; a poor experience from slow-loading or broken GIFs can reduce engagement and subsequently harm sender reputation.
  • Load Time is Critical: Slow loading GIFs, particularly those taking 4 seconds or longer, significantly frustrate recipients, leading to email abandonment and potentially lower reported open and click rates. This poor experience signals low engagement to Internet Service Providers (ISPs).
  • Potential for Skewed Metrics: Very large or heavy GIFs can prevent tracking pixels from loading correctly, which may lead to an inaccurate measurement of actual open and click rates, complicating performance analysis.
  • Varying Client Compatibility: Not all email clients fully support animated GIFs; many will only display the first static frame. This necessitates careful design to ensure the initial image conveys the core message effectively.

Key considerations

  • Optimize GIF File Size: Keep GIF file sizes small, ideally under 1MB, to ensure rapid loading across various devices and internet speeds. This prevents recipient frustration and abandoned emails, which can negatively impact engagement metrics.
  • Prioritize First Frame Content: Ensure the first frame of your GIF conveys the core message or a compelling static image, as many older email clients, like certain Outlook versions, only display this initial frame without animation.
  • Monitor and Optimize Load Times: Actively test and monitor GIF load times; anything exceeding 4 seconds is considered excessive and can cause recipients to move on. Consider technical workarounds like reducing dimensions and scaling via HTML to improve speed.
  • Verify GIF Host URL: Check that the host URL for your GIFs is not blacklisted. A blacklisted host can prevent image loading and interfere with tracking pixels, leading to inaccurate open and click rate reporting.
  • Maintain Image-to-Text Balance: While not a primary concern, an email heavily reliant on images, especially large GIFs, with minimal text, could in rare cases increase the risk of being flagged by spam filters. Aim for a balanced content approach.

Marketer view

Marketer from Email Geeks suggests that heavy GIFs may prevent tracking pixels from loading, impacting perceived open and click rates, and advises checking if the GIF's host URL is blacklisted.

21 Nov 2022 - Email Geeks

Marketer view

Marketer from Email Geeks confirms experiencing drops in CTR and conversion rates when using GIFs, noting a specific GIF had a 4-second load time.

2 Jan 2022 - Email Geeks

What the experts say

4 expert opinions

When considering the use of GIFs in email, it's important to understand that they generally do not directly trigger spam filters, making them acceptable for deliverability. The main challenges arise from user experience. Large GIF file sizes can lead to significant download delays, causing recipients to abandon emails due to frustration. This negatively impacts engagement metrics and, indirectly, sender reputation. Furthermore, a crucial design consideration is the varying support among email clients; older versions of Outlook, for instance, will only display the first static frame. Therefore, the initial frame must be designed to convey the essential message. While GIFs are not inherently problematic, an email largely composed of images with minimal textual content, especially if it includes a heavy GIF, could heighten the risk of being flagged by spam filters.

Key opinions

  • GIFs Are Not Spam Triggers: Animated GIFs are generally acceptable for email deliverability and do not directly trigger spam filters.
  • File Size Impact on Engagement: Excessively large GIF file sizes cause slow email downloads, frustrating recipients and leading to email abandonment, which indirectly harms engagement and sender reputation.
  • First Frame Essential for Older Clients: Older email clients, specifically Outlook 2007, 2010, and 2013, display only the first static frame of a GIF, necessitating that this frame convey the essential message.
  • Image-Heavy Content Risk: While GIFs themselves aren't spam triggers, an email primarily composed of images with minimal text, including an animated GIF, can increase the risk of being flagged as spam.
  • User Preference and Context: Some recipients may simply dislike GIFs, and factors like device and network conditions significantly influence the perceived load time and overall user experience.

Key considerations

  • Prioritize GIF Optimization: Keep GIF file sizes small to ensure quick loading times across all devices and network conditions, which directly impacts user experience and prevents abandonment.
  • Crucial First Frame Design: Always ensure the first frame of your GIF effectively communicates the essential message, as many older email clients will only display this static image.
  • Maintain Text-to-Image Ratio: Avoid creating emails that are predominantly images with minimal text, especially if they contain GIFs, to reduce the likelihood of being flagged by spam filters.
  • Account for User Preferences and Context: Be aware that some users may dislike GIFs, and acknowledge that varying device and network conditions will impact how quickly GIFs load for recipients.

Expert view

Expert from Email Geeks advises using smaller GIFs and explains that long load times can deter recipients, leading them to abandon the email, also noting that some users may simply dislike GIFs.

18 Dec 2024 - Email Geeks

Expert view

Expert from Email Geeks asks about the specific context for GIF load times, implying that factors like device and network conditions significantly influence user experience.

3 Mar 2024 - Email Geeks

What the documentation says

5 technical articles

GIFs are highly effective for boosting email engagement, injecting dynamic visuals that can improve open and click-through rates. However, their influence on deliverability is primarily indirect, stemming from the recipient's experience. Expert documentation highlights that large GIF file sizes are a key concern, as they can cause slow loading times that frustrate subscribers and lead to email abandonment. This negative user experience, in turn, can lower engagement metrics, indirectly signaling lower content quality to Internet Service Providers and potentially impacting sender reputation. Furthermore, due to varying email client support, especially older versions that display only the first static frame, it's crucial to ensure this initial image effectively conveys the core message. Therefore, optimizing file size, prioritizing the first frame, and maintaining a positive user experience are paramount for successful GIF implementation without compromising deliverability.

Key findings

  • Enhanced Engagement: GIFs can significantly boost email engagement, increasing open rates, click-through rates, and overall visual appeal by conveying dynamic content and complex ideas efficiently.
  • Indirect Deliverability Impact: GIFs do not directly trigger spam filters or harm deliverability. However, their impact on user experience, primarily due to slow loading times from large file sizes, can indirectly affect engagement metrics and sender reputation, which are crucial for inbox placement.
  • File Size Affects Experience: Excessively large GIF file sizes lead to slow email loading, frustrating recipients and causing them to abandon emails, which negatively impacts engagement and sender reputation.
  • First Frame is Critical: Many older email clients, notably specific versions of Outlook, do not support animated GIFs and will only display the first static frame. If this first frame is not informative, the message may be lost.
  • Indirect Spam Risk: While GIFs are generally acceptable, an email that is heavily reliant on images with minimal text, especially when combined with a very large GIF, could be perceived as 'heavy' or poorly rendered, indirectly increasing the risk of spam flagging.

Key considerations

  • Optimize GIF File Size: Keep GIF file sizes small, ideally under 1MB, to ensure quick loading times across all devices and network conditions, which is crucial for a positive user experience and prevents abandonment.
  • Prioritize First Frame: Design your GIFs so the first frame conveys the essential message. This is vital for older email clients, like Outlook 2007-2016, which only display the initial static image.
  • Monitor Load Performance: Actively test and monitor how quickly your GIFs load. Slow loading times can frustrate recipients and negatively impact engagement metrics.
  • Utilize Alt Text: Provide descriptive alt text for GIFs to improve accessibility and ensure the message is conveyed even if the image fails to load.
  • Balance Image-Text Ratio: While GIFs themselves are not direct spam triggers, an email composed primarily of images, especially large GIFs, with minimal text, could increase the risk of being flagged by spam filters.

Technical article

Documentation from Mailchimp Knowledge Base explains that GIFs can enhance engagement and convey more information than static images. However, they advise keeping GIF file sizes small to avoid slow loading times, which can negatively impact user experience. They also recommend ensuring the first frame of the GIF conveys the main message, as some email clients (like Outlook 2007-2016) do not support animated GIFs and will only display the first frame. While not directly stating an impact on deliverability from the GIF itself, slow loading or broken rendering due to large files can indirectly affect engagement metrics that influence deliverability.

13 Mar 2025 - Mailchimp Knowledge Base

Technical article

Documentation from SendGrid Blog explains that while GIFs can be highly engaging and improve click-through rates by grabbing attention, they also come with drawbacks such as increased file size and potential display issues in older email clients. SendGrid advises optimizing GIF file size to prevent slow loading and ensuring the first frame is a static fallback for unsupported clients. The article implies that large file sizes or poor rendering can lead to a negative user experience, which, while not a direct deliverability block, can reduce engagement and implicitly affect overall email program health.

20 Mar 2023 - SendGrid Blog

Start improving your email deliverability today

Sign up