Dmarcian provides a comprehensive suite of DMARC-specific features designed to guide users through the implementation and enforcement process. Their platform offers detailed reporting and analysis, enabling us to quickly identify email sending sources, understand DMARC compliance rates, and pinpoint potential spoofing attempts.
Beyond core DMARC reporting, Dmarcian includes tools like automatic subdomain detection, DMARC/SPF/DKIM checkers, and Alert Central for notifications. They also offer forensic reporting (RUF) which can provide deeper insights into malicious activity, though this feature is not available on their lower-tier plans. While robust, the feature set is primarily focused on DMARC and related protocols.
ELK DMARC, being an open-source, self-hosted solution built on the ELK Stack (Elasticsearch, Logstash, Kibana), offers immense flexibility and control over your DMARC data. Its feature set is largely dependent on how we configure and leverage the underlying ELK components, allowing for deep customization of dashboards and alerts.
Out of the box, ELK DMARC focuses on ingesting and visualizing DMARC RUA reports. While it provides core DMARC analytics, advanced features like automated source identification or hosted DMARC are not built-in, requiring manual configuration or additional tools. It's a powerful framework for those who prefer to build and manage their own DMARC infrastructure.
ELK DMARC
How easy is each product to use
User experience
ELK DMARC
Dmarcian presents a polished, intuitive user interface that is generally easy to navigate. The dashboards are well-organized, with clear visualizations of DMARC data, compliance rates, and identified sending sources. Onboarding is straightforward, guiding us through the initial setup of DMARC records and report forwarding.
While the interface is user-friendly, some advanced features, particularly within forensic reporting, can take a bit of time to master. However, the platform does a good job of breaking down complex DMARC concepts into digestible information, making it accessible even for those new to email authentication.
ELK DMARC's user experience is inherently tied to Kibana, the visualization component of the ELK Stack. For users familiar with Kibana, the experience is powerful and highly customizable. We can create bespoke dashboards, queries, and visualizations tailored to our specific needs, offering unparalleled analytical depth.
However, for those without prior ELK Stack or data visualization experience, the initial setup and configuration can be challenging. It requires a significant technical understanding to deploy, maintain, and effectively utilize. It's less of an out-of-the-box solution and more of a toolkit for experts, which means a steeper learning curve but greater ultimate flexibility.
ELK DMARC
Which product has the best support
Support
ELK DMARC
Dmarcian offers structured support channels typical of a commercial SaaS product. This includes access to documentation, a knowledge base, and direct support from their team, often via email or a ticketing system. For paid plans, we generally find the response times and quality of assistance to be reliable.
Their support team is knowledgeable about DMARC and can assist with complex configuration issues or data interpretation. However, the level of support often scales with the pricing tier, with enterprise customers likely receiving more dedicated assistance. They also have a community forum and educational resources that are quite helpful.
As an open-source project, ELK DMARC's support model is community-driven. Assistance primarily comes from GitHub issues, forums, and the wider ELK Stack community. This means we're reliant on the availability and expertise of other users and maintainers for troubleshooting and guidance.
While community support can be robust, it lacks the guaranteed response times and personalized service of a commercial offering. Organizations deploying ELK DMARC should have internal expertise in the ELK Stack and Docker, or be prepared to self-solve issues, as there's no official, dedicated support team to lean on.
ELK DMARC
Who should use each product
Suitability
ELK DMARC
Dmarcian is an excellent choice for businesses that prefer a managed, hosted solution for their DMARC reporting and enforcement. It's highly suitable for SMBs, mid-market companies, and enterprises that need a robust, user-friendly platform without the overhead of self-hosting and maintaining infrastructure.
MSPs can also leverage Dmarcian's multi-domain capabilities, though the pricing structure might become a consideration for a very large number of client domains. It's designed for those who want a clear path to DMARC compliance, relying on a provider to handle the complexities of data ingestion and visualization.
ELK DMARC is best suited for organizations with strong internal IT and DevOps capabilities, particularly those already using or familiar with the ELK Stack. It's ideal for enterprises that require complete control over their data, wish to integrate DMARC reporting into existing security information and event management (SIEM) systems, or have unique data retention and privacy requirements.
For MSPs with the technical expertise to deploy and manage it, ELK DMARC offers a highly customizable, cost-effective (in terms of licensing) solution for multiple clients. SMBs, however, might find the technical barrier to entry too high, as it demands significant operational overhead compared to a SaaS offering.
ELK DMARC
How does Dmarcian compare with ELK DMARC?
ELK DMARC
DMARC report analysis
Analyzes aggregate (RUA) and forensic (RUF) DMARC reports.
Comprehensive RUA and RUF analysis on higher tiers.
RUA analysis out-of-the-box, RUF possible with customization.
Source detection
Automatically identifies and categorizes email sending sources.
Automatic identification and grouping of sending sources.
Requires manual configuration or custom Kibana dashboards.
Forward detection
Identifies legitimate email forwarding that may impact DMARC.
Helps distinguish forwarded mail from spoofing.
Needs custom implementation and logic.
Spoof detection
Detects and helps mitigate email spoofing attempts.
Core functionality to identify and resolve spoofing.
Provides alerts for DMARC policy changes or anomalies.
"Alert Central" feature for custom alerts.
Leverages Kibana Alerting for custom notifications.
Reporting
Generates various reports for DMARC compliance and email health.
Standardized and custom reports available.
Customizable reports via Kibana dashboards.
API
Offers an API for programmatic access to data and features.
API access available on Enterprise plan.
Access data via Elasticsearch API.
Multi-tenancy
Supports managing multiple domains or organizations from a single account.
Supports domain groups and multiple domains.
Scalable for multiple domains via ELK architecture.
SPF flattening
Helps manage SPF record limits to avoid exceeding DNS lookup limits.
Not a direct feature, but offers SPF checker.
Not a direct feature of the DMARC tool, but can be managed externally.
Hosted DMARC
Provides hosted DMARC services.
Fully hosted DMARC reporting and management.
Self-hosted solution, no hosted service.
BIMI
Support for Brand Indicators for Message Identification (BIMI).
Tools to check and help implement BIMI.
Not a native feature, requires custom implementation.
MTA-STS/TLS-RPT
Support for MTA-STS and TLS-RPT protocols.
TLS Reporting is an included feature.
Focuses on DMARC, not directly on these protocols.
Blocklists and reputation
Monitors sender reputation and checks against email blocklists (blacklists).
Primarily DMARC focused, not a blocklist monitoring tool.
Not a native feature, though can be integrated with other data sources.
AI copilot
Utilizes AI for automated insights and recommendations.
No AI copilot feature currently advertised.
Open-source, no built-in AI copilot.
DNS monitoring
Monitors DNS records for changes or misconfigurations.
Offers DMARC/SPF/DKIM record checkers, but not general DNS monitoring.
Not a native feature, external tools needed.
Self hostable
Ability to host the software on your own infrastructure.
Cloud-based SaaS offering.
Designed for self-hosting on user infrastructure.
Free trial/free tier
Offers a free trial or a permanently free tier.
Free Personal plan and 30-day trials for paid plans.
Open-source, free to use (excluding infrastructure costs).
Drawbacks and what to watch out for
Dmarcian's drawbacks often center around its cost for smaller organizations and the occasional complexity of its advanced features. We also noted some users mention API integration challenges. ELK DMARC's main drawback is its inherent technical complexity, requiring significant expertise in the ELK Stack and infrastructure management. This makes it less accessible for teams without dedicated technical resources.
We have pulled the average ratings from G2 for each product, and also included the most recent negative reviews for each product in full. Positive reviews tend to have less detail and have a higher chance of being fraudulent, so negative reviews are a better signal for your decision.
3.5 / 5(5)
ELK DMARC
0 / 5(0)
The security of emails made difficult
0.5 / 5
What do you like best about dmarcian?Its operation, to its responses dmarcian has obstructed my expectations. It has not simplified my experience with email authentication. Made my job hectic. The less user friendly interface makes navigating tough.What do you dislike about dmarcian?There are concerns about its effectiveness in solving email scams and spoofing attempts. The system does not fully. Prevent emails, which leave businesses vulnerable to attacks. It also lacks comprehensive and detailed activity logs making it difficult to monitor and investigate security breaches.What problems is dmarcian solving and how is that benefiting you?dmarcian is a poor tool when it comes to preventing activities that harm businesses. Its worst technology does not simply work for individuals. Improvements need to be made to increase the interface and user experience for navigation and management of security settings.
G2 is the most popular review platform for DMARC products, so this is a strong signal that this product is not popular.
One of the best email security software
3.5 / 5
What do you like best about dmarcian?The best part about using dmarcian is it keeps our domain name safe from all the nonsense out there in terms of phishing, spam, fraud and its plans are competitive in nature which is why we don't need to shell out a big chunk of money to protect our domain.What do you dislike about dmarcian?The downside of using dmarcian is its API Integration, which has many flaws, which is why it gets really difficult to integrate it with our servers and this is where we would like to see an improvement.What problems is dmarcian solving and how is that benefiting you?Today, keeping domain safe is one big challenge and along with it, the activity log of your domain is critical; this is where dmarcian comes in and helps us keep everything secure and uptight.
Nishay S.
Executive Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)
Prevents business digital work from fraudulents at ease
4.0 / 5
What do you like best about dmarcian?Easy to use integrated software to protect business emails from fraud.Increases deliverability of emails from business domains and ensures smooth outgoing.Uses best-in-class technology and process to configure emails and safeguard them from phishing.What do you dislike about dmarcian?No major dislike about Dmarcian. The only challenge is the lower ability towards threat intelligence.The excellent customer support offered. Highly agile and faster than traditional email security gateways.What problems is dmarcian solving and how is that benefiting you?Helps businesses in protection from viruses, malware and email threat. Just with one single click company can blocklist and allowlist IPs and Domains. Solid technology to protect business data from any fraud and bad behaviour. The technology is ideal for medium, small and large enterprise businesses.
Aswath V.
Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)
Empowering Email Authentication
4.5 / 5
What do you like best about dmarcian?dmarcian's clear mission to promote email security and combat phishing resonates and I appreciate their work beyond pure profit motives. I am satisfied with dmarcian's tools, highlighting their ease of use, helpful support, and effectiveness in improving email security.What do you dislike about dmarcian?While they offer free tools, their paid services can be expensive for smaller organizations or individual users. Their platform may not integrate seamlessly with all email service providers or security solutions, requiring additional configuration or workarounds.What problems is dmarcian solving and how is that benefiting you?Dmarcian helps me to protect our domain from being spoofed by email attackers. This prevents fake emails from appearing to come from their domain, which can be used to steal sensitive information or impersonate individuals. This benefits me indirectly by ensuring the information I access is from reliable sources and not tampered with by malicious actors.
Tytus J.
IT Manager Information Technology and Services Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)
Protected email identity
5.0 / 5
What do you like best about dmarcian?With its operation, it has allowed electronic emails not to be usurped and all the information in each email is not released for improper useOur clients have the security that when an email is sent on our part it is safe because Dmarcian does not allow the domains to be kidnapped causing pirate emails to be receivedWhat do you dislike about dmarcian?I think that nothing dislikes because all its operation has been correct and executing all its processes wellWhat problems is dmarcian solving and how is that benefiting you?It was the problem that emails arrived with the same domain but we were not who sent them and robbed the information or requested payments to other accounts and the client thought that if it was our work team that sent those emails because the domain was the same, with Dmarcian that problem was solved because our emails were never piracy
Sophia G.
supervisor Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)
Pricing
Dmarcian operates on a tiered subscription model, scaling with domains and message volume, whereas ELK DMARC is an open-source, self-hosted solution where costs are primarily associated with infrastructure and maintenance.
ELK DMARC
Small
Up to 10k emails / month
$24/month (Basic plan, up to 100k emails)
Self-hosted
Medium
Up to 100k emails / month
$24/month (Basic plan)
Self-hosted
Large
Up to 1 million emails / month
$240/month (Plus plan)
Self-hosted
Enterprise
Over 1 million emails / month
$600/month (Enterprise plan, up to 5M emails). Contact for higher volume.
3.5 / 5(5)
