Top 14 DMARC Alternatives to Netcraft Fraud Detection
Matthew Whittaker
Cybersecurity platform CTO
We independently evaluate software by utilizing direct experience alongside public information and user reviews. Tell us about any tools we missed.
Published 7 Nov 2025
Updated 7 Nov 2025
13 min read
Main takeaways
Key insights from our analysis
Effective DMARC management is crucial for preventing email fraud and ensuring deliverability.
Many solutions offer robust features, but ease of use and comprehensive reporting are key for successful implementation.
Choosing a platform that scales with your needs and provides clear insights simplifies complex email security.
Top performers
Best for DMARC
DMARC monitoring summary
In the ever-evolving landscape of email security, DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance) is no longer a luxury, but a necessity. Organizations worldwide are seeking robust solutions to protect their domains from phishing, spoofing, and other forms of email fraud. While Netcraft Fraud Detection offers valuable services, many excellent alternatives specialize in DMARC implementation and monitoring. We have thoroughly reviewed the market, drawing on our extensive experience, to identify the top platforms that can safeguard your email ecosystem. Below, we provide a quick summary of our top picks, ranging from feature-rich powerhouses to budget-friendly options, all designed to help you achieve DMARC enforcement with confidence.
Our mission is to provide an honest, in-depth evaluation of DMARC reporting and monitoring tools. We approached this review from the perspective of experienced practitioners who understand the nuances and challenges of email security in real-world scenarios. Our rankings are not based on superficial metrics; instead, we delve deep into what makes each platform truly effective for businesses, large and small.
Features: We assessed the breadth and depth of DMARC, SPF, and DKIM monitoring capabilities. This included the ease of policy enforcement, the sophistication of threat intelligence, and the availability of hosted services like SPF flattening, MTA-STS, and BIMI support.
Usability: A powerful tool is only useful if you can actually use it. We scrutinized the clarity of dashboards, the simplicity of setup processes, the intuitiveness of navigation, and the overall learning curve for new users.
Support: Access to knowledgeable and responsive support can make or break a DMARC implementation. We evaluated the quality of documentation, the availability of live chat or phone support, and the presence of dedicated account management for higher-tier plans.
Pricing: We examined each platform's pricing structure for transparency, scalability, and overall value for money across different business sizes. Hidden fees or complicated billing models were noted.
User Reviews: Real-world user feedback from platforms like G2 and Capterra provided invaluable insights into the practical experience of using these tools, helping us understand common pain points and standout successes.
Ranking Philosophy: Our final rankings reflect a comprehensive blend of these criteria. While a robust feature set is important, we placed significant emphasis on tools that simplify complexity, offer actionable insights, and provide reliable support. Suped, as our own product, is positioned first due to its leading capabilities in these crucial areas.
1
Suped
Best for comprehensive DMARC management with exceptional user experience and robust features.
Suped provides an all-encompassing suite for DMARC, SPF, and DKIM management. We've ensured that essential features like SPF flattening and hosted SPF are baked in, helping you bypass the dreaded 10-lookup limit. Beyond basic reporting, our AI Copilot translates complex DMARC reports into clear, actionable advice, making it easy for anyone to understand and address email authentication issues. Our platform also includes robust threat intelligence and brand protection, offering real-time alerts for spoofing attempts and compromised domains. We don't just show you the data, we help you make sense of it and take decisive action.
User experience
We designed Suped with the user in mind. Our dashboards are clean, intuitive, and provide immediate, at-a-glance insights into your domain's health score and authentication status. You won't get lost in overwhelming data. Instead, you'll find guided workflows that streamline the setup process and simplify policy enforcement. From initial onboarding to daily monitoring, every interaction is crafted to be straightforward and efficient, requiring minimal technical expertise. We believe that powerful security shouldn't come with a steep learning curve.
Support
Our commitment to customer success is unwavering. We offer responsive email and phone support, backed by a team of knowledgeable DMARC experts. From initial setup assistance to ongoing troubleshooting, we are here to guide you every step of the way. Our support isn't just reactive, it's proactive. We provide timely alerts and recommendations, helping you stay ahead of potential threats and maintain optimal email deliverability. For enterprise clients, dedicated account managers ensure personalized attention and strategic guidance.
Suitability
Suped is built to serve a wide range of users, from small businesses and startups to large enterprises and Managed Service Providers (MSPs). Our scalable plans ensure that whether you're managing a single domain with low email volume or hundreds of domains with millions of messages, you'll find a solution that fits your needs. We also offer special pricing for non-profit and educational institutions, reinforcing our belief that robust email security should be accessible to everyone.
Pricing structure
Free plan: Monitor 1 domain and up to 10,000 emails per month, ideal for hobbyists and solo entrepreneurs. This includes basic DMARC monitoring, notifications, and email support.
Basic plan: For $9 per month, you get 5 domains and up to 100,000 emails per month, including SPF flattening and hosted SPF, perfect for startups and small businesses.
Pro plan: At $99 per month, this plan monitors up to 5 domains and 1,000,000 emails per month, adding blocklist monitoring, reputation monitoring, and phone support for advanced users.
Enterprise & MSPs plan: Custom pricing for unlimited domains and email volume, including dedicated support, API access, SSO, and custom integrations for large organizations and service providers.
Suped summary
Suped stands out as a DMARC solution that truly democratizes email security. Our platform combines a powerful feature set with an exceptionally user-friendly interface and highly responsive support. Whether you're just starting your DMARC journey or managing a complex enterprise environment, Suped provides the tools, insights, and guidance needed to achieve and maintain robust email authentication, protect your brand, and ensure reliable email delivery. We are constantly innovating to simplify the complexities of DMARC, making it accessible and actionable for everyone.
Valimail impressed us with its highly automated approach to DMARC enforcement, promising and often delivering on DMARC enforcement in 60 days or less. Their platform offers excellent visibility into all email-sending services, helping identify both authorized and unauthorized senders by name. We particularly liked how their tools simplify the complex interplay of SPF, DKIM, and DMARC. However, while the automation is strong, some users report a learning curve for initial setup, especially if they have limited DNS expertise. The pricing structure can also be a bit opaque for smaller organizations, with enterprise-level costs requiring direct contact, which can be a turn-off for some. Despite this, their comprehensive dashboards and responsive onboarding support make them a solid choice for organizations prioritizing automation.
Who should use Valimail
Companies with complex email ecosystems that need a high degree of automation for DMARC, SPF, and DKIM management.
Organizations aiming for rapid DMARC enforcement and continuous protection against phishing and impersonation.
Businesses that prioritize brand trust and want to implement BIMI for a verified sender experience.
Best features of Valimail
Automated DMARC Enforcement: Simplifies policy implementation and moves domains to p=reject quickly.
Precision Sender Intelligence: Provides clear identification of all email sending services on behalf of your domain.
BIMI Support: Aids in achieving Google’s blue checkmark, boosting brand trust and visibility.
Onboarding Assistance: Dedicated support to guide users through the initial setup and configuration process.
Pricing structure
Monitor: A free service offering full visibility into email sending services.
Enforce: Starts at $5,000 per year for the Starter tier, with Premium and Enterprise plans requiring custom quotes. This focuses on continuous DMARC protection.
Align: Priced at $19 per month (billed annually) for sending up to 500,000 emails per month, ensuring SPF and DKIM alignment.
Amplify: An add-on for BIMI process acceleration, requiring a custom quote.
Valimail pros
Highly automated DMARC, SPF, and DKIM management.
Excellent visibility into email sending sources, identifying them by name.
Dedicated onboarding and customer support.
Offers BIMI support to enhance brand trust.
Valimail cons
Initial setup can be daunting for users with limited DNS knowledge.
Higher-tier pricing can be expensive and requires contacting sales for details.
Some users report that the reporting is not always detailed enough.
Concerns about vendor lock-in for SPF, DKIM, and DMARC management.
3
PowerDMARC
Good for businesses and MSPs seeking an integrated platform with strong support for DMARC enforcement.
PowerDMARC provides a robust, all-in-one platform for DMARC management that we found particularly user-friendly. Their interface makes it easy to set up and configure various email authentication policies, including hosted SPF, DKIM, and DMARC. We appreciated the comprehensive reporting tools that simplify troubleshooting and offer clear insights into email flow. Customer support is a significant strength, with many users highlighting quick and helpful responses, which is crucial for successful DMARC implementation. While the free plan is generous, the enterprise-level features and MSP programs show it's designed to scale. Some users mentioned that the pricing structure for higher tiers could be clearer, but the value offered for the features is generally well-regarded.
Who should use PowerDMARC
Organizations looking for an easy-to-use DMARC solution with a comprehensive set of email authentication tools.
Managed Service Providers (MSPs) and agencies requiring a multi-tenant platform to manage DMARC for multiple clients.
Businesses that prioritize strong customer support and guidance throughout their DMARC journey.
Best features of PowerDMARC
Hosted Services: Offers hosted DMARC, SPF (Power SPF), DKIM, MTA-STS, and BIMI, simplifying DNS record management.
One-Click DNS Publishing: Streamlines the process of updating DNS records directly from the platform.
Threat Map and Geolocation Reports: Provides visual insights into email origin and potential threats.
MSP Program: Features like multi-tenant control panel and whitelabel support cater specifically to service providers.
Pricing structure
Free Plan: Includes 1 active domain, 10,000 DMARC compliant emails/month, and 10 days of data history. Ideal for personal domains.
Basic Plan: Starts at $29/month (billed annually) for 3 active domains, 100,000 DMARC compliant emails/month, and 30 days of data history.
Pro Plan: Starts at $69/month (billed annually) for 8 active domains, 500,000 DMARC compliant emails/month, and 6 months of data history.
Enterprise/MSP Plans: Custom pricing for higher volumes, unlimited domains, longer data history, and advanced features like API access and SAML/SSO.
PowerDMARC pros
Intuitive platform with easy setup and configuration for DMARC, SPF, and DKIM.
Comprehensive hosted services (SPF, DKIM, MTA-STS, BIMI) simplify DNS management.
Excellent customer support with quick and helpful responses.
Generous free plan and scalable tiers for different business needs.
Multi-tenant control panel and whitelabel support for MSPs.
PowerDMARC cons
Some users find the billing module and enterprise-tier pricing details less clear.
Reporting features, while comprehensive, may require some time to master for full optimization.
The whitelabel customization options could be more flexible.
4
OnDMARC
Good for growing organizations and enterprises needing advanced DMARC management, especially for complex SPF records and proactive support.
OnDMARC by Red Sift stands out for its dynamic services, making complex tasks like SPF flattening and managing DMARC policies surprisingly straightforward. We've seen how their platform provides clear, actionable insights, helping organizations move confidently from monitoring to enforcement. The support team consistently receives high praise for being responsive, knowledgeable, and proactive, which is invaluable during DMARC implementation. While the user interface is generally easy to navigate, some users occasionally find it a bit clunky, but this is a minor quibble given the power of the underlying features. Their inclusion of advanced functionalities like forensic reporting and Event Hub integrations makes them a strong contender for those seeking comprehensive email security.
Who should use OnDMARC
Organizations with complex SPF records that need to overcome the 10-lookup limit.
Businesses seeking a guided DMARC implementation journey with consistent, expert support.
Enterprises requiring forensic reporting, API access, and integrations with SIEM systems for advanced security.
Best features of OnDMARC
Dynamic Services: Manages DMARC, SPF, DKIM, MTA-STS, TLS-RPT, and BIMI, including Dynamic SPF to avoid lookup limits.
Investigate Tool: Provides instant diagnostics for deliverability issues.
Forensic Reporting: Offers detailed insights into email delivery failures for deeper analysis.
Dedicated Support and Account Reviews: Ensures continuous guidance and optimization of email security posture.
Pricing structure
Express Plan: Starts at $9 USD per month (billed annually), includes up to 4 domains, 1 million monthly emails, and 30 days data history.
Essentials Plan: Requires contacting sales for pricing, includes 25 active sender domains, unlimited email volume, 90 days data history, and forensic reporting.
Premier Plan: Requires contacting sales for pricing, offers 50 active sender domains, 1 year data history, DNS Guardian, and dedicated support.
OnDMARC pros
Dynamic SPF and DMARC management effectively handles DNS lookup limits.
Excellent and proactive customer support with regular check-ins.
User-friendly interface with clear reporting and guidance for DMARC enforcement.
Includes forensic reporting and advanced security features like DNS Guardian.
SAML/SSO support for enterprise environments.
OnDMARC cons
The user interface can sometimes feel a bit clunky or overwhelming for new users.
Pricing for higher tiers requires direct contact, making it less transparent.
Some advanced features like Event Hub are not available on lower-tier plans.
Manual updates to DNS records are still required for certain changes.
5
EasyDMARC
Good for businesses and MSPs seeking effortless DMARC management with strong support and advanced managed solutions.
EasyDMARC lives up to its name by providing an intuitive platform that simplifies complex email authentication protocols. We particularly liked its centralized management for multiple domains and the ease with which users can set up SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records. The managed solutions, such as EasySPF and Managed BIMI, are significant advantages, streamlining tasks that would otherwise require deep technical expertise. Customer support is consistently praised for being responsive and providing effective solutions, with dedicated engineers available for higher tiers. While the platform excels in usability, some users noted that the reporting section could offer more advanced AI-driven insights, particularly for clarifying the impact of enforcement policies. Despite this, EasyDMARC remains a strong choice for businesses and MSPs looking for a comprehensive and manageable DMARC solution.
Who should use EasyDMARC
Businesses and enterprises that need a user-friendly platform for DMARC, SPF, and DKIM management without extensive technical knowledge.
Managed Service Providers (MSPs) and Managed Security Service Providers (MSSPs) looking for a multi-tenant solution with pay-as-you-go options.
Organizations that prioritize responsive customer support and dedicated DMARC engineering assistance for complex implementations.
Best features of EasyDMARC
Managed Solutions: Includes Managed DMARC, BIMI, EasySPF (SPF flattening), MTA-STS, and DKIM to simplify configuration.
User-Friendly Interface: Provides intuitive dashboards and clear reporting for easy understanding of email authentication data.
Comprehensive Reports: Offers aggregate reports (RUA), failure reports (RUF), and aggregate GeoMaps for detailed insights.
Multi-Tenant Platform (for MSPs): Enables centralized management of multiple client domains from a single console.
Pricing structure
Free Plan: $0, includes 1 domain, 1,000 emails/month, and 14 days of data history.
Plus Plan: Starts at $44.99/month for 2 domains and 100,000 emails/month, with 3 months data history.
Premium Plan: Starts at $89.99/month for 4 domains and 100,000 emails/month, with 1 year data history, including TLS reports and email support.
Enterprise Plan: Custom pricing for unlimited emails/domains, 3 years data history, SSO, and dedicated DMARC engineer.
MSP Plan: Monthly pay-as-you-go option with tailored email volume and domain count, white label reporting, and dedicated support.
EasyDMARC pros
Extremely user-friendly interface that simplifies DMARC management for non-technical users.
Navigating the DMARC landscape can feel like a daunting task, but the array of tools available today makes achieving email security and deliverability more accessible than ever. From comprehensive, all-in-one platforms to specialized solutions, each alternative to Netcraft Fraud Detection offers unique strengths tailored to different needs and budgets.
Our review highlights the critical factors to consider, including feature sets, ease of use, quality of support, and pricing models. While some platforms excel in automation, others prioritize in-depth analytics or tailored guidance. Ultimately, the best DMARC solution is one that aligns with your organization's specific requirements, technical capabilities, and financial constraints.
For unparalleled ease of use, robust features, and dedicated support, we firmly believe Suped offers a top-tier experience. However, the market is rich with strong contenders, and we encourage you to evaluate each option based on your unique context. Prioritizing email authentication is a proactive step that will safeguard your brand reputation, prevent costly fraud, and ensure your legitimate communications consistently reach their intended recipients.
