Summary
Beyond the basic reporting offered by Email Service Providers, a robust strategy for tracking email deliverability involves leveraging a diverse array of external tools. These resources offer deeper insights into inbox placement, sender reputation, and technical configurations crucial for successful email delivery.
Key findings
- Postmaster Tools are Essential: Major mailbox providers like Google and Microsoft offer free Postmaster Tools, such as Google Postmaster Tools and Microsoft SNDS, that provide invaluable insights into delivery errors, spam reports, and domain-IP reputation directly from the source.
- Seed List Services for Inbox Placement: Dedicated third-party services, including 250ok, Return Path, GlockApps, Folderly, and Litmus, utilize seed lists to test actual inbox placement across various mailbox providers, offering detailed reports on where emails land and identifying spam filter issues.
- Foundational DNS and Reputation Checks: Tools like MXToolbox, Spamhaus Project, BarracudaCentral, Talos Intelligence, and Validity's Sender Score are vital for monitoring DNS records, such as SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, checking against major blacklists, and assessing overall IP/domain reputation, which directly impacts deliverability.
- DMARC Monitoring for Authentication: Services like DMARC Analyzer provide critical reporting on email authentication failures, helping identify unauthorized sending and ensuring legitimate mail is properly verified, which enhances deliverability.
- Free Diagnostic Tools Available: Tools such as Mail-Tester.com offer quick, free diagnostics on email quality, content, and authentication setup, serving as excellent pre-send checks.
Key considerations
- Tailor Tool Selection to Needs: The most effective deliverability strategy involves selecting tools based on individual requirements, whether focusing on deep analytics, pre-send checks, or comprehensive reputation monitoring.
- Combine External with Internal Data: Augmenting external tool insights with an analysis of internal bounce rates, block rates by domain, and open rates provides a holistic view of sending practices and helps pinpoint specific areas for improvement.
- Proactive and Continuous Monitoring: Email deliverability is dynamic; continuous external monitoring of reputation, blocklist status, and inbox placement is crucial for maintaining sender health and addressing issues promptly.
- Understand Tool Limitations: While powerful, some tools may have limitations, such as reduced reliability for specific mailbox providers, requiring a diversified approach.
What email marketers say
11 marketer opinions
While Email Service Providers offer foundational insights, external tools are indispensable for a comprehensive understanding of email deliverability. These specialized platforms extend visibility into crucial areas like inbox placement, technical authentication, and ongoing sender reputation, providing marketers with the data needed to optimize performance.
Key opinions
- Specialized Inbox & Spam Diagnostics: Dedicated deliverability platforms such as GlockApps, Folderly, 250ok, Return Path, and Litmus offer sophisticated inbox placement testing via seed lists, providing detailed reports on content issues, spam filter triggers, and specific insights to resolve complex deliverability challenges.
- Essential Technical Health Checks: Fundamental to strong deliverability are tools like MXToolbox for verifying SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records, monitoring IP blacklists, and analyzing email headers. Complementary free resources like Google Postmaster Tools and Microsoft SNDS provide direct insights into domain reputation, while Mail-Tester.com offers quick email quality assessments.
Key considerations
- Tailor Tool Selection to Specific Needs: The optimal deliverability strategy involves selecting a mix of external tools that align with specific marketing objectives, whether focusing on pre-send validation, in-depth inbox placement analytics, or continuous reputation monitoring.
- Integrate External Insights with Internal Data: For a complete picture of email performance, it is crucial to analyze external deliverability reports alongside internal ESP data, such as bounce rates by domain, block rates, and open rates, to pinpoint specific issues and refine sending practices.
- Prioritize Continuous Monitoring: Email deliverability is a constantly evolving landscape. Proactive and continuous monitoring of sender reputation, blocklist status, and inbox placement across various external tools is vital to swiftly identify and address any emerging deliverability issues.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks recommends 250ok for deliverability tracking.
2 Apr 2024 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks recommends Return Path for deliverability tracking.
3 Aug 2022 - Email Geeks
What the experts say
4 expert opinions
Gauging email deliverability effectively beyond the confines of an ESP requires leveraging a suite of specialized external tools. These platforms offer critical insights, from pre-send diagnostics to real-time inbox placement and direct feedback from major mailbox providers, all essential for maintaining sender health.
Key opinions
- Mail-Tester for Pre-Campaign Assessment: Mail-Tester.com is a valuable pre-send diagnostic tool, offering a score and a comprehensive report on potential deliverability hurdles, including SPF/DKIM issues, content flags, and blacklist presence, enabling senders to rectify problems before deployment.
- Leveraging Postmaster Tools: Critical for post-send analysis, Postmaster Tools from providers like Google, Yahoo, AOL, and Outlook.com offer unparalleled insights into sender reputation, complaint rates, and delivery errors directly from the mailbox providers, supplementing ESP data.
- Third-Party Seed List Monitoring: Utilizing third-party tools with seed lists is vital for accurately tracking inbox placement across diverse mailbox providers, offering a granular view of where emails land and helping diagnose specific deliverability challenges.
Key considerations
- Multi-Faceted Approach to Monitoring: A robust deliverability strategy involves integrating pre-send checks from tools like Mail-Tester with ongoing performance monitoring via Postmaster Tools and real-time inbox placement verification from seed list services.
- Proactive Problem Identification: External tools empower senders to identify and troubleshoot deliverability issues, whether technical or content-related, before they escalate, preventing widespread delivery failures.
- Direct Mailbox Provider Feedback: Prioritize insights from Postmaster Tools as they provide a direct, authoritative perspective on your sending reputation and performance from the perspective of the largest email service providers.
Expert view
Expert from Spam Resource explains that Mail-Tester is a valuable external tool for pre-send deliverability checks, offering a score and detailed report on potential issues like SPF/DKIM configuration, content problems, and blacklist status, helping senders identify and fix problems before large-scale sending.
13 Mar 2025 - Spam Resource
Expert view
Expert from Spam Resource shares that Postmaster Tools from providers like Google, Yahoo, AOL, and Outlook.com are essential external resources for tracking email deliverability, providing crucial insights into sender reputation, complaint rates, and delivery errors outside of an ESP.
23 Feb 2025 - Spam Resource
What the documentation says
7 technical articles
Beyond the analytics provided by Email Service Providers, mastering email deliverability necessitates a deep dive into external tools that offer granular insights into sender reputation, email authentication, and direct performance feedback from major mailbox providers. These resources are critical for identifying and mitigating issues that could prevent emails from reaching the inbox.
Key findings
- Direct Feedback from Major Mailbox Providers: Google Postmaster Tools and Microsoft SNDS provide invaluable, first-party data on delivery errors, spam reports, and domain-IP reputation specific to their large user bases, directly informing deliverability strategy.
- Holistic Sender Reputation Monitoring: Tools like Validity's Sender Score offer a real-time, independent assessment of IP reputation, while BarracudaCentral and Talos Intelligence provide insights into how your sending IPs are perceived by major security vendors, influencing inbox placement.
- Essential Blocklist Verification: Utilizing services like the Spamhaus Project allows senders to proactively check if their IP addresses or domains are listed on critical spam blocklists, a common cause of deliverability failures.
- Comprehensive Authentication Reporting: DMARC Analyzer provides detailed visibility into email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) failures, helping to secure your domain from unauthorized sending and improve legitimate email delivery.
Key considerations
- Proactive Reputation Management: Regularly monitoring your sender reputation across various external platforms, including direct mailbox provider tools and third-party scoring systems, is crucial for preventing deliverability issues before they impact campaigns.
- Strategic Use of Authentication Data: Leveraging DMARC reports is not just about security; it's a key deliverability practice that helps identify and rectify authentication misconfigurations, ensuring your emails are trusted by receiving servers.
- Continuous Blocklist Vigilance: Integrating blocklist checks into your routine deliverability monitoring allows for swift action, minimizing the impact of any listings on your email campaigns.
- Combine Diverse External Insights: A comprehensive approach means synthesizing data from mailbox provider tools, reputation services, blocklist lookups, and authentication reporting to gain a full understanding of external factors affecting deliverability.
Technical article
Documentation from Google Postmaster Tools Help explains that Google Postmaster Tools offers valuable data on email performance with Gmail users, including delivery errors, spam reports, and domain-IP reputation, providing insights crucial for optimizing deliverability to Google's ecosystem.
15 Apr 2023 - Google Postmaster Tools Help
Technical article
Documentation from Microsoft Docs shares that Microsoft SNDS provides data on mail sent to Outlook.com and other Microsoft properties, allowing senders to monitor their IP reputation, view spam complaint rates, and identify potential deliverability issues affecting their audience on Microsoft platforms.
1 Jul 2022 - Microsoft Docs
What are the best email deliverability tools and monitoring practices?
What are the best tools and methods to measure email deliverability outside of campaign metrics, like GlockApps?
What are the best tools for monitoring and fixing email deliverability issues, considering budget constraints?
What are the best tools for tracking all-round email deliverability?
What deliverability monitoring tools are good alternatives to Return Path, Everest and Sparkpost?
What tools can I use to monitor deliverability when sending emails from Microsoft Office or Google Workspace?
