Summary
Experts and marketers generally agree that SenderScore is a valuable, but not definitive, indicator of sender reputation. Its accuracy in associating domains with specific IP addresses depends on the freshness, diversity, and credibility of its data sources, including ISP partnerships, spam traps, and feedback loops. Maintaining good sending practices like authentication, list hygiene, and engaging content positively influences SenderScore and overall deliverability. It's crucial to use SenderScore in conjunction with other reputation monitoring tools for a comprehensive assessment, and to verify its data before taking action. Documentation indicates that while SenderScore is used by systems such as Microsoft to filter emails, it is only one factor to be taken into account.
Key findings
- Data Source: SenderScore accuracy hinges on the quality and timeliness of its data sources (ISPs, spam traps).
- Reputation Indicator: SenderScore serves as an indicator of sender reputation, not a guaranteed measure of deliverability.
- Sending Practices: Following email marketing best practices (authentication, list hygiene, content) has a positive impact on SenderScore.
- Multiple Tools: For a holistic view, SenderScore should be used alongside other reputation monitoring tools.
- Potential Mismatches: Cases of mismatch exist between SenderScore data and actual IP/domain associations, requiring further investigation.
Key considerations
- Data Verification: Always verify SenderScore information with other data points before making decisions.
- Dynamic Data: Recognize that SenderScore is based on dynamic data and can fluctuate over time.
- Proactive Management: Focus on implementing and maintaining strong sending practices to proactively improve SenderScore.
- Complete Picture: Understand that SenderScore alone doesn't provide the complete picture of email deliverability.
- External Factors: Recognize that factors outside of your direct control may influence SenderScore.
What email marketers say
11 marketer opinions
SenderScore's accuracy in associating domains with specific IP addresses is influenced by various factors. Experts suggest it's a useful indicator of sender reputation, but not a definitive measure. Its accuracy depends on the freshness and diversity of data sources like ISP partnerships, spam traps, and feedback loops. Practices like maintaining clean email lists, engaging content, and proper authentication play a crucial role in influencing SenderScore. It's essential to use SenderScore in conjunction with other reputation monitoring tools for a comprehensive view of deliverability, as no single tool provides a complete picture.
Key opinions
- Data Source: Accuracy depends on the variety and recency of SenderScore's data sources (ISPs, spam traps).
- Reputation Indicator: SenderScore is an indicator, not a guarantee, of sender reputation and deliverability.
- Impact Factors: Factors like spam complaints, low engagement, and invalid email addresses negatively impact SenderScore.
- Best Practices Influence: Positive sending practices (clean lists, authentication, engagement) improve SenderScore.
- Multiple Tools: SenderScore should be used alongside other reputation tools for a comprehensive assessment.
Key considerations
- Verification: Always verify SenderScore data with other sources before taking action.
- Holistic View: Consider SenderScore as part of a broader deliverability monitoring strategy.
- Dynamic Data: Recognize that SenderScore is based on dynamic data and can change over time.
- External Factors: Acknowledge that SenderScore may not always reflect the complete picture due to external factors.
- Proactive Management: Focus on maintaining good sending practices to positively influence SenderScore.
Marketer view
Email marketer from StackExchange responds that Sender Score can be a useful tool for identifying potential issues with your sending reputation but advises verifying the data with other sources before taking action.
8 Dec 2023 - StackExchange
Marketer view
Email marketer from ReturnPath article says monitoring your sender reputation, including Sender Score, allows you to identify and address deliverability problems quickly. This involves tracking your sending volume, bounce rates, and complaint rates.
10 Nov 2021 - ReturnPath
What the experts say
3 expert opinions
Experts agree that SenderScore's domain association accuracy relies on several factors. Historically, data based on return-path domains has been mostly accurate, but inaccuracies are possible. The freshness and diversity of data sources, like spam traps and feedback loops, are crucial. Maintaining strong sending practices, including authentication and list hygiene, positively impacts the accuracy of domain association.
Key opinions
- Historical Accuracy: Return-path domain data has been generally accurate historically, but errors can occur.
- Data Source Importance: Accuracy depends on fresh and diverse data sources, including spam traps and feedback loops.
- Best Practices Impact: Good sending practices (authentication, list hygiene, engagement) improve domain association accuracy.
Key considerations
- Potential Inaccuracies: Acknowledge that inaccuracies are possible, especially when relying solely on external IP analysis.
- Data Freshness: Consider how recently the data used by SenderScore was updated.
- Proactive Approach: Focus on maintaining good sending practices to positively influence your sender reputation and the accuracy of domain association.
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise shares that consistently following email best practices (authentication, list hygiene, engagement) helps maintain a positive sender reputation and influences how accurately your IP is associated with your domains by reputation systems.
9 Jun 2023 - Word to the Wise
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks says historically, the associated domains list has been mostly accurate based on return-path domains, but inaccuracies are possible. He wouldn't worry about it unless it is causing a problem and that determining senders from a given IP from the outside is not easy.
26 Jul 2022 - Email Geeks
What the documentation says
3 technical articles
Documentation indicates that SenderScore is a reputation metric, assigning scores based on data from a sensor network. While it's an indicator, it's not definitive. Other entities like Spamhaus use IP reputation for blocklists based on observed spam activity, but don't directly correlate domains and IPs like SenderScore. Microsoft also uses IP reputation as a factor in email acceptance, highlighting its importance in deliverability.
Key findings
- Reputation Metric: SenderScore is a metric for outbound email server reputation based on sensor data.
- Indicator, Not Definitive: SenderScore serves as an indicator, not a definitive measure, of reputation.
- Alternative Methods: Spamhaus uses IP reputation for blocklists based on observed spam activity, differing from SenderScore's domain-IP correlation.
- Deliverability Impact: Microsoft uses IP reputation as a factor in determining whether to accept or reject email, influencing deliverability.
Key considerations
- Contextual Use: Use SenderScore as one of several factors when evaluating email deliverability.
- Algorithm Transparency: The exact algorithm behind SenderScore is proprietary, limiting full understanding.
- Reputation Importance: Recognize the overall importance of IP reputation in email filtering decisions by major providers.
Technical article
Documentation from Spamhaus explains that they maintain blocklists based on IP reputation. They associate IPs with spam activity based on direct observation and reports, but don't directly correlate domains to IPs in the same way SenderScore does.
18 May 2024 - Spamhaus
Technical article
Documentation from Microsoft highlights that they use IP reputation as one factor in determining whether to accept or reject email. A poor IP reputation may lead to emails being filtered as spam.
12 Dec 2024 - Microsoft
Does domain/IP reputation affect BIMI logo display with VMC?
How accurate is SNDS and Google Postmaster Tools reputation data?
How can I best evaluate my sender score to improve inbox placement?
How can I get SenderScore using a DNS lookup?
How do Sender Score and Google Postmaster Tools differ in measuring email sender reputation, and when should each be used?
