Summary
Sender Score is a vital metric that reflects the reputation of your email sending IP addresses, impacting whether your emails reach the inbox or are sent to spam. A high score indicates a good reputation, built upon factors like low bounce rates and minimal spam complaints. A sudden decline in email open rates typically signals underlying deliverability problems. These issues often stem from a poor sender reputation, inadequate email authentication, sending to unengaged or outdated subscriber lists, or email content that triggers spam filters. Troubleshooting such declines requires a multi-faceted approach, including diligent monitoring of your Sender Score and other reputation metrics, ensuring robust email authentication, rigorous list hygiene, and optimizing email content for relevance and engagement. It's also critical to investigate any recent changes in your sending behavior that might have preceded the drop, as these often point directly to the cause.
Key findings
- Sender Score Definition: Sender Score, provided by Validity, is a crucial metric that evaluates the reputation of your sending IP address on a scale of 0 to 100, influencing inbox placement based on factors like sending volume, bounce rates, spam complaints, and blacklisting. It does not refer to Sender Score having its own sending infrastructure, but rather rates the IPs you use.
- Open Rate Decline Signal: A sudden decline in email open rates is a strong indicator of underlying deliverability issues, meaning emails are likely landing in spam folders or being blocked entirely, rather than reaching the inbox.
- Key Causes of Declines: The primary causes for sudden open rate drops include poor sender reputation (IP and domain), ineffective email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), stale or unengaged subscriber lists, content that triggers spam filters, increased spam complaints or bounces, and changes in sending practices like sudden volume increases.
- Troubleshooting Approaches: Effective troubleshooting involves checking reputation metrics, verifying email authentication, monitoring blocklists, reviewing email content and sending practices for spam triggers, and actively cleaning and segmenting subscriber lists. Deliverability services can also aid in placement testing.
- Beyond Technical Issues: While often technical, open rate declines can also stem from less technical issues like unengaging subject lines, irrelevant content, inconsistent sending frequency, or increased competition in the inbox, highlighting the importance of content and audience engagement.
Key considerations
- Proactive Monitoring: Regularly monitor your Sender Score and other reputation metrics using tools like Google Postmaster Tools and Microsoft SNDS. This proactive approach helps in detecting issues before they severely impact deliverability.
- Email Authentication: Consistently ensure your email authentication records (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) are correctly configured and maintained. Proper authentication is fundamental to building and maintaining sender trust with ISPs.
- List Hygiene: Implement rigorous list hygiene practices, including segmenting your audience and regularly removing unengaged, inactive, or invalid email addresses. Sending to a clean, engaged list significantly improves deliverability and open rates.
- Content Optimization: Continuously review and optimize your email content for relevance, engagement, and to avoid triggering spam filters. A/B testing subject lines and personalizing content can re-capture subscriber attention.
- Investigate Pre-Drop Events: When open rates decline, investigate any changes that occurred just prior to the drop, such as increased sending volume, altered content, or shifts in sending frequency. These can often be direct culprits.
- IP Warm-up: If using new sending IP addresses, follow a careful 'warm-up' process by gradually increasing email volume. This helps establish a positive reputation and prevents being flagged as spam by ISPs.
What email marketers say
11 marketer opinions
Expanding on the importance of proactive monitoring, a sudden decline in email open rates is a critical alert, demanding a thorough investigation into your email program's health. This often points to deliverability challenges, where emails are either being blocked or shunted to spam folders. Key culprits typically include a deterioration of your sender reputation, issues with fundamental email authentication protocols like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, or a decline in the quality and engagement of your subscriber list. Content relevance and consistency in sending practices also play significant roles. Addressing such a drop effectively requires a comprehensive strategy that spans technical checks, audience management, and content optimization, ensuring that your messages consistently reach the inbox.
Key opinions
- Sender Score Definition: Sender Score evaluates the reputation of your email sending IP addresses, not an internal forwarding service, directly influencing inbox placement based on factors like spam complaints and bounce rates.
- Reputation as a Core Cause: A leading reason for open rate drops is a damaged sender reputation, encompassing both IP and domain, often due to high complaint rates, bounces, or appearing on blacklists.
- Authentication Imperative: Inadequate or improperly configured email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) is a frequent technical root cause, hindering trust with ISPs and leading to emails being flagged as spam.
- List Hygiene Impact: Sending to unengaged, stale, or unverified subscriber lists significantly diminishes open rates, leading to negative sender feedback and reduced inboxing.
- Content and Engagement: Beyond technical aspects, unengaging subject lines, irrelevant content, or inconsistent sending frequency can cause declines, highlighting the need for content optimization and personalization.
- Pre-Drop Events: Significant changes in sending behavior, such as a sharp increase in volume, altered content, or changes in frequency, frequently precede and directly contribute to sudden drops in open rates.
Key considerations
- Monitor Reputation Tools: Regularly utilize tools like Google Postmaster Tools, Microsoft SNDS, and your Sender Score to proactively track your domain and IP reputation, catching potential issues early.
- Verify Authentication: Consistently audit and ensure the correct implementation and validity of SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records to build and maintain sender trust with Internet Service Providers (ISPs).
- Implement List Segmentation and Cleaning: Actively segment your audience and regularly remove inactive, unengaged, or invalid email addresses to improve list quality, engagement, and overall deliverability.
- Optimize Email Content: Continuously A/B test subject lines, personalize content, and review email body for elements that might trigger spam filters or reduce subscriber engagement.
- Analyze Sending Practices: Review recent changes in sending volume, frequency, and audience targeting prior to any open rate decline to identify potential triggers for deliverability issues.
- Utilize Deliverability Services: Consider employing third-party deliverability services like GlockApps for advanced testing, placement monitoring, and insights into why emails might be missing the inbox.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks explains that Sender Score's Sending IPs likely refer to relaying or forwarding services. For example, if mailbox provider A forwards emails to provider B, the IP listed in Sender Score would be from provider A.
29 Apr 2024 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks explains that Sender Score lists IP addresses that send email on behalf of your domain, rating their reputation. For sudden open rate drops, he suggests investigating pre-drop events like increases in complaints, changes in sending frequency, or sending to unsubscribed users. He also recommends signing up for Google Postmaster Tools and Microsoft SNDS for detailed reputation data.
17 Mar 2024 - Email Geeks
What the experts say
1 expert opinions
A sudden drop in email open rates signals deeper deliverability challenges that extend beyond traditional technical issues. While sender reputation, email authentication, and list quality remain crucial, recent privacy shifts, such as Apple Mail Privacy Protection, can also skew reported open rates. Furthermore, evolving ISP filtering rules and the continued relevance of your email content and subject lines significantly influence whether messages reach the inbox or are filtered out. Effective diagnosis requires a systematic review of email logs, engagement metrics, and a thorough check of your technical configuration to pinpoint and address the root causes of reduced inbox placement.
Key opinions
- Privacy Feature Impact: New privacy features like Apple Mail Privacy Protection (AMPP) can significantly alter how open rates are tracked and reported, potentially leading to misleading declines or inflated metrics.
- Evolving ISP Rules: Internet Service Providers frequently update their filtering algorithms, meaning a sudden decline can be attributed to changes in these unseen rules, requiring constant vigilance.
- Engagement and List Health: Issues stemming from low recipient engagement, poor list quality, or the presence of bot subscribers are direct contributors to emails landing in spam folders.
- Comprehensive Log Analysis: Troubleshooting effectively involves a detailed review of email logs and engagement metrics to identify patterns, errors, or specific points of failure.
- Content Relevancy Criticality: Even with perfect technical setup, less appealing subject lines and content that lacks relevance can drastically reduce open rates and overall engagement, influencing deliverability.
Key considerations
- Factor in Privacy Effects: When analyzing open rates, account for the impact of email privacy features, like Apple Mail Protection, as they can distort true engagement figures or reporting.
- Adapt to ISP Shifts: Recognize that Internet Service Provider filtering rules are dynamic; continuously adapt your sending practices and content to align with evolving deliverability standards.
- Thorough Data Analysis: Perform a comprehensive analysis of email logs and engagement metrics, such as click-through rates and unsubscribe rates, to diagnose the root cause of declining open rates beyond just the headline number.
- Sustain Engagement: Prioritize strategies to maintain high recipient engagement and regularly audit your list to identify and address unengaged or potentially bot-generated subscribers.
- Optimize for Relevance: Continuously refine your subject lines and content for maximum relevance and appeal, as even minor improvements can significantly impact whether an email is opened and valued by the recipient.
Expert view
Expert from Spam Resource explains that a sudden decline in email open rates can be due to various factors including recent privacy changes (like Apple Mail Privacy Protection affecting open rate tracking), issues with recipient engagement leading to messages going to spam, poor list quality from unengaged or bot subscribers, problems with sender reputation such as high complaint rates or bounces, technical problems like incorrect email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), changes in ISP filtering rules, or less appealing subject lines and content relevance. To troubleshoot, it's crucial to investigate these areas, checking email logs, engagement metrics, and ensuring proper technical setup.
8 Feb 2023 - Spam Resource
What the documentation says
4 technical articles
While Sender Score is a robust metric for gauging the health of your email sending infrastructure, it is crucial to understand it assesses the reputation of your own sending IP addresses, rather than providing or managing them. A sharp decline in email open rates serves as a significant red flag, frequently indicating underlying deliverability issues. Such a drop necessitates a strategic approach, focusing on bolstering your sender reputation, ensuring all email authentication protocols are correctly implemented, rigorously maintaining a clean and engaged subscriber list, and meticulously reviewing email content for any elements that might trigger spam filters. For new sending IPs, a diligent warm-up process is indispensable to establish a positive reputation and ensure consistent inbox placement.
Key findings
- Sender Score's Purpose: Sender Score is a metric that assesses the reputation of your email sending IP addresses, providing a score from 0 to 100 that influences email deliverability. It clarifies that Sender Score itself does not own or provide 'sending IPs,' but instead evaluates the reputation of those you use.
- IP Reputation Influence: Your sending IP addresses' history and behavior, including factors like volume, bounce rates, and spam complaints, significantly shape the Sender Score associated with them.
- IP Warm-up Necessity: New IP addresses require a careful, gradual warm-up process to build a positive sending reputation and avoid being flagged as spam by Internet Service Providers.
- Open Rate as Deliverability Metric: A sudden drop in email open rates is a primary indicator of deliverability problems, signifying emails are not consistently reaching the recipient's inbox.
- Troubleshooting Fundamentals: Effective troubleshooting for open rate declines involves verifying email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), monitoring overall sender reputation, implementing rigorous list hygiene, and optimizing email content to avoid spam triggers.
Key considerations
- Understand Sender Score's Function: Recognize that Sender Score is a diagnostic tool for your IP reputation, emphasizing the importance of managing the performance of your own sending infrastructure rather than it providing IPs.
- Strategic IP Warm-up: When deploying new sending IP addresses, plan and execute a methodical warm-up strategy to gradually increase sending volume and establish trust with Internet Service Providers.
- Comprehensive Authentication Checks: Periodically review and ensure all email authentication protocols, including SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, are accurately set up and maintained to build sender trust.
- Proactive List Management: Consistently clean your subscriber lists by removing unengaged or invalid addresses to improve engagement metrics and reduce negative feedback from ISPs.
- Content and Reputation Synergy: Review email content for potential spam triggers and ensure it is relevant and engaging, as content quality directly influences recipient interaction and, consequently, your sender reputation.
Technical article
Documentation from Validity explains that Sender Score is a metric provided by Validity that evaluates the reputation of an IP address on a scale of 0 to 100. A higher score indicates a better reputation, increasing the likelihood of emails reaching the inbox. It assesses the IP's sending behavior, including volume, bounce rates, spam complaints, and blacklisting, but does not refer to Sender Score having its own "sending IPs."
24 Jul 2024 - Validity (Sender Score)
Technical article
Documentation from Postmark explains that Sender Score is heavily influenced by the history and behavior of your sending IP addresses. New IPs require a careful "warm-up" process, gradually increasing email volume over time, to build a positive sending reputation and avoid being flagged as spam, which directly impacts the Sender Score associated with those IPs.
2 Oct 2024 - Postmark Blog
How to troubleshoot and address a dropping email sender score?
How to troubleshoot sudden drops in email open rates for a large newsletter?
What causes unexpected IP addresses to appear on Senderscore for dedicated IPs?
Why did my email open rates drop after increasing sending volume on a shared IP?
Why has my sender score dropped and what can I do about it?
Why is my email sender score low and what can I do about it?
