Suped

What are the differences between BIMI and Apple Branded Mail, and do you need both for email branding?

Published 25 Jun 2025
Updated 12 Oct 2026
14 min read
Summarize with
BIMI and Apple Branded Mail email logo branding, with an envelope, DNS tile, and Apple logo.
Updated on 12 Oct 2026: We clarified certificate choices, Apple Branded Mail requirements, and the DMARC rules behind email logo display.
BIMI and Apple Branded Mail are different ways to show a brand logo in email clients. BIMI (Brand Indicators for Message Identification) is an open email specification that relies on DNS, DMARC enforcement, a brand logo file, and in many major inboxes a VMC or CMC certificate. Apple Branded Mail is an Apple Business feature that lets a verified organization show its logo and brand name in Apple's Mail experience.
Both are optional. Use both when their combined coverage justifies the separate setup and review work. BIMI helps with mailbox providers that support BIMI, such as Gmail, Yahoo, Fastmail, and Apple iCloud Mail. Apple Branded Mail covers Apple's managed display path in Mail on supported-language iPhones and in iCloud Mail on the web. A mailbox opened in Apple's Mail app is a different display environment from the same mailbox opened in its provider's app.
Apple Branded Mail is not a BIMI replacement. It is an Apple-specific brand layer that sits next to BIMI. Start with DKIM and DMARC because both paths depend on trustworthy authentication, then decide whether the extra Apple setup is worth it based on the audience that uses Apple's supported Mail experiences.

Choose BIMI, Apple Branded Mail, or both

BIMI answers the question, "Can participating mailbox providers find and verify my brand logo through email standards?" Apple Branded Mail answers the question, "Can Apple connect my verified organization, brand, and sending identity to a logo in its supported Mail experiences?" Those overlap, but they do not produce identical coverage.
  1. Prioritize BIMI when broader mailbox-provider coverage is the goal. BIMI is tied directly to your email authentication program.
  2. Use Apple Branded Mail when Apple's supported Mail experiences are a meaningful share of customer engagement. It can be your first logo program because it does not depend on BIMI or a purchased mark certificate.
  3. Both logo paths require DMARC enforcement, and Apple also requires customer mail to authenticate with DKIM. Use DMARC monitoring before changing policy or adding brand-logo records.
  4. BIMI and Apple Branded Mail have different logo formats, review paths, and failure modes.
BIMI
  1. The identity comes from a DNS record at your sending domain, plus a hosted SVG logo file.
  2. Trust depends on DMARC enforcement, logo validation, sender reputation, and certificate rules where required.
  3. BIMI supports brand display across inboxes that choose to support it.
Apple Branded Mail
  1. The identity comes from Apple Business organization verification, brand approval, and enrolled sending identities.
  2. Trust depends on Apple's organization review, domain verification, DKIM, and DMARC checks.
  3. Branded Mail supports brand display in Mail on supported-language iPhones and in iCloud Mail on the web.

BIMI and Apple Branded Mail compared

The simplest way to think about the split is that BIMI is published by the sending domain and evaluated by each receiver, while Apple Branded Mail is enrolled and reviewed inside Apple Business. BIMI asks the receiving mailbox provider to fetch your DNS record, verify the logo rules, and decide whether to show the logo. Apple asks you to connect a verified organization and approved brand with a verified sending domain or address.

Area

BIMI

Apple Branded Mail

Setup
DNS TXT
Apple Business
Logo
SVG Tiny PS
Approved 1:1 image
DMARC
p=quarantine or p=reject
Enforcement for the enrolled identity
DKIM
Passing SPF or DKIM must match the From domain under DMARC rules
DKIM required, plus DMARC pass
Certificate
Provider-dependent
No VMC or CMC
Display
Receiver-decided
Apple-decided
Scope
Participating inboxes
Supported Apple Mail experiences
Compact comparison of BIMI and Apple Branded Mail.
The certificate row is where many teams get surprised. A self-asserted BIMI record can exist without a VMC or CMC, but support is limited and major display cases require one of these certificates. Apple Branded Mail uses Apple's organization, brand, and domain review instead of a BIMI certificate. Apple Business registration and Branded Mail are free, while BIMI certificate costs vary.
DMARC enforcement is the shared requirement
Both BIMI and Apple Branded Mail require DMARC at enforcement. Apple requires p=quarantine or p=reject, or an enforcing parent-domain sp policy for an enrolled subdomain. All customer mail must authenticate with DKIM. Fix legitimate authentication failures before working on brand display.
Apple's enrollment requirements still request pct=100. RFC 9989 removed pct from DMARC; receivers implementing that standard ignore it. Retain pct=100 for Apple's documented enrollment checks. It is a compatibility setting and no longer controls policy sampling under RFC 9989.

VMC and CMC requirements by provider

A Verified Mark Certificate (VMC) and a Common Mark Certificate (CMC) are paid certificates with independent validation. A self-asserted BIMI record has no certificate. A VMC normally requires a registered trademark or recognized government mark. Under the mark certificate requirements, a prior-use CMC requires evidence that the logo appeared on the verified domain at least 12 months earlier. A CMC also has a modified-registered-mark route.

Display path

Certificate requirement

What to expect

Gmail BIMI
VMC or CMC
Both support logo display; only a VMC qualifies for Gmail's verification checkmark.
Yahoo and Fastmail BIMI
Certificate not mandatory
Self-asserted logos are supported, subject to the provider's other display criteria.
Apple Mail BIMI
Supported BIMI evidence document
Apple documents VMCs and other evidence documents. Confirm certificate acceptance and mailbox-provider support before buying.
Apple Branded Mail
No VMC or CMC
Apple reviews the organization and brand separately from BIMI.
Certificate acceptance and logo display depend on the receiving provider.
Google's BIMI requirements distinguish a logo from the verification checkmark. The BIMI Group's certificate guidance distinguishes self-asserted records from VMCs and CMCs. Budget for certificate renewal where required; Apple Branded Mail approval does not provide a Gmail logo or checkmark.

How BIMI works

BIMI starts with your sending domain. You publish a DNS TXT record, point it at a compliant SVG logo, and include a certificate URL when the receiving mailbox provider expects one. Before any of that matters, the message has to pass DMARC using the visible From domain. For a deeper setup path, the BIMI setup workflow covers the practical pieces.
The BIMI record itself is not complicated. The hard parts are SVG Tiny PS formatting, certificate eligibility, trademark or prior-use proof, DNS correctness, sender reputation, and the time mailbox providers take to cache and re-check the record. Replace the example domains, asset URLs, and reporting address with your own values. Strict SPF and DKIM domain matching is not required for either branding path; this example uses DMARC's default relaxed rules.
Example BIMI record and Apple-compatible DMARC policydns
default._bimi.example.com. 3600 IN TXT ( "v=BIMI1; " "l=https://assets.example.com/bimi.svg; " "a=https://assets.example.com/vmc.pem" ) _dmarc.example.com. 3600 IN TXT ( "v=DMARC1; p=quarantine; rua=mailto:dmarc@example.com; " "pct=100" )
Before publishing or changing a BIMI record, validate the DMARC side first. Suped's DMARC checker helps identify a missing tag, malformed reporting address, or non-enforcement policy that can stop the logo work from producing visible results.
BIMI email logo display path: DMARC pass, BIMI DNS record, SVG logo, certificate, and inbox display.
BIMI email logo display path: DMARC pass, BIMI DNS record, SVG logo, certificate, and inbox display.

How Apple Branded Mail works

Apple Business Connect Branded Mail setup showing email domain verification and logo review.
Apple Business Connect Branded Mail setup showing email domain verification and logo review.
Apple Branded Mail is configured through Apple Business. Apple moved the brand tools previously found in Apple Business Connect into Apple Business on April 14, 2026, and existing account data migrated automatically. The organization verifies its identity, adds an approved brand and logo, enrolls a sending domain or address, completes DNS verification, and waits for review. Use Brands > Branded Mail, then Set Up Branded Mail.
  1. Apple verifies the organization behind the brand, not only the email domain.
  2. You prove control of the sending domain with Apple's DNS verification record.
  3. Apple reviews the brand and uploaded logo rather than reading a BIMI SVG file.
  4. The current documented targets are Mail on iPhone with a supported default language and iCloud Mail on the web.
Test the mailbox and app combination
A mailbox provider's app and the same mailbox opened in Apple's Mail app are separate logo-display situations. Branded Mail uses Apple's enrolled business identity, so test each client and account combination your audience actually uses.
Apple's BIMI documentation lists support in iOS 16, iPadOS 16, macOS Ventura 13 or later, and on iCloud.com. Both the sender and mailbox provider must meet Apple Mail requirements. That device coverage is separate from Branded Mail's documented iPhone and web coverage. The where BIMI appears guide helps set realistic display expectations.

Current Apple Branded Mail requirements

Apple's current setup rules are more specific than checking for any DMARC record. Confirm the sending identity and authentication state before starting the 14-day domain-verification window.
  1. The organization, brand, brand name, and logo need Apple approval.
  2. Use an Apple Business role with permission to manage Branded Mail. Franchisees need to work with the brand owner to use it.
  3. Use a domain associated with the business. Public consumer mailbox domains cannot be enrolled as the brand's sending domain.
  4. Use a 1:1 HEIF, JPEG, PNG, or SVG file between 1024 by 1024 and 4864 by 4864 pixels. Preview it in square and circular crops before review.
  5. The domain needs an MX, A, or AAAA record.
  6. Use DMARC with p=quarantine or p=reject, or an enforcing sp policy on the parent domain for an enrolled subdomain. Follow Apple's published pct=100 enrollment requirement. Every customer email must authenticate with DKIM because SPF alone is not supported.
  7. Enroll a root domain, a subdomain, or a specific address. One brand can have up to 100 combined domains, subdomains, and addresses.
  8. Complete domain verification within 14 calendar days. Apple's review can take up to seven business days. If the verification window expires, restart verification.
Current display availability includes Mail on iPhone when the default language is English, Portuguese, French, Italian, German, Spanish, or Simplified Chinese, plus iCloud Mail on the web. Check Apple's regional availability before planning a launch. See Apple's Branded Mail requirements for the supported display environments and enrollment limits.

Do you need both?

Use both when branded inbox display has measurable value and Apple's supported Mail audience is large enough to justify another verification process. If your team has limited bandwidth, get DKIM and DMARC stable first. Then choose the first logo program based on supported clients, certificate budget, and brand-verification readiness.
Use audience evidence rather than a fixed Apple Mail percentage. Apple's Mail Privacy Protection downloads remote content in the background, so tracked opens do not reliably establish human engagement or the supported devices your readers use. Combine client testing with first-party audience information and business value when deciding whether to add Branded Mail.
Apple Branded Mail can still matter with a smaller audience share. Stores with physical locations, appointment-based services, financial institutions, travel brands, and healthcare senders can benefit when the brand name and logo reduce confusion around time-sensitive messages.
?

What's your domain score?

Deep-scan SPF, DKIM & DMARC records for email deliverability and security issues.

Before putting time into either logo path, check the whole domain rather than only the BIMI record. Suped's domain health checker checks published SPF and DMARC records and DKIM keys at common selectors. Use Suped's DMARC reports to identify sending sources and inspect actual authentication results. If a key is not found, check the selector in a real message; a DNS scan alone cannot prove that every email passes.
BIMI alone is enough when
  1. Apple's supported Mail experiences are not a meaningful part of customer engagement.
  2. Apple enrollment has no clear additional business value for the program.
  3. Your target mailbox providers already display the BIMI logo consistently.
Both make sense when
  1. Apple's supported Mail experiences account for meaningful customer engagement.
  2. The brand sends invoices, alerts, booking updates, or account emails.
  3. You can complete organization verification and keep the sending domain authenticated.
Stabilize the authentication layer before working on logo display. All legitimate senders should pass DMARC, reporting should be monitored, and policy changes should be staged against real sending data.
  1. List every platform that sends as your domain, including marketing, billing, support, CRM, and internal systems.
  2. Set up SPF and DKIM for legitimate senders. DMARC passes when either passing method matches the visible From domain under relaxed or strict rules; Apple Branded Mail also requires DKIM. Move to quarantine or reject after reports confirm sender coverage.
  3. Choose the first branding path based on recipient coverage and budget. For BIMI, prepare the SVG Tiny PS logo, certificate if required, and DNS record. For Apple Branded Mail, complete organization review, brand approval, and domain verification.
  4. Add the other branding path when it provides useful coverage. BIMI adds participating mailbox providers; Apple Branded Mail adds Apple's enrolled brand-display path.
  5. Check each supported app, mailbox provider, sending domain, and address combination that matters to your audience.
Suped's DMARC reporting and email authentication platform supports the authentication work behind either logo path. Its DMARC reports and SPF and DKIM results help teams identify failing senders, stage DMARC enforcement, and watch for regressions before and after brand enrollment.
Hosted DMARC configuration dialog showing policy controls, CNAME setup, and expanded advanced options
Hosted policy management helps when teams need to stage DMARC safely before BIMI or Apple review. Suped's hosted DMARC workflow keeps policy changes, reporting, and verification checks in the same operational loop.
The practical rule
Do not judge success by whether one test inbox shows a logo. Judge success by authenticated mail volume, DMARC pass rates, policy state, and repeatable logo display across the client and mailbox combinations your customers use. Logo display does not guarantee inbox placement or higher open rates.

Common mistakes

Most failures are sequencing problems. A team buys a certificate before DMARC is stable, starts Apple review before confirming that every customer message passes DKIM, or tests one inbox and assumes the logo program is broken.

Symptom

Likely cause

First check

No logo
Policy not enforced
Effective p or sp policy; Apple's documented pct check
Provider app works
Client path differs
Apple Mail test
Apple display fails
Review or DKIM issue
Apple Business status
Some mail fails
Sender gap
DMARC sources
Common logo-display failures and the first thing to check.
Another common issue is subdomain control. BIMI Group's subdomain guidance explains that a receiver checks the From domain and can fall back to the organizational domain when no BIMI record is found there. A subdomain record can specify a different logo. DMARC policy also needs to be checked at the effective domain. Apple Branded Mail can cover a root domain and its subdomains, or use more specific subdomain and address enrollments. If marketing mail uses mail.example.com and billing uses example.com, treat those as separate authentication and display test cases.
BIMI and Apple Branded Mail troubleshooting: authentication, DNS records, client tests, and caching.
BIMI and Apple Branded Mail troubleshooting: authentication, DNS records, client tests, and caching.

Views from the trenches

Best practices
Test BIMI and Apple display separately because mailbox app choice changes logo behavior.
Move DMARC to enforcement and confirm DKIM before expecting stable Apple branding.
Track supported Apple Mail usage before starting a second brand verification process.
Common pitfalls
Assuming one mailbox behaves the same in every app leads to misleading test results.
Publishing BIMI before sender authentication is stable makes logo troubleshooting slow.
Using one test mailbox hides client-specific caching and provider display differences.
Expert tips
Keep a client matrix covering the mailbox apps and providers your audience uses most.
Verify each sending subdomain used by campaigns, billing, support, and product mail.
Recheck reports after launch because a new failing sender can interrupt logo display.

Expert view

An Email Geeks participant says Apple Branded Mail adds value for brands with physical locations because Apple connects mail identity with the broader business profile.
2025-03-25 - Email Geeks

Expert view

An Email Geeks participant says Apple Branded Mail can cover account and app combinations where BIMI alone does not display consistently.
2025-03-25 - Email Geeks

Practical recommendation

If BIMI already works, Apple Branded Mail is still worth evaluating. It adds coverage when a meaningful share of customers uses Mail on a supported-language iPhone or iCloud Mail on the web. It covers an Apple-managed display path that BIMI does not consistently cover across every mailbox and client combination.
If BIMI is not set up yet, start with authentication: identify sending sources, make DKIM pass with a signing domain that matches the visible From domain under DMARC rules, configure SPF, monitor DMARC reports, and move to enforcement. Then choose BIMI or Apple Branded Mail based on your target clients and certificate budget.

Frequently asked questions

No. BIMI is a DNS-based email standard evaluated by participating receivers. Apple Branded Mail is an Apple Business feature for verified organizations in Apple's supported Mail experiences.

No. Apple Branded Mail does not use a BIMI VMC or CMC as its approval path. Apple uses its own organization, brand, and domain verification process.

Yes. Apple requires every customer email to authenticate with DKIM. Authentication only by SPF is not supported for Branded Mail.

Do not assume it will. BIMI appears in Apple Mail only when the sender and email service provider meet the applicable BIMI and Apple Mail requirements, so test the specific account and client combination.

Start with DKIM and DMARC enforcement. Apple Branded Mail can be the first logo program when its supported audience matters and you want to avoid buying a BIMI certificate. Add BIMI for other participating providers when coverage justifies the asset work and any required certificate.

Test each supported mailbox app, provider, sending domain, subdomain, and approved address used by the brand. Recheck DMARC data after launch for new authentication failures.
DMARC monitoring

Start monitoring your DMARC reports today

Suped DMARC platform dashboard
What you'll get with Suped
Real-time DMARC report monitoring and analysis
Automated alerts for authentication failures
Clear recommendations to improve email deliverability
Protection against phishing and domain spoofing