Summary
It can be confusing and concerning when an email appears to have been opened, sometimes multiple times, only to later show up as bounced. This seemingly contradictory behavior is a common phenomenon in email deliverability, often stemming from the intricate processes involved in how emails are received, scanned, and reported by recipient mail servers and email service providers (ESPs). The primary reason for this lies in the way email opens are tracked, which typically relies on a small, invisible pixel embedded in the email. When this pixel is loaded, it registers as an "open" by your ESP. However, this pixel can be loaded by automated systems, such as spam filters, security scanners, or pre-fetch mechanisms, before the email is fully delivered to the recipient's inbox or before a final delivery decision is made by the recipient's mail server. Consequently, a bounce notification, which is a definitive delivery failure message from the recipient's server, can arrive later, after the initial pixel load has already been recorded as an open.
Key findings
- Automated engagement: Many email security systems and mail transfer agents (MTAs) automatically download email content, including tracking pixels, to scan for malicious links or spam before the email reaches the recipient's inbox. This triggers an "open" event without human interaction.
- Delayed bounce reports: Bounce notifications (Non-Delivery Reports or NDRs) can sometimes be delayed. An email might initially be accepted by the receiving server, triggering an open pixel, but then later be rejected and bounced back for reasons discovered during deeper content analysis or after multiple delivery attempts. For example, a soft bounce may occur if an inbox is full.
- Server-side filtering: Some recipient mail servers perform extensive checks on email content and links after initial acceptance but before final delivery to the user's mailbox. If issues are found, the email may be bounced (even if temporarily) after the tracking pixel has fired.
- Greylisting: Temporary rejections (like greylisting) can lead to multiple delivery attempts. An initial attempt might trigger an open pixel (if the server downloads content for scanning), and a later attempt might then be hard bounced if the recipient address is ultimately invalid or has been moved. This highlights why bounce notifications vary.
Key considerations
- Open rate accuracy: Recognize that reported open rates may not always reflect genuine human engagement due to automated processes.
- Bounce type analysis: Differentiate between soft bounces (temporary issues) and hard bounces (permanent failures). The context of the bounce is crucial.
- Recipient server behavior: Understand that different mail servers have varying policies for email acceptance, scanning, and bounce reporting, leading to diverse behaviors.
- Log investigation: For specific cases, checking detailed MTA logs from your ESP can provide clarity on the sequence of events and the precise reason for the bounce.
What email marketers say
Email marketers frequently encounter the perplexing scenario of an email appearing opened before a bounce is registered. This discrepancy often leads to confusion about campaign performance and list hygiene. The consensus among marketers points to automated systems interacting with emails, rather than human recipients, as the primary cause for these phantom opens. It underscores the importance of interpreting engagement metrics with a nuanced understanding of how mail flow and security mechanisms operate. Understanding this helps marketers adjust their strategies, ensuring they focus on genuine engagement while also maintaining a clean and healthy email list.
Key opinions
- Bot activity: Many marketers attribute opens followed by bounces to bots or security scanners at the recipient's mail server. These automated systems open emails to check for malicious content or spam before a delivery decision is finalized.
- Filtering layer interaction: There are instances where an organization's internal filtering system interacts with an email and generates an open event, even if the email is later rejected. This could be due to a human intervention or automated rule within the filtering system.
- ESP reporting quirks: Some marketers suspect that the timing of how ESPs record opens versus process bounces can lead to this observed anomaly, suggesting a reporting lag or specific internal processing order.
- Pre-delivery scans: The pixel loading (and thus the open report) can happen while the email is still in a pending state or being scanned before it's officially delivered or bounced.
Key considerations
- Auditing open metrics: Marketers should be aware that their reported open rates might include automated interactions and not solely human engagement.
- List cleaning: Regardless of phantom opens, a hard bounce signifies an undeliverable address and should be removed from the mailing list to protect sender reputation.
- Bounce tracking: Rely on the bounce status as the definitive indicator of delivery failure, even if an open was previously recorded.
- ESP support: If encountering frequent instances, consult your ESP's support documentation or team for insights into their specific tracking and reporting mechanisms.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks explains that opens recorded before a bounce are often not true human engagement. Instead, they are typically triggered by machines downloading assets within the email before a final delivery decision is made, indicating that the recipient's server scanned the content.
Marketer view
Marketer from Respona suggests that a common reason for emails bouncing back is when the recipient's inbox is full or when the email address is non-existent, but automated systems can still trigger opens during initial scanning. This means an email might be previewed by a server before a full bounce is declared.
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts highlight that the phenomenon of an email bouncing after being opened is a nuanced issue rooted in the technical intricacies of email delivery protocols and recipient server behaviors. They emphasize that "opens" as reported by ESPs often do not equate to human engagement, especially in the context of post-delivery bounces. The critical takeaway is that many security and filtering systems inspect email content, including loading tracking pixels, before making a final decision on whether to accept or reject an email. This pre-delivery scanning can mistakenly trigger an "open" event. Therefore, understanding the underlying mail flow, including SMTP stages and potential greylisting behaviors, is key to deciphering these reports.
Key opinions
- Machine-triggered opens: Experts universally agree that automated systems (such as spam filters and security scanners) at the recipient's end download email assets, including tracking pixels, before deciding to deliver or bounce the email. This is not a human open.
- Post-DATA rejection: Some recipient mail servers, like Yahoo, accept the entire email content (after the SMTP DATA command) before determining if the address exists or if the content is acceptable. They may then reject the message, leading to a bounce after an open pixel has fired.
- Temporary failures: Servers can issue temporary failures (e.g., 4xx SMTP codes) after receiving the email data. During a subsequent re-delivery attempt, the server may have completed its analysis and decided on a hard bounce, even if the initial attempt caused an open. This can also happen when an email hard bounces for a seemingly valid address.
- Sending queue interaction: It's possible for opens and clicks to be registered while an email is still technically in the sending queue or being processed by the recipient's system, before a definitive delivery or bounce status is determined.
Key considerations
- SMTP protocol understanding: A deep understanding of the SMTP protocol, particularly the difference between initial handshake and post-DATA processing, is crucial.
- Bounce reporting accuracy: Prioritize bounce reports over initial open metrics for determining ultimate deliverability, as they represent a definitive rejection.
- ISP-specific behaviors: Be aware that large ISPs (Internet Service Providers) like Yahoo have unique ways of processing emails and reporting bounces, which can influence these observed phenomena.
- Deliverability metrics: Focus on deliverability and inbox placement rates as more reliable indicators than raw open rates, especially when bounces occur after recorded opens. Refer to Mailgun's insights on what to do about email bounces.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks explains that opens, as measured by tracking pixels, are simply recordings of asset downloads. It's highly probable that a machine, such as a spam filter, reviewed the email and downloaded these assets, then subsequently decided to bounce the message rather than a human recipient.
Expert view
Expert from SpamResource clarifies that opens before bounces are a known issue, frequently caused by security scanning. These scanners typically download email content to check for threats, firing the open pixel, before the email is ultimately blocked or bounced due to policy violations or other issues.
What the documentation says
Official documentation from various email service providers and industry standards sheds light on the technical reasons behind emails bouncing after being opened. The core explanation often revolves around the sequence of events during email delivery and the limitations of open tracking. Documentation confirms that an "open" is typically registered when an embedded pixel image is loaded. This can happen during various stages of mail processing, including automated pre-scanning by security software or a temporary acceptance by the recipient's mail server. The final bounce decision, however, is a separate process that can occur later, after content analysis or subsequent delivery attempts. This is particularly relevant for scenarios like mailbox full bounces where an open precedes the bounce.
Key findings
- Open tracking mechanism: ESPs use a tracking pixel that, when loaded, registers an open. This load can be triggered by automated systems or a human interaction.
- Security scanning: Recipient mail servers and security appliances often scan incoming emails for viruses, spam, and phishing attempts, which involves downloading all content, including tracking pixels, before delivery.
- SMTP delivery stages: A mail server might initially accept an email (triggering an open) but then later reject it (bounce) after a deeper content analysis or if the recipient's mailbox is found to be full or inactive during subsequent processing.
- Temporary vs. permanent bounces: Documentation often distinguishes between soft bounces (temporary issues) and hard bounces (permanent failures), with soft bounces being more likely to occur after an initial open, pending further attempts or resolution.
Key considerations
- Reporting discrepancies: ESPs' reporting dashboards may show opens before bounces due to the sequence in which events are recorded versus final delivery outcomes.
- Understanding bounce codes: Familiarize yourself with common SMTP bounce codes to understand the specific reason for delivery failure, irrespective of prior open activity.
- Impact on deliverability: Hard bounces, even if preceded by an open, should lead to immediate list removal to maintain sender reputation, as explained in Mailchimp's guide on soft versus hard bounces.
- Inbox behavior: Recognize that recipient systems prioritize security and filtering, sometimes at the expense of immediately clear deliverability metrics.
Technical article
Documentation from Klaviyo Help Center clarifies that a soft bounce is always caused by a temporary reason, such as when a recipient's inbox is full or their email server is momentarily down. These temporary issues could still allow an initial scan that triggers an open pixel before the final bounce is reported.
Technical article
Documentation from Mailchimp explains that soft bounces indicate a temporary delivery issue and are handled differently than hard bounces. When an email soft bounces, it typically means there was a temporary inability to deliver, but during that process, automated systems might have loaded the email's content.
Related resources
10 resources
Related pages
Why are emails hard bouncing then opening and clicking links later?
Why do email bounce notifications differ and why might bounced emails be marked as read?
Why am I seeing bounces for mailbox full followed by opens?
Why did a valid email address hard bounce, and how can I resolve it?
Understanding email greylisting and how it works
Is it bad to email addresses that keep soft bouncing?
How do I troubleshoot email bounce messages?
Why am I getting soft bounces and how do I fix them?
Why Your Emails Are Going to Spam in 2024 and How to Fix It
Email Deliverability Issues: Getting Your Messages to the Inbox in 2025
