Summary
Gmail inboxing fluctuations, characterized by a temporary 100% inbox rate followed by a subsequent drop to 0%, arise from a complex interplay of factors influencing sender reputation, authentication, content, user engagement, and adherence to regulations. A single successful campaign is insufficient to guarantee consistent inboxing if underlying issues related to these factors persist. Gmail’s filtering system considers various aspects of the sender, the message, and the recipient interactions. Temporary improvements in deliverability from seed lists can be misleading, and focusing on engaged recipients is critical for maintaining a positive sender reputation. Correctly configuring authentication protocols (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) and adhering to CAN-SPAM regulations are essential. Google prioritizes recipient behavior over spam traps. Inconsistent filtering indicates potential problems with content or list segmentation. Poor list hygiene, sudden spikes in sending volume, and the use of shared IPs can negatively impact deliverability. Regular monitoring, testing, and analysis are crucial for identifying and resolving deliverability issues.
Key findings
- Sender Reputation Dominance: A low or inconsistent sender reputation is a primary driver of erratic Gmail inboxing. Past engagement or deliverability issues can outweigh temporary successes.
- Authentication Integrity: Missing or improperly configured authentication protocols (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) make it harder for mailbox providers to verify sender identity and affect deliverability.
- List Hygiene Importance: Poor list hygiene, including sending to inactive or unengaged subscribers, negatively impacts sender reputation.
- Gradual Sending Volume: Drastic increases in sending volume without warming up the IP address trigger spam filters.
- Seed List Unreliability: Seed list results may be unreliable; temporary positive results may not reflect real-world deliverability.
- Content Vulnerability: Spam trigger words or poorly formatted HTML can cause emails to be filtered.
- Engagement-Driven Filtering: Recipient behavior and engagement significantly influence Gmail filtering decisions.
- CAN-SPAM Adherence: Adherence to CAN-SPAM regulations, including including a physical postal address, is critical for avoiding being flagged as spam.
- Harvested List Detriment: Sending to harvested email addresses hurts sender reputation.
- Audience Based Filters: Gmail might be filtering based on the recipient audience, with the fact that the email was delivered when fewer Gmail addresses were included suggesting stringent targeting is needed.
Key considerations
- Consistent Reputation Monitoring: Regularly monitor sender reputation using tools like Google Postmaster Tools.
- Proactive List Cleaning: Implement a process for removing inactive subscribers and managing bounces to improve list hygiene.
- Cautious IP Warm-up: If using a new IP address, gradually increase sending volume to build trust and avoid triggering spam filters.
- Robust Authentication: Properly configure SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records to authenticate your sending domain effectively.
- Scrutinize Email Content: Use spam checkers to identify and remove spam trigger words and improve HTML formatting before sending emails.
- Dedicated IP Consideration: Consider using a dedicated IP address to avoid deliverability issues caused by other senders on a shared IP.
- Compliance Vigilance: Ensure strict compliance with all aspects of CAN-SPAM regulations, including including a physical postal address, and an easy to use opt-out mechanism.
- Engagement-based Segmentation: Segment list based on engagement levels to help improve deliverability by sending relevant content to active users.
- Continuous Testing: Regularly test email deliverability and analyze campaigns to identify potential issues.
- Review Targeting: Ensure your email targeting is stringent.
What email marketers say
11 marketer opinions
The inconsistent inboxing in Gmail, characterized by a temporary 100% inbox rate followed by a drop to 0%, is attributed to a combination of factors influencing sender reputation and email filtering. These include sender reputation, spam traps, list hygiene, sending volume, authentication issues, content triggers, shared IP issues, recipient engagement, and CAN-SPAM compliance. A single successful campaign doesn't guarantee consistent inboxing if other factors are negatively impacting deliverability.
Key opinions
- Sender Reputation: Low or inconsistent sender reputation is a primary driver of deliverability issues. Past poor engagement or deliverability can outweigh temporary success.
- Spam Traps: Hitting spam traps severely damages sender reputation, leading to deliverability problems.
- List Hygiene: Poor list hygiene, including inactive subscribers, negatively impacts sender reputation.
- Sending Volume: Drastic increases in sending volume without proper IP warm-up trigger spam filters.
- Authentication: Missing or misconfigured authentication protocols (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) hinder email verification.
- Content Triggers: Spam trigger words or poorly formatted HTML can cause emails to be filtered.
- Shared IP: Using a shared IP address exposes you to the deliverability issues caused by other users.
- Seed List: Seed list results may be unreliable. Temporary positive results may not reflect real-world deliverability.
- Recipient Engagement: Gmail uses recipient engagement to filter emails. A lack of engagement will impact deliverability.
- CAN-SPAM Compliance: CAN-SPAM Act requires a physical postal address in your emails. Not including it can trigger the spam folder.
Key considerations
- Monitor Reputation: Regularly monitor your sender reputation using tools like Google Postmaster Tools.
- Clean Your List: Implement a process for removing inactive subscribers and managing bounces.
- Warm-Up IP: If using a new IP address, gradually increase sending volume to build trust.
- Authenticate Emails: Properly configure SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records to authenticate your sending domain.
- Check Content: Use spam checkers to identify and remove spam trigger words and improve HTML formatting.
- Consider Dedicated IP: For high-volume sending, consider using a dedicated IP address to avoid issues caused by other senders.
- Address & Opt-out: Comply with CAN-SPAM by including a physical postal address and an easy opt-out mechanism.
- Test Deliverability: Test your email deliverability with seed lists or other testing tools.
- Analyse Recipient Behaviour: Continuously test email deliverability with seed lists and real email addresses.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Reddit shares that seed list results can be unreliable. A small seed list might show temporary positive results that don't reflect real-world deliverability.
28 Nov 2021 - Reddit
Marketer view
Email marketer from Postmark discusses that CAN-SPAM Act requires that you include a physical postal address in your emails. Not including a valid physical postal address can get emails flagged as spam.
15 Oct 2021 - Postmark
What the experts say
8 expert opinions
The fluctuations in Gmail inboxing, from 100% to 0%, are attributed to a combination of factors. Focusing on highly engaged recipients can help improve sender reputation, and Gmail's filtering is influenced by the recipient audience and their behaviors. While spam traps aren't a primary focus for Gmail, content variations, sender reputation, and adherence to regulations like CAN-SPAM are crucial. Sending to harvested addresses is detrimental. Inconsistent filtering may point to content or segmentation issues. Continuous testing and monitoring are essential for identifying and resolving deliverability problems.
Key opinions
- Recipient Engagement: Focusing sends on highly engaged recipients improves sender reputation and overall deliverability.
- Recipient Audience: Gmail filters based on the recipient audience. Stringent targeting and avoiding harvested addresses are crucial.
- Spam Traps (Gmail): Gmail prioritizes recipient behavior and engagement over traditional spam traps.
- Content Variation: Inconsistent filtering can arise from variations in email content triggering different filters.
- Sender Reputation: Deliverability is significantly impacted by sender reputation, which needs continuous monitoring.
- CAN-SPAM Compliance: Compliance with CAN-SPAM, including accurate headers, a physical address, and an opt-out mechanism, is critical.
- Harvested Addresses: Sending to harvested email addresses is detrimental and damages sender reputation.
Key considerations
- Targeted Sending: Prioritize sending to segments of your list that demonstrate high engagement (opens, clicks).
- Audience Analysis: Analyze your recipient audience to identify and remove problematic addresses and ensure relevant targeting.
- Content Review: Regularly review your email content for potential spam triggers or inconsistencies.
- CAN-SPAM Compliance: Ensure strict compliance with all aspects of CAN-SPAM regulations.
- Continuous Monitoring: Continuously monitor your sender reputation and deliverability metrics to identify and address issues promptly.
- Testing and Analysis: Regularly test and analyze your email campaigns to help identify the root cause of deliverability issues.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks explains that Google doesn't rely on spam traps. Recipient behavior and engagement are more important factors.
30 Jun 2021 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from SpamResource explains that inconsistent filtering can occur if only a specific segment of your list is experiencing the issue, or if variations in your email content are triggering different filters. Review the content of the emails that are being filtered to identify potential issues.
13 Jun 2023 - SpamResource
What the documentation says
4 technical articles
Gmail inboxing fluctuations, characterized by a sudden drop from 100% inbox to 0%, stem from Gmail's complex filtering system. This system evaluates sender reputation, email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), content quality, and user engagement. Incorrectly configured or temporarily broken SPF, DKIM, or DMARC records, or a DMARC policy set to 'reject' or 'quarantine', can also lead to deliverability issues.
Key findings
- Gmail Filtering Factors: Gmail considers sender reputation, authentication, content, and user engagement when filtering emails.
- Sudden Shifts: Sudden shifts in sender reputation, authentication configuration, or other factors cause inboxing fluctuations.
- SPF Impact: Incorrect or incomplete SPF records cause authentication failures and spam filtering.
- DMARC Impact: A DMARC policy set to 'reject' or 'quarantine' prevents unauthenticated emails from reaching the inbox.
- DKIM Impact: Invalid, modified, or missing DKIM signatures flag emails as spam.
Key considerations
- Evaluate Sender Factors: Regularly evaluate sender reputation, authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), content quality, and user engagement.
- Authentication Verification: Verify that SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records are properly configured and valid.
- DMARC Policy Review: Review DMARC policies to ensure that they are not inadvertently blocking legitimate emails.
- DKIM Signature Check: Ensure DKIM signatures are valid and the emails are not modified during transit.
Technical article
Documentation from RFC 4871 shares that if the DKIM signature is invalid, modified during transit, or not present, the email may be flagged as spam. Check the DKIM signature and record validity.
2 Feb 2023 - RFC 4871
Technical article
Documentation from DMARC.org explains that a DMARC policy set to "reject" or "quarantine" can prevent unauthenticated emails from reaching the inbox. Incorrectly configured DMARC can cause deliverability problems.
20 Aug 2022 - DMARC.org
How can I fix consistent spam landing in Gmail with 0% user-reported spam when using Mailchimp?
How can I fix my emails landing in Gmail spam folder?
How can I fix my Gmail email deliverability issues?
How can I improve my domain reputation with Gmail?
What actions can be taken to fix a low IP and domain reputation with a high spam rate?
What could be causing Gmail deliverability issues for a bulk sender using Salesforce Marketing Cloud?
