Summary
It can be confusing and concerning to see your IP addresses listed as blocked in Microsoft's Smart Network Data Services (SNDS) dashboard, yet not experience any corresponding email bounces. This discrepancy often leads senders to question the accuracy of the data and the true state of their deliverability to Microsoft domains. While SNDS is a crucial tool for monitoring your sender reputation with Microsoft, its data does not always paint a complete picture of your email performance. Several factors can contribute to this scenario, ranging from delayed data updates within SNDS to different filtering mechanisms that don't always trigger a bounce.
Key findings
- Data Discrepancy: SNDS data can be delayed or inaccurate, showing IPs as blocked even when mail is delivering, or vice versa.
- Spam Complaints: User spam complaints are a primary reason for an IP to be blocklisted in SNDS, even if hard bounces aren't occurring.
- Internal Filtering: Microsoft's internal filtering systems might route messages to spam folders or silently discard them without generating a bounce notification, making it seem like no bounces are happening despite a block.
- Legacy Listings: IPs can remain listed as blocked in SNDS for extended periods due to past issues, even if the underlying problems have been resolved and current sending is clean. Learn more about contradictory SNDS data.
Key considerations
- Beyond Bounces: Do not solely rely on bounce rates as an indicator of deliverability. Low bounce rates combined with high SNDS blocklistings might mean your emails are being junked.
- User Engagement: Focus on positive user engagement metrics (opens, clicks) as these are strong signals to mailbox providers like Microsoft that your mail is wanted. Conversely, low engagement can lead to blocks.
- Complaint Feedback Loop: Ensure you are enrolled in Microsoft's Junk Mail Reporting Program (JMRP) to receive feedback on spam complaints. This can provide insight even if bounces are absent.
- Microsoft Support: If your IP is blocklisted in SNDS without bounces, consider submitting a delisting request directly to Microsoft support using their sender information for delisting form. Find out common issues with SNDS.
What email marketers say
Email marketers often encounter the frustrating situation of IPs being blocklisted in SNDS without seeing corresponding bounces. Their experiences suggest that Microsoft’s systems can operate with a degree of unpredictability, where blocklistings do not always immediately translate into explicit bounce messages. This leads to a puzzling scenario where delivery appears unaffected on the surface, but the SNDS portal indicates a problem.
Key opinions
- Spam Designation: Many marketers believe that IPs are listed as blocked in SNDS due to users marking emails as spam, rather than a hard bounce.
- Inconsistent Data: There's a shared sentiment that SNDS data can be misleading or contradictory to actual delivery observations, with high open rates sometimes coexisting with blocklisted statuses.
- Hidden Blocks: Microsoft (especially Hotmail) is perceived as having unique filtering behaviors that may block emails without providing an explicit bounce code.
- Persistent Listings: Some report IPs remaining blocklisted in SNDS for years, even after issues are resolved or IPs become inactive, impacting future deliverability to Microsoft domains.
Key considerations
- Monitor Spam Rate: Even without bounces, a blocklisting in SNDS strongly suggests a high spam complaint rate or low sender reputation that requires attention. Consider checking what happens if your IP is blocklisted.
- Dig Deeper: Don't just rely on SNDS status. Analyze your delivery logs for subtle clues or hidden blocking indicators.
- Audience Hygiene: Proactive list cleaning and permission-based sending are critical to prevent spam complaints, which appear to be the root cause for many of these blocklistings.
- Context Matters: Understand that different Microsoft domains and internal systems might react differently. What applies to Outlook.com might not apply directly to corporate Exchange servers.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks suggests that seeing IPs listed as blocked in SNDS without corresponding Microsoft bounces is not uncommon. They note that the issue often stems from users marking emails as spam, which flags the IP in SNDS but does not necessarily generate a hard bounce from the mail server. This means the email might still be delivered to the junk folder or silently dropped without a bounce message, making it appear as if delivery is fine.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Marketing Forum states that Microsoft's systems, particularly those related to Hotmail (now Outlook.com), can behave unpredictably. They've observed situations where IPs are not listed as blocked, yet bounces occur, and conversely, where SNDS shows a block but no bounces are recorded. This suggests a complex and sometimes contradictory relationship between SNDS reporting and actual mail flow behaviors, making troubleshooting difficult for marketers.
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts highlight that the disconnect between SNDS blocklistings and the absence of bounce messages points to the nuanced and often complex nature of Microsoft’s email filtering. They emphasize that a block in SNDS is a reputation signal from Microsoft, which may not always result in an immediate SMTP 5xx bounce code. Instead, it could indicate a variety of other actions, such as direct junking or silent discarding of mail. This requires senders to look beyond simple bounce rates to truly understand their deliverability to Microsoft properties.
Key opinions
- Reputation Signal: Experts agree that an SNDS blocklisting primarily serves as a reputation warning from Microsoft, indicating that your IP is viewed negatively, regardless of bounce status.
- Silent Filtering: Many believe Microsoft's systems, especially for low-reputation senders, silently accept mail but then discard it or place it in the junk folder without generating a bounce. This behavior is a form of shadow banning.
- Historical Weight: SNDS listings can reflect historical reputation issues that persist long after the original problems are resolved, leading to a discrepancy between current sending behavior and the reported block status.
- Engagement Metrics: True deliverability is best gauged by engagement metrics (opens, clicks, complaints) rather than solely relying on SNDS or bounce rates when facing this specific issue.
Key considerations
- Proactive Monitoring: Utilize SNDS not just for block status, but for complaint rates and other reputation metrics, understanding its limitations. Ensure you also leverage comprehensive blocklist monitoring.
- Beyond SMTP: Realize that mail filtering happens at multiple layers beyond the initial SMTP connection. A lack of bounces doesn't guarantee inbox placement. Check out our guide on deliverability issues.
- Reputation Management: Focus on consistent positive sending practices: sending wanted mail, managing opt-ins, and quickly processing unsubscribes to improve your overall sender reputation with Microsoft.
- Don’t Panic: The SNDS blocked status without bounces is a known quirk. Investigate further but avoid immediate drastic changes to your sending strategy without clear evidence of impact.
Expert view
Expert from SpamResource explains that Microsoft often employs a practice known as graylisting or greylisting, where emails from suspicious IPs are temporarily rejected. While this can lead to delays, a legitimate sending system will retry, and the email eventually goes through. However, a consistent blocklisting in SNDS without bounces suggests a more severe underlying reputation issue that is leading to silent filtering rather than temporary deferrals.
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise suggests that when SNDS shows an IP as blocked without bounces, it could mean the IP has reached a threshold of spam traps hit or a high volume of user complaints. These types of negative signals often lead to emails being delivered directly to the junk folder (or spam folder) without a bounce, or being silently discarded. The absence of bounces masks the fact that the emails are not reaching the inbox, creating a false sense of security for the sender.
What the documentation says
Microsoft's official documentation and authoritative sources on their Smart Network Data Services (SNDS) highlight its role as a key reporting tool for sender reputation. While SNDS provides insight into IP status and abuse complaints, it's crucial to understand that a blocked status in SNDS does not always directly correlate with immediate hard bounces. This indicates that Microsoft employs various filtering strategies that can impact email delivery without always generating a bounce message, directing mail to the junk folder or silently dropping it based on their internal algorithms.
Key findings
- Reputation-Based Filtering: Microsoft's systems filter emails based on a comprehensive reputation score, which includes spam complaints, spam trap hits, and engagement data. A low score can lead to blocks without bounces.
- Junk Folder Delivery: Emails from blocklisted IPs might still be delivered to the junk mail folder rather than being bounced, which means no bounce notification is generated for the sender.
- Delayed Updates: SNDS data can have a reporting delay. An IP might appear blocked due to recent issues, but the impact (or lack thereof) on bounces could be due to the time lag in reporting or the nature of the block.
- Junk Mail Reporting Program: Microsoft strongly recommends enrollment in JMRP to receive spam complaint feedback, which is a direct indicator of negative recipient reaction, often leading to SNDS blocks.
Key considerations
- SNDS and JMRP: These tools should be used in conjunction to get a full picture of your reputation and identify the root cause of issues, even in the absence of bounces.
- Content and Engagement: Reviewing email content and monitoring engagement are critical, as these factors heavily influence Microsoft’s filtering decisions, even when IPs are not explicitly bouncing. Understand technical solutions for deliverability.
- Delisting Process: If an IP is listed as blocked, follow Microsoft's official delisting procedures. This indicates to them that you are actively managing your sending reputation and addressing any underlying issues.
- Authentication: Ensure your email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) is correctly configured and aligned, as this provides foundational trust signals to Microsoft. Refer to a simple guide to email authentication.
Technical article
Documentation from Twilio Blog explains that Microsoft Smart Network Data Services (SNDS) provides insights into your sending reputation with Microsoft Outlook.com. It monitors the health of your IP addresses and domains, reporting on factors like complaint rates and blocklistings. A blocklisting indicates that Microsoft has flagged your IP for potential abuse, even if explicit bounces are not immediately visible in your logs.
Technical article
Documentation from Microsoft Learn on sender reputation details that Microsoft uses a combination of factors, including IP reputation, domain reputation, content, and user feedback, to make filtering decisions. When an IP is blocklisted in SNDS, it signals a negative reputation that can lead to messages being marked as spam or quietly discarded, rather than generating an SMTP bounce. This subtle filtering means that the absence of bounces does not necessarily mean successful inbox delivery.
Related resources
1 resources
Related pages
How to identify Microsoft domains contributing to IP blocks in SNDS?
Why do new IPs remain red in Microsoft SNDS during warming?
How to resolve Microsoft email blocks when SNDS shows normal status?
Why does Microsoft SNDS data contradict deliverability during IP warming?
Why are we seeing transactional deliverability issues on Microsoft?
Why is SNDS reporting all green IPs with no delivery uplift?
Why does SNDS show blocked IPs with good acceptance rates?
What are the common issues with Microsoft SNDS?
How email blacklists actually work: a simple guide
Why your emails fail: expert guide to improve deliverability
