Summary
A sudden decrease in Gmail open rates is a complex issue with several potential causes, ranging from seasonal trends and algorithmic changes to sender reputation, list hygiene, and user behavior. Experts, marketers, and documentation emphasize the importance of continuous monitoring, proactive adjustments, and adherence to best practices to mitigate the impact of these factors and maintain healthy email engagement.
Key findings
- Seasonal Trends: Holidays can lead to crowded inboxes and decreased engagement.
- Algorithm Changes: Gmail might tweak algorithms, affecting filtering even with good reputation.
- False Perspective: Declines may be a false reading due to Google caching trackers.
- Volume Impact: Increased volume, especially to inactive users, hurts open rates.
- User Behavior: Users are more selective, impacting open rates.
- Stricter Spam Thresholds: Gmail is tightening spam rate thresholds.
- Red Light Green Light: Gmail may temporarily penalize senders.
- Bulk Folder Placement: Emails going to the bulk/promotions folder reduce open rates.
- Image Pre-fetching: Google may not pre-fetch images, signaling reputation issues.
- List Hygiene: Poor list hygiene lowers engagement and deliverability.
- Email Fatigue: Sending too many emails fatigues subscribers.
- MPP Impact: Apple's MPP skews open rate metrics.
- Blocklisting: Being blocklisted drastically reduces deliverability.
- Spam Traps: Hitting spam traps damages reputation and deliverability.
Key considerations
- Monitor Metrics: Track open rates, clicks, sender reputation, and inbox placement.
- Segment Data: Segment audiences based on engagement and tailor content.
- Practice Hygiene: Clean lists regularly by removing inactive subscribers.
- Optimize Content: Craft relevant subject lines and engaging content.
- A/B Test: Continually test subject lines, content, and sending times.
- Adjust Sending Frequency: Avoid sending too many emails to the same subscribers.
- Monitor Sender Score: Monitor and maintain a healthy sender score.
- Check Blocklists: Check blocklist status and take action if listed.
- Follow Best Practices: Adhere to email marketing best practices to avoid spam traps.
- Measure Inbox Placement: Measure inbox placement over time, not just deliverability.
- Stabilize Open Rates: Focus on recent engaged subs, phase in the less engaged.
- Adapt to MPP: Adapt email performance due to Apple Mail Privacy
What email marketers say
15 marketer opinions
A sudden decrease in Gmail open rates can be attributed to a multitude of factors, ranging from seasonal trends and algorithm changes to email volume, sender reputation, and user behavior. Monitoring and adapting to these factors is crucial for maintaining healthy open rates.
Key opinions
- Seasonal Impact: Holidays often lead to crowded inboxes and decreased engagement.
- Algorithm Tweaks: Gmail's algorithm changes can impact email filtering, even with good sender reputation.
- False Perspective: Open rate decline might be a false perspective caused by Google caching trackers.
- Volume Increase: Increased email volume, especially to inactive contacts, lowers average open rates.
- User Behavior: Changes in user behavior, such as increased selectivity, can decrease open rates.
- Spam Thresholds: Gmail is becoming stricter with spam rate thresholds.
- Red Light Green Light: Gmail might temporarily reduce engagement for certain senders, requiring adjustments.
- Email Fatigue: Sending too many emails can lead to email fatigue, decreasing open rates.
- Mobile Shifts: Users may be shifting towards mobile devices for reading emails.
- Deliverability Issues: Emails landing in spam folders lead to reduced open rates.
Key considerations
- Monitor Metrics: Consistently monitor open rates, click rates, sender reputation, and inbox placement.
- Segment Data: Segment audiences based on engagement and adjust sending frequency accordingly.
- Practice Hygiene: Maintain clean email lists by removing inactive subscribers and managing bounce rates.
- Optimize Content: Craft relevant and compelling subject lines and email content.
- A/B Test: Continuously A/B test subject lines, content, and sending times to optimize performance.
- Reduce Volume: Reduce email volume to less engaged subscribers to stabilize open rates.
- Stay Under Threshold: Stay consistently under the 0.1% spam rate threshold.
- Check Postmaster Tools: Utilize Gmail Postmaster Tools to gain insights into deliverability issues.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks shares anecdotal experience that Gmail sometimes plays 'red light, green light' with senders, where open rates for new subscribers or re-engagement sends drop. Recommends reducing volume to less engaged subscribers and focusing on recently engaged subscribers to stabilize open rates, then phasing in less engaged subscribers while monitoring performance.
29 Jul 2022 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks explains that it is a common pattern to see average clicks and opens drop when volume increases, especially when mailing inactive contacts. Also notes changes in Gmail's mail filtering and recommends checking Google Postmaster Tools for insights.
17 Jul 2022 - Email Geeks
What the experts say
4 expert opinions
Experts attribute sudden decreases in Gmail open rates to potential issues such as emails being filtered into the bulk folder, Google not pre-fetching images, or deliverability problems that may be early warning signs. They emphasize the importance of consistently measuring inbox placement, checking sender authentication and reputation metrics, and examining factors like email volume, IP address changes, and list hygiene.
Key opinions
- Bulk Folder Placement: Emails may be going to the bulk folder instead of the inbox.
- Image Pre-fetching: Google might not be pre-fetching images, indicating a lower sender reputation.
- Early Warning Signs: Decreasing open rates can be early warning signs for deliverability issues.
- Inbox Placement Measurement: Consistently measuring inbox placement helps identify changes.
- Adverse Factors: Increased volume, IP changes and poor list quality affect delivery.
Key considerations
- Investigate Bulk Folder: Check if emails are landing in the bulk folder.
- Monitor Image Pre-fetching: Monitor if Google is pre-fetching images for your emails.
- Early Detection: Address deliverability issues early to prevent larger problems.
- Measure Inbox Placement: Consistently measure inbox placement, not just deliverability.
- Check Authentication: Check your authentication practices and reputation metrics.
- Check List Quality: Examine email volume, IP address changes, and list hygiene.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks states that these issues might be early warning signs for deliverability problems, and catching them early can mean the fixes are much smaller and less intrusive.
14 Oct 2022 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks suggests investigating if mail is going to the bulk folder and notes inbox testing inaccuracy. Also suggests that mail might be going to the inbox, but Google is not prefetching images. Also points out Validity's complaint rate might not be specific to Google, suggesting a need to dig into address collection and hygiene processes if the complaint rate is high.
30 Mar 2025 - Email Geeks
What the documentation says
6 technical articles
Decreasing Gmail open rates are linked to several factors identified in documentation. These include more aggressive promotion tab filtering, changes in sender reputation, poor list hygiene, the impact of Apple's Mail Privacy Protection, blocklisting, and hitting spam traps. Addressing these issues requires proactive monitoring, list cleaning, adherence to best practices, and adapting to changes in email privacy.
Key findings
- Promotion Tab Filtering: Gmail's promotion tab may be filtering more emails, reducing open rates.
- Sender Reputation: Changes in sender reputation can negatively affect inbox placement.
- Poor List Hygiene: Poor list hygiene leads to lower engagement and open rates.
- Mail Privacy Protection: Apple's Mail Privacy Protection inflates open rates, affecting metric accuracy.
- Blocklisting: Being listed on blocklists reduces deliverability and open rates.
- Spam Traps: Hitting spam traps damages sender reputation and deliverability.
Key considerations
- Check Promotion Tab: Ensure emails aren't mistakenly categorized as promotional.
- Monitor Sender Score: Monitor sender score and address deliverability issues.
- Clean Email List: Regularly clean email lists to remove inactive subscribers.
- Adapt to MPP: Adapt how email performance is evaluated due to Apple's Mail Privacy Protection.
- Check Blocklist Status: Check blocklist status and take steps to be removed if listed.
- List Hygiene: Practice proper list hygiene and obtain explicit consent from subscribers to avoid spam traps.
Technical article
Documentation from Spamhaus explains that hitting spam traps can severely damage sender reputation and negatively impact deliverability and open rates. They advise practicing proper list hygiene and obtaining explicit consent from subscribers.
2 Dec 2024 - Spamhaus
Technical article
Documentation from Mailchimp explains that poor list hygiene can lead to lower engagement and open rates. Mailchimp recommends regularly cleaning your email list to remove inactive subscribers to improve deliverability and engagement metrics.
28 Feb 2023 - Mailchimp
Do email clicks improve inbox deliverability?
Does Gmail accurately track email opens?
How can I improve email deliverability and open rates for a client with a bad domain reputation, especially with Gmail, and what strategies should I use for unengaged users?
How can I improve Gmail open rates for my e-commerce emails?
How do AI assistants and MPP impact email open rates, and what are better metrics to measure outbound campaign effectiveness?
How do I improve email deliverability for a client with a dormant list and low sending volume?
