Summary
Many email senders are reporting a puzzling trend: a significant drop in email open rates, particularly for Gmail users and especially affecting welcome emails or initial communications. This phenomenon often appears suddenly, sometimes fluctuating daily, and seems to disproportionately impact new subscribers compared to established, engaged segments. While overall deliverability metrics might appear stable, the decline in engagement from these crucial early interactions points to evolving challenges in inbox placement and recipient trust within Gmail's ecosystem.
Key findings
- Specific impact: Open rates are dropping notably for Gmail addresses, with other email domains showing consistent performance.
- Welcome series affected: Welcome emails and first communications to new subscribers are experiencing the most severe declines in open rates and associated revenue.
- Fluctuating performance: The drop often isn't constant; open rates can be low for days, then return to normal briefly, before declining again.
- Engagement disparity: Inbox placement for first-time communications can be as low as 59.4%, while prior engaged recipients see rates around 80%.
- Diagnostic ambiguity: Postmaster Tools might show a good sender status, making the specific cause of the open rate drop unclear.
Key considerations
- Apple privacy changes: The impact of Apple Mail Privacy Protection (MPP) on open rate metrics, particularly for welcome emails, needs to be considered. If a platform is excluding these opens, it could appear as a drop, even if actual engagement is similar.
- Sender reputation: Even with a 'medium' domain reputation, persistent issues suggest a need to identify and remove problematic subscribers or segments causing deliverability challenges. Understanding your email domain reputation is crucial.
- Content and engagement: A less engaged audience or unoptimized welcome email content might contribute to lower initial opens. Regularly reviewing and optimizing your content and list engagement is vital to improve Gmail open rates.
- Platform-specific issues: If testing shows opens aren't being accurately passed back, it might indicate a reporting bug within the email service provider (ESP) rather than a true deliverability issue.
What email marketers say
Email marketers frequently discuss the challenges of maintaining high open rates, especially for new subscribers and welcome emails in Gmail. They often report experiencing sudden, unexplainable drops that disproportionately affect Gmail users compared to other domains. These fluctuations can severely impact the effectiveness of initial customer journeys and overall revenue, prompting a search for answers beyond standard troubleshooting steps.
Key opinions
- Unpredictable fluctuations: Many marketers observe a cyclical pattern where open rates drop, then recover slightly, only to fall again, making diagnosis difficult.
- New subscriber vulnerability: The primary concern is the impact on new subscribers and welcome series, where drops are most pronounced, affecting initial engagement and revenue attribution.
- Gmail's unique behavior: There's a consensus that Gmail's algorithms behave differently for first-time communications versus established sender-recipient relationships.
- Reporting discrepancies: Some suspect that reported open rates might not accurately reflect actual engagement, potentially due to platform bugs or Apple's Mail Privacy Protection.
- Revenue impact: Declining open rates directly translate into reduced attributed revenue, highlighting the business-critical nature of the issue.
Key considerations
- Audience segmentation: Focusing on sending to highly engaged subscribers initially, especially when new, can help build sender reputation and warm up a new IP or domain.
- Content relevance: Marketers should ensure their email content is highly relevant and valuable to new subscribers to encourage early engagement.
- Platform diagnostics: It's important to differentiate between actual deliverability issues and reporting anomalies. Marketers should confirm metrics directly by sending test emails.
- Patience and persistence: Recovering from open rate drops in Gmail can take time, requiring consistent effort in monitoring, testing, and adjusting sending practices.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks suggests that their welcome email open rates for Gmail addresses have dropped by almost half between January and February, while other domains remain stable. This indicates a specific issue with how Gmail is handling initial communications from senders.
Marketer view
Email marketer from SyncSpider highlights that common reasons for open rate drops include low-quality content or the use of tracking domains and URLs. This suggests that the content and technical setup of emails play a significant role in deliverability and engagement.
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts often attribute sudden drops in Gmail open rates to nuanced changes in Gmail's filtering algorithms, particularly affecting new contacts or welcome sequences. They emphasize the complexity of domain reputation, the potential for hidden issues even with seemingly good Postmaster status, and the crucial role of email authentication and engagement signals. Technical alignment and adapting sending strategies are frequently highlighted as solutions to navigate these challenges.
Key opinions
- First-time communication sensitivity: Experts note that Gmail treats initial emails differently, leading to significantly lower inbox placement for welcome emails or first interactions.
- Domain reputation nuances: A 'medium' domain reputation persisting for months suggests underlying issues, possibly from specific cohorts on the engaged list, impacting overall sender trust.
- Technical alignment importance: Checking email headers for bounce domain alignment issues or other technical misconfigurations is a critical step in troubleshooting deliverability.
- Engagement as a factor: Low engagement rates from certain segments can drag down domain reputation, even if overall deliverability seems high. Gmail prioritizes engagement signals.
- Apple Mail Privacy Protection (MPP): MPP can skew open rate metrics, making it harder to accurately assess true recipient engagement. ESPs might adjust their reporting to account for this.
Key considerations
- Gradual re-engagement: If a drop occurs, slowly re-engaging the most active users first, and then gradually expanding to other segments, can help restore sender reputation and improve open rates.
- List hygiene tools: Utilizing email list cleaning services (like Kickbox, as mentioned in the Slack thread) can help identify and remove problematic subscribers that negatively impact domain reputation.
- Authentication checks: Ensure all email authentication standards (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) are correctly configured and aligned, as any issues can lead to lower inbox placement. Using a deliverability tester can help identify issues.
- Monitor Postmaster Tools: Even if 'good' status is reported, regularly reviewing Google Postmaster Tools can provide deeper insights into specific metrics like spam rate or IP/domain reputation over time, helping to diagnose subtle shifts.
Expert view
Email deliverability expert from Email Geeks suggests that Gmail's algorithms for "likely-first communication" (like welcome emails) showed a significantly lower inbox placement rate of 59.4% in February, compared to 80% for brands with prior communication. This highlights a clear distinction in how Gmail filters initial outreach.
Expert view
Email deliverability expert from SpamResource states that changes in internet service provider (ISP) filtering logic or blocklist (or blacklist) listings can cause sudden drops in deliverability and open rates. Senders should always monitor their standing with major ISPs and blocklists.
What the documentation says
Official documentation from major mailbox providers and industry bodies often emphasizes the importance of sender reputation, engagement metrics, and proper email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) as foundational elements for optimal inbox placement. Recent updates, particularly from Gmail and Apple, have intensified the focus on recipient engagement and data privacy, which can indirectly impact how open rates are tracked and interpreted. Documentation also highlights the dynamic nature of spam filtering and the need for senders to continuously adapt to evolving best practices.
Key findings
- Engagement signals: Mailbox providers like Gmail heavily weigh recipient engagement (opens, clicks, replies, non-complaints) when determining inbox placement, especially for new senders or first-time communications.
- Authentication enforcement: Strong email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) is no longer optional; it's a critical baseline for deliverability, with failures often leading to messages being blocked or sent to spam.
- Privacy impact on metrics: Features like Apple's Mail Privacy Protection (MPP) have fundamentally altered how open rates are reported, making them less reliable as a sole measure of engagement.
- Domain and IP reputation: Maintaining a positive sender reputation for both the sending domain and IP address is paramount for consistent inbox delivery. A low or medium reputation can trigger stricter filtering.
- Spam complaint rates: High spam complaint rates are a strong negative signal, quickly damaging sender reputation and leading to emails landing in the spam folder.
Key considerations
- List hygiene and quality: Regularly cleaning email lists to remove unengaged subscribers, invalid addresses, and spam traps is essential for maintaining a healthy sender reputation and improving inbox placement. This is critical for preventing your email from going to spam.
- Content optimization: Ensure email content is relevant, personalized, and avoids characteristics commonly associated with spam (e.g., excessive capitalization, spammy keywords, broken links).
- Feedback loops: Utilizing feedback loops from major ISPs can provide insights into spam complaints, allowing senders to identify and address issues promptly.
- Authentication compliance: Regularly verify that SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records are correctly set up and aligned. Gmail and Yahoo's new sender requirements emphasize these technical standards.
Technical article
Documentation from Google's Email Sender Guidelines highlights that consistent high engagement (opens, clicks, replies) and low complaint rates are crucial for maintaining a good sender reputation with Gmail. Low engagement, especially from new subscribers, can negatively impact future deliverability.
Technical article
Documentation from Apple's Mail Privacy Protection (MPP) describes how it prevents senders from knowing when a user opens an email. This feature prefetches content and pixels, artificially inflating or obscuring traditional open rate metrics, making them less reliable for measuring true engagement.
Related resources
13 resources
Related pages
How to improve low Gmail email open rates?
What causes a sudden drop in email open rates?
Why did my email have lower open rates in Gmail, and go to spam?
Why are my welcome series email open rates suddenly dropping?
How to troubleshoot a sudden drop in Gmail open rates?
Why do new Gmail signups or new email templates have low open rates?
Why Your Emails Are Going to Spam in 2024 and How to Fix It
Email Deliverability Issues: Getting Your Messages to the Inbox in 2025
A practical guide to understanding your email domain reputation
A simple guide to DMARC, SPF, and DKIM
