Summary
When emails are blocked by major Internet Service Providers (ISPs) despite passing DMARC, SPF, and DKIM authentication, it signals that the issue lies beyond technical validation. Instead, it points predominantly to sender reputation and recipient engagement. ISPs employ a holistic evaluation, considering numerous factors such as spam rates, IP and domain reputation, user complaints, engagement metrics like opens and clicks, and even the email content itself. Sending unwanted emails, maintaining poor list hygiene, or failing to adhere to best practices like consistent sending volume and low bounce rates can severely damage a sender's standing, leading to blocks regardless of authentication success.
Key findings
- Sender Reputation Reigns: ISPs prioritize a comprehensive sender reputation score, which is influenced by spam complaints, bounce rates, spam trap hits, and overall user engagement. Even with perfect authentication, a poor reputation can lead to blocks.
- Content and Engagement Drive Deliverability: Email content, including potentially spammy keywords, suspicious links, and image-heavy formats, can trigger filters. Crucially, low recipient engagement coupled with high complaint rates strongly signals to ISPs that emails are unwanted, overriding technical compliance.
- Beyond Basic Authentication: ISP filters, such as Outlook's SmartScreen, evaluate sender behavior, content characteristics, attachments, and links, extending beyond DMARC, SPF, and DKIM. Technical issues like a missing Reverse DNS (PTR) record or an IP/domain listed on blacklists can also cause blocks.
- Permission is Foundational: The root of blocking often stems from inadequate address collection processes, where recipients have not given clear permission or are no longer engaged. Sending 'unwanted' email, even if legally permissible, consistently results in blocks.
- Consistency and IP Warming: For new sending IPs, proper warming is essential to build a positive reputation. Inconsistent email volumes, such as sudden spikes, can also negatively impact deliverability.
Key considerations
- Utilize ISP Postmaster Tools: Actively monitor deliverability, spam rates, and reputation insights using Google Postmaster Tools and Microsoft SNDS & JMRP, especially for dedicated IPs.
- Employ Deliverability Monitoring Services: Leverage third-party tools like 250ok or eDataSource's deliveryindex.org for detailed insights into block reasons and overall deliverability trends. Analyzing deeper mail server logs, perhaps with tools like Kibana, can also provide clues.
- Deep Dive into Email Headers and Bounces: Examine full email headers for 'spam weight tags' and analyze bounce responses to differentiate between outright blocks and deferrals, aiding in specific issue investigation.
- Prioritize Permission and Engagement: Regularly review and refine address acquisition methods to ensure explicit consent. Focus on sending highly relevant, personalized content to enhance engagement and minimize complaints. Strategic audience segmentation is also key.
- Maintain IP and Domain Health: Regularly check your sending IP and domain against major blacklists. Verify that a correct Reverse DNS (PTR) record is configured for your IP address.
- Engage Directly with ISPs: For specific issues, like Gmail rejections or suspected false-positives, consider using direct contact forms such as Google's bulk sender contact form, which can assist with IP warming and resolution.
- Understand Feedback Loop Mechanisms: While often managed by ESPs, comprehending how Feedback Loops (FBLs) transmit user complaints is vital for proactive list hygiene and managing sender reputation.
What email marketers say
17 marketer opinions
When emails bypass DMARC, SPF, and DKIM yet still face blocking by major Internet Service Providers, the root causes invariably lie beyond mere authentication. ISPs meticulously evaluate a sender's comprehensive reputation, a score built upon a multitude of factors including user engagement, complaint rates, spam trap hits, and the integrity of the sending infrastructure. Even with perfect technical validation, issues such as a tarnished IP or domain reputation, irrelevant content, insufficient list hygiene, or a lack of proper sender behavior, like IP warming or consistent volume, can trigger stringent filtering mechanisms. This indicates that deliverability is less about 'if' an email is authentic, and more about 'if' it is wanted and well-received by recipients.
Key opinions
- Beyond Authentication, Reputation is King: Successful DMARC, SPF, and DKIM merely establish authenticity; deliverability hinges on overall sender reputation, heavily influenced by user complaints, spam trap hits, and blacklisting of IPs or domains.
- Content and Engagement are Paramount: Email content, including spammy keywords, suspicious links, excessive capitalization, or an unfavorable image-to-text ratio, can trigger filters. Crucially, low recipient engagement, poor audience segmentation, and high complaint rates signal unwanted mail, leading to blocks regardless of authentication.
- Technical Hygiene Extends to PTR Records: Even with perfect email authentication, a missing or incorrect Reverse DNS, PTR, record for the sending IP can cause emails to be blocked, as many ISPs require it for reputation checks.
- IP Warming and Sending Consistency: For new sending IPs, a proper warming period is critical to build reputation. Similarly, sudden, inconsistent spikes in sending volume can negatively impact deliverability and trigger spam filters.
- User Feedback and Spam Traps are Deliverability Red Flags: Direct user complaints, such as clicking 'This is spam,' are powerful signals to ISPs. Hitting spam traps - invalid email addresses used to identify senders of unsolicited mail - also severely damages sender reputation.
Key considerations
- Leverage ISP-Specific Tools and Postmaster Programs: Proactively monitor deliverability, spam rates, and reputation via Google Postmaster Tools, Microsoft SNDS and JMRP, and utilize their specific contact forms for unblocking, especially for Gmail issues and false positives.
- Conduct Comprehensive Technical and Log Analysis: Examine mail server logs for specific rejection messages from ISPs, analyze full email headers for 'spam weight tags,' and differentiate between outright blocks and deferrals from bounce responses. Regularly check your IP and domain against major blacklists.
- Prioritize List Hygiene, Engagement, and Personalization: Regularly clean email lists, ensure explicit consent for all addresses, segment audiences effectively, and personalize content to enhance recipient engagement, thereby reducing complaints and increasing inbox placement.
- Maintain Sound Sending Practices: Implement a proper IP warming strategy for new sending IPs. Avoid sudden, inconsistent email volume spikes. Ensure a valid Reverse DNS, PTR, record is configured for your sending IP address.
- Utilize Third-Party Deliverability Tools: Employ services like eDataSource's deliveryindex.org or 250ok for granular insights into sender score, inbox placement across major ISPs, and deeper investigations into block reasons, supplementing data from ISP postmaster tools.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks suggests starting with Google Postmaster Tools and Microsoft SNDS, especially if on a dedicated IP.
13 Jul 2023 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks recommends eDataSource's free tool, deliveryindex.org, for checking sender score and inbox placement on major ISPs like Gmail, Yahoo, AOL, and Hotmail, with a daily limit of 5 subdomains.
20 May 2023 - Email Geeks
What the experts say
4 expert opinions
Even when emails successfully pass DMARC, SPF, and DKIM authentication, persistent blocking by major Internet Service Providers often signals a deeper problem: a compromised sender reputation. This reputation is heavily influenced by how recipients engage with your mail, or conversely, how they perceive it as unwanted. ISPs prioritize user experience, so factors like high spam complaint rates, sending to invalid addresses, and a fundamental lack of recipient permission are critical drivers of deliverability issues, irrespective of technical validation. Addressing these core issues of permission and engagement is essential, as technical authentication alone cannot overcome a poor sending reputation.
Key opinions
- Reputation Overrides Authentication: While authentication verifies legitimacy, a poor sender reputation is the primary cause of blocks, derived from factors like high spam complaints and sending to invalid addresses, rather than technical validation failures.
- Permission is the Core Problem: Widespread blocking, even with proper authentication, points to fundamental issues in how email addresses are collected and whether recipients have truly opted in.
- Unwanted Mail Leads to Blocks: Sending emails that recipients consider unsolicited or irrelevant, irrespective of legal compliance, will consistently result in deliverability blocks from ISPs.
- Authentication is Necessary, Not Sufficient: SPF, DKIM, and DMARC are foundational for email trust, but ISPs ultimately base blocking decisions on sender reputation and blocklisting, making technical authentication a prerequisite, not a guarantee.
Key considerations
- Rectify Permission Gaps: Proactively review and refine all email address acquisition methods to ensure explicit consent, and remove any addresses where opt-in is questionable.
- Prioritize Engagement and List Hygiene: Implement strategies to reduce spam complaints, regularly clean email lists of inactive or invalid addresses, and send relevant content to improve recipient engagement.
- Utilize Advanced Monitoring Tools: Leverage specialized deliverability monitoring services, such as 250ok.com, for in-depth insights into inbox placement, block reasons, and sender performance.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks suggests exploring 250ok.com as a tool for email deliverability monitoring.
3 Nov 2024 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks states that widespread blocking by multiple providers, despite passing authentication, indicates a core issue of permission and recipient engagement, not just a technical problem. She advises thoroughly reviewing and fixing the client's address collection processes to ensure recipients have given clear permission, and removing addresses that likely did not opt-in. She emphasizes that if recipients feel spammed, technical tools will not solve the underlying problem, and this fundamental issue must be resolved before proceeding with deliverability repair tools. She also reiterates that sending 'unwanted' email, even if legally permissible, will lead to blocks.
30 Jul 2021 - Email Geeks
What the documentation says
5 technical articles
Even with robust DMARC, SPF, and DKIM authentication in place, emails can still face blocks from major Internet Service Providers (ISPs) because deliverability is fundamentally determined by a holistic sender reputation, not just technical validation. ISPs rigorously evaluate how recipients interact with emails, examining factors such as spam rates, user complaints, and overall engagement. Additionally, the quality of email content, the hygiene of the mailing list, and adherence to industry best practices, like consistent sending volumes and low bounce rates, all contribute significantly to this reputation. A negative score in these areas will lead to blocks, underscoring that trusted sender behavior is paramount.
Key findings
- Holistic Reputation Assessment: ISPs employ a multifaceted approach that extends beyond authentication protocols to evaluate sender trustworthiness. This involves rigorously analyzing spam rates, IP and domain reputation, and direct user feedback, such as complaints.
- Content and Behavior Analysis: Filters like Outlook's SmartScreen scrutinize email content for suspicious characteristics, attachments, and links, as well as overall sender behavior. This deep analysis impacts deliverability, even when DMARC, SPF, and DKIM pass.
- Engagement Metrics are Decisive: Major ISPs closely monitor recipient engagement, including opens, clicks, unsubscribes, and particularly complaints. Low engagement combined with high complaint rates significantly damages sender reputation, triggering blocks.
- Best Practices for Deliverability: Adherence to industry best practices, including consistent sending volume, maintaining low bounce rates, and avoiding spam trap hits, forms a crucial part of the holistic sender reputation ISPs assess for deliverability.
Key considerations
- Monitor Comprehensive Reputation Signals: Actively use ISP Postmaster Tools, such as those from Google and Outlook, to track crucial metrics like spam rates, IP and domain reputation, and user complaint feedback. These tools provide insights into the very signals ISPs assess beyond authentication.
- Enhance Content Quality and Relevance: Regularly review your email content for any characteristics that might be flagged as suspicious, including attachments and links. Ensure your messaging is clear, provides genuine value, and avoids common spam triggers to improve content-based filtering outcomes.
- Optimize for Engagement and List Hygiene: Prioritize strategies that encourage positive recipient interaction, such as personalization and segmentation, to boost opens and clicks while minimizing unsubscribes and complaints. Rigorously clean your email lists to remove invalid or unengaged addresses, which helps maintain low bounce and complaint rates.
- Adhere to Industry Best Practices: Implement consistent sending volumes, maintain low bounce rates, and proactively monitor for spam trap hits. Adhering to these fundamental industry best practices is crucial for building and preserving a strong, trusted sender reputation with major ISPs.
Technical article
Documentation from Google Postmaster Tools Help explains that even with DMARC, SPF, and DKIM configured, ISPs still evaluate sender reputation based on factors like spam rate, IP reputation, domain reputation, and user complaints, which can lead to blocks if poor.
30 Aug 2024 - Google Postmaster Tools Help
Technical article
Documentation from Outlook.com Postmaster indicates that their SmartScreen Filter goes beyond authentication protocols, assessing email content for suspicious characteristics, attachments, links, and overall sender behavior, which can cause blocks even if DMARC, SPF, and DKIM pass.
2 Sep 2021 - Outlook.com Postmaster
How to troubleshoot emails landing in spam despite passing DKIM, SPF, and DMARC?
Why are my emails landing in spam even though they pass SPF, DKIM, and DMARC?
Why are some emails failing DMARC checks even with correct SPF and DKIM alignment, and how can I troubleshoot it?
Why are transactional emails with passing SPF, DKIM, and DMARC landing in spam?
Why do my emails go to spam due to DMARC, SPF, and DKIM alignment failures?
Why is DKIM failing at some ISPs but not others, and how can I fix it?
