Suped

What tools and methods are available to generate DKIM public and private keys?

Summary

Generating DKIM public and private keys is a crucial step for email authentication and deliverability. The tools and methods available largely depend on whether an email system is managed by a third-party service provider or self-hosted. Many leading email service providers (ESPs) and cloud-based mail services automate this process entirely, generating and managing the keys on behalf of their users, who then simply need to add a provided DNS record to their domain. For self-managed mail servers, command-line tools are the standard. OpenSSL is a highly versatile and common utility for manual key generation, allowing users to create both the private key for their server and extract the public key for DNS. Additionally, specific mail server software, like OpenDKIM for Postfix, offers specialized command-line tools such as 'opendkim-genkey' that streamline the process by generating both components. For those seeking a simpler approach, various online DKIM key generators exist, providing a web-based interface to produce the necessary key pair with minimal input.

Key findings

  • Automated Generation by ESPs: Many email service providers and cloud mail services, including Zoho Mail, Google Workspace, Microsoft 365, SendGrid, and Amazon SES, automatically generate and manage DKIM keys for their users, simplifying the setup process.
  • OpenSSL for Manual Generation: OpenSSL is a widely adopted command-line tool for manually generating DKIM private and public key pairs, typically involving 'openssl genrsa' for the private key and 'openssl rsa -pubout' to extract the public key.
  • OpenDKIM for Linux Servers: For Linux-based mail servers, particularly those using Postfix with OpenDKIM, the 'opendkim-genkey' command-line tool is a common and efficient method to generate both private keys and corresponding public key DNS entries.
  • Online Key Generators: Several online tools, such as DKIMcore.org and Port25 DKIM Wizard, provide a straightforward web interface to generate DKIM public and private keys, requiring only the domain and selector as input.
  • Private vs. Public Key: All methods generate a pair of keys: a private key, which remains on the sending server for signing emails, and a public key, which is published in the domain's DNS as a TXT or CNAME record for verification.

Key considerations

  • Service Provider Role: Your choice of email service provider (ESP) or mail server software significantly influences the key generation process. Many leading ESPs and cloud-based email services, such as Google Workspace, Microsoft 365, Zoho Mail, SendGrid, and Amazon SES, automatically handle DKIM key generation and rotation, providing users with the public key components to add to their DNS.
  • Self-Managed Servers: For self-managed mail servers like Postfix with OpenDKIM, or PowerMTA, command-line tools are the primary method. OpenSSL is a universally recognized tool for generating both private and public keys. Tools like 'opendkim-genkey' simplify the process on Linux systems by generating both keys and the DNS record entry.
  • Key Security: Regardless of the generation method, the private key must be kept secret and secure on the sending server, while the public key is published in your domain's DNS records as a TXT or CNAME entry. Ensure secure storage and restricted access for the private key.
  • Ease of Use: Online DKIM key generators, like DKIMcore.org or Port25 DKIM Wizard, offer a user-friendly way to generate keys for those who prefer not to use command-line tools, simplifying the process by taking domain and selector inputs and providing ready-to-use keys.

What email marketers say

11 marketer opinions

For email marketers, establishing DKIM authentication is vital for deliverability, and generating the necessary public and private keys can be achieved through several methods. The approach often depends on whether you manage your own mail server or utilize an Email Service Provider (ESP). Command-line utilities like OpenSSL are widely used for manual key generation, offering precise control over the process by creating the private key and then extracting the corresponding public key. For specific mail server environments such as Postfix with OpenDKIM, dedicated tools like 'opendkim-genkey' streamline the creation of both keys and their respective DNS record entries. Additionally, a range of online DKIM key generators, including Dkimcore.org and Port25 DKIM Wizard, provide a user-friendly web interface, simplifying the process for those less familiar with command-line operations. Many contemporary ESPs and mail server solutions also offer automated or built-in key generation, significantly reducing the manual effort involved. Regardless of the method chosen, the fundamental outcome is always a public-private key pair, with the private key securely residing on the sending server and the public key published in the domain's DNS.

Key opinions

  • OpenSSL for Manual Control: OpenSSL remains a foundational command-line tool, enabling users to generate DKIM private and public keys, often through commands like 'genrsa' and 'rsa -pubout', for various mail server setups including PowerMTA.
  • Specialized Mail Server Tools: Utilities such as 'opendkim-genkey' within OpenDKIM environments, common for Postfix, simplify the process by generating both key files and the DNS public key entry, based on specified domain and selector.
  • Convenient Online Generators: Web-based tools like Dkimcore.org and the Port25 DKIM Wizard offer a straightforward way to produce key pairs, requiring minimal input and providing ready-to-use keys.
  • Automated ESP and Software Features: Many modern ESPs and mail server software, including SocketLabs which uses OpenSSL internally, feature automated or built-in key generation processes, streamlining setup for users.
  • Key Pair Structure: All generation methods consistently produce a pair consisting of a private key, which is securely stored on the sending server, and a public key, which is published as a DNS TXT record for verification.

Key considerations

  • System Environment Dictates Method: The choice of key generation method largely depends on your email infrastructure, whether it's a self-managed server requiring command-line tools or an Email Service Provider (ESP) that automates the process.
  • Balancing Simplicity and Customization: Online tools offer ease of use for quick generation, while command-line options like OpenSSL provide greater flexibility and control over key parameters.
  • Critical Private Key Security: Regardless of how they are generated, the private key must be protected with the utmost security on the sending server to prevent unauthorized use and maintain email integrity.
  • Proper Integration with Mail Servers: The generated keys must be correctly configured within your specific mail server software or ESP settings to ensure proper DKIM signing of outgoing emails.

Marketer view

Email marketer from Email Geeks recommends Dkimcore.org for generating DKIM keys, noting its simplicity, and mentions that OpenSSL documentation is also available there.

15 Oct 2021 - Email Geeks

Marketer view

Email marketer from Email Geeks shares their consistent use of OpenDKIM for generating DKIM keys, providing a link to its opendkim-genkey documentation.

26 Nov 2022 - Email Geeks

What the experts say

2 expert opinions

The process for generating DKIM public and private keys varies significantly depending on the email infrastructure. Users relying on an Email Service Provider (ESP) will find that these providers typically offer integrated tools or automated processes to handle key generation. In contrast, administrators of self-managed mail servers commonly turn to open-source utilities like OpenSSL to create their DKIM key pairs. This distinction highlights two primary paths for acquiring the essential keys for email authentication, with ESPs often simplifying the process and self-managed systems requiring direct engagement with tools like OpenSSL.

Key opinions

  • ESPs Provide Tools: Email Service Providers frequently offer built-in tools or automated systems to generate DKIM public and private keys for their users.
  • OpenSSL for Self-Managed: For self-managed mail servers, OpenSSL is a widely utilized open-source tool for manually creating DKIM key pairs.
  • Method Depends on Management: The specific tools and methods used for DKIM key generation are primarily determined by whether the mail server is self-managed or if an Email Service Provider is in use.

Key considerations

  • System Environment: The method for generating DKIM keys is dictated by your email setup; Email Service Providers (ESPs) often provide automated solutions, while self-managed servers typically rely on manual tools like OpenSSL.
  • Automation vs. Control: ESPs generally offer a simpler, automated process for key generation, whereas self-managed servers using tools such as OpenSSL provide greater direct control over the key creation.

Expert view

Expert from Spam Resource shares that email service providers (ESPs) often provide tools to generate DKIM keys. Alternatively, open-source tools like OpenSSL can be utilized for this purpose.

1 Sep 2024 - Spam Resource

Expert view

Expert from Word to the Wise explains that DKIM key generation depends on whether a mail server is self-managed or an Email Service Provider (ESP) is used. For self-managed servers, OpenSSL is the most common tool, while most ESPs generate the DKIM keys for their users.

9 Apr 2024 - Word to the Wise

What the documentation says

7 technical articles

The generation of DKIM public and private keys is a fundamental aspect of email authentication, with the available tools and methods largely dictated by the email infrastructure in use. For organizations leveraging cloud-based email services or Email Service Providers (ESPs), the process is typically automated. Providers like Zoho Mail, Google Workspace, Microsoft 365, SendGrid, and Amazon SES handle the complex key generation and management internally, then provide users with specific DNS records-either TXT or CNAME-containing the public key information to publish. Conversely, for self-managed mail servers, command-line utilities are the preferred approach. OpenSSL is a versatile and widely used tool for manually creating both the private key, which resides securely on the server, and extracting the corresponding public key for DNS publication. Dedicated server-side tools, such as 'opendkim-genkey' for Postfix servers, further streamline this process by generating both key components with simple commands. This dual approach ensures that regardless of the deployment model, secure DKIM authentication can be readily implemented.

Key findings

  • Automated Generation by Service Providers: Leading email service providers and cloud email platforms like Zoho Mail, Google Workspace, Microsoft 365, SendGrid, and Amazon SES automate DKIM key generation and management, supplying users with the public key component to add to their DNS.
  • OpenSSL for Manual Generation: For self-hosted or more customized server environments, the OpenSSL command-line tool is commonly used to manually generate both the private key and extract the public key.
  • Specialized Server-Side Tools: Specific mail server software, such as OpenDKIM for Postfix, offers dedicated utilities like 'opendkim-genkey' to streamline the creation of both private and public DKIM keys with simple commands.
  • Dual Key System: All generation methods produce a pair of keys, with the private key securely stored on the sending server for signing, and the public key published in the domain's DNS for verification by recipients.
  • DNS Record Variations: Public keys are published in DNS either directly as TXT records, or as CNAME records which point to keys managed and rotated by the service provider.

Key considerations

  • Infrastructure Dictates Method: The specific tools and methods for DKIM key generation are directly influenced by your email infrastructure. Cloud-based services and ESPs typically automate this process, while self-managed servers require direct engagement with command-line tools.
  • Private Key Security is Paramount: No matter how keys are generated, the private key must be kept extremely secure on the sending server. Its compromise could undermine email authentication and sender reputation.
  • Accurate DNS Publication: The public key, once generated, must be correctly published in your domain's DNS records, either as a TXT or CNAME entry, for successful DKIM verification by recipient mail servers.
  • Automation Benefits: Leveraging automated key generation from ESPs or cloud services simplifies setup and management, often including key rotation, reducing the manual burden on administrators compared to self-managed solutions.

Technical article

Documentation from DigitalOcean explains that DKIM public and private keys can be generated using the OpenSSL command-line tool. The private key is typically generated first using 'openssl genrsa -out dkim.private 2048', and then the public key is extracted from the private key using 'openssl rsa -in dkim.private -pubout -out dkim.public'. The private key is kept on the sending server, and the public key is published in the DNS records.

14 Dec 2024 - DigitalOcean Community

Technical article

Documentation from Zoho Mail explains that for users of their service, DKIM keys are automatically generated by the Zoho Mail system. Users do not need to manually generate them using external tools; instead, they retrieve the generated public key from their Zoho Mail admin console and publish it as a TXT record in their domain's DNS.

27 Nov 2023 - Zoho Mail Help

Start improving your email deliverability today

Sign up