Summary
Essential email service provider (ESP) capabilities for strong email authentication and valuable deliverability insights encompass a robust suite of tools. This includes comprehensive support for authentication protocols like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, with flexibility in domain alignment to ensure message legitimacy and DMARC compliance. Beyond authentication, ESPs must offer detailed, actionable reporting on email performance, encompassing traditional metrics, bounce management, and crucial reputation data such as complaint rates, spamtrap hits, and inbox placement across various ISPs. Access to granular data, the ability to manage sending profiles, and proactive monitoring tools are critical for marketers to effectively diagnose, resolve, and prevent deliverability issues, thereby optimizing inbox placement.
Key findings
- DMARC Flexibility: The ability for an ESP to allow DMARC's 'd=' identifier to align with either the visible From: domain or a subdomain is crucial for effective DMARC implementation and overall email security, enabling compliance and preventing spoofing.
- Granular Reputation Data: Access to specific, detailed reputation data, such as daily and per-IP complaint counters from major ISPs, SignalSpam user complaints, and spamtrap hits, offers highly valuable insights, particularly for ISPs lacking traditional feedback loops.
- Authentication Protocol Importance: Robust, user-friendly setup and ongoing support for essential protocols like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC are fundamental ESP capabilities, as they directly impact email authentication success and a sender's reputation.
- Reporting Depth and Breadth: Comprehensive reporting that goes beyond basic open and click rates to include detailed bounce classifications, spam complaint rates, inbox placement, and DMARC aggregate reports, is vital for accurately diagnosing and improving deliverability issues.
- Sender Profile Management: An ESP's flexibility in managing sending profiles and providing associated engagement data is a key differentiator, empowering brands to better segment their sending, control their reputation, and ultimately enhance their deliverability.
Key considerations
- Full Authentication Support: Prioritize ESPs offering easy setup and robust support for SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, including flexible domain alignment options and the provision of DMARC aggregate and forensic reports for comprehensive authentication oversight.
- Actionable Deliverability Analytics: Look for detailed reporting on opens, clicks, bounce rates, and crucially, spam complaints per destination. This should include access to automated feedback loops and potentially spamtrap data to provide actionable insights.
- Reputation Monitoring Tools: Consider ESPs that provide or integrate with tools for monitoring sender reputation, blocklist status, and inbox placement across various ISPs, such as alignment with Google Postmaster Tools and pre-send testing capabilities.
- List Hygiene and Bounce Management: Ensure the ESP offers automated bounce management and integrated email validation tools to maintain a clean list, which is essential for sustained deliverability and a positive sender reputation.
- Access to SMTP Logs and Error Codes: Granular access to SMTP logs and specific bounce reason codes can be invaluable for diagnosing complex deliverability problems that may not be apparent from high-level reports.
- Dedicated IP and Domain Warm-up Support: For high-volume senders, the availability of dedicated IP addresses and robust support for domain warm-up strategies are important considerations to establish and maintain a strong sending reputation.
What email marketers say
13 marketer opinions
The capabilities of an Email Service Provider (ESP) are paramount for ensuring robust email authentication and providing actionable deliverability insights. Core to this is comprehensive support for authentication protocols, including SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, with flexibility in how these are implemented, such as aligning DMARC's 'd=' identifier. Beyond secure authentication, essential ESP features extend to advanced analytics and detailed reporting that go beyond basic metrics. This encompasses granular data on bounces, spam complaints per destination, spamtrap hits, and inbox placement across diverse Internet Service Providers (ISPs). The ability to effectively manage multiple sending profiles, coupled with tools for list hygiene, pre-send testing, and ongoing reputation monitoring, empowers marketers to identify, diagnose, and resolve deliverability challenges proactively, ultimately optimizing their email program's performance.
Key opinions
- Advanced Authentication Setup: ESPs must offer comprehensive, yet flexible, support for authentication protocols like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, including options for subdomain alignment and legacy header support for unique sending configurations.
- Detailed Reputation Metrics: Access to granular, per-IP and per-destination complaint counters, spamtrap data, and specific ISP feedback loop insights, such as those from French ISPs or SignalSpam, is invaluable for diagnosing and improving deliverability.
- Actionable Post-Send Analytics: Essential capabilities include post-send analytics providing insights into inbox placement, detailed bounce classifications, spam complaint rates per destination, and engagement metrics, which are critical for continuous optimization.
- Strategic Sending Profile Control: The ability for an ESP to support the management of multiple sending profiles, along with specific engagement and reputation data for each, significantly empowers brands to segment and protect their sender reputation.
- Proactive Deliverability Monitoring: Key ESP features extend to pre-send testing tools to check for spam triggers, real-time blocklist monitoring, integrated email validation, and support for domain warm-up strategies to proactively manage sender reputation.
Key considerations
- Comprehensive Authentication Support: Prioritize ESPs that offer seamless setup and management of SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, allowing for flexible domain alignment and providing DMARC reporting for compliance and security.
- Granular Deliverability Reporting: Seek ESPs providing deep insights into deliverability, including detailed bounce classifications, per-destination complaint rates, spamtrap alerts, and inbox placement metrics across various ISPs. Access to SMTP logs and specific bounce reason codes is also highly beneficial.
- Advanced List Hygiene Tools: Essential ESPs should include automated bounce management, integrated email validation, and tools for list hygiene to proactively remove invalid addresses and maintain list quality, which directly impacts sender reputation.
- Proactive Reputation Management: Look for features like pre-send testing tools to check for spam triggers, real-time blocklist monitoring, and support for domain warm-up strategies to establish and maintain a positive sender reputation.
- Flexible Sending Profile Management: Consider ESPs that provide options for managing different sending profiles or subdomains, along with associated reputation data, enabling better segmentation and reputation control.
- Dedicated IP and Deliverability Consulting: For high-volume senders, the availability of dedicated IP addresses and access to deliverability experts or consulting services can be critical for ongoing optimization and issue resolution.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks explains that while many ESPs default to aligning 'd=' with the visible From: domain, it is still possible to use a subdomain for 'd='. He elaborates on how his system allows adding a Sender: header with the Envelope MailFrom domain for DKIM signing, which is a legacy feature enabling this flexibility without additional development.
22 Nov 2023 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks shares that ESPs' options for managing sending profiles are a key differentiator in deliverability. He notes that many brands, lacking understanding, cannot improve deliverability due to ESP inflexibility, particularly regarding access to reputation data like SNDS and SignalSpam, and the lack of engagement reporting per destination or sending profile.
2 Nov 2024 - Email Geeks
What the experts say
4 expert opinions
For successful email programs, an Email Service Provider's (ESP) capabilities in handling email authentication and providing actionable insights are indispensable. This includes fundamental support for critical protocols like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, coupled with flexible implementation options for DMARC's domain alignment. Crucially, access to DMARC reporting is vital for monitoring sending activities, identifying authentication failures, and countering malicious spoofing attempts, which directly impacts a sender's reputation and security. While some specific industry tools like SNDS may have limited utility for certain experts, the overarching requirement remains for ESPs to offer robust authentication setups and transparent reporting to ensure legitimate mail reaches its destination.
Key opinions
- DMARC 'd=' Flexibility: The flexibility for an ESP to allow DMARC's 'd=' identifier to be based on the visible From: domain, or a subdomain of it, is fundamental for proper DMARC implementation and email security.
- DMARC Reporting Value: DMARC reporting is an essential ESP capability for deliverability insights, enabling senders to understand who is sending on their behalf, identify SPF and DKIM authentication failures, and detect malicious spoofing. This data is critical for improving email reputation and security.
- Core Authentication Support: Essential ESP capabilities for email authentication involve the comprehensive setup and ongoing support for SPF, DKIM, and SenderID for clients. These protocols are vital for verifying sender identity and preventing spoofing, directly contributing to deliverability and reputation.
- Tool Utility Varies: The perceived utility of certain deliverability monitoring tools, such as SNDS or SignalSpam, can vary among experts based on their specific market experiences and operational needs, suggesting that not all tools provide universal value.
Key considerations
- Ensure DMARC Flexibility: When evaluating an ESP, verify its ability to offer flexible DMARC 'd=' alignment, allowing it to be based on your visible From: domain or a subdomain, which is crucial for effective DMARC deployment.
- Prioritize DMARC Reporting: Select an ESP that provides robust DMARC reporting capabilities, as these reports are invaluable for gaining insights into your sending patterns, detecting authentication issues, and preventing email spoofing.
- Confirm Core Authentication Support: Choose an ESP that offers comprehensive setup and continuous support for SPF, DKIM, and SenderID, as these foundational authentication protocols are essential for maintaining sender reputation and deliverability.
- Assess Tool Relevance: When considering specific deliverability tools, evaluate their relevance and proven utility for your particular market and operational context, recognizing that not all tools may be equally effective for every sender.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks responds that the flexibility to put 'd=' based on the visible From: domain, or a subdomain of it, makes DMARC possible.
18 Apr 2025 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks shares her perspective that she has never found SNDS to be particularly useful. She also expresses uncertainty about the utility of SignalSpam due to her limited work within the French market.
20 Feb 2022 - Email Geeks
What the documentation says
5 technical articles
For effective email delivery, an Email Service Provider (ESP) must offer a range of specific capabilities centered on robust authentication and actionable performance analytics. This begins with comprehensive support for core email authentication protocols-SPF, DKIM, and DMARC-which are vital for verifying sender identity and combating spoofing. Equally important are the advanced reporting features that provide deep deliverability insights, including DMARC aggregate and forensic reports, automated feedback loops for bounces and complaints, and a full spectrum of campaign metrics such as open, click, and bounce rates. Furthermore, an ESP's ability to provide data that aligns with major sender reputation tools, like Google Postmaster Tools, is essential for monitoring and maintaining a healthy sending reputation.
Key findings
- Authentication Core: Robust support for SPF, DKIM, and DMARC is fundamental for validating email origin, preventing spoofing, and improving deliverability.
- DMARC Reporting: The provision of DMARC aggregate and forensic reports by an ESP is crucial for gaining visibility into authentication failures, detecting abuse, and fine-tuning DMARC policies.
- Automated Feedback Loops: Essential for deliverability insights, automated feedback loops for bounces and complaints allow senders to promptly identify and address issues, optimizing list hygiene and sending practices.
- Comprehensive Campaign Metrics: An ESP should offer broad reporting, including open, click, bounce, and abuse complaint rates, providing a holistic view of email performance and deliverability health.
- Reputation Tool Alignment: Capabilities that provide data aligning with sender reputation metrics from major platforms, such as Google Postmaster Tools, are vital for continuous monitoring of spam rates, IP and domain reputation.
Key considerations
- Strong Authentication Protocol Support: Choose an ESP that offers comprehensive, easy-to-implement support for SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, enabling robust email authentication.
- Detailed DMARC Reporting: Prioritize ESPs capable of generating and providing DMARC aggregate and forensic reports for in-depth insights into authentication status and potential abuse.
- Automated Bounce and Complaint Feedback: Ensure the ESP offers automated feedback loops for bounces and complaints, which are critical for timely issue detection and list management.
- Holistic Deliverability Reporting: Evaluate ESPs based on their ability to provide comprehensive campaign performance reports, including open rates, click-through rates, bounce classifications, and abuse complaints.
- Sender Reputation Alignment: Select an ESP that offers tools or data streams that integrate with or reflect metrics from major sender reputation services, like Google Postmaster Tools, for proactive reputation management.
Technical article
Documentation from SendGrid Documentation explains that essential ESP capabilities include robust support for email authentication protocols like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, which are critical for validating email origin and preventing spoofing, thereby improving deliverability.
17 Dec 2021 - SendGrid Documentation
Technical article
Documentation from Mailchimp Documentation details that an ESP should provide tools for DMARC implementation to enhance email security and deliverability. Additionally, comprehensive reporting features, including open rates, click-through rates, bounces, and abuse complaints, are crucial for gaining deliverability insights.
22 Oct 2021 - Mailchimp Documentation
How do ESPs impact deliverability on dedicated IPs?
How do Internet Service Providers track email engagement and its impact on deliverability?
How do SPF, DKIM, DMARC, and dedicated IPs affect email deliverability when using a third-party ESP?
How to evaluate an ESP for deliverability before setting it up?
What are the essential tools and practices for email deliverability?
What deliverability and compliance tools should a new ESP implement?
