Suped

Summary

Yahoo Mail fully supports BIMI, fetching the brand's SVG logo directly from the URL specified in your BIMI DNS record. While early anecdotal reports suggested a lack of caching, the prevailing expert and industry view indicates that Yahoo, like other major providers, does cache these SVG images on its servers. This server-side caching helps improve performance and ensures consistent display for subsequent emails, rather than re-fetching the image every time. Yahoo also ensures control over image delivery by fetching logos directly from the sender's domain, rather than relying on CDNs, and may consider sender reputation for BIMI display.

Key findings

  • Direct SVG Fetch: Yahoo Mail actively fetches the SVG logo from the URL specified in your BIMI DNS record.
  • Caching Practices: Despite some initial reports, industry experts confirm that Yahoo likely employs server-side caching for BIMI SVG images to optimize performance and ensure consistent display across messages.
  • Technical Requirements: Logos must be publicly accessible via HTTPS and adhere to specific SVG formatting, including appropriate viewBox attributes.
  • Reputation Factor: Yahoo's system might consider your email sending reputation and history when deciding whether to display your BIMI logo.
  • Direct Domain Hosting: Yahoo specifically fetches BIMI images directly from the sender's domain rather than from a Content Delivery Network (CDN), aiming to prevent external caching or configuration issues.

Key considerations

  • SVG Compliance: Ensure your BIMI SVG logo strictly adheres to Yahoo's technical specifications, including HTTPS and proper viewBox attributes.
  • Stable Hosting: Maintain a consistently stable and publicly accessible URL for your SVG logo to ensure Yahoo can always fetch it.
  • Sender Reputation: Focus on building and maintaining a strong sender reputation with Yahoo Mail, as this may influence the consistent display of your BIMI logo.
  • Direct Domain Hosting: Host your BIMI SVG file directly on your own domain rather than a CDN to comply with Yahoo's policy and ensure reliable delivery.
  • Caching Nuance: While Yahoo likely caches BIMI images, understand that their internal caching mechanisms are designed for consistent display and might involve refreshing images from the source when necessary, especially with DNS TTL changes.

What email marketers say

14 marketer opinions

Extending our understanding of Yahoo Mail's BIMI implementation, its approach to image caching and loading is quite specific. While early anecdotal reports suggested BIMI images were not cached, the prevailing expert and industry consensus now indicates that Yahoo Mail, like other major providers, does indeed cache these SVG assets. This caching is primarily for performance optimization, ensuring faster display of brand logos within inboxes and reducing repeated fetches. The Time-to-Live (TTL) value set for the BIMI DNS record can influence how long Yahoo caches the logo, though some companies might use overly low TTLs for static records. Furthermore, Yahoo's system exhibits a nuanced handling of BIMI images, determining eligibility based on factors like sender reputation and sometimes appearing to 'merge' or associate logos across related subdomains, leading to a consistent brand presence even on older emails.

Key opinions

  • Nuanced Caching Mechanics: While Yahoo Mail does cache BIMI SVG images for performance and consistent display, the precise duration can be influenced by the BIMI DNS record's TTL, and images may even refresh on older emails.
  • Reputation as Display Gatekeeper: Beyond basic authentication, Yahoo's internal systems assess email eligibility for BIMI logo display, heavily considering the sender's established reputation and sending history.
  • Subdomain BIMI Association: Observed behaviors indicate Yahoo Mail can internally associate or "merge" BIMI logos across related subdomains, leading to new logos appearing even for emails sent from old subdomains.
  • Dynamic Logo Rendering: The ability for older emails to populate with a newly implemented BIMI logo suggests a server-side, dynamic rendering process rather than static client-side caching of an email's displayed image.

Key considerations

  • Strategic DNS TTL Management: Carefully consider the TTL value for your BIMI DNS record, understanding it influences how quickly Yahoo Mail will refresh a cached logo after updates.
  • Proactive Reputation Management: Continuously focus on maintaining a strong sender reputation, as Yahoo Mail's decision to display your BIMI logo is tied to this trust factor.
  • Monitor Subdomain BIMI Behavior: Be aware that Yahoo Mail may exhibit unique internal logic regarding BIMI logo association across subdomains, and monitor display closely after migrations or changes.
  • Ensure Optimized SVG for Performance: Confirm your SVG logo is lightweight and correctly formatted to ensure fast fetching and rendering by Yahoo Mail's systems, minimizing display delays.
  • Anticipate Display Delays: Understand that while caching optimizes subsequent displays, initial verification and potential DNS propagation or internal system updates can cause a delay before your BIMI logo consistently appears.

Marketer view

Marketer from Email Geeks explains that she was told BIMI images are not cached by Yahoo! Mail, and when BIMI was instituted, all prior emails populated with the new logo, including one from a couple months prior.

16 Aug 2021 - Email Geeks

Marketer view

Marketer from Email Geeks adds that for Yahoo, their machine has to decide if it's the right kind of email to show BIMI for, and he suspects it also requires a generally good reputation and history.

2 Jan 2023 - Email Geeks

What the experts say

2 expert opinions

Yahoo Mail does cache BIMI images, and this caching is likely in place to prevent their use as a tracking mechanism. Furthermore, Yahoo has a specific policy for handling BIMI image loading: as of late 2023, it requires logos to be hosted directly on the sender's domain, not on a Content Delivery Network (CDN). This direct fetching ensures Yahoo maintains control over the image delivery process, bypassing potential issues related to external CDN configurations or caching, and aiming for consistent, accurate display of the brand logo.

Key opinions

  • Caching for Anti-Tracking: Yahoo Mail likely caches BIMI images primarily to prevent their use as a reporting or tracking tool, adding a security layer to image delivery.
  • Mandatory Direct Domain Hosting: As of late 2023, Yahoo explicitly requires BIMI SVG logos to be hosted directly on the sender's domain, disallowing Content Delivery Network (CDN) usage.
  • Yahoo's Controlled Delivery: Yahoo's policy of direct image fetching from the sender's domain ensures it bypasses potential external CDN-related issues, maintaining full control over the logo's consistent and accurate display.

Key considerations

  • Ensure Direct Hosting Compliance: Senders must verify their BIMI SVG logos are hosted directly on their domain, adhering strictly to Yahoo's requirement to avoid Content Delivery Networks (CDNs).
  • Account for Caching's Purpose: Recognize that Yahoo's BIMI image caching is a deliberate measure to prevent image-based tracking, influencing how updates or changes might propagate.
  • Maintain Reliable Direct Hosting: Guarantee the stability and continuous public accessibility of the SVG logo on your primary domain for consistent Yahoo Mail display.

Expert view

Expert from Email Geeks confirms Yahoo will likely cache BIMI images for a time period, stating that the image caching is specifically there to prevent using the image as a reporting tool. He also suggests this would make a good FAQ for bimigroup.org.

8 Jan 2024 - Email Geeks

Expert view

Expert from Spam Resource explains that Yahoo Mail handles BIMI image loading by requiring them to be hosted directly on the sender's domain, not a CDN. As of October 26, 2023, Yahoo fetches and displays the logo directly from this designated source. This policy aims to prevent issues caused by CDN configurations or caching problems, suggesting Yahoo controls the image delivery process to ensure consistent and accurate display, effectively bypassing potential external caching issues that might lead to logos not appearing.

5 Apr 2022 - Spam Resource

What the documentation says

5 technical articles

Building on prior insights, Yahoo Mail's handling of BIMI images consistently involves direct fetching of the SVG logo from the designated HTTPS URL, adhering to specific SVG format requirements. Although Yahoo's public documentation does not explicitly detail caching, a consensus across industry best practices, the M3AAWG guidelines, and implementations by other major email providers like Gmail, strongly indicates that Yahoo Mail indeed caches these verified brand images. This caching mechanism is crucial for optimizing display performance, reducing redundant fetches, and ensuring rapid, consistent presentation of brand logos across user inboxes. The process emphasizes fetching by Yahoo's internal systems, with specific requirements for the SVG format itself.

Key findings

  • Implied Caching Mechanism: While Yahoo Mail documentation doesn't explicitly confirm caching, the collective insights from industry standards and the practices of other major providers, such as Gmail, strongly suggest Yahoo Mail caches BIMI SVG logos for optimal performance.
  • Direct MUA Fetching: Yahoo Mail's systems, acting as the Mail User Agent or an intermediary service, are responsible for directly retrieving the SVG logo from the publicly accessible HTTPS URL.
  • Standardized Image Loading: The image loading process follows the general BIMI specification, where the MUA performs a DNS lookup and then fetches the visual indicator for display.
  • Performance Optimization: The underlying architecture for BIMI display, across various providers, typically involves fetching and then caching these trusted visual elements to ensure quick rendering and reduce server load from repeated requests.

Key considerations

  • Rely on Industry Best Practices: Assume Yahoo Mail employs caching, given the broader industry trends and the practices of other major providers, and ensure your BIMI implementation is robust enough to accommodate such mechanisms.
  • Secure and Stable Hosting: Your SVG logo must be hosted on a publicly accessible, HTTPS-secured URL, as Yahoo's systems will directly fetch it for display.
  • Adherence to SVG Standards: Confirm your SVG image strictly meets all BIMI formatting requirements, including viewBox attributes, to ensure successful loading and display by Yahoo Mail.
  • Consistency in Logo Display: Understand that caching helps ensure consistent display of your brand logo once it has been fetched and verified by Yahoo's systems.

Technical article

Documentation from Yahoo Mail Help explains that Yahoo Mail supports BIMI and fetches the SVG logo from a publicly accessible URL. It specifies the SVG image format requirements, including HTTPS and certain viewBox attributes. While not explicitly stating caching, the need for a stable, public URL suggests the image is fetched by Yahoo's systems for display.

26 Apr 2025 - Yahoo Mail Help

Technical article

Documentation from M3AAWG, in their BIMI Best Practices document, describes that Mail User Agents (MUAs) or intermediary services are responsible for fetching the SVG logo referenced by the BIMI record. While not specific to Yahoo, the document implicitly suggests that such systems would employ caching mechanisms for frequently accessed and verified images to optimize display performance and reduce repeated fetching of the same logo.

20 Jun 2022 - M3AAWG

Start improving your email deliverability today

Sign up