Summary
Increased bot clicks and unexpected spam rates are growing concerns for email marketers. These issues can distort campaign metrics, leading to misinformed strategic decisions and potentially harming sender reputation. Bot clicks, often originating from security scanners or automated systems, can artificially inflate click-through rates (CTR) and create misleading engagement data. Meanwhile, sudden spikes in spam rates, even on historically clean accounts, can signal underlying deliverability challenges, sometimes exacerbated by new mail provider policies or changes in filtering mechanisms.
Key findings
- Automated Interaction: Bot clicks are often generated by anti-spam filters, security tools, or privacy features (such as those employed by Outlook.com or iCloud) that pre-scan links for malicious content before delivery to the inbox. This inflates reported click rates without actual human engagement.
- Skewed Metrics: Artificial clicks can severely distort email campaign performance metrics, making it difficult to accurately assess genuine subscriber engagement, A/B test results, and overall ROI.
- Sudden Spam Spikes: Unforeseen increases in spam rates, particularly for accounts with a long history of low complaints, can occur randomly and are sometimes observed days after a campaign send, possibly due to delayed spam reporting or evolving filter behaviors.
- .edu Accounts: Educational institutions (.edu domains) frequently use custom, robust anti-spam and security systems, leading to more erratic or heightened non-human interaction (NHI) patterns.
Key considerations
- Identify Bot Activity: It is crucial to develop methods for distinguishing between genuine human clicks and automated bot interactions to ensure data accuracy. This may involve implementing honeypot links or analyzing click patterns for unusual speed or volume.
- Monitor Spam Rates: Regularly monitor your spam rates, especially through tools like Google Postmaster Tools, to detect unusual spikes or patterns that could indicate deliverability issues or blocklisting.
- List Hygiene: Implement proactive list cleaning strategies to remove bot-generated or low-quality email addresses that could contribute to spam complaints or artificial engagement. This is critical for maintaining sender reputation.
- Adapt to Provider Changes: Stay informed about updates and enforcement changes from major mailbox providers (like Google and Yahoo), as these can significantly impact how your emails are processed and metrics are reported.
What email marketers say
Email marketers frequently encounter challenges with artificial clicks and unpredictable spam rates, which can obscure the true performance of their campaigns. Many report seeing unusual click patterns, particularly from educational domains, and unexplained increases in spam complaints. These observations highlight the impact of evolving security measures and how they complicate accurate metric analysis for email professionals.
Key opinions
- Unexpected Click Patterns: Marketers frequently observe spikes in clicks at send time, especially from .edu accounts, which seem legitimate based on email lists but don't align with website traffic. These are often from non-human interactions.
- Random Spam Spikes: Random spikes in spam rates (e.g., 4-6%) are reported on accounts that historically had near-zero spam rates, typically occurring a few days after a campaign rather than on the send day itself.
- Privacy Measures Impact: The increase in bot activity from providers like iCloud.com is often attributed to privacy measures designed to test links, making it difficult to distinguish real user clicks from automated ones and skewing tracking data.
- Distorted Data: Bot clicks distort key marketing data, affecting everything from click-through rates to A/B test results, making it harder to make data-driven decisions.
Key considerations
- Identifying Bot Clicks: Some marketers use strategies like embedding hidden, hyperlinked characters (e.g., a period) with matching text color, bolding, and underlining. A click on this indicates potential bot activity, which can then be tagged and segmented for further analysis.
- Cleaning Lists: Regularly reviewing and cleaning subscriber lists based on identified bot clicks helps to maintain data integrity and improve overall campaign effectiveness. This is part of a broader strategy to identify and prevent suspicious email addresses.
- Monitoring Tools: Leverage analytics platforms and email service provider (ESP) features to detect and segment bot clicks. Some marketers also use custom pixels for better vetting.
- Data Reliability: While manual detection methods may not be perfect, they can provide useful insights into data reliability and help inform reporting and strategy.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks highlights a pattern of numerous clicks at send time that appear legitimate based on email lists but do not match website traffic. They also note that these clicks are predominantly from .edu accounts, suggesting an unusual trend that seems off.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Cyberimpact explains that robot clicks, also known as automated or server clicks, occur when bots or automated systems interact with links in emails. These clicks can significantly inflate email metrics, making it difficult to gauge true human engagement and campaign performance.
What the experts say
Experts in email deliverability acknowledge the rising complexity of distinguishing legitimate engagement from bot activity. They point to the sophisticated nature of anti-spam systems, especially within large organizations and educational institutions, as a primary driver for non-human interactions. The consensus is that while these bots serve a security function, their actions significantly complicate email analytics and can lead to misleading performance indicators.
Key opinions
- Expected NHI: Non-human interaction (NHI) on .edu accounts is expected because many educational institutions use custom anti-spam third-party systems that generate diverse patterns of bot activity.
- Reputation Impact: An increase in inbox rates can, paradoxically, sometimes lead to increased spam complaint rates, as more emails reach recipients who may then mark them as spam.
- Broad Bot Activity: There has been a notable increase in bot activity from providers like Outlook.com Office 365 accounts since late March, observed across multiple clients and ESP products, potentially linked to recent platform updates.
- Filter Tracking: Tracking the specific filters responsible for NHI (non-human interaction) can provide much clearer patterns and insights into bot behavior.
Key considerations
- Analyze Click Data: Marketers should analyze click data from specific IP ranges or user agents that are known to be associated with security scanners or privacy features, which can help identify and mitigate the impact of bot clicks.
- Implement Honeypot Links: Strategically placing hidden (honeypot) links in emails that are only visible to bots can help in isolating and identifying automated clicks without affecting human users. This is a common tactic to combat spam filter and bot clicks.
- Leverage Feedback Loops: Utilizing Feedback Loops (FBLs) from major mailbox providers can offer insights into spam complaints, although some FBLs, like GPT FBL, might require experimentation with identifiers to work properly due to their non-intuitive nature.
- Stay Informed: Keep up to date with updates from major mailbox providers like Microsoft (for Outlook.com and Office 365), as changes in their systems can directly impact bot activity and spam rates.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks explains that non-human interaction (NHI) is expected on .edu accounts because many educational institutions use custom anti-spam third-party systems. This means that the patterns of bot activity can vary widely when sending to such recipients.
Expert view
Expert from SpamResource highlights that the majority of clicks seen in email tracking originate from legitimate security products. These tools are widely utilized by organizations to safeguard their systems, often by scanning links for malicious content before emails reach the recipient.
What the documentation says
Official documentation and research frequently address the mechanics of email security and filtering, which are direct causes of bot clicks and can influence spam rates. These sources explain how email security solutions pre-scan links to prevent malware and phishing, leading to automated interactions that are recorded as clicks. They also highlight how various updates and configurations in mail systems can contribute to shifts in deliverability and metric reporting.
Key findings
- Security Scanning: Email security systems and anti-spam filters automatically click on links in emails to verify their safety, identify malicious content, and prevent phishing attacks before the email reaches the recipient's inbox.
- Privacy Protections: Mailbox providers often employ privacy measures, such as Apple's Mail Privacy Protection, which can pre-fetch and click all links in an email, regardless of whether a human recipient opens or clicks. This activity is designed to protect user data and masks actual engagement.
- Inflated Metrics: The primary consequence of bot clicks is the artificial inflation of email marketing metrics like click-through rates (CTR) and engagement data, making it challenging for marketers to gain accurate insights into campaign performance.
- Deliverability Impact: While intended for security, extensive bot activity can sometimes overload servers, contribute to invalid traffic, and potentially affect an email's overall deliverability and sender reputation.
Key considerations
- Data Interpretation: Marketers must understand that reported email click data may not solely reflect human interaction. Adjusting data analysis to account for automated clicks is essential for accurate insights.
- Leverage ESP Features: Many email service providers offer features to help identify and filter out bot clicks or provide insights into their impact on metrics. Utilizing these tools is crucial for cleaner data.
- Consider Multi-Platform Data: Cross-referencing email campaign data with website analytics and other marketing platforms can provide a more holistic view of user engagement, helping to distinguish between bot clicks and genuine interest.
- Impact of Updates: System updates by major mailbox providers (e.g., Microsoft Office 365) can significantly alter bot click behavior and reported spam rates. Marketers should monitor these updates.
Technical article
Documentation from HubSpot Community explains that bots are specifically designed to click links in emails as a method of exploration, identification, and prevention. This helps to stop links to malware or phishing attacks from ever reaching a recipient's inbox, serving a critical security function.
Technical article
Documentation from Omeda confirms that many clicks observed in email tracking originate from legitimate security products. These products are widely utilized by organizations to protect their systems, contributing to non-human interaction that appears as valid clicks.
Related resources
15 resources
Related pages
How to identify artificial email opens and clicks generated by spam filters?
How do Barracuda spam filter clicks impact email metrics and deliverability?
Why do hidden links in emails get high click rates from bots and automated systems?
How to combat spam filter and bot clicks on emails?
How to identify and remove bot-generated spam email addresses from contact lists and prevent future bot sign-ups?
How to avoid false email click and open data from anti-spam bots?
How can I prevent bot clicks from hurting my email reputation?
Why am I seeing a sudden increase in bot click activity in my email campaigns?
What could cause unusual click activity concentrated on a single link in an email campaign, primarily from Amazon EC2 IPs?
How can I identify and mitigate the impact of bot clicks on email marketing metrics?
