Summary
Bot clicks and opens, particularly from large providers like Microsoft and Outlook, can significantly skew email marketing campaign data. These automated interactions are often security or privacy-related scans, designed to check for malicious content before an email reaches a recipient's inbox. Identifying and handling them is crucial for accurate metric analysis and effective campaign optimization.
Key findings
- Opens vs. Clicks: Automated opens are increasingly unreliable due to privacy measures and email client pre-fetching. Bot clicks, however, are often part of security checks to scan for spam or malware.
- Microsoft/Outlook Specifics: There's a noticeable increase in bot activity from Microsoft and Outlook domains, sometimes leading to inflated click and unsubscribe numbers.
- User Agent Analysis: While null user agents can indicate bot opens, bot clicks often mimic real user agents, making them harder to distinguish by this method alone. Refer to our guide on identifying automated scripts and crawlers for more.
- Timestamp Analysis: Many non-human interaction (NHI) clicks occur immediately upon delivery, within a few seconds, which can be a strong indicator of bot activity.
Key considerations
- Unsubscribe Link Handling: If bot clicks are triggering unsubscribes, it indicates a critical configuration issue with your unsubscribe mechanism that needs immediate attention. An HTTP GET request should not instantly unsubscribe a user. This is further explained in our guide on how bot clicks affect deliverability.
- Landing Page Behavior: Beyond the initial click, analyzing bot behavior on the landing page (e.g., lack of JavaScript execution, typical bot patterns) can help differentiate them from human interactions. More details are available in this article on identifying email click bot activity.
- Beyond Raw Metrics: Relying solely on raw open and click rates can be misleading due to bot activity. Focus on more sophisticated metrics that reflect true human engagement and conversion.
What email marketers say
Email marketers frequently encounter challenges with bot clicks and opens, particularly from major ISPs like Microsoft/Outlook. These automated interactions can distort campaign performance data, leading to misinterpretations of engagement and potentially affecting list hygiene if not properly managed. Marketers are actively seeking solutions to accurately segment bot activity from genuine human interaction.
Key opinions
- Inflated Metrics: Marketers often observe seemingly high click and unsubscribe rates from Microsoft domains, which do not correlate with actual human engagement. For more insights, read about inflated clicks in ESP reporting.
- Seeking ESP Solutions: There's a desire for ESPs to proactively identify and filter bot clicks, ideally in collaboration with ISPs, to provide more accurate data to their users.
- Unsubscribe Concerns: A significant concern is when bot activity leads to automated unsubscribes, which directly impacts list health and legitimate subscriber counts.
- Challenges with Identification: While some bot opens might be identifiable by null user agents, the challenge remains with bot clicks that use realistic user agents, making them difficult to filter.
Key considerations
- Data Accuracy: Marketers need robust methods to distinguish between legitimate and bot-generated engagement to ensure their campaign analytics truly reflect human interaction.
- Impact on Segmentation: Inaccurate click data can lead to incorrect audience segmentation and targeting, as bot interactions may be misinterpreted as genuine interest. This also impacts inbox placement metrics.
- Advanced Bot Detection: While user agent and timestamp analysis are starting points, more advanced techniques are required to effectively identify sophisticated bot behavior, as discussed in this article on combating bot clicks.
Marketer view
An email marketer from Email Geeks observes a significant increase in bot clicks and opens, particularly from Microsoft/Outlook recipient domains, leading to questions about identification methods.
Marketer view
An email marketer from ActiveCampaign suggests that implementing CAPTCHA verification on in-line forms can be an effective strategy to combat bot clicks in email marketing campaigns.
What the experts say
Deliverability experts recognize that distinguishing bot clicks from human interactions is an ongoing challenge, especially with evolving security mechanisms from major email providers. They emphasize that while automated opens are becoming less reliable as a metric, clicks are still being used by security systems to scan for malicious content. Experts also caution against misinterpreting bot-generated activity as genuine engagement and highlight the importance of proper unsubscribe handling.
Key opinions
- Opens are Dead: Many experts consider email opens an unreliable metric due to caching and privacy-enhancing features by Mail User Agents (MUAs).
- Clicks for Security: Automated clicks primarily serve to test email content for spam, malware, and phishing. These clicks are not cached, so genuine human clicks will still be registered.
- Sophisticated Bots: Bots performing clicks often attempt to mimic human behavior to bypass phishing defenses, making them harder to detect through simple user agent checks. Learn how to handle suspicious bot clicks.
- Widespread NHI: Non-Human Interaction (NHI) has been present in click data for years, and it's not exclusive to Microsoft domains; many marketers may simply not have noticed it until recent spikes. For more, see our article on increased bot click activity.
Key considerations
- Unsubscribe Process: It is critical to ensure that clicking an unsubscribe link does not automatically unsubscribe a user; there should be a confirmation step. Failure to do so indicates a significant underlying problem with your unsubscribe mechanism.
- Real-time Adjustment: While retroactive cleanup of click data isn't strictly necessary, it's feasible to adjust counts as they are received to approximate true human engagement.
- Focus on Deeper Metrics: Email marketers should shift their focus from raw click rates to more meaningful engagement metrics that indicate true human interaction and conversion. As noted in this Act-On article, bot clicks can sometimes offer valuable deliverability signals.
Expert view
A deliverability expert from Email Geeks emphasizes that email opens are now largely unreliable as a metric, due to caching and privacy features implemented by MUAs.
Expert view
A deliverability expert from SpamResource explains that automated clicks are generally for content testing, such as spam or malware filtering, and are not cached.
What the documentation says
Official documentation and security research often provide insights into the mechanisms behind bot activity, particularly from email providers like Microsoft. These sources explain that automated systems pre-scan emails for security threats, leading to clicks and opens that are not reflective of human interaction. Understanding these technical underpinnings is vital for accurate data interpretation and maintaining robust email deliverability practices.
Key findings
- Security Scanning: Email systems employ automated scripts to scan links for phishing or malware before an email is delivered or accessed by a user. This is a common practice across major ISPs.
- Pre-fetching Content: Many email clients and security services pre-fetch or pre-load email content (including images, leading to 'opens') to enhance user experience or for security analysis. This explains a significant portion of bot opens.
- Botnet Activity: Botnets are known to be used for various malicious activities, including click fraud campaigns, which can contribute to spurious clicks on emails.
- Link Tracking Mechanisms: Email service providers (ESPs) track clicks via redirects to help senders understand engagement, but these mechanisms are also susceptible to bot interactions. Review documentation on how link tracking works.
Key considerations
- Mitigation Strategies: Documentation often suggests that effective strategies to combat bot clicks include analyzing specific user-agent strings, monitoring unusual click patterns or timeframes, and setting up alerts for suspicious activity. This aligns with our guidance on combating spam filter and bot clicks.
- Understanding Purpose: It's important to understand that bot interactions are often a necessary part of email security, rather than an attempt to intentionally skew marketer data.
- Privacy Measures: Some bot activities, particularly open tracking, are designed to enhance user privacy by masking true engagement, making it intentionally difficult for senders to track precisely. For example, some documentation details how to stop spam emails which may involve bot-like pre-scanning.
Technical article
Documentation from EmailTooltester.com defines a bot click or open as an interaction by an automated script, used primarily for checking for phishing links or viruses within an email.
Technical article
Mimecast documentation indicates that high click rates (e.g., 100%) originating from a single IP address, especially in phishing training scenarios, are strong indicators of bot clicks.
Related resources
11 resources
Related pages
How to identify artificial email opens and clicks generated by spam filters?
How to combat spam filter and bot clicks on emails?
How to avoid false email click and open data from anti-spam bots?
Why are we seeing automatic opens and clicks on Office 365 hosted recipient domains?
Why am I seeing a large uptick in Outlook clicks that appear to be bots?
How to Increase Email Click Through Rate [Step By Step Guide]
Why Your Email Deliverability Rate Is Wrong: Hidden Factors Most Marketers Miss
What does it mean when your email is blocklisted?
A simple guide to DMARC, SPF, and DKIM
Why Your Emails Fail: Expert Guide to Improve Email Deliverability [2025]
