Summary
Suspicious bot clicks are a common challenge in email marketing, often skewing performance metrics and raising questions about list quality and engagement. These automated interactions, originating from security software, spam filters, or malicious bots, can inflate click rates, making it difficult to discern genuine human interest. Identifying and managing these clicks is crucial for accurate campaign analysis and maintaining a healthy sender reputation.
Key findings
- Synchronized clicks: A high volume of clicks from the same domains at the exact moment an email is sent often indicates automated scanning by security software or email service providers (ESPs). These are typically benign scans checking for malicious links.
- Non-CTA clicks: When automated systems click on elements like logos or hidden pixels, rather than primary calls-to-action, it further suggests non-human interaction. For more on this, see why hidden links get high bot click rates.
- Impact on metrics: Bot clicks can significantly inflate open and click-through rates, making it difficult to assess true campaign performance and subscriber engagement. Learn more about how to avoid false email click data.
- Security vs. malicious bots: Not all bot activity is harmful. Many clicks come from legitimate security software scanning links for phishing or malware, aimed at protecting recipients. However, some are from malicious bots attempting to identify live email addresses.
Key considerations
- Data accuracy: Prioritize strategies to filter out bot clicks from your reports to gain a clearer understanding of genuine engagement. This ensures your marketing decisions are based on reliable data.
- Engagement metrics: Focus on metrics beyond initial clicks, such as subsequent opens, engagement with follow-up emails, and conversion rates, to gauge real recipient interest. Learn more from ActiveCampaign's strategies to handle bot clicks.
- Sender reputation: While security scans are generally harmless, a high volume of suspicious, non-organic activity (especially from certain IP ranges or user agents) could still impact how email providers perceive your sending behavior. Consider how to combat spam filter and bot clicks.
- Segmentation and exclusion: Implement strategies to identify and segment bot-driven clicks, excluding them from your primary engagement reports. This allows for more accurate analysis and better campaign optimization.
What email marketers say
Email marketers frequently encounter bot clicks, which can obscure real campaign performance and lead to misinformed decisions. The consensus among marketers often points towards distinguishing between benign security scans and potentially harmful bot activity that could affect deliverability or list hygiene. They seek practical methods to identify and filter these clicks to preserve data integrity.
Key opinions
- Security software as a source: Many marketers suspect that automated clicks, especially those occurring immediately upon send, originate from their recipients' security software or ESPs conducting link checks.
- Hidden link strategy: A common technique involves embedding invisible 1x1 pixel links in emails. Clicks on these hidden elements are a strong indicator of machine-driven activity. This helps marketers identify artificial email clicks.
- Focus on real engagement: Even if bot clicks inflate numbers, marketers are keen to understand if genuine engagement (subsequent opens, conversions) still occurs, indicating good inbox placement despite the noise.
- Data scrubbing: There's a strong desire to deduct non-organic clicks from reporting to ensure accurate metrics, especially for lead-generation campaigns.
Key considerations
- List health: While security scans aren't necessarily bad, identifying persistent bot activity helps in maintaining a cleaner email list and preventing bot sign-ups. For more information, see how to identify and filter bot email addresses.
- Reporting accuracy: Marketers need reliable methods to exclude bot-driven clicks from their reports to accurately measure campaign success and inform future strategies. Find out more about how email bots affect campaigns.
- Impact on lead nurturing: For B2B sales cycles, understanding if clicks are from real prospects or automated systems is vital for sales team follow-up. Bot clicks can create false positives in engagement scores.
- Observing trends: Marketers are advised to observe bot click patterns over time, as some machine-driven behaviors might be temporary or not directly tied to sender reputation.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks notes that suspicious click activity, such as 34 clicks from two domains at the exact send time on a small list, strongly suggests a bot situation. These are often automated scans by security software rather than human interaction.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks suggests that automated clicks often come from security software or an ESP's automatic link checking. It's a common occurrence in email marketing that can skew initial engagement metrics.
What the experts say
Experts in email deliverability acknowledge that distinguishing between legitimate security scans and malicious bot activity is critical. They highlight that while some bot clicks are a protective measure by recipients' IT systems, others can be indicative of list quality issues or attempts to trigger spam traps. Accurate identification is key to maintaining a strong sender reputation and ensuring messages reach the inbox.
Key opinions
- IP address monitoring: Experts suggest closely monitoring the IP addresses associated with clicks. Multiple clicks from the same IP or from data center IPs shortly after sending are strong indicators of bot activity. This helps identify the source of sudden increases in bot click activity.
- User-agent analysis: Analyzing the user-agent string of the clicker can reveal whether the interaction is from a known security scanner or an unusual bot. Many security bots have identifiable user-agent patterns.
- Impact on sender reputation: While security scans are usually benign, persistent engagement from non-human sources, especially if it leads to spam trap hits, can negatively impact your sender reputation and lead to blacklisting. Consider ways to prevent bot clicks from hurting your reputation.
- Beyond click rates: Experts stress that email marketers should look beyond raw click-through rates and focus on deeper engagement metrics that confirm human interaction, such as subsequent page visits or conversions.
Key considerations
- Filtering bot activity: Implementing robust filtering mechanisms within your email service provider or analytics tools to exclude known bot traffic is essential for accurate reporting. Check MailSoar's guide on email click bots.
- List hygiene: Regularly cleaning your email list to remove unengaged or suspicious contacts can mitigate the impact of bot activity. Bots often target inactive addresses or attempt to validate new ones.
- Authentication protocols: Strong email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) helps mail servers trust your sending domain, reducing the likelihood of your emails being subjected to aggressive scanning by filters. This is important for understanding why automated scripts are opening your emails.
- Monitoring tools: Leverage deliverability monitoring platforms that provide insights into unusual click patterns, IP addresses, and user agents to proactively detect and address bot activity.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks explains that the presence of bot clicks, particularly those from security scanners, indicates that an email passed initial spam filtering, suggesting it landed in the inbox. While the clicks are not human, the delivery itself is a positive signal for deliverability.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks advises that anomalous click activity often doesn't directly correlate with sender reputation, especially if it's due to time-sensitive machine scanning. Marketers should continue monitoring for consistent patterns rather than reacting to isolated incidents.
What the documentation says
Official documentation from various email service providers, security vendors, and industry bodies provides technical insights into how automated systems interact with emails. This information is vital for understanding the mechanisms behind bot clicks and implementing robust strategies for identification and mitigation. The emphasis is often on maintaining data integrity while ensuring legitimate emails reach their intended recipients without triggering unnecessary security measures.
Key findings
- Automated security checks: Email security systems (e.g., ATP, anti-phishing solutions) automatically open and click links in incoming emails to scan for malicious content before delivery to the user's inbox.
- User-agent headers: Many automated systems identify themselves via specific user-agent strings in HTTP requests. Monitoring these headers can help distinguish bot traffic from human clicks, as explained in Interspire's guide to decoding automated clicks.
- IP ranges of scanners: Documentation often provides lists or characteristics of IP ranges belonging to known security services or data centers, from which bot clicks frequently originate.
- Impact on metrics: Platforms like Klaviyo acknowledge that bot clicks can affect engagement metrics and provide guidance on how to measure engagement while accounting for automated activity. See Klaviyo's documentation on understanding bot clicks.
Key considerations
- Filtering bot data: ESPs and analytics platforms often have built-in features to detect and filter bot clicks, ensuring that reported metrics reflect human engagement. It's crucial to utilize these tools for data hygiene.
- Engagement measurement: Focus on metrics that bots are less likely to influence, such as conversions, replies, or multi-step engagement flows, to assess true campaign effectiveness. Learn more about hidden factors affecting deliverability rate.
- Authentication standards: Adhering to email authentication standards (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) is highlighted as a best practice to build trust with receiving mail servers, which can reduce the need for extensive pre-delivery scanning. See how to boost deliverability rates with technical solutions.
- Proactive bot prevention: Beyond identifying clicks, documentation often covers methods to prevent bot sign-ups, which helps maintain a clean and engaged subscriber list from the outset.
Technical article
Google Postmaster Tools documentation describes how email security systems often pre-fetch URLs in incoming emails to check for malicious content. These automated visits appear as clicks, and while they don't represent human engagement, they confirm the email reached an inbox protected by such systems.
Technical article
Microsoft 365 Security documentation outlines the behavior of Advanced Threat Protection (ATP), where links are rewritten and scanned upon delivery. This scanning mechanism results in automated clicks that are part of the security process, not user interaction.
Related resources
15 resources
Related pages
How to identify artificial email opens and clicks generated by spam filters?
How to prevent bot sign-ups and suspicious contacts on email lists?
Why do hidden links in emails get high click rates from bots and automated systems?
How to combat spam filter and bot clicks on emails?
How to avoid false email click and open data from anti-spam bots?
Why am I seeing a sudden increase in bot click activity in my email campaigns?
Why are automated scripts and crawlers opening my emails, and how can I identify and exclude them from tracking?
How can I prevent bot clicks from hurting my email reputation?
How to identify and filter bot email addresses for email list hygiene?
Why your email deliverability rate is wrong: hidden factors most marketers miss
