What is a DKIM temperror in simple terms?

A DKIM temperror means the receiving email server (like Microsoft's) had a temporary issue trying to retrieve your DKIM public key from your DNS. This could be due to a DNS timeout, a network glitch, or a temporary problem on the receiver's end. It's not a permanent failure, but it does prevent DKIM from passing for that specific email.

Will a temperror cause my emails to bounce?

Not directly. These are temporary errors and mail servers are generally tolerant of them in small numbers. However, if they happen frequently, they can cause DMARC to fail, which could lead to your emails being sent to spam or being rejected with a bounce error . It's a sign that your authentication isn't as robust as it could be.

What is the first step I should take to fix this?

Start by checking your DKIM record's syntax and ensuring it's published correctly in your DNS. Then, evaluate your DNS provider's performance. Upgrading to a faster, more reliable DNS host is often the most effective solution. For Microsoft 365, double-check that your selector1 and selector2 CNAME records are set up exactly as specified by Microsoft.

Can I get my temperror rate to zero?

Unfortunately, you can't eliminate them completely because some of the causes are within Microsoft's vast network and outside of your control. The goal is to minimize them by making your configuration as perfect and resilient as possible, which reduces the probability of a transient issue causing a validation failure.

Diagnosing and reducing DKIM temporary error rates with Microsoft - DKIM - Learn

An illustration of a computer sending an email that encounters a temporary error on its way to a server.

Struggling with DKIM 'temperror' results in your DMARC reports from Microsoft? This article breaks down what these temporary errors mean, why they are common with Outlook and Microsoft 365, and provides actionable strategies to diagnose your setup and reduce their frequency. Learn how to strengthen your email authentication and improve deliverability.

If you've ever dug into your DMARC reports, you might have come across a frustratingly vague result: temperror. This temporary error can be particularly common in reports from Microsoft's email services, like Outlook.com and Microsoft 365. It's a tricky issue because, as the name implies, it's temporary. It doesn't mean your DKIM record is wrong, but it does mean that for a moment, the receiving server couldn't verify it.

This can feel like chasing a ghost. One minute your emails are authenticating perfectly, the next you see a spike in these temporary failures. While a few of these are normal in any large-scale email operation, a high rate of DKIM temperrors can weaken your overall email authentication posture. Understanding why they happen, especially with Microsoft, is the first step toward minimizing their impact and keeping your deliverability strong.

What is a DKIM temperror?

In the context of DMARC, a temperror status for DKIM means that the receiving mail server (in this case, Microsoft) encountered a temporary problem while trying to look up your DKIM public key in the DNS. It's not a permanent failure (permerror), which would indicate a definitively broken or incorrect DNS record. Instead, it's a transient issue.

Think of it like trying to call a friend. A permerror is like dialing a number that doesn't exist. A temperror is like getting a busy signal or a dropped call; the number is correct, but something temporarily prevented the connection. For DKIM, this could be a DNS query timing out, a momentary network problem between the receiver and your DNS server, or a temporary issue on the receiving server's end.

These errors are particularly concerning because they prevent a successful DKIM signature validation. When this happens, the email can't pass a DMARC check that relies on DKIM alignment. If SPF also fails or isn't aligned, the email could be quarantined or rejected, impacting your overall deliverability and sender reputation.

The specific challenge with Microsoft's ecosystem

Many senders notice a higher frequency of DKIM temporary errors originating from Microsoft's mail servers. This isn't necessarily a fault in your configuration. Microsoft operates one of the largest and most complex email infrastructures on the planet. The sheer volume of DNS lookups they perform every second means that even a tiny percentage of transient failures can result in a noticeable number of intermittent SPF or DKIM checks appearing in DMARC reports.

There has been long-standing community discussion about this phenomenon, with system administrators and email experts sharing similar experiences of Microsoft DKIM verification failures. Factors can include internal DNS resolver load within Microsoft's network, rate limiting, or specific ways their systems handle DNS timeouts. While you can't control Microsoft's internal operations, you can ensure your own setup is as resilient and efficient as possible to give their servers the best chance of success.

Ideal DKIM lookup

The receiving server (Microsoft) initiates a DNS lookup for the public key specified in the DKIM signature's selector and domain.

Your DNS provider responds quickly with the correct TXT record containing the public key. The lookup is successful.

Microsoft's server uses the key to verify the email's signature. DKIM passes, contributing positively to the DMARC alignment check.

temperror scenario

The receiving server initiates the same DNS lookup, but a transient issue occurs, such as a network timeout or a delay in the DNS resolver chain.

The lookup fails to complete within the server's allowed time. It doesn't receive a definitive 'not found' but rather no successful response.

The server cannot verify the signature and records a DKIM result of temperror in your DMARC report. This counts as a DKIM fail for DMARC evaluation.

A server rack with network cables connecting to a large cloud symbol, depicting DNS lookups for email authentication.

How to investigate your DKIM setup

Before you can mitigate these errors, you need to be certain your own house is in order. The first step is always to verify your DKIM DNS records. A simple typo or formatting error can lead to validation problems. Your DMARC reports are the primary source for identifying which sending sources and selectors are producing these errors. Look for patterns; is it happening with a specific third-party sender or only with mail sent directly from your own servers?

You should manually check that your DKIM record is published correctly and is publicly resolvable. A correct DKIM record is a TXT record in your DNS, and it must be formatted precisely. For example, if your domain is example.com and your selector is s1, the record will be at s1._domainkey.example.com.

Example DKIM Recorddns

s1._domainkey.example.com.   IN   TXT   "v=DKIM1; k=rsa; p=MIIBIjANBgkqhkiG9w0BAQEFAAOCAQ8AMIIBCgKCAQEA..."

This shows the typical format for a DKIM TXT record in DNS. It includes the version, key type, and the public key itself.

Ensure your DNS provider is reliable and has fast response times globally. A slow DNS provider can contribute significantly to lookup timeouts, which are the primary cause of temperror results. If you suspect DNS issues, your provider's status page or support team might be able to offer insights.

Strategies for reducing DKIM temperror rates

While you can't completely eliminate these errors due to factors outside your control, you can take steps to minimize their frequency. Your goal is to make your DNS records as easy and fast as possible for Microsoft's servers to look up.

Use a high-performance DNS provider. This is the single most effective change you can make. A DNS host with a global anycast network will serve your records from a location physically closer to Microsoft's resolvers, reducing latency and the chance of a timeout.
Correctly configure Microsoft 365 DKIM. If you're sending from Microsoft 365, ensure you've set up the two required CNAME records for your custom domain. Microsoft uses a rotating selector system (selector1 and selector2), and both CNAMEs must point to the correct initial domain provided by Microsoft. An error here is a common source of validation problems.
Keep DKIM keys at a reasonable length. While 2048-bit keys are the standard for security, ensure they are formatted correctly. Some DNS providers have issues with very long TXT records, sometimes splitting them in ways that can cause lookup failures.
Monitor your DMARC data. Regularly check your reports to see if your changes are having an effect. If your temperror rate decreases over time, you'll know your efforts are paying off.

Ultimately, managing DKIM temporary errors with Microsoft is a game of percentages. Your aim is to make your configuration so flawless and your DNS so fast that you minimize the chances of a transient issue on their end causing a validation failure. By authenticating outbound email correctly and robustly, you are putting your best foot forward in a complex ecosystem.

Seeing a temperror in your DMARC reports can be alarming, but it's not always a sign of a critical problem. By understanding what it means, confirming your own configuration is perfect, and optimizing your DNS performance, you can significantly reduce the rate of these errors. This proactive approach ensures your emails have the best possible chance of being authenticated correctly, protecting your sender reputation and improving deliverability to Microsoft's vast user base.

0.0

What's your domain score?

Deep-scan SPF, DKIM & DMARC records for email deliverability and security issues.

Suped

Diagnosing and reducing DKIM temporary error rates with Microsoft