Summary
Gmail's practice of sometimes deleting the href tag from .zip download links in emails is a perplexing issue for many senders. While official documentation often discusses link rewriting for security, outright deletion suggests more stringent filtering. This behavior is primarily driven by Google's advanced security mechanisms aimed at protecting users from potential malware and phishing attempts, especially concerning executable content often found in archive files. Even if the content is benign, certain characteristics of the link or the hosting domain can trigger these protective measures.
Key findings
- Security protocols: Gmail employs aggressive security to protect users, which includes scanning and sometimes removing href tags on links perceived as risky, such as those pointing to .zip files. Google's link protections are in place for all its clients.
- Content scanning: Beyond the file type, Gmail scans the content of the linked resource for malicious code or suspicious patterns.
- Domain reputation: The reputation of the domain hosting the .zip file significantly impacts how the link is handled. Links from new, generic, or shared domains might be treated with more suspicion. Learn more about why Gmail shows 'dangerous' warnings.
- Differential treatment: Gmail (free accounts) and Google Workspace accounts may have different policies regarding attachment and link handling, with Workspace often having more permissive settings for trusted environments.
Key considerations
- Host reputable files: Consider hosting .zip files on well-known, secure content delivery networks (CDNs) or trusted cloud storage providers rather than less established or shared hosting.
- Review content: Examine the contents of your .zip file. Even if it's a data export, certain file types within the archive could trigger security flags.
- Test extensively: Send test emails to various Gmail accounts, including both free and Workspace, to observe link behavior. This can help identify specific email templates or content that causes issues.
- Monitor deliverability: Keep a close eye on your email deliverability rates and sender reputation. Poor reputation can lead to more aggressive filtering, including link manipulation or removal.
- Understand filters: Familiarize yourself with how email filters modify links to better anticipate potential issues.
What email marketers say
Email marketers often encounter unexpected behaviors with email clients, and Gmail's handling of .zip download links is a frequent point of discussion. Many report observing not just link rewriting, but complete deletion of href tags, which can significantly impact user experience and campaign effectiveness. Marketers suspect that Gmail's enhanced security measures, particularly for archive files, are the primary cause, alongside the nature of the hosting domain and file content. This highlights the need for thorough testing and alternative delivery methods.
Key opinions
- Unexpected behavior: Some marketers have directly observed the complete removal of the href tag, which differs from Gmail's stated policy of simply rewriting links for protection.
- Archive file scrutiny: There's a strong belief that Google Workspace and free Gmail impose significant blocks on remotely hosted archive files (like .zip), given their potential for malware distribution.
- Content matters: The specific content within the .zip file, even if it's non-PII data, is suspected to be scanned and could trigger deletion if deemed suspicious. This applies even if it's not a direct attachment, but a link, as noted by Quora users discussing zip blocking.
- Domain reputation and sharing: Links to shared or customer-facing domains (e.g., Shopify) that host content are flagged as potential issues due to their common use for file sharing, which can be exploited.
Key considerations
- Test different zips: Try sending emails with links to different .zip files, varying their content to isolate what might be triggering the deletion.
- Hosting location: Evaluate the hosting solution for your .zip files. Generic or multi-tenant cloud storage might be treated differently than links to your own, well-established domain.
- Template consistency: If the issue appears in one template, verify other templates with .zip links. This can help confirm if it's a specific email design or a broader policy enforcement.
- User experience: Consider the impact of deleted links on email click-through rates and overall user experience. Alternative methods for large file delivery might be necessary, for instance, links to a branded landing page.
- Attachment limits: While the issue is with links, remember that Gmail has attachment size limits (e.g., 25MB), which can influence the decision to use download links.
Marketer view
A marketer from Email Geeks observed that Gmail sometimes completely removes the href tag from .zip download links in emails, even though documentation only mentions rewriting. This behavior is perplexing because it goes beyond simple link modification.
Marketer view
A marketer from Email Geeks noted finding old forum discussions about Gmail not allowing .zip files as attachments, but their issue concerned download links. This indicates a broader concern with archive files, regardless of how they are delivered.
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts often analyze such behaviors through the lens of evolving threat landscapes and mailbox provider security. The deletion of href tags from .zip download links is not random; it's a calculated security measure. Experts suggest that Gmail's algorithms likely identify specific characteristics of the link, the host, or the expected content of the .zip file that trigger an outright block rather than a simple rewrite. This advanced filtering aims to prevent sophisticated phishing and malware distribution where malicious content might be nested within archives.
Key opinions
- Proactive security: Experts believe that Gmail's system is highly proactive, potentially identifying and neutralizing threats even before a user clicks, leading to link removal for high-risk items like executable files within zips.
- Reputation-based filtering: The sender's domain and IP reputation, combined with the reputation of the linked domain, heavily influence filtering decisions. A low or questionable reputation can lead to more severe actions like link stripping. Improving your domain reputation is crucial.
- Advanced content inspection: Modern email filters perform deep content inspection of linked resources, not just the email body, to detect suspicious elements inside compressed files.
- Heuristic analysis: Gmail likely uses heuristic analysis to flag links to zip files that resemble known spam or phishing patterns, even if the specific payload is new or unknown.
Key considerations
- Sender authentication: Ensure proper SPF, DKIM, and DMARC authentication is in place and aligned. Strong authentication builds trust and reduces the likelihood of aggressive filtering.
- Domain and IP consistency: Links should ideally point to domains that align with your sending domain, especially for sensitive downloads. Avoid using generic or shared file-hosting domains for critical content.
- Pre-delivery testing: Utilize email testing tools to preview how links appear in various email clients, including Gmail, before sending to your entire list.
- Monitor postmaster tools: Regularly check Google Postmaster Tools for insights into your sending reputation and spam rates, which can indirectly affect link handling.
Expert view
An expert from Email Geeks indicates that Gmail's aggressive security protocols often lead to the removal or alteration of links perceived as risky, especially those pointing to executable or archive files. This measure is taken to protect users from potential threats.
Expert view
An expert from SpamResource recommends avoiding generic file hosting domains for sensitive or unexpected downloads, as these are frequently abused by spammers and are under heavy scrutiny. Such domains are often blocklisted or filtered.
What the documentation says
Official documentation from Google and other sources provides insight into their approach to email security and link handling. While direct statements about deleting href tags from .zip download links are rare, the emphasis is consistently on protecting users from malicious content. This protection involves comprehensive scanning of attachments and linked resources, often leading to modifications or blocks. The documentation also suggests that Gmail's algorithms are designed to evolve, adapting to new threats, which means filtering policies can change over time.
Key findings
- Link protection: Google states that link protections are added for all official Gmail clients to combat malicious websites, often involving rewriting links. While deletion isn't explicitly mentioned, it implies severe action for deemed threats.
- Content analysis: Documentation hints at deep content analysis of attachments and linked files, particularly for formats like .zip that can contain executables or scripts. This goes beyond simple file type checks.
- Threat evolution: Mailbox providers constantly update their security algorithms to counter evolving threats. What was permissible last month might be blocked today, impacting how email deliverability is affected.
- HTML parsing: Email clients may parse and render HTML differently, potentially leading to issues with complex or malformed href tags, even if RFC 5322 specifications are followed.
Key considerations
- Adhere to best practices: Beyond technical compliance, documentation implies that adhering to general email best practices and maintaining a good sender reputation is crucial for avoiding aggressive filtering.
- Transparent communication: When providing download links, make the purpose and content of the .zip file clear to the recipient, reducing the likelihood of it being flagged as suspicious.
- Alternative delivery: If sensitive or large files are frequently shared, consider directing users to a secure, authenticated portal or dedicated download page instead of direct .zip links.
- Understand blocklists: Familiarize yourself with how email blocklists work, as being listed can exacerbate link issues.
Technical article
Google support documentation on click-time link protections explains that Google adds link protection for all official Gmail clients due to malicious websites being sent in emails. This emphasizes their strong stance on user security.
Technical article
Google support documentation mentions that some link protections, including rewriting, are now available to users, highlighting their commitment to evolving security features. This implies that link behavior can change as new protections are rolled out.
Related resources
7 resources
![[FIXED] How to Fix “Can't Attach Files in Gmail” Error](https://www.auslogics.com/en/articles/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/shutterstock_718755355.jpg)
Related pages
Why do email filters modify or break links?
Why is Gmail showing 'This message seems dangerous' warning?
Why is Gmail throwing errors and marking my emails as phishing?
Why Your Emails Are Going to Spam in 2024 and How to Fix It
Email Deliverability Issues: Getting Your Messages to the Inbox in 2025
How to Improve Domain Reputation Using Google Postmaster Tools [2025 Guide]
An in-depth guide to email blocklists
What RFC 5322 Says vs. What Actually Works
