Summary
Email open tracking events not being registered for some recipients is a common issue with a variety of underlying causes, often unrelated to email deliverability itself. While emails might successfully reach the inbox, the traditional open tracking pixel might not fire due to recipient-side factors such as privacy features, ad-blockers, or how different email clients and devices handle image loading. This can lead to misleadingly low open rates, even when recipients are actively engaging with the content and clicking links.
Key findings
- Pixel reliance: Open tracking typically relies on a tiny, invisible image pixel embedded in the email. If this image doesn't load, the open isn't recorded.
- Privacy features: Apple's Mail Privacy Protection (MPP) and similar features from other email clients pre-fetch images, making it appear as if an email has been opened even if the recipient hasn't seen it, or they block pixels from loading entirely. For more details, see our guide on how Gmail's image proxy affects tracking.
- Client and device variations: Open tracking can behave differently across various email clients (Outlook, Gmail, Yahoo Mail) and devices (desktop, mobile apps, web clients). Some apps might block image loading by default or handle it inconsistently.
- Ad-blockers and firewalls: Certain ad-blocking extensions, corporate firewalls, or network configurations can prevent tracking pixels from loading, regardless of the user's interaction.
- Subdomain impact: The choice of subdomain for tracking links can sometimes influence whether tracking pixels are blocked, especially if the subdomain name contains terms that ad-blockers might flag.
- Inaccurate data: Open rates are increasingly becoming an unreliable metric for engagement due to these blocking mechanisms and pre-fetching behaviors, as highlighted by SocketLabs.
Key considerations
- Shift focus to clicks: Since open rates are less reliable, consider prioritizing click-through rates (CTR) as a primary engagement metric. Clicks are a more definitive sign of recipient interest and interaction. Our guide on how to accurately measure email open rates offers alternatives.
- Verify tracking setup: Ensure your email service provider's (ESP) tracking is correctly configured. Sometimes, issues can stem from the ESP's processing of data or technical glitches on their end.
- Test across environments: Conduct thorough testing of your emails across various email clients, devices, and network settings to identify where tracking might be failing. This includes testing with and without privacy features enabled.
- Monitor deliverability: While directly unrelated to open tracking, ensure your emails are consistently reaching the inbox. Issues with sender reputation or blocklistings can prevent emails from being delivered, which in turn means no opens can be registered. Understand why your emails are going to spam.
- Consider alternatives: Explore alternative engagement metrics, such as website visits from email links, conversions, or replies, to gauge campaign effectiveness more accurately, as suggested by Digital Marketing on Cloud.
What email marketers say
Email marketers frequently encounter discrepancies in open tracking, leading to frustration when reported opens don't match expected recipient engagement. Many share experiences where emails are clearly opened and interacted with, yet the open event is not registered by their tracking systems. This often points towards challenges with pixel loading, rather than an issue with email delivery itself. The conversation among marketers highlights the growing unreliability of open rates as a sole metric.
Key opinions
- Inconsistent tracking: Marketers report that open tracking can be highly inconsistent, with emails opened on one device or application (e.g., Outlook mobile) not registering an open, while the same email in a different client (e.g., Outlook web) might.
- Not a deliverability issue: If emails are confirmed to be delivered to the inbox, but opens are not tracked, marketers generally agree this points to a tracking system problem rather than a core deliverability issue. Our article on why emails show as delivered but not received is related.
- Impact of subdomains: Some marketers observe that the subdomain used for tracking can influence whether open events are registered. This suggests potential issues with ad-blockers or privacy tools targeting specific tracking URLs, or even GDPR implications for certain top-level domains like .eu.
- External ESP tracking: Even when using reputable ESPs like Sendgrid for open tracking, marketers report difficulties, indicating that the problem extends beyond homegrown solutions.
Key considerations
- Diagnose tracking implementation: It's crucial to investigate the technical implementation of your open tracking pixel. Ensure it's correctly embedded and that your ESP is processing the data as expected. Confirming that your tracking links are secure (HTTPS) is also important.
- Alternative engagement metrics: Rely less on open rates as a sole indicator of engagement. Focus on clicks, conversions, and replies, as these provide a more reliable measure of recipient interaction, particularly in the age of Mail Privacy Protection.
- Recipient environment factors: Recognize that issues might stem from the recipient's end, including their email client settings, network firewalls, or privacy software. This is a common challenge for all email senders.
- Subdomain and brand naming: Be mindful of the names used for tracking subdomains and overall branding, as these can sometimes trigger ad-blockers or content filters. Learn more about understanding your email domain reputation.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks shared their observation that sometimes an email opened in a mobile app, like Outlook, doesn't register an open, but if the same email is opened in the Outlook app on a computer or a web client, it might send an open event for some recipients but not others. This inconsistency makes it hard to rely on open rates.
Marketer view
Email marketer from FollowUp.cc Blog explains that open tracking serves more as an indicator than an absolute metric. They note that tracking every email open is impossible, as recipients may occasionally block tracking mechanisms.
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts generally agree that issues with open tracking are increasingly common and often stem from factors beyond whether an email successfully reached the inbox. They emphasize that open rates are becoming less reliable due to evolving privacy protections and technical nuances in how email clients handle tracking pixels. Experts advise focusing on the technical implementation of tracking and shifting to more robust engagement metrics.
Key opinions
- Tracking system focus: Experts primarily suggest that issues with open tracking not being registered usually point to a problem within the tracking system itself, rather than the email's deliverability to the inbox. This aligns with advice on whether email tracking pixels affect deliverability.
- Open rates are unreliable: It's a widely accepted view among experts that open rates are an increasingly unreliable metric due to factors like Mail Privacy Protection (MPP) and automated image pre-loading, as explained further in our insights on sudden drops in open rates.
- Data preprocessing by ESPs: Some ESPs (Email Service Providers) might preprocess open data to filter out automated loads, which can lead to discrepancies in reported open rates without the sender's direct knowledge.
- Ad-blocking influence: The content of a subdomain used for tracking can sometimes trigger ad-blocking extensions, preventing the tracking pixel from firing, even if the email is delivered successfully.
- GDPR implications: Privacy regulations like GDPR can influence how open tracking data is collected and processed, potentially affecting the reliability of open rates for recipients in certain regions (e.g., .eu domains).
Key considerations
- Technical troubleshooting: Conduct internal technical tests by generating tracking links and programmatically fetching them (e.g., using wget or curl) to confirm whether open events are correctly recorded by your tracking system.
- Distinguish deliverability vs. tracking: If emails are consistently hitting the inbox, the problem is most likely with open tracking, not deliverability. Focus troubleshooting efforts on the tracking mechanism rather than general email delivery issues.
- Adapt to privacy changes: Acknowledge that privacy-focused features from major ISPs and email clients are fundamentally changing the accuracy of open rates. This necessitates a broader approach to measuring engagement beyond just the open pixel. Explore alternative email tracking mechanisms.
- Holistic engagement view: Rely on a combination of metrics, including clicks, conversions, and subscriber feedback, to get a comprehensive understanding of campaign performance, rather than solely depending on potentially misleading open rates. Sparkle.io provides insights on this.
Expert view
Email expert from Email Geeks suggested that the user's tracking system might be the source of the problem. They recommended generating links and using tools like wget or curl to manually fetch them to verify if opens are being correctly recorded.
Expert view
Email expert from Word to the Wise notes that open tracking reliability has significantly declined due to privacy features like Apple's Mail Privacy Protection and increasing use of image blocking by various email clients and security software.
What the documentation says
Official documentation from email service providers and related platforms frequently highlights the limitations of open rate tracking, particularly concerning image loading and privacy. These resources often clarify that open rates are not 100% accurate and can be influenced by recipient settings and technical behaviors of email clients. The emphasis is increasingly on using open rates as an indicator rather than an absolute measure of engagement, and suggesting supplementary metrics.
Key findings
- Image-based tracking: Documentation confirms that open rate tracking relies on invisible images (pixels). If a recipient's email client has images turned off by default, the tracking image will not load, and the open will not be recorded.
- Inaccurate by design: Major ESPs like Mailchimp openly state that open rate tracking isn't 100% accurate due to various technical and user-controlled factors. This is an inherent limitation of pixel-based tracking, also discussed in our piece on Gmail's open tracking accuracy.
- Privacy feature impact: Modern privacy features, such as Apple's Mail Privacy Protection, pre-load images on proxy servers, which can falsely inflate open rates or cause them to register without actual recipient engagement. This fundamentally alters how engagement tracking is impacted.
- Focus on engagement: Documentation often recommends tracking other engagement metrics, such as clicks, to gain a more accurate understanding of recipient interaction, as clicks typically require explicit action from the user.
Key considerations
- Enable all tracking: Many platforms advise enabling both open and click tracking to get the most comprehensive picture of recipient behavior, as opens alone are no longer sufficient.
- Educate on limitations: Understand and communicate the inherent limitations of open tracking to stakeholders. Open rates should be seen as a directional indicator rather than a precise measurement.
- Review ESP guidelines: Regularly review your ESP's (Email Service Provider's) official documentation for updates on how they handle open tracking, particularly with new privacy features and changes in email client behavior.
- User interaction focus: Design emails to encourage explicit actions like clicks, which are more reliably tracked, to measure actual engagement effectively. This supports the move towards more robust email deliverability strategies.
Technical article
Documentation from Mailchimp explains that open rate tracking relies on images, making it less than 100% accurate. For instance, if a recipient's email client prevents images from loading, the tracking image won't load, and the open will not be recorded.
Technical article
Documentation from SendLayer states that their open tracking feature helps identify recipient engagement by recording who opens emails and the total count. However, it also implies reliance on pixel loading which can be influenced by client settings.
Related resources
11 resources
Related pages
How to accurately measure email open rates without relying on image pixels or clicks?
Do email tracking pixels affect deliverability?
What causes a sudden drop in email open rates?
How does Gmail's image proxy affect email open tracking and what could cause very fast opens?
Why are automated scripts and crawlers opening my emails, and how can I identify and exclude them from tracking?
Email Deliverability Issues: Getting Your Messages to the Inbox in 2025
Does Gmail accurately track email opens?
What is the deliverability impact of non-HTTPS engagement tracking in email marketing?
Why Your Emails Are Going to Spam in 2024 and How to Fix It
A practical guide to understanding your email domain reputation
