Suped

Why am I hitting spamtraps with double opt-in email addresses, and do spamtraps click?

Summary

It can be confusing and concerning to encounter spam traps, or blocklists, especially when you maintain a meticulously clean email list using double opt-in (DOI). The prevailing understanding is that legitimate spam traps are designed to catch egregious spamming practices, not engage with emails. So, the question of whether spam traps click on links in your emails is a critical one for deliverability professionals. While the direct answer is generally no, there are nuances related to how some mail providers process emails that can give the appearance of interaction, even from a spam trap address.

What email marketers say

Email marketers often grapple with spam trap hits, even when employing best practices like double opt-in. The common understanding within the marketing community is that double opt-in should filter out most problematic addresses, including many potential spam traps. However, practical experience sometimes reveals otherwise, leading to questions about the nature of these hidden blocklist addresses and their interactions.

Marketer view

An email marketer from Email Geeks explains that they are experiencing spam trap hits even with IPs dedicated solely to double opt-in (DOI) confirmed addresses, which they monitor via Microsoft SNDS. This situation is particularly puzzling given the expected protection offered by DOI.

20 Mar 2019 - Email Geeks

Marketer view

An email marketer from MailMonitor emphasizes that spam traps can infiltrate email lists due to accidental mistyped addresses during signup. This highlights the importance of data entry accuracy, even for those using double opt-in processes.

22 Mar 2025 - MailMonitor

What the experts say

Email deliverability experts offer a deeper insight into why marketers might hit spam traps even with double opt-in. Their perspectives often highlight the intricate mechanisms of spam trap networks, the lifecycle of email addresses, and the specific behaviors of major internet service providers (ISPs) like Microsoft. The consensus leans towards the idea that while spam traps themselves don't 'click', other factors might simulate such behavior or explain the presence of traps on seemingly clean lists.

Expert view

An email expert from Email Geeks indicates that there are other reasons for hitting spam traps beyond them clicking, such as recycled addresses that previously belonged to humans but are now traps. They note that sophisticated spam trap networks will 'season' these addresses by bouncing mail for at least a year before activating them as traps.

20 Mar 2019 - Email Geeks

Expert view

An email expert from Wordtothewise.com asserts that spam trap hits are often not the primary or sole cause of delivery problems. Instead, they serve as a straightforward indicator that certain email sending practices, such as mailing unknown addresses, lead to undesirable outcomes, prompting a deeper investigation into underlying issues.

22 Mar 2025 - Wordtothewise.com

What the documentation says

Technical documentation and research papers provide the foundational understanding of spam traps and email deliverability. They clarify the design and purpose of spam traps, explain the role of double opt-in, and describe how various anti-spam mechanisms operate. While they don't typically discuss spam traps 'clicking' in the traditional sense, they shed light on automated processes that might be misinterpreted as such.

Technical article

Documentation from Mailmunch states that email spam traps are hidden addresses specifically designed to catch senders with poor email practices, such as purchasing email lists or neglecting proper email hygiene. They are not intended for human interaction.

22 Mar 2025 - Mailmunch

Technical article

Documentation from TechTarget defines a double opt-in as a process that ensures recipients truly desire a sender's emails and verifies that the sender's list contains only legitimate addresses. This is a core mechanism for maintaining list quality.

22 Mar 2025 - Search Security

14 resources

Start improving your email deliverability today

Get started