Summary
Troubleshooting SPF authentication issues, particularly when managing multiple Email Service Providers (ESPs) across subdomains and CNAMEs, primarily revolves around two critical challenges: the 10 DNS lookup limit and the strict rule of having only one SPF TXT record per domain. A common pitfall occurs when subdomains CNAME'd to a main domain inherit the main domain's SPF record, leading to authentication failures if not properly addressed with dedicated subdomain SPF records. Solutions focus on consolidating 'include' statements into a single record to prevent exceeding the lookup limit, or using SPF flattening services that streamline multiple 'include' mechanisms into a single lookup. Proper management of subdomain-specific SPF records and consistent use of validation tools are also essential for maintaining email deliverability.
Key findings
- DNS Lookup Limit: The SPF authentication process fails if the SPF record exceeds the 10 DNS lookup limit, a frequent issue when multiple ESPs require their own 'include' mechanisms.
- Single SPF Record Rule: A domain must have only one SPF TXT record; having multiple SPF records for a single domain will cause authentication to fail.
- CNAME & SPF Compatibility: SPF records must be TXT records and cannot directly use CNAME records; if a domain or subdomain is CNAME'd, the SPF record should be configured on the CNAME's target domain or include the necessary mechanisms directly.
- Subdomain SPF Inheritance: Subdomains inherit the SPF record of their parent domain unless a specific SPF TXT record is defined for the subdomain, which is necessary if the subdomain sends email from different sources.
- Common Error Types: Frequent SPF issues include exceeding the 10 DNS lookup limit, the presence of multiple SPF records, and syntax errors within the SPF record itself.
Key considerations
- Consolidate Includes: Combine all necessary 'include' mechanisms from various ESPs into a single SPF TXT record for your domain to avoid exceeding the DNS lookup limit and prevent 'multiple SPF records' errors.
- Utilize SPF Flattening: Employ SPF flattening services to reduce multiple 'include' mechanisms to a single DNS lookup, a crucial strategy for complex setups with numerous ESPs or when consistently hitting the 10-lookup limit.
- Dedicated Subdomain SPF: Create dedicated SPF records for subdomains that send email independently or use different ESPs than the root domain to ensure proper authentication and isolate potential deliverability issues.
- Leverage Validation Tools: Regularly use SPF validation tools to check for syntax errors, verify the number of DNS lookups, and ensure there is only a single SPF record for your domain.
- Update Existing Records: When integrating a new Email Service Provider, always edit your existing SPF TXT record to include their specified mechanism, rather than creating a new SPF record.
What email marketers say
11 marketer opinions
Effectively managing SPF authentication in complex environments, particularly when integrating multiple Email Service Providers, subdomains, and CNAMEs, demands adherence to specific DNS record best practices. The primary challenges involve staying within the strict 10 DNS lookup limit and ensuring that each domain has only one SPF TXT record. Special attention is required for subdomains and CNAMEs; SPF records must be TXT, not CNAMEs, and subdomains sending mail from different sources necessitate their own dedicated SPF records. Key solutions include consolidating all 'include' statements into a single record, utilizing SPF flattening services to bypass the lookup limit, and regularly employing validation tools to preempt authentication issues. These measures are vital for maintaining robust email deliverability and preventing spoofing.
Key opinions
- Lookup Limit Constraint: A critical constraint for SPF authentication is the 10 DNS lookup limit, which often leads to failures when integrating multiple Email Service Providers (ESPs) requiring separate 'include' mechanisms.
- Uniqueness of SPF Records: Only a single SPF TXT record is permitted per domain; the presence of multiple SPF records for the same domain will inevitably result in authentication failures.
- CNAME-SPF Incompatibility: SPF records are exclusively TXT records and cannot be CNAME aliases; if a domain uses a CNAME, its SPF record must be defined on the CNAME's target domain or contain direct IP addresses and 'include' mechanisms.
- Subdomain SPF Autonomy: While subdomains generally inherit their parent domain's SPF record, they require their own dedicated SPF TXT record if they send email independently or via different sources.
- Prevalent SPF Errors: Common SPF authentication failures stem from exceeding the DNS lookup limit, mistakenly creating multiple SPF records for one domain, and various syntax errors.
Key considerations
- Unified SPF Record: Integrate all required 'include' mechanisms from various Email Service Providers into a single SPF TXT record for your domain, a crucial step to prevent exceeding the DNS lookup limit and avoid errors from multiple SPF entries.
- Employ SPF Flattening: Consider using SPF flattening services to consolidate numerous 'include' mechanisms into a single DNS lookup, especially beneficial for complex email infrastructures with many ESPs that might otherwise breach the 10-lookup limit.
- Specific Subdomain Records: Establish unique SPF records for subdomains that operate independently or utilize different Email Service Providers, helping to ensure accurate authentication and manage deliverability more effectively.
- Regular Tool Validation: Periodically employ SPF validation tools to scrutinize for syntax errors, confirm adherence to the 10 DNS lookup limit, and verify the singular presence of an SPF record for your domain.
- Amend Current Records: Upon adding a new Email Service Provider, always modify your existing SPF TXT record to incorporate their required 'include' mechanism, rather than generating a new, separate SPF record.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Mailgun explains how to combine multiple ESPs' SPF records by including each 'include' mechanism in a single SPF TXT record, warning against exceeding the 10 DNS lookup limit. They suggest using a single 'v=spf1' and 'all' modifier ('?all' or '~all') at the end, and consolidating 'include' statements to prevent authentication failures.
26 Sep 2023 - Mailgun Blog
Marketer view
Email marketer from Postmark emphasizes the 10 DNS lookup limit for SPF records and suggests consolidating 'include' statements when using multiple ESPs. They clarify that SPF records must be TXT records and cannot use CNAME records directly, as the SPF record must reside on the root domain or a specific subdomain's TXT record, not an alias.
8 Apr 2023 - Postmark Blog
What the experts say
3 expert opinions
Addressing SPF authentication challenges in environments with multiple Email Service Providers (ESPs), subdomains, and CNAMEs requires a deep understanding of DNS limitations and best practices. A central challenge is the 10 DNS lookup limit, frequently exceeded when various ESPs each require their own 'include' mechanisms. A common issue arises when a subdomain CNAME'd to a main domain incorrectly inherits the main domain's SPF record, leading to authentication failures; this necessitates specific SPF records for such subdomains. To mitigate these complexities, SPF management services prove invaluable by flattening multiple 'include' statements into a single, dynamically updated record, thus bypassing the lookup limit. While SPF records are TXT and not direct CNAMEs, their mechanisms can resolve through CNAMEs via DNS. Effective management also requires using up-to-date syntax and validating records with testing tools.
Key opinions
- Lookup Limit Constraint: The 10 DNS lookup limit is a primary cause of SPF authentication failures, especially when integrating multiple Email Service Providers, each requiring its own 'include' mechanism.
- Subdomain CNAME Inheritance: Subdomains CNAME'd to a main domain often inherit the parent's SPF record, potentially causing authentication failures if a distinct SPF record is not set for the subdomain.
- Role of SPF Management: Services like OnDMARC act as SPF management tools, effectively flattening multiple 'include' mechanisms into a single record to bypass the DNS lookup limit.
- SPF-HTTPS Distinction: SPF authentication is entirely separate and unrelated to HTTPS, despite both being DNS-reliant protocols.
Key considerations
- Strategic Subdomain Allocation: Assign separate subdomains to different Email Service Providers to allow for custom SPF records and prevent conflicts or incorrect inheritance.
- Direct Updates via Management Services: When using an SPF management service, route all new vendor additions or changes through that service, as it handles the underlying flattening and lookup compliance.
- Proactive Record Validation: Routinely employ SPF testing tools to verify record syntax, ensure adherence to the DNS lookup limit, and confirm the singular presence of an SPF record for your domain.
- Dedicated Subdomain SPF: For subdomains that are CNAME'd or send emails independently, define a specific SPF record to prevent them from inheriting and failing on the main domain's SPF.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks explains that HTTPS and SPF are distinct and unrelated. Matt V advises that for setups with multiple Email Service Providers (ESPs) like Customer.io and SendGrid, using separate subdomains for each ESP allows for custom SPF records tailored to each service. He identifies a common issue where an SPF record for a subdomain fails to authenticate because the subdomain is CNAME'd to the main domain, causing it to inherit and read the main domain's SPF record instead of its own. He also clarifies that if an SPF management service like OnDMARC is in use, it likely flattens the necessary includes and manages the SPF record to comply with lookup limits, suggesting that new vendors should be updated directly with the management service rather than through manual DNS record changes.
20 Sep 2024 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from Spam Resource explains that troubleshooting SPF authentication issues, especially when using multiple ESPs, commonly involves addressing the 10 DNS lookup limit and avoiding multiple SPF records. Each ESP often requires its own 'include' mechanism, which can quickly exhaust the lookup budget, leading to authentication failures. While CNAMEs are not directly allowed in SPF records, the mechanisms can resolve to them via DNS; however, it's crucial to use up-to-date syntax and leverage testing tools to validate the SPF record's integrity and prevent common errors.
3 Nov 2022 - Spam Resource
What the documentation says
4 technical articles
When troubleshooting SPF authentication issues across multiple Email Service Providers (ESPs), subdomains, and CNAMEs, the core principles involve adhering to the 10 DNS lookup limit and maintaining a single SPF TXT record per domain. It's crucial to understand that SPF records must be TXT records and cannot be CNAMEs directly; if a domain uses a CNAME, the SPF record should be configured on the CNAME's target domain. Furthermore, subdomains sending email from different sources than the parent domain require their own distinct SPF TXT records. Effective resolution relies on consolidating all 'include' statements into one existing SPF record, rather than creating multiple records, and utilizing third-party services to 'flatten' SPF records when the lookup limit is a concern. This strategic approach ensures proper authentication and prevents common errors like 'multiple SPF records' issues.
Key findings
- DNS Lookup Limit Impact: Exceeding the 10 DNS lookup limit in an SPF record will cause authentication to fail, a common problem with multiple 'include' statements from various ESPs.
- Single SPF Record Rule: A domain should only have one SPF TXT record; creating multiple SPF records for the same domain is a primary cause of authentication errors.
- SPF and CNAME Incompatibility: SPF records must be TXT records and cannot directly point to CNAME records. If a domain utilizes a CNAME, the SPF record must be set on the CNAME's target domain.
- Subdomain SPF Autonomy: Subdomains require their own separate SPF TXT record if they send mail from different sources or through different ESPs than the main domain.
Key considerations
- Consolidate SPF Records: Always integrate new ESP 'include' statements into your existing single SPF TXT record, rather than creating new ones, to prevent authentication failures.
- Utilize SPF Flattening: For complex setups or when approaching the 10-lookup limit, consider employing third-party services that can 'flatten' your SPF record to reduce DNS lookups.
- Dedicated Subdomain Records: Configure distinct SPF TXT records for subdomains that send email independently or from different sources than their parent domain.
- Target Domain Configuration for CNAMEs: If a domain uses a CNAME, ensure the SPF record is properly configured on the CNAME's target domain, not directly on the CNAME itself.
Technical article
Documentation from Microsoft Learn explains that exceeding the 10 DNS lookup limit in an SPF record will cause authentication to fail. For organizations with multiple email services, they advise consolidating 'include' statements where possible or utilizing third-party services that can 'flatten' SPF records to reduce the number of DNS lookups, ensuring proper authentication.
11 Jan 2025 - Microsoft Learn
Technical article
Documentation from Cloudflare explicitly states that SPF records must be TXT records and cannot point to CNAME records. They advise that if a domain uses a CNAME, the SPF record should be configured on the CNAME's target domain. For subdomains, a separate TXT record for the subdomain is necessary if it sends mail from different sources than the parent domain.
10 Jul 2023 - Cloudflare Documentation
How do I configure DNS records to send emails from two different ESPs using the same subdomain?
How do I troubleshoot and fix SPF and DMARC settings for email deliverability issues?
How do I troubleshoot DMARC, SPF, and DKIM setup issues in Klaviyo?
How do I troubleshoot SPF validation errors in Pardot?
How to troubleshoot deliverability issues when ESP and corporate email domains are the same?
How to troubleshoot intermittent email delivery failures caused by SPF and DNS issues?
