Suped

Summary

For effective email deliverability, A records, which map domain names to IPv4 addresses, are an indispensable component of an email sending domain's DNS setup. Although MX records primarily direct incoming email, they rely on A records to resolve the mail server's hostname to an IP address. This resolution is fundamental for other mail servers to locate and communicate with the sender's infrastructure, ensuring messages can be sent successfully. Missing or incorrect A records can severely impact deliverability, leading to emails being rejected or marked as suspicious. Furthermore, A records support critical authentication mechanisms like SPF and are vital for establishing proper reverse DNS (PTR) records for sending IP addresses, contributing to overall sender reputation.

Key findings

  • Indirect but Essential Role: While MX records directly guide email delivery, A records are indirectly essential. They map the hostnames specified in MX records to an IPv4 address, allowing recipient mail servers to locate and connect to the sender's mail server.
  • RFC Requirements: SMTP standards, such as RFC 5321 and RFC 1035, mandate that the domain names provided in MX records must resolve to one or more A records. This underscores their fundamental necessity for proper email functionality.
  • Critical for Mail Server Resolution: Without an A record for the mail server's hostname, recipient systems cannot resolve the IP address of the sending server. This prevents successful communication and can lead to email rejections or deliverability issues.
  • Supports SPF and rDNS: A records play a role in email authentication; the SPF 'a' mechanism authorizes sending hosts with A records for the current domain, and they are crucial for setting up correct reverse DNS (PTR) records, both of which enhance deliverability.
  • Standard ESP Practice: Major Email Service Providers (ESPs) commonly include a naked host or A record for subdomains used in the 'Header From' field as a standard best practice when setting up client DNS, often pointing to the client’s website IP for legitimacy.

Key considerations

  • Maintain All Relevant A Records: Ensure that all hostnames referenced in your MX records, as well as any dedicated IP addresses used for sending email, have corresponding A records. This foundational DNS mapping is crucial for mail server discoverability and successful communication.
  • Align A Records with Web Presence: For transparency and legitimacy, it is a best practice for A records associated with email sending domains, especially those for the 'Header From' domain, to point to a related web presence or a redirect to your main site. This helps identify the sender to recipients and mail servers.
  • Prioritize MAIL FROM Domain A Record: An A record for the 'MAIL FROM' (or RFC 5321.From) domain is considered essential, as many Mail Transfer Agents (MTAs) may reject emails if it is missing. While an A record for the 'Header From' (or RFC 5322.From) domain is recommended for best practice, it is generally less critical for acceptance.
  • Ensure Proper rDNS Setup: The A record for your sending IP address's hostname should correspond to a valid reverse DNS (PTR) record. This alignment is vital for authentication and establishing sender reputation, improving deliverability.

What email marketers say

12 marketer opinions

Building on the foundational understanding that A records are indispensable for mapping domain names to IP addresses, a strong consensus among email experts affirms their absolute necessity for successful email sending. While MX records dictate mail routing, their reliance on A records to resolve the mail server's hostname to an IP address is paramount. Without this mapping, recipient mail servers cannot locate the sender's infrastructure, leading to communication failures and email rejections. Experts particularly emphasize the critical need for an A record for the 'MAIL FROM' domain, as its absence frequently causes emails to be rejected by Mail Transfer Agents. For the 'Header From' domain, an A record, ideally pointing to a web presence, is strongly recommended as a best practice to enhance sender legitimacy and prevent suspicious flags, underscoring that any domain lacking an A record can inherently appear untrustworthy. This practice is so crucial that it is being formalized in upcoming documentation and is a standard setup for large Email Service Providers.

Key opinions

  • Universal Requirement for Mail Server Location: A records are universally confirmed as essential for mail servers to be located and communicated with, underpinning successful email delivery by enabling recipient mail servers to resolve the sender's IP.
  • MX Record Reliance on A Records: Although MX records define the mail server, they must point to a hostname, which in turn absolutely requires an A record to resolve to an IP address, making the A record an indispensable, though indirect, component.
  • MAIL FROM Domain Criticality: An A record for the 'MAIL FROM' (RFC 5321.From) domain is considered essential, with its absence often leading to email rejections by receiving Mail Transfer Agents, making it a crucial deliverability factor.
  • Header From Domain Best Practice: While less critical for acceptance than 'MAIL FROM', an A record for the 'Header From' (RFC 5322.From) domain is a recommended best practice, ideally pointing to a related web presence for transparency and legitimacy.
  • Suspicion Without A Record: Any domain used in an email, whether for 'MAIL FROM' or 'Header From', that lacks an A record can inherently appear suspicious to recipient mail systems, potentially impacting deliverability and sender reputation.
  • Formalization and ESP Standard: The necessity of A records for email domains is a recognized best practice, actively being formalized in industry documents and implemented as a standard DNS setup by large Email Service Providers (ESPs) for their clients.

Key considerations

  • Ensure All Email-Related Domains Have A Records: Verify that all domains and subdomains used in your email sending, particularly those referenced by MX records or for dedicated sending IPs, possess valid A records. This foundational DNS mapping is crucial for mail server discoverability and successful communication.
  • Point A Records to Web Presence: For enhanced sender transparency and legitimacy, ensure that A records for email sending domains, especially the 'Header From' domain, point to an associated web presence or a redirect to your main site, rather than solely the MX server.
  • Address MAIL FROM A Record as Priority: Given that the absence of an A record for the 'MAIL FROM' (RFC 5321.From) domain can lead to direct rejections by many Mail Transfer Agents, confirming its presence is a critical deliverability measure.
  • Consider A Record for Header From Domain: While not always strictly required for acceptance, including an A record for your 'Header From' (RFC 5322.From) domain is a strong recommendation to build trust, align with standard ESP practices, and avoid appearing suspicious to mail systems.

Marketer view

Email marketer from Email Geeks explains that having an A record for the MAIL FROM domain is essential, as MTAs often reject emails if it's missing. For the Header From domain, an A record is recommended but less critical, as emails are usually accepted without it, although any domain lacking an A record can appear suspicious.

25 Jul 2022 - Email Geeks

Marketer view

Email marketer from Email Geeks shares that it appears to be a standard best practice, observed from how large ESPs set up client DNS, to include a naked host/A record for the subdomain used in the 5322 From header, pointing to the client’s website IP.

2 Dec 2021 - Email Geeks

What the experts say

2 expert opinions

Further clarifying the role of A records in email deliverability, experts affirm that an A record is explicitly required for the hostname from which emails are sent. This A record serves to map that specific sending hostname to its corresponding IP address, a fundamental step for recipient mail servers to properly identify and connect with the sender. Critically, this A record must perfectly align with a valid reverse DNS (PTR) record for the mail server's IP address. This synchronized DNS setup, extending to every machine involved in the email sending path, is essential for robust email authentication and maintaining a positive sender reputation.

Key opinions

  • Sending Hostname Mapping: An A record is necessary for the specific hostname used by a mail server to send email, linking it directly to the sending IP address.
  • Mandatory rDNS Correspondence: The A record for the sending hostname must have a corresponding, valid reverse DNS (PTR) record for the mail server's IP address. This direct alignment is crucial for verification.
  • Comprehensive Infrastructure Requirement: A records are needed for all machines and hostnames that are actively involved in the email sending path, ensuring full traceability and legitimacy.

Key considerations

  • Verify Sending Hostname A Record: Confirm that the specific hostname used by your mail server for outbound email has an accurate A record, mapping it to the correct sending IP.
  • Ensure A Record-PTR Match: Prioritize ensuring that the A record for your mail server's sending hostname corresponds precisely with its reverse DNS (PTR) record for the associated IP address, as this is a key deliverability factor.
  • Map All Sending Path Components: Extend your A record verification to cover every machine and hostname contributing to your email sending path to maintain a fully transparent and verifiable infrastructure.

Expert view

Expert from Spam Resource explains that an A record is needed for the hostname from which email is sent, mapping it to the sending IP address. This A record should correspond to a valid reverse DNS (PTR) record for the mail server's IP address.

9 Jul 2024 - Spam Resource

Expert view

Expert from Word to the Wise explains that an A record is needed for every machine involved in the email sending path. Specifically, the IP address used by the mail server to send email requires an A record to define its hostname, which is crucial for proper reverse DNS (PTR record) matching.

31 Oct 2024 - Word to the Wise

What the documentation says

7 technical articles

An A record, fundamental for mapping a domain name to an IPv4 address, is indeed a critical component for email sending domains. While MX records primarily direct email traffic, the hostnames they specify for mail servers must resolve to an IP address via an A record. This essential resolution allows recipient mail servers to locate, connect to, and exchange email with the sender's infrastructure. Without accurate A records for the mail server's hostname, email delivery would fail, as receiving servers could not establish a connection. Furthermore, A records play a supportive role in email authentication mechanisms like SPF, which utilizes these mappings to verify sending authorization.

Key findings

  • Fundamental DNS Mapping: A records provide the essential mapping of hostnames to IPv4 addresses, which is a prerequisite for any internet-based communication, including email.
  • MX Record Interdependence: Although MX records specify where to deliver email, they rely on A records to resolve the hostname of the designated mail server to an actual IP address, making the mail server discoverable.
  • Enabling Mail Server Connection: The primary function of A records in email sending is to allow recipient mail servers to successfully locate and establish a connection with the sender's mail server, crucial for message delivery.
  • Adherence to SMTP Standards: Core email protocols like SMTP (RFC 5321) explicitly mandate that domain names in MX records must resolve to A records, affirming their fundamental necessity for proper email functionality.
  • Role in Sender Authentication: A records are integral to email authentication, such as the SPF 'a' mechanism, which verifies sending hosts by checking their A record against the domain, thereby enhancing deliverability and combating spoofing.

Key considerations

  • Accurate A Records for Mail Servers: Ensure that every hostname used by your mail servers, particularly those specified in your MX records, has a precise and up-to-date A record pointing to its correct IPv4 address.
  • Compliance with RFCs: Confirm that your DNS configuration, especially concerning A records for mail server hostnames, aligns with IETF RFCs governing SMTP and domain names to guarantee reliable email communication.
  • Support for SPF and Deliverability: Recognize the direct impact of correctly configured A records on your SPF authentication and overall email deliverability, as they contribute to verifying sender legitimacy.

Technical article

Documentation from Cloudflare explains that an A record maps a domain name to an IPv4 address. While MX records are primary for directing email, the host specified by an MX record (which is usually a subdomain or the main domain) will typically require an A record to resolve to an IP address, making it indirectly essential for the mail server's reachability.

22 Jun 2023 - Cloudflare Developers Documentation

Technical article

Documentation from Microsoft explains that while MX records are crucial for directing incoming email, they themselves rely on an A record (or AAAA record) to map the mail server's hostname to its IP address. This means that for an email sending domain to function correctly, the underlying mail server or hostname referenced in the MX record must have a proper A record for successful resolution.

24 Sep 2024 - Microsoft Learn

Start improving your email deliverability today

Sign up