Summary
Setting up a Yahoo Feedback Loop (FBL) when using Sendinblue with a dedicated IP and having your primary domain email hosted on Microsoft Office 365 can seem complex due to the split email infrastructure. The core challenge often lies in receiving the FBL verification email from Yahoo to a postmaster@ address on the sending domain, especially when that domain's MX records point to your Email Service Provider (ESP) like Sendinblue, while the main domain's email is with Office 365.
Key findings
- Delegated FBL management: Many ESPs, including Sendinblue, manage FBLs on behalf of their users by enrolling their own DKIM domains with major ISPs. This means they often already receive and process complaint data for emails sent through their platform, even if your specific sending domain isn't directly enrolled.
- Double signing for FBLs: ESPs frequently use a 'double signing' method for DKIM, where emails are signed by both the client's domain and the ESP's domain. This enables the ESP to gain easier access to FBL data from providers like Yahoo and Gmail.
- Yahoo's FBL purpose: Yahoo's FBL primarily provides data on spam complaints, not the comprehensive deliverability metrics found in tools like Google Postmaster Tools (GPT) or Microsoft SNDS. However, Yahoo (Verizon Media) does offer broader deliverability performance feeds beyond basic FBL.
- Domain ownership verification: To receive FBL reports directly, you must be able to prove ownership or have access to the DKIM signing domain. Yahoo sends verification to the postmaster@ address of the domain that signs the email.
Key considerations
- Contact your ESP first: Before attempting manual FBL registration, confirm with Sendinblue if they already handle Yahoo FBLs for your dedicated IP and sending domain. Given their standard practices, they likely do.
- Postmaster email accessibility: If you need to receive Yahoo FBL reports directly, you might need to set up a postmaster@ alias or mailbox for your sending subdomain (e.g., foo.example.com) that can receive emails, even if your primary domain email is on Office 365. This might involve a forwarding rule or a temporary mailbox setup.
- Understanding DKIM signatures: Ensure you understand which domain is performing the primary DKIM signing for your emails. This is crucial for FBL registration, as verification emails are sent to the postmaster address of the DKIM signing domain. For more on this, explore how to decode DKIM errors and ensure proper setup.
- Leveraging existing tools: If your ESP already manages the Yahoo FBL, focus on using Google Postmaster Tools for your sending domain and obtaining Microsoft SNDS access for your dedicated IP address to cover your deliverability monitoring needs.
What email marketers say
Email marketers often face challenges navigating ISP-specific requirements when managing their email infrastructure across multiple providers. The consensus points towards trusting ESPs to handle the complexities of FBLs, while understanding the nuances of how different authentication protocols and reporting tools operate. The discussions highlight the need for clear communication with ESPs and a grasp of the technical details.
Key opinions
- FBL ownership: Many marketers initially assume they need to register their sending domain directly for FBLs, similar to Google Postmaster Tools, but often find their ESP already handles this.
- Postmaster email setup: There's a common struggle to set up a postmaster@ email address on a subdomain when the primary domain's MX records are with a different email host.
- Reliance on ESPs: Marketers frequently rely on their ESPs to manage FBLs due to the technical complexities involved, especially with dedicated IPs.
- Understanding Yahoo's data: There's a general understanding that Yahoo FBL primarily provides spam complaint data, distinct from the broader metrics available through other postmaster tools.
Key considerations
- Verifying ESP FBL coverage: Always confirm with your ESP whether they cover Yahoo FBLs for your sending setup. This can save significant time and effort trying to register manually.
- Subdomain email configuration: If direct FBL access is needed, investigate options for creating a postmaster@ address on your sending subdomain that can receive mail, possibly through your Office 365 setup or a simple mail forwarding service.
- Dedicated IP reputation: Using a dedicated IP address with an ESP like Sendinblue requires careful monitoring of its reputation. Even if the ESP handles FBLs, understanding your complaint rates is vital for maintaining dedicated IP reputation.
- Leveraging other tools: Focus on Google Postmaster Tools for general domain health and Microsoft SNDS for specific dedicated IP insights. These tools provide more comprehensive data than basic FBLs.
Marketer view
Email Marketer from Email Geeks notes that they primarily want to register their customer's dedicated IP with Yahoo's FBL but face issues with email verification. The problem stems from foo.example.com (sending domain via Sendinblue) signing the emails, while the primary domain example.com has email hosting through Microsoft Office 365 with GoDaddy.
Marketer view
Email Marketer from Email Geeks mentions that Sendinblue is signing emails with d=foo.example.com and also d=sendib.com. They had not initially considered the second signing domain and planned to inquire with Sendinblue about their FBL setup after this discovery.
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts highlight that ESPs like Sendinblue proactively manage Feedback Loops, leveraging their own infrastructure and strategic practices like double DKIM signing. They also clarify the scope of Yahoo's FBL data versus their more extensive postmaster tools, guiding senders on how to effectively monitor their reputation across various ISPs.
Key opinions
- ESPs manage FBLs: Experts confirm that many ESPs are already enrolled in major FBLs, including Yahoo's, and manage complaints for their clients' sending IPs and domains.
- Double DKIM signing: ESPs strategically use double DKIM signing (client domain and ESP domain) to ensure FBL data is properly routed and managed on their end.
- Direct FBL access: Any DKIM signing domain can be enrolled in Yahoo's FBL, provided the sender can prove ownership and receive verification emails.
- Beyond FBLs: Yahoo (Verizon Media) offers more comprehensive deliverability performance feeds in addition to FBLs, similar to other major ISP postmaster tools.
Key considerations
- Verify ESP FBL enrollment: The primary step is to confirm directly with Sendinblue that their IPs are enrolled in Yahoo's FBL and that they manage complaint data for your dedicated IP.
- Understanding DKIM roles: It's important to differentiate between the primary sending domain and any secondary domains that might be signing emails (e.g., ESP's domain) for FBL purposes. Incorrect DKIM configurations can lead to deliverability issues, especially with Microsoft domains, as highlighted in troubleshooting Microsoft Office 365 DKIM failures.
- Accessing Yahoo Postmaster Tools: Even if FBLs are handled by the ESP, senders should consider registering their DKIM signing domain for Yahoo's broader Postmaster Tools to access more granular performance data.
- Holistic monitoring strategy: Combine Yahoo FBL (if directly accessible or through ESP reports) with Google Postmaster Tools and Microsoft SNDS for a comprehensive view of your email deliverability across major ISPs. This can help identify and resolve issues like email IP blocks with Yahoo Mail.
Expert view
Email Expert from Email Geeks states that in their experience, you will likely need to create a postmaster@foo.example.com email address to receive the Yahoo FBL verification. This indicates a direct requirement for the postmaster address of the signing domain.
Expert view
Email Expert from Email Geeks suggests asking Sendinblue if they already receive FBL data for the sending domain. They highlight that many ESPs leverage double signing to gain easier access to FBL data from major ISPs like Yahoo.
What the documentation says
Official documentation from ISPs and email service providers emphasizes the role of Feedback Loops in managing sender reputation by providing direct insights into spam complaints. It also highlights the importance of proper domain authentication (like DKIM) for FBL registration and access to broader deliverability performance data.
Key findings
- FBL application process: Applying for a Feedback Loop typically involves providing your IP address or DKIM signing domain to the ISP, followed by a verification process.
- DKIM alignment: For Yahoo FBL, verification is often sent to the postmaster@ address of the domain that performed the DKIM signature.
- Broader performance feeds: ISPs like Yahoo (Verizon Media) provide not just FBL data but also comprehensive email deliverability performance feeds, offering deeper insights into sender reputation, complaint rates, and more.
- Essential configurations: DNS configurations, including SPF, DKIM, and rDNS, are crucial for proper email authentication and are often prerequisites for accessing FBLs and other postmaster tools.
Key considerations
- Verification email access: Ensure that the postmaster@ email address for your DKIM signing domain is functional and accessible, as it's typically required for FBL registration and verification.
- DKIM setup: Maintain correct DKIM records for your sending domain, as proper DKIM authentication is often a prerequisite for FBL services. You can use our guide to common DKIM selectors for assistance.
- SPF and DMARC: Beyond DKIM, robust SPF and DMARC configurations are essential for email deliverability and reputation management across all ISPs, including Microsoft. Learn more about SPF DNS timeouts with Microsoft.
- Utilize available tools: Leverage comprehensive postmaster tools provided by ISPs (e.g., Yahoo's Email Deliverability Performance Feeds) to gain a holistic understanding of your email program's performance beyond just spam complaints.
Technical article
Documentation from Scribd's 'Email Deliverability Playbook' indicates that setting up a Feedback Loop requires applying to each ISP that offers an FBL service. The application process, while varying, generally involves providing your IP address or sending domain for verification.
Technical article
Verizon Media (Yahoo) Postmaster documentation outlines that they offer email deliverability performance feeds which provide detailed insights beyond just FBLs, including data on sending reputation, complaint rates, and delivery success.
Related resources
6 resources
Related pages
How to resolve email IP blocks with Yahoo Mail?
How to maintain dedicated IP reputation with ISPs for email sending?
How to get Microsoft SNDS access when using an Email Service Provider?
Why are Microsoft Office 365 DKIM signatures failing and how to fix it?
A list of the most common DKIM selectors and how to use them
Why your emails fail at Microsoft: the hidden SPF DNS timeout
Ultimate guide to google postmaster tools v2
How do I use SPFBL feedback loop for email?
How do I resolve temporary deferral errors and warm up new IP addresses for transactional emails on Yahoo?
How to diagnose Yahoo deliverability issues with a new SFMC instance during IP warming?
