Re-assigning domain ownership in Google Postmaster Tools (GPT) isn't a direct process of transferring an existing verified domain from one account to another. Instead, it typically involves the new owner verifying the domain under their own Google account. This approach ensures that ownership is tied directly to the individual or entity responsible for the domain's email operations and its DNS records.
Key findings
Direct transfer limitation: Google Postmaster Tools does not offer a direct feature to re-assign or transfer domain ownership from one Google account to another. Ownership is inherently linked to the account that performed the initial domain verification.
New verification required: To effectively re-assign ownership, the new designated owner must add and verify the domain from scratch under their own Google account using a unique DNS TXT record. This establishes their independent ownership.
DNS entry management: The existing DNS TXT record for verification, tied to the old owner's account, can be removed once the new owner successfully verifies the domain with their own DNS record. This prevents conflicts and ensures clean handover.
Caching and propagation: DNS changes can take time to propagate, and Google Postmaster Tools may have a caching period. It is important to allow sufficient time after updating DNS records for the changes to take effect and for the new owner to verify. Clearing browser cache might also help.
Read-only vs. ownership: While you can add other users with read-only access, this does not confer full ownership or the ability to manage verification records. True ownership requires independent verification.
Key considerations
Coordination is key: Ensure clear communication between the current and new domain owners regarding the process of adding and removing DNS records.
Timing of DNS changes: The old owner's TXT record should only be removed after the new owner's verification is complete and confirmed, to avoid any disruption in data collection during the transition.
Impact on data continuity: A new verification means the new account starts collecting data from the point of verification. Historical data from the old account will not be transferred. For insights on setting up GPT, consult Email Industries' guide on setting up GPT.
Preventing unverified domains: If a domain is removed from one account without being added and verified by another, there will be a gap in monitoring data.
What email marketers say
Email marketers often encounter challenges when trying to re-assign Google Postmaster Tools domain ownership, especially in scenarios like personnel changes or agency transitions. The common understanding is that a direct transfer feature is unavailable, necessitating a fresh verification process by the new owner. This often leads to questions about caching periods and ensuring a smooth transition of access without data loss.
Key opinions
No direct transfer: Many marketers confirm that GPT does not allow for a simple re-assignment of domain ownership; a new verification process is required for the new owner.
Independent verification: The consensus is that the new owner must add the domain to their own GPT account and perform their own DNS TXT record verification.
DNS record removal: The previous owner should remove their DNS verification record only after the new owner successfully verifies their ownership.
Read-only vs. full control: Marketers often highlight the distinction between adding a read-only user and establishing full ownership, noting that only the latter provides complete control over domain settings and data collection.
Key considerations
Caching issues: A common challenge is that previous read-only access might interfere with new verification attempts, possibly due to caching. Clearing browser cache and waiting for DNS propagation are suggested remedies. Learn more about managing users in Google Postmaster Tools.
User removal first: If the new owner was previously a read-only user, the old owner should remove them from access before the new owner attempts verification. This clears any lingering associations.
Patience with DNS: Marketers emphasize that DNS changes and GPT updates can take time (hours to a day or more), so patience is required during the re-verification process. See our guide on why Google Postmaster Tools might not be updating.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks notes that Google Postmaster Tools doesn't allow direct porting of domain ownership. They clarify that the new owner will need to add the domain on their end, using their own DNS entry for verification. The existing DNS record is tied to the current account and cannot be transferred.
03 Sep 2021 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks explains a common issue: if the new owner was already a read-only user, trying to add the domain again might not provide the option for a new DNS record. This suggests a caching issue within GPT that prevents a fresh verification prompt.
03 Sep 2021 - Email Geeks
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts agree that Google Postmaster Tools does not offer a dedicated feature for transferring domain ownership directly between accounts. The recommended approach involves the new owner performing a fresh domain verification. This process requires careful coordination to avoid disruptions in data collection and ensures proper control is established for reputation monitoring.
Key opinions
No built-in transfer mechanism: Experts confirm that Google Postmaster Tools is designed with ownership tied to the verifying Google account, lacking a direct transfer button or process.
Independent re-verification: The only way to 're-assign' ownership is for the new party to add the domain to their own account and complete the TXT record verification process as if it were a new domain.
DNS record hygiene: It's crucial for the old owner to remove their DNS verification record only after the new owner's verification is complete to maintain clean DNS records and prevent conflicts.
Importance of clear state: If the new owner previously had read-only access, this access needs to be revoked by the old owner before the new owner attempts full verification to avoid caching issues or automatic re-assignment without the DNS prompt.
Key considerations
Data continuity implications: Experts advise that performing a new verification means the historical data associated with the old GPT account will not transfer. The new account will start collecting data from its verification date. For insights on managing user access, refer to sharing Google Postmaster Tools access.
DNS propagation time: Factor in DNS propagation delays. It can take up to 24-48 hours for new DNS records to fully propagate globally, though often it's quicker. See our guide on adding TXT records for GPT.
Access after departure: If the previous owner is no longer accessible, regaining access or re-assigning ownership can become more complex, potentially requiring direct contact with Google support or a more prolonged re-verification process from the new owner's side. For recovery, consult Customer.io's guide on Google Postmaster Tools.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks explains that the core challenge with Google Postmaster Tools is that verification is tied to a specific Google account through a DNS TXT record. This means that to effectively change ownership, a new account must perform its own verification, as direct transfers are not supported by the platform's architecture.
01 Jan 2024 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks suggests that if you are facing issues with re-verifying a domain after a previous user had read-only access, it is best practice for the original owner to completely remove all associated users. This action helps clear any lingering permissions or caching that might impede the new verification process for the new owner.
05 Jan 2024 - Email Geeks
What the documentation says
Google's own documentation (and general technical guides from reputable sources) for Postmaster Tools implies that domain ownership is established via a DNS TXT record unique to the verifying account. While user management features allow sharing access for viewing data, they do not facilitate a transfer of primary verification responsibility. Therefore, re-assigning ownership effectively means the new owner must undertake the standard domain verification process.
Key findings
Verification method: Domain ownership in Google Postmaster Tools is primarily verified by adding a specific TXT record to the domain's DNS settings.
Account linkage: This TXT record ties the domain to the specific Google account that initiated the verification process.
User management vs. ownership: Postmaster Tools allows users to be added to a domain with various permission levels (e.g., read-only), but this feature is for delegated access, not for transferring the underlying domain ownership itself.
New verification process: To 're-assign' ownership, a new Google account must go through the entire domain addition and verification process, generating its own unique TXT record.
Key considerations
DNS record uniqueness: Each verifying Google account will generate a distinct TXT record. Ensure the old record is removed only after the new record is successfully verified to avoid conflicts. More details on verification can be found in this Rejoiner guide for Google Postmaster Tools.
Domain deletion from old account: While not strictly necessary if the new account verifies successfully, removing the domain from the old GPT account can prevent confusion and ensure clean management going forward.
Implications for data: The data in GPT is associated with the verifying account. A re-verification by a new account will start a new data collection stream for that account, meaning historical data from the old account will not be carried over. Learn more about Google Postmaster Tools V2.
Technical article
Customer.io documentation on Google Postmaster Tools states that you access user management by clicking the three vertical dots next to your domain, then choosing 'Manage Users'. This functionality is specifically for granting and revoking access to view data, not for transferring the primary domain ownership itself, which is established through DNS verification.
05 Feb 2024 - Customer.io
Technical article
Rejoiner's documentation confirms that once a domain is added to Google Postmaster Tools, verification of ownership is required by copying a TXT record provided by GPT into your DNS. This TXT record serves as the proof of ownership for the specific Google account that added the domain.