Summary
Aligning a tracking URL subdomain with the primary sending domain generally enhances email deliverability, though some experts suggest misalignment is not always critically problematic and the effort might occasionally outweigh the benefits. The majority view, supported by email service providers and deliverability experts, is that custom tracking domains, typically configured as subdomains of the main sending domain, build trust with Internet Service Providers, ISPs, and recipients. This alignment fosters a consistent brand identity, reinforces sender legitimacy, and helps prevent emails from being flagged as suspicious redirects or spam, leading to better sender reputation and improved inbox placement.
Key findings
- Trust and Reputation Boost: Aligning tracking domains with sending domains significantly enhances trust with Internet Service Providers, ISPs, and recipients, positively impacting sender reputation.
- Improved Inbox Placement: Custom tracking domains, often subdomains, contribute to better deliverability and a reduced likelihood of emails being marked as spam.
- Consistent Branding: Using an aligned tracking domain ensures brand consistency across all email elements, signaling legitimacy and professionalism.
- Efficient Filter Processing: Some insights suggest that aligned domains can help spam filters process emails more efficiently, potentially favoring such messages.
- Avoids Third-Party Links: Custom tracking domains prevent the appearance of generic or unrelated third-party hostnames in links, which could otherwise negatively affect deliverability.
Key considerations
- Resource Investment: While beneficial, the operational resources required for full alignment, especially in complex email environments, might sometimes outweigh incremental deliverability gains.
- Subdomain vs. Primary Domain: Using a different tracking subdomain is significantly better than having completely unrelated primary domains appearing throughout the email content.
- Contextual Impact: The absence of alignment is not always a critical issue, as many legitimate senders operate effectively with different tracking subdomains.
- ESP Features: Many Email Service Providers offer features like 'link branding' or 'custom tracking domains' to simplify achieving this alignment.
What email marketers say
10 marketer opinions
For optimal email deliverability, the alignment of tracking URL subdomains with the primary sending domain is widely recommended by email marketing experts and service providers. This practice, often facilitated by 'link branding' or 'custom tracking domain' features from ESPs, significantly enhances trust with Internet Service Providers and recipients by presenting a consistent and legitimate sender identity. It aids in boosting inbox placement, reinforcing brand consistency, and preventing emails from being flagged as suspicious. While some experts note that misalignment is not always critically problematic and the operational effort for full alignment might occasionally outweigh marginal benefits, the general consensus firmly supports the use of custom tracking subdomains to strengthen sender reputation and improve overall email performance.
Key opinions
- Fosters Sender Trust: Aligning tracking domains with sending domains builds significant trust with Internet Service Providers, ISPs, and recipients, as it presents a cohesive and legitimate sender identity.
- Boosts Inbox Placement Rates: Using custom tracking domains, typically as subdomains of the sending domain, enhances deliverability by reducing the likelihood of emails being flagged as suspicious or spam, leading to improved inbox placement.
- Reinforces Brand Identity: Custom tracking domains ensure consistent branding across all elements of an email, from the sender's address to the link URLs, reinforcing professionalism and sender reputation.
- Streamlines Filter Processing: Aligned domains can assist spam detection systems in processing emails more efficiently, potentially favoring such messages and contributing to faster deliverability.
- Mitigates Suspicion: Custom tracking domains eliminate generic or third-party hostnames from links, which could otherwise be perceived as suspicious redirects by ISPs and negatively impact deliverability.
- Aids DMARC Compliance: Ensuring all domains in email headers and body links are aligned by using custom tracking subdomains significantly contributes to DMARC compliance and overall email authentication success.
Key considerations
- Weighing Resource Investment: While beneficial, the resources required to achieve full domain alignment, particularly across complex email infrastructures or multiple organizational mailstreams, might sometimes exceed the incremental deliverability benefits.
- Distinction Between Domain Levels: Having a different tracking subdomain is significantly less problematic than using a completely different primary domain throughout the email content, which would have a far more negative impact on deliverability.
- Minimal Impact in Some Cases: Some experts suggest that in certain scenarios, having a different tracking-URL subdomain from the 'from' address subdomain may have minimal to no impact on deliverability, though it remains a recommended best practice for clarity.
- Leveraging ESP Tools: Many Email Service Providers offer features, often termed 'link branding' or 'custom tracking domains', that simplify the process of aligning tracking links with your sending domain.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks responds that having a different tracking-URL subdomain from the from-address subdomain is not problematic. He adds that while it is recommended for alignment to make things less confusing for receivers and recipients, and may be mentioned in future best current practices, it should have minimal to no impact on deliverability.
23 Apr 2025 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks shares that Tobias Herkula from Cyren's spam detection team indicated that aligned domains help them save resources, leading to faster spam filter processing and favoring such aligned mails. He also noted that having different subdomains is significantly better than having different primary domains appearing throughout the email content.
29 Aug 2024 - Email Geeks
What the experts say
4 expert opinions
While some experts note that misalignment of tracking URL subdomains is common and not always critically problematic, the consensus emphasizes the significant benefits of aligning custom tracking domains with the primary sending domain. This practice, often involving a subdomain of the main sending domain, is crucial for establishing and maintaining a consistent brand identity and a positive domain reputation. Aligned domains streamline the reputation assessment process for email filters and signal legitimacy to Internet Service Providers, ISPs, ultimately reducing the likelihood of spam flagging and improving inbox placement. However, operational practicality and the common occurrence of multiple domains within email headers mean that perfect, full alignment may not always be feasible or necessary for every sender.
Key opinions
- Enhanced Brand & Reputation: Using a custom tracking domain that aligns with your primary sending domain, often as a subdomain, consistently builds and maintains a positive brand identity and strengthens domain reputation with Internet Service Providers, ISPs.
- Improved Filter Processing: Aligning domains and subdomains throughout the entire email, including sending, authentication, and click domains, reduces the number of reputation points that filters need to calculate, potentially leading to more efficient processing and better deliverability.
- Signals Legitimacy: When your tracking domain aligns with your primary sending domain, it provides a consistent signal of legitimacy to ISPs, which is crucial for maintaining a good reputation and enhancing email deliverability by reducing the likelihood of being flagged as spam.
- Common Discrepancy: Despite the benefits of alignment, many legitimate email campaigns successfully operate with different tracking-URL subdomains from their from-address subdomains, suggesting it is not always a critical barrier to deliverability.
Key considerations
- Operational Practicality: The operational effort required for perfect domain alignment might sometimes outweigh the incremental deliverability benefits, as full alignment is often unachievable in practice and emails frequently contain multiple domains in headers.
- Contextual Impact: While beneficial, the vast majority of email campaigns use a different tracking-URL subdomain from the from-address subdomain, indicating that misalignment is not inherently problematic for all senders and its impact can vary.
- Weighing Benefits: Senders should consider the balance between strict adherence to full alignment and the practical realities of email infrastructure, recognizing that operational ease can sometimes be prioritized over vague, preference-based deliverability recommendations.
- Overall Reputation: While tracking domain alignment contributes to deliverability, it is one component of a broader sender reputation, which is also influenced by authentication, content quality, and recipient engagement.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks explains that the vast majority of mail uses a different tracking-URL subdomain from the from-address subdomain, indicating it's not inherently problematic. She questions the real deliverability impact, stating that operational practicality often outweighs vague preferences from blocklist runners. She also notes that full alignment is often unachievable in practice, with emails frequently containing multiple domains in headers.
3 Sep 2024 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks explains that, according to Tobias Herkula, aligning domains and subdomains throughout the entire email-including sending, authentication, and click domains-reduces the number of reputation points that filters need to calculate.
24 Dec 2021 - Email Geeks
What the documentation says
6 technical articles
Leading Email Service Providers, ESPs, consistently advocate for the alignment of tracking URL subdomains with the primary sending domain, often through features like 'custom tracking domains' or 'link branding.' This practice is presented as a fundamental step for improving email deliverability and ensuring consistent brand representation. According to major ESPs, this alignment significantly enhances the trustworthiness of emails in the eyes of recipients and Internet Service Providers, ISPs, helps to bypass email filters, and reduces the likelihood of messages being flagged as spam.
Key findings
- Trust and Deliverability Boost: ESPs across the board confirm that aligning tracking domains with sending domains makes emails appear more trustworthy to recipients and ISPs, which directly improves overall deliverability.
- Filter Avoidance: Custom tracking domains, by replacing generic links with aligned ones, help emails avoid spam filters and ensure better inbox placement.
- Enhanced Brand Consistency: Using a custom tracking domain that mirrors the sending domain reinforces brand identity and professionalism, signaling legitimacy to both users and email providers.
- Ensured Link Functionality: Beyond deliverability, alignment helps ensure that all links within emails open as expected, contributing to a seamless user experience.
Key considerations
- ESP-Provided Solutions: Most prominent Email Service Providers, ESPs, offer built-in features, such as 'link branding' or 'custom tracking domains,' specifically designed to facilitate this crucial alignment.
- Foundation for Trust: The mechanism behind improved deliverability through alignment is primarily the establishment of trust and a consistent sender identity, which Internet Service Providers, ISPs, rely on for reputation assessment.
- Proactive Deliverability Step: Implementing tracking domain alignment is viewed as a proactive and beneficial step by ESPs to strengthen sender reputation and maximize email campaign effectiveness.
Technical article
Documentation from Mailchimp explains that when custom domain authentication is set up, a tracking domain is also provided, which helps improve deliverability and ensures links open as expected, implying alignment benefits.
15 Mar 2025 - Mailchimp Knowledge Base
Technical article
Documentation from SendGrid explains that link branding, which replaces the generic SendGrid click-tracking domain with your own domain, improves deliverability by making emails appear more trustworthy to recipients and their Internet Service Providers (ISPs).
15 Jan 2024 - SendGrid Docs
How do HTTP tracking links affect email deliverability and user experience?
How does sending domain differing from click tracking domain affect email deliverability?
Is using the same subdomain for email and CloudPages bad for deliverability in Marketing Cloud?
Should I use separate or global tracking links for different email subdomains?
Should I use subdomains for outbound email delivery to improve deliverability?
What is the deliverability impact of using subdomains vs sub-subdomains in email marketing?
