Summary
When establishing a new sending domain, it is common for emails, even with low volumes, to be routed directly to spam folders by major inbox providers like Gmail, Yahoo, and Outlook. This phenomenon is primarily due to the nascent reputation of a brand new domain, which email providers view with suspicion until a positive sending history is established. Without a sufficient volume of positive engagement signals, ISPs (internet service providers) err on the side of caution, classifying unknown senders as potential threats.
Key findings
- New domain suspicion: New domains inherently lack sender reputation, causing ISPs to default to spam placement until trust is built. This is particularly true for those that haven't undergone a proper domain warm-up.
- Low sending volume: Extremely low sending volumes, such as 6 emails per day, do not provide enough data for ISPs to assess sender behavior effectively, leading to a cautious spam placement.
- IP reputation vs. domain reputation: While pooled IP addresses from reputable ESPs (email service providers) might have good standing, a new domain's reputation starts from scratch, overshadowing any positive IP reputation.
- Authentication importance: Even with SPF and DKIM passing, the absence of DMARC can leave a gap in your authentication strategy, making it harder for ISPs to verify your legitimacy. Proper email authentication is crucial.
- Content quality: Although mail-tester and Postmark might give positive content scores, these tools do not account for the real-world reputation impact of a new domain or the subjective filtering of major ISPs.
Key considerations
- Prioritize domain warm-up: Before sending to a large audience, implement a structured domain warm-up plan. This involves gradually increasing sending volume to engaged recipients over time, building a positive sender reputation.
- Implement DMARC: Configure DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance) to further strengthen your domain's authenticity and help ISPs trust your emails. Even a relaxed DMARC p=none policy provides valuable reporting.
- Send to engaged recipients first: During warm-up, send to your most active and engaged subscribers to generate positive engagement signals (opens, clicks), which are critical for reputation building.
- Monitor deliverability: Continuously monitor your inbox placement and sender reputation metrics. Pay close attention to spam rates and delivery to major ISPs.
- Avoid sending to unengaged lists: Sending to recipients who haven't opted in or who are unlikely to engage can quickly damage a new domain's reputation, leading to blocklisting or permanent spam placement.
What email marketers say
Email marketers frequently encounter challenges with new domains, particularly when starting with low sending volumes. The consensus among marketers is that the lack of prior sending history and engagement data makes new domains susceptible to spam filtering, regardless of content quality or basic authentication (like SPF/DKIM). They often express surprise at the severity of immediate spam placement across multiple inbox providers.
Key opinions
- Immediate spam filtering: Marketers frequently observe that new domains, even with low volumes, are immediately flagged as spam by various ISPs, indicating a default suspicion.
- Domain reputation is paramount: The domain's age and lack of established reputation are seen as primary culprits, outweighing content quality checks from tools like Mail-Tester.
- Warm-up is non-negotiable: Many believe that proper domain warm-up is essential for any new domain to achieve inbox placement, regardless of initial volume.
- Poor advice from other vendors: Some marketers highlight instances where clients are advised to switch to new domains by email security vendors, which can complicate deliverability rather than solve it.
- Testing patterns: Sending low volumes, especially in a sporadic pattern, can itself look like suspicious 'testing' behavior to ISPs.
Key considerations
- Start warm-up early: Integrate domain warm-up into the very first stages of your email program, even before content is finalized, to proactively build trust with ISPs and avoid early spam filtering issues.
- Focus on engagement, not just content: Shift focus from purely content-based checks (like Mail-Tester) to understanding and improving email deliverability factors that build actual sender reputation, such as user engagement and list hygiene.
- Seek expert deliverability advice: Before making significant domain changes or starting a new sending infrastructure, consult with deliverability experts rather than relying solely on general IT or security vendors.
- Understand ISP behavior: Recognize that ISPs are increasingly strict with new domains and small sending patterns due to rampant spam, making deliberate warm-up more crucial than ever. This aligns with modern deliverability best practices.
Email marketer from Email Geeks notes that a brand new domain will inherently have a bad reputation, especially in the eyes of major inbox providers. They stress that a domain's age plays a significant role in how it's perceived for email sending.
Marketer from Quora advises that the most common reason emails land in spam, especially for new domains, is a known (or suspected) history of spamming. They suggest that content issues or poor domain reputation can also contribute significantly to this problem, leading to immediate spam classification.
What the experts say
Deliverability experts agree that new domains face significant hurdles in achieving inbox placement, even at low volumes. They emphasize that domain age, sending consistency, and positive engagement are far more critical than initial content quality. Experts highlight that ISPs treat new domains with caution due to the prevalence of spammers who frequently cycle through fresh domains to evade detection. The advice generally points towards diligent warm-up and comprehensive authentication as the only reliable path to building a trusted sending reputation.
Key opinions
- New domain, no trust: A newly registered domain has zero historical data for ISPs to evaluate, leading to a default 'suspicious' categorization regardless of other factors like content or basic SPF/DKIM.
- Warm-up is critical: Experts stress that proper domain warm-up is the only way to establish trust and build a positive sending reputation over time, by demonstrating consistent, wanted email traffic.
- Engagement matters most: The most important signal for ISPs is positive engagement from recipients. Sending to a few highly engaged contacts during warm-up is more effective than sending to many unengaged ones.
- Avoid 'testing' patterns: Sending very low, irregular volumes for 'testing' can mimic spammer behavior and negatively impact reputation building, making it harder for the domain to gain traction.
- DMARC is essential: While SPF and DKIM are foundational, DMARC provides a critical layer of authentication and reporting that helps ISPs verify your domain's legitimacy, especially important for new senders. Our guide to DMARC benefits explains more.
Key considerations
- Strategic warm-up: Design a strategic warm-up plan that slowly escalates sending volumes to highly engaged segments of your audience, gradually expanding to broader groups as reputation improves.
- Comprehensive authentication: Ensure all email authentication protocols (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) are correctly implemented from day one to maximize trustworthiness for new domains. Our article on advanced email authentication delves deeper.
- Monitor domain reputation closely: Utilize postmaster tools from major ISPs (e.g., Google Postmaster Tools) to monitor your new domain's reputation metrics and identify any red flags early on.
- Reconsider domain changes: Experts often advise against impulsively changing to a new domain unless absolutely necessary, as rehabilitating an old domain can sometimes be easier than starting a new one from scratch. This is a common pitfall in avoiding Gmail's spam folder.
Deliverability expert from Email Geeks explains that the situation described, where emails from a new domain with low volume go directly to spam across multiple providers, is the new reality of email sending. They imply that ISPs have become much stricter.
Expert from Spamresource.com states that a new domain essentially starts with no reputation, which means it carries a default level of suspicion from email providers. They highlight that this neutral or slightly negative starting point is why warm-up is necessary.
What the documentation says
Official documentation from major inbox providers and email standards bodies consistently highlights the importance of sender reputation and authentication, particularly for new sending domains. They emphasize that a domain's lack of history or engagement data leads to initial filtering into spam or junk folders. Documentation often outlines the need for a gradual increase in sending volume (warm-up) and robust email authentication protocols (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) to build trust and ensure inbox placement. They rarely make exceptions for low sending volumes, as even small amounts of unsolicited mail can be detrimental.
Key findings
- New domain policies: ISPs have specific policies for new domains, often subjecting them to stricter filtering until a positive sending history is established.
- Sender reputation foundation: Sender reputation is built over time through consistent, positive sending behavior, including low bounce rates, high open rates, and low complaint rates. New domains lack this foundation.
- Volume and consistency: While low volume seems innocent, it also means insufficient data for ISPs to build trust, often leading to a default spam categorization. Consistent sending patterns are preferred.
- Authentication standards: Official guidelines from Google and Yahoo now mandate robust authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) for senders to ensure messages are not immediately classified as spam or rejected.
- Engagement as a key metric: Engagement metrics like opens, clicks, and lack of spam complaints are heavily weighted in reputation algorithms, which are absent for new, low-volume domains.
Key considerations
- Adhere to warm-up guidelines: Follow recommended warm-up schedules provided by ESPs or postmaster guidelines to gradually introduce your new domain to ISPs, allowing them to assess your legitimate sending behavior.
- Implement DMARC fully: Beyond SPF and DKIM, ensure DMARC is set up with a reporting policy (e.g., p=none with a rua tag) to gain visibility into your email authentication results across all receivers. This is detailed in DMARC tag documentation.
- Monitor postmaster tools: Regularly check Google Postmaster Tools and other ISP-specific dashboards to track your domain's reputation, spam rate, and authentication failures. This proactive monitoring is key to understanding Google Postmaster Tools Domain Reputation.
- Understand spam filter logic: ISPs utilize sophisticated algorithms that factor in domain age, sending volume patterns, and recipient engagement. New domains with low, inconsistent volumes often trigger these filters due to lack of trust signals.
Documentation from Google Postmaster Tools states that a new domain has no established reputation, which means emails sent from it are subject to higher scrutiny and may default to spam folders. They explain that reputation is built incrementally based on sending history and user feedback.
RFC 7489, the DMARC specification, outlines the importance of DMARC records for domain authentication, which helps receiving mail servers make informed decisions about incoming email. For new domains, this additional layer of trust is crucial to combat spoofing and enhance deliverability.
![Email Deliverability: Avoiding The Spam Folder [2025]](https://moosend.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/Email-Deliverability.png)
