Summary
Migrating to a new email service provider (ESP) involves a critical phase known as IP and subdomain warmup. This process is essential for building a positive sending reputation with internet service providers (ISPs) like Gmail, Outlook, and Hotmail. Failing to warm up properly can lead to severe deliverability issues, including emails landing in spam folders, being rate-limited, or even outright blocked. Many senders encounter challenges such as temporary blocks and dips in engagement rates, which are often normal during this transition. The goal is to gradually increase sending volume, allowing ISPs to recognize and trust the new sending infrastructure.
Key findings
- Gradual ramp-up: Proper IP and domain warming involves a carefully planned, gradual increase in email volume to new domains and IPs. This prevents ISPs from flagging sudden high volumes as suspicious, which can lead to blocks.
- Reputation is key: New domains and IPs lack established sending reputations, making them vulnerable to strict ISP filtering. Issues like low sender scores or unassigned domain reputations are common during warmup.
- Authentication importance: Correctly configured authentication protocols, such as SPF and DKIM, are vital from day one to establish trust and ensure messages are not immediately rejected. Inadequate authentication can result in delivery failures.
- Content matters: Even with legitimate subscribers, email content that is perceived as 'spammy,' (e.g., heavily promotional, image-heavy) can negatively impact inbox placement during the sensitive warmup phase.
- ISP-specific challenges: Hotmail, Outlook, and Gmail often present unique challenges during warmup due to their sophisticated filtering algorithms and strict reputation requirements. Gmail's Postmaster Tools can provide valuable insights into your sending reputation and spam rates. Microsoft also provides a Postmaster Site.
Key considerations
- Dedicated warmup plan: Develop a detailed plan for increasing volume to highly engaged segments of your audience first, gradually expanding to broader lists. This strategy helps build a positive reputation efficiently.
- Monitor reputation tools:Regularly monitor your sending reputation using tools like Google Postmaster Tools, Outlook's Postmaster site, and other industry-standard sender score platforms. This allows for early detection and correction of issues. You can find more information about Google's Postmaster Tools here.
- Authentication setup: Ensure your new subdomain and IP have correctly configured SPF and DKIM records from the outset. Consider implementing DMARC for comprehensive domain protection and reporting, which can also aid reputation building.
- Audience segmentation: Segment your audience based on engagement levels. Prioritize sending to your most active and engaged subscribers during the initial warmup phases to generate positive engagement signals.
- Content optimization: Review your email content for potential spam triggers. While promotional emails are common, balancing content with a clear call to action and avoiding overly aggressive sales language can help.
- Fallback strategy: If possible, maintain your old ESP (and domain) for critical sends during the warmup of the new one. This ensures business continuity and provides a fallback if deliverability issues become severe. Read more about how to mitigate deliverability issues.
What email marketers say
Email marketers frequently face significant hurdles when warming up new IPs and subdomains after an ESP migration. A common mistake is underestimating the time and effort required for a proper warmup, often treating the migration as an instant switch. Many report experiencing temporary blocks, rate limiting, and noticeable dips in engagement metrics, even when following standard warmup procedures. The general consensus is that patience and meticulous monitoring are crucial, especially when dealing with major inbox providers like Gmail and Outlook.
Key opinions
- Warmup is non-negotiable: Marketers emphasize that skipping or rushing the warmup process for new IPs and domains can lead to long-term damage to sending reputation and severe email deliverability problems.
- Engagement is paramount: Sending to highly engaged segments first is a critical best practice. It helps establish a positive feedback loop with ISPs, indicating that your mail is wanted.
- ISP variations: Hotmail/Outlook are often cited as particularly challenging during warmup, sometimes attributed to features like their tabbed inbox or stricter filtering, leading to lower-than-expected rates even with established IPs.
- Content sensitivity: Even if subscribers opt-in, promotional or image-heavy content can be flagged as spam by ISPs during the warmup period, impacting inbox placement without explicit spam complaints.
- Domain delegation complexity: The delegation of sending domains to previous ESPs can complicate the transition, forcing marketers to warm up new subdomains or IPs while maintaining existing sending volume on the old infrastructure, posing a risk if the old domain is suddenly disabled.
Key considerations
- Patience and persistence: Accept that warmup is a marathon, not a sprint. Deliverability issues like temporary blocks and dips in engagement are part of the process and require consistent effort to overcome.
- Monitor everything: Utilize all available tools like Google Postmaster Tools for Gmail, and ensure you check your sender reputation regularly, even if it doesn't immediately show your domain. This can give you insights into why emails are going to spam.
- Ensure authentication: Double-check that your DKIM and SPF records are correctly set up for the new sending infrastructure. Misconfigurations are a common cause of initial deliverability problems. More on email authentication protocols.
- Strategic domain management: If retaining control of your primary sending domain is an option, it's generally preferable. If a new subdomain is necessary, understand that it starts with zero reputation and requires dedicated warmup.
- Don't stop critical sends: If email is a primary revenue driver, marketers often find it impractical to halt all sends. Consider using a temporary, established solution for bulk sends while the new infrastructure warms up.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks explains their current ESP manages their sending domain, necessitating a new subdomain and IP for their new ESP. They are experiencing significant deliverability issues with Hotmail, Outlook, and Gmail despite following standard warmup procedures. Their initial plan of doubling users every second day seemed effective but has since stalled, leading to frustration. They have scaled back sends to 4,000 users with a reported 70% open rate, yet deliverability to major providers has not improved. This suggests that even positive engagement metrics from a small segment do not guarantee broader inbox placement during warmup.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks highlights the constraint of reclaiming their old sending domain. To do so, they would need to remove delegation from their current ESP, which would immediately render their old ESP non-functional. This creates a challenging situation where they cannot simply switch back to their established, high-reputation domain without disrupting their primary email operations. The dilemma involves balancing the need for better deliverability on a new setup against the risk of completely shutting down a revenue-generating channel. It underscores the importance of carefully planning domain migration strategies.
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts consistently advise a cautious and data-driven approach to IP and subdomain warmup. They stress that building a positive sender reputation is a delicate process, particularly when migrating ESPs and introducing new sending infrastructure. Experts highlight that issues like high bounce rates, low engagement, and blocklistings are direct consequences of inadequate warmup or poor sending practices. They advocate for stringent list hygiene, proper authentication, and continuous monitoring of key metrics to navigate the complexities of ISP filtering.
Key opinions
- Reputation is earned: Experts affirm that new IPs and subdomains begin with a neutral or even negative reputation. This reputation must be built over time through consistent, positive sending behavior and engagement signals.
- Authentication is foundational: SPF, DKIM, and DMARC are not optional, but essential. Experts confirm that misconfigured or absent authentication records are a primary cause of emails failing to reach the inbox during warmup, as they erode trust with ISPs.
- Volume control: Over-sending too quickly on a new IP is one of the fastest ways to get blocklisted or experience severe rate limiting. Experts advise strict adherence to a gradual volume ramp-up schedule based on engagement.
- Engagement feedback loops: High engagement (opens, clicks, replies) on warmup sends is critical. Low engagement or high complaint rates can swiftly damage reputation, leading to emails being sent to spam or junk folders.
- Monitoring tools are vital: Leverage postmaster tools from major ISPs and third-party monitoring services to track deliverability, reputation metrics, and identify issues like spam traps or blocklistings early.
Key considerations
- Consistent sender identity: Maintain consistent branding, content, and sender practices during migration to avoid confusing ISPs and subscribers. This continuity aids in establishing trust.
- Leverage prior engagement: During warmup, segment your most active subscribers from your existing list. Sending to these highly engaged recipients helps generate positive signals for the new IP and domain. You can also boost your click-through rate.
- Proactive blocklist monitoring: Regularly check if your new IP or domain appears on any public or private blocklists (also known as blacklists). Early detection allows for faster remediation and reduces long-term impact on your reputation. Learn more about how email blocklists work.
- Address content issues: If emails are consistently going to spam without explicit complaints, review content for potential triggers. This includes subject lines, image-to-text ratio, and common spammy phrases.
- Understand ISP filtering: Acknowledge that ISPs continually update their filtering algorithms. What worked last year might not work today, especially on new infrastructure. Stay informed about major ISP changes.
Expert view
Expert from SpamResource clarifies that IP addresses are frequently flagged as spam due to factors such as a poor sender reputation, a high frequency of spam complaints, or elevated bounce rates. These negative indicators quickly alert ISPs to potential abusive sending practices. When an IP address becomes blacklisted or blocklisted, it severely damages email deliverability, preventing messages from reaching their intended recipients. Maintaining a clean sending list and actively managing bounce rates are crucial to avoiding such issues.
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise explains that building a new sending reputation is a delicate process that requires patience and consistency. They emphasize that any new IP or domain starts with no history, meaning ISPs treat it with inherent suspicion until positive sending patterns are established. This initial period is critical for demonstrating good sending practices. Rushing the process or sending low-quality traffic will inevitably lead to reputation damage and poor deliverability outcomes, making it harder to recover later.
What the documentation says
Official documentation from major email service providers and industry bodies consistently outlines best practices for IP and domain warmup, emphasizing its necessity for maintaining healthy email deliverability. These sources typically highlight that ISPs closely monitor sending patterns, volume, and engagement to assess sender reputation. They provide guidelines on gradual volume increases, the importance of proper email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), and the critical role of recipient engagement in building trust. Ignoring these guidelines can lead to severe deliverability penalties.
Key findings
- Sender reputation is dynamic: Documentation confirms that sender reputation is continuously evaluated based on various factors, including volume, bounce rates, spam complaints, and positive engagement. New IPs and domains have no established reputation and must build it incrementally.
- Warmup phases: Most documentation suggests a phased warmup approach, starting with low volumes to highly engaged recipients and gradually increasing volume and list breadth over several weeks or months.
- Authentication is mandatory: Official guidelines mandate the proper configuration of SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records. These protocols are essential for email authentication and are a prerequisite for good deliverability.
- Monitoring tools offered by ISPs: ISPs like Google and Microsoft provide Postmaster Tools to help senders monitor their reputation, spam rates, and other key metrics. These tools are critical for diagnosing and addressing deliverability issues.
- Bounce and complaint rates: High bounce rates (especially hard bounces) and user spam complaints are strong negative signals that can quickly damage a new IP or domain's reputation, leading to blocklistings or throttling.
Key considerations
- Adhere to ISP guidelines: Always consult and follow the specific IP and domain warmup guidelines provided by major ISPs (e.g., Gmail, Outlook.com, Yahoo) and your new ESP. These are tailored to their filtering systems.
- List hygiene: Ensure your recipient list is clean, actively engaged, and consists of genuinely opted-in subscribers to minimize bounces and spam complaints during the sensitive warmup period. Learn about spam traps.
- Subdomain strategy: If using a new subdomain, treat it as a new entity that needs its own reputation building from scratch, separate from the main domain. Ensure all DNS records are correctly pointed to the new ESP.
- Feedback loops (FBLs): Register for all available ISP feedback loops. FBLs notify you when recipients mark your emails as spam, allowing you to remove those users from your list and maintain a healthy sender reputation. You can also boost your deliverability rates.
Technical article
Documentation from Amazon Web Services (AWS) Messaging and Targeting Blog advises on the common challenges associated with moving email traffic and warming up on a new ESP. It notes that transitioning email traffic to a new ESP can present unique and significant challenges, particularly concerning maintaining deliverability during the switch. The guidance emphasizes that a well-executed warmup strategy is not merely a suggestion, but a fundamental requirement for success in email delivery. This documentation serves as a guide to ensure a smoother transition, highlighting the importance of understanding ISP requirements and building a trusted sender identity on new infrastructure. It underscores that failing to prepare for these challenges can lead to severe deliverability setbacks.
Technical article
Documentation from Twilio SendGrid's Email Guide to IP Warm Up explains how to successfully warm up an IP address to improve email deliverability and avoid delivery failures. It outlines a comprehensive guide designed to help senders navigate the complexities of establishing a new IP's reputation with various mailbox providers. This resource stresses that a structured approach, which includes careful volume ramping and consistent monitoring, is essential to ensure that emails reach the inbox rather than being rejected or sent to spam folders. It emphasizes that proper warmup is a critical investment in long-term deliverability success.
Related resources
15 resources
Related pages
Email deliverability issues: getting your messages to the inbox in 2025
Why your emails fail: expert guide to improve email deliverability [2025]
Boost email deliverability rates: technical solutions from top performing senders
Ultimate guide to Google Postmaster Tools V2
Google Postmaster Tools domain reputation: the ultimate guide for email marketers
A simple guide to DMARC, SPF, and DKIM
An in-depth guide to email blocklists
What happens when your IP gets blocklisted?
Why your emails fail at Microsoft: the hidden SPF DNS timeout
Why your emails are getting a 'DMARC verification failed' error
