Summary
When it comes to email deliverability, the consensus among experts is that domain reputation has increasingly become a more significant factor than IP reputation. This shift has evolved over several years, driven by factors such as the widespread use of shared IP addresses and the domain's direct link to a sender's brand identity, content quality, and long-term sending habits. While IP reputation still holds considerable importance, especially for new senders or in cases of extremely poor IP health where it can even override a strong domain reputation, domain reputation is now often considered the primary indicator of a sender's trustworthiness by major mailbox providers. Proper domain authentication, including SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, is crucial for establishing and maintaining this vital reputation.
Key findings
- Domain Dominance: Domain reputation is largely considered more critical for email deliverability than IP reputation by most mailbox providers and experts.
- Evolutionary Shift: This increased emphasis on domain reputation has been a gradual shift over the past decade, accelerating in recent years.
- Shared IP Influence: The prevalence of shared IP addresses has made domain reputation a more reliable and stable identifier of a sender's legitimacy.
- IP's Enduring Role: Despite the rise of domain reputation, IP reputation remains a foundational factor, very poor IP reputation can still cause significant deliverability problems, sometimes even preventing domain reputation from being considered.
- Brand Identity and Content: Domain reputation is directly tied to a sender's brand, content quality, and consistent sending practices over time, making it a stronger long-term indicator of trust.
- Authentication as Key: Implementing strong domain authentication protocols like DKIM, SPF, and DMARC is fundamental for building and sustaining a positive domain reputation.
Key considerations
- Holistic Approach: Maintain a holistic view of sender reputation, understanding that both domain and IP reputation contribute significantly to overall deliverability.
- Prioritize Domain Health: Focus diligently on practices that build and preserve a strong domain reputation, including consistent sender behavior, relevant content, and positive subscriber engagement.
- Robust Authentication: Ensure all sending domains are correctly authenticated with SPF, DKIM, and DMARC to signal legitimacy to mailbox providers.
- Monitor Both Metrics: Regularly track both your domain and IP reputation scores, as issues with either can impact inbox placement.
- Provider Specifics: Be aware that certain mailbox providers, such as Microsoft, may still weigh IP reputation more heavily than others, requiring a balanced approach.
- Long-Term Strategy: Develop a long-term strategy for email marketing that prioritizes building and maintaining a strong domain reputation, as it reflects sustained sender trustworthiness.
What email marketers say
14 marketer opinions
While both IP and domain reputation are crucial for successful email deliverability, current expert opinion heavily leans towards domain reputation as the more influential factor in today's email ecosystem. This elevated standing for domain reputation has developed over years, primarily because it offers a more stable and reliable indicator of a sender's legitimacy. Unlike IP addresses, which can be shared or cycled, the domain is inherently tied to a brand's identity, content quality, and long-term sending behavior. Even so, the foundational importance of IP reputation persists; an extremely poor IP reputation can still prevent messages from reaching the inbox, regardless of a strong domain. Therefore, a comprehensive approach to deliverability must account for both, with particular emphasis on meticulously maintaining domain health through proper authentication.
Key opinions
- Domain's Greater Weight: The vast majority of email deliverability experts agree that domain reputation generally holds more significance than IP reputation for inbox placement.
- Years of Evolution: This heightened importance of domain reputation is the result of a gradual, multi-year evolution in how mailbox providers assess sender trustworthiness.
- Shared IP Catalyst: The widespread use of shared IP addresses by email service providers has made domain reputation a more stable and reliable metric for assessing a sender's ongoing practices.
- IP Still Foundational: Despite domain reputation's rise, IP reputation remains a vital baseline, with severely poor IP health capable of overriding positive domain standing and blocking delivery.
- Brand & Content Link: Domain reputation is intricately linked to the sender's brand identity, the quality of their email content, and their consistent sending habits over time.
- Authentication's Role: Proper domain authentication, such as DKIM signing, is a critical component for establishing and maintaining a positive domain reputation.
Key considerations
- Balance Both: Adopt a balanced approach to deliverability, acknowledging that both domain and IP reputation contribute to overall sender trustworthiness and inbox success.
- Nurture Domain Health: Dedicate significant effort to building and preserving a strong domain reputation through consistent, legitimate sending practices and positive subscriber engagement.
- Implement Authentication: Ensure all email sending is properly authenticated using domain-based protocols like DKIM, SPF, and DMARC to signal legitimacy to mailbox providers.
- Monitor All Metrics: Regularly monitor both your domain and IP reputation metrics, as a decline in either can adversely affect deliverability.
- Provider Nuances: Be aware that while domain reputation is broadly dominant, some mailbox providers, notably Microsoft, may still place substantial emphasis on IP reputation.
- Long-Term Trust: View domain reputation as a long-term asset that reflects sustained sender trustworthiness, requiring ongoing diligence in email program management.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks explains that while everything is important, domain reputation has gained more awareness and importance. This shift has been occurring over years, not just months.
28 Jun 2022 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks explains that domain reputation has been relevant for about 10 years, gaining more prominence in the past few years as it's leveraged differently. They note that many factors now contribute to reputation, not just IP or domain. Ignoring domain reputation, such as DKIM, can lead to problems, but IP reputation should not be disregarded either.
12 Nov 2023 - Email Geeks
What the experts say
2 expert opinions
Industry experts widely agree that domain reputation has solidified its position as the preeminent factor in email deliverability, overshadowing IP reputation for most established senders. Major mailbox providers now primarily evaluate a sender's trustworthiness by analyzing their domain's historical sending patterns and recipient engagement. While IP reputation continues to be relevant, particularly for new senders establishing their presence or those with a troubled IP history, a robust domain reputation can often mitigate minor IP-related issues. Conversely, a compromised domain reputation almost invariably leads to significant deliverability challenges, regardless of the underlying IP's status. This shift reflects ISPs' refined ability to track sender behavior directly associated with the brand, making the domain the key determinant of inbox placement.
Key opinions
- Domain as Primary: For established senders, domain reputation is the leading determinant of email deliverability, widely considered more important than IP reputation.
- ISP Tracking Shift: Internet Service Providers now predominantly track sender behavior and trustworthiness at the domain level, even across various sending infrastructures and shared IP addresses.
- Engagement Driven: Mailbox providers primarily assess a sender's reliability through their domain's historical sending patterns and user engagement metrics, such as opens and clicks.
- IP's Niche Role: IP reputation retains importance for new senders establishing their presence or those recovering from poor IP health, acting as an initial or supplementary filter.
- Mitigation & Impact: A strong domain reputation can often overcome minor IP reputation issues, but a weak domain reputation will critically impair deliverability regardless of the IP's status.
- Trust Indicator: The domain is seen as the direct representation of the sender's brand and their long-term commitment to good sending practices, making it the dominant indicator of trust.
Key considerations
- Prioritize Domain Health: Actively cultivate and protect your domain reputation through consistent, high-quality sending and positive subscriber interaction.
- Understand IP's Context: Recognize that while domain is dominant, IP reputation still plays a screening role, especially for senders with limited history or a problematic past.
- Monitor Domain Behavior: Regularly review domain-level metrics for signs of declining reputation, as this is the primary signal ISPs use for sender trustworthiness.
- Engage Subscribers: Foster strong subscriber engagement to build and maintain a positive domain reputation, as this directly influences how mailbox providers view your trustworthiness.
- Proactive Management: Implement a proactive strategy for domain reputation management, recognizing its critical impact on inbox placement and long-term deliverability.
- Address Domain Issues Swiftly: Be prepared to quickly identify and rectify any factors that could negatively affect your domain's standing, as a poor domain reputation almost guarantees deliverability problems.
Expert view
Expert from Spam Resource explains that while IP reputation still plays a role, particularly for new senders or those with poor IP history, domain reputation has become significantly more important and is the primary factor influencing inbox placement for established senders. ISPs now track sender behavior at the domain level across various IP addresses and services, making domain reputation the dominant determinant of email deliverability.
2 Jul 2025 - Spam Resource
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise shares that domain reputation has largely surpassed IP reputation as the leading factor for email deliverability. While IP reputation still holds some weight, especially for new senders, major mailbox providers now primarily assess a sender's trustworthiness based on their domain's sending history and user engagement. A strong domain reputation can mitigate issues with IP reputation, but a poor domain reputation will almost certainly lead to deliverability problems.
2 Mar 2023 - Word to the Wise
What the documentation says
5 technical articles
Leading email service providers and industry experts broadly concur that domain reputation has emerged as the primary determinant of email deliverability, often carrying more weight than IP reputation in current filtering systems. While IP reputation remains a foundational element, especially for blocking egregious spam or identifying problematic shared infrastructure, major mailbox providers like Google, Microsoft, and Yahoo increasingly rely on a sender's domain history and authentication to assess their legitimacy and trustworthiness. This emphasis underscores the domain as the key identifier for long-term sender behavior and brand reliability.
Key findings
- Domain's Primary Influence: Major mailbox providers like Google, Microsoft, and Yahoo generally prioritize domain reputation when determining inbox placement, viewing it as a stronger indicator of sender trustworthiness.
- Increasing Domain Reliance: There is a clear and consistent trend among leading email services to place greater emphasis on domain-based signals for filtering decisions.
- IP Still Matters: Despite the heightened focus on domains, IP reputation remains a fundamental factor, serving as an initial screening layer and a critical component for identifying severe spam or network abuse.
- Authentication's Crucial Role: Implementing robust domain authentication protocols, such as SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, is consistently highlighted by providers as essential for establishing and maintaining a positive domain reputation.
- Trust and Legitimacy Indicator: Domain reputation directly reflects a sender's long-term behavior, consistent practices, and legitimacy, making it the preferred metric for assessing a sender's reliability.
Key considerations
- Strategize for Domain Health: Dedicate significant effort to maintaining a positive domain reputation through all sending activities, as it is increasingly the most influential factor.
- Don't Overlook IP Basics: While domain reputation is dominant, ensure your IP reputation remains solid, as it still functions as a foundational filter and can impact delivery.
- Implement Strong Authentication: Properly set up and maintain domain authentication protocols, including SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, as they are crucial for validating your sender legitimacy and building domain trust.
- Continuously Monitor Metrics: Regularly track both your domain and IP reputation scores across various platforms and tools to proactively identify and address potential issues.
- Adapt to Provider Requirements: Recognize that while there's a general trend, specific mailbox providers may have nuanced approaches to weighing domain versus IP reputation, requiring a balanced strategy.
Technical article
Documentation from Google Workspace Admin Help explains that sender reputation, which includes domain reputation, is crucial for deliverability, influencing whether emails are delivered to the inbox or marked as spam. While IP reputation plays a role, domain reputation is increasingly emphasized for identifying legitimate senders.
27 Dec 2021 - Google Workspace Admin Help
Technical article
Documentation from Microsoft 365 explains that both domain and IP reputation contribute to deliverability, but domain reputation is a significant factor in how emails are handled by their systems. A strong domain reputation, built on consistent good sending practices, is essential for avoiding the junk folder.
1 Mar 2022 - Microsoft 365
How does domain reputation affect email deliverability compared to IP reputation?
How does domain reputation affect subdomain reputation in email marketing?
How important is email warming on shared IPs, and how do domain and IP reputations interact?
How important is IP and domain reputation for B2B email filtering?
How important is IP reputation versus domain reputation, especially for B2B senders with low engagement and emails going to spam?
What is the difference between IP and domain reputation in email deliverability?
