Summary
When a user registers for an event, the subsequent email updates can fall into a grey area between transactional and marketing communications. The distinction is crucial for email deliverability and compliance with regulations like CAN-SPAM and CASL. Generally, transactional emails are sent in direct response to a user's action and provide essential information related to that action, while marketing emails are promotional and aim to persuade the recipient to take a future action. The key lies in the primary purpose and content of the email.
Key findings
- Purpose-driven: Transactional emails are strictly tied to a specific action a user has taken, such as registration confirmation or a virtual ticket.
- Content focus: If the email provides necessary information for the event's fulfillment, it's typically transactional. Any content that promotes other products, services, or even speakers beyond basic event details, shifts it towards marketing.
- User expectation: Users expect to receive information directly related to an event they registered for. They do not necessarily expect promotional content.
- Unsubscribe rules: Transactional emails are generally exempt from unsubscribe requirements, but marketing emails must always include a clear unsubscribe mechanism.
Key considerations
- Legal compliance: Ensure your classification aligns with regulations like CAN-SPAM to avoid penalties.
- Sender reputation: Misclassifying emails can harm your sender reputation and lead to blocklisting.
- Content segmentation: Separate strictly transactional content from any promotional material. Consider distinct emails.
- Primary purpose test: If an email's primary purpose is commercial advertising, it's marketing.
What email marketers say
Email marketers often face a dilemma when sending event-related updates, particularly when some recipients have previously opted out of marketing communications. There's a strong consensus that the user's action and the email's primary purpose are key to classification, with a preference for caution to maintain good deliverability and avoid being added to a blocklist or blacklist.
Key opinions
- Strict transactional scope: Updates should be strictly limited to service delivery, like confirmations and calendar invites.
- No promotional creep: Any content promoting speakers, sponsors, or future events automatically shifts the email to marketing.
- Opt-in for marketing: Event registration does not automatically imply consent for marketing communications.
- Default to marketing: When in doubt, it's safer to classify an email as marketing to avoid compliance issues.
Key considerations
- Recipient respect: Honor previous unsubscribe requests, especially when sending non-essential content.
- Segmentation strategy: For unsubscribed users, send only critical transactional messages and consider a separate re-subscription option for additional event details.
- Clear communication: Be transparent about the purpose of your emails, particularly when communicating with attendees.
- Deliverability best practices: Using separate IP addresses for marketing and transactional emails can protect your sender reputation.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks suggests that transactional emails should be specifically related to the registration and service delivery process, such as billing notifications or virtual tickets.
Marketer view
A marketer from Reddit discusses the challenge of balancing crucial event information with tempting promotional elements, emphasizing a clean separation.
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts typically advocate for a very narrow definition of transactional emails to safeguard sender reputation and ensure adherence to various global email regulations. They stress that any deviation into promotional content can easily reclassify an email, leading to potential inbox placement issues or even blocklisting.
Key opinions
- Unambiguous purpose: Transactional emails must have an unambiguous, functional purpose directly tied to a user's action.
- Zero promotion: Even subtle promotional elements, such as banners or links to other products, can change the email's legal classification.
- Consent is king: Without explicit consent for marketing, stick to purely transactional communication.
- Separate streams: It is best practice to use entirely separate sending infrastructures (IPs, domains) for transactional versus marketing emails.
Key considerations
- Deliverability impact: Misclassification can lead to increased spam complaints and a damaged sender reputation, affecting all your email sends.
- Regulatory scrutiny: Regulators and ISPs increasingly scrutinize email content for compliance with anti-spam laws. It is critical to know when transactional email becomes commercial.
- Technical separation: Consider using separate subdomains or domains for different types of email.
- Proactive auditing: Regularly audit your email content against a strict definition of transactional email.
Expert view
Expert steve589 from Email Geeks recommends careful content review and a conservative approach to email classification to prevent unintended marketing designation.
Expert view
Deliverability expert from SpamResource states that sender reputation critically hinges on accurate email classification between transactional and marketing messages.
What the documentation says
Official documentation and widely accepted industry standards consistently define transactional emails by their direct relevance to a customer's action or an ongoing relationship. They emphasize that the primary purpose of the message, not the sender's underlying business goal, dictates whether an email is transactional or commercial.
Key findings
- Defined by action: A transactional email is triggered directly by a user's action, such as an order, registration, or password reset.
- Non-commercial intent: Its primary purpose must not be commercial advertisement or promotion, but rather to facilitate a transaction.
- Information-centric: The content should primarily provide information directly related to the user's initiated activity.
- Unsubscribe exemption: Transactional messages are typically exempt from the unsubscribe mechanism requirement found in anti-spam laws.
Key considerations
- Strict interpretation: Many regulatory bodies and mailbox providers apply a strict 'primary purpose' test to classify emails.
- Avoid mixed content: Adding any marketing content can result in the entire email being treated as commercial, requiring opt-in consent and an unsubscribe link.
- Clear user value: Each transactional email should clearly offer direct value related to the user's interaction.
- Deliverability best practices: Proper email authentication is crucial for all email types, including transactional ones.
Technical article
Documentation from Shopify emphasizes that transactional emails are automated and triggered after a customer takes a specific action with the brand.
Technical article
A guide from Mailmodo states that transactional emails are typically triggered by recipient actions, such as an event registration confirmation.
Related resources
5 resources
Related pages
How should account update emails be classified if users can opt out?
Do transactional emails negatively impact marketing email deliverability?
What are the legal implications of including promotional content in emails?
Should I separate transactional and marketing emails?
When does transactional email become commercial email?
A simple guide to DMARC, SPF, and DKIM
What happens when your domain is on an email blacklist?
Email Deliverability Issues: Getting Your Messages to the Inbox
Why Your Emails Are Going to Spam and How to Fix It
Should I use separate email subdomains for transactional and promotional emails?
