Summary
The overwhelming consensus among email marketing experts, community members, and official documentation sources is that inbox placement platforms (including email warming services and engagement farms) are generally *not* a good long-term strategy for email deliverability. While some acknowledge potential short-term benefits or niche uses (e.g., warming new IPs), the risks and potential drawbacks far outweigh the advantages. Key concerns include ethical considerations, the potential for detection by mailbox providers, legal implications, and the fact that these services don't address the underlying issues that cause deliverability problems in the first place. The recommended approach is to prioritize building a strong email marketing foundation based on genuine engagement, high-quality content, list hygiene, proper authentication, and consistent sending practices.
Key findings
- Limited Long-Term Value: Inbox placement platforms offer temporary gains but don't fix fundamental deliverability issues.
- Ethical & Legal Risks: These platforms often operate in a gray area, potentially bordering on fraud or violating anti-spam laws.
- Risk of Detection & Penalization: Mailbox providers are increasingly sophisticated at detecting and penalizing inauthentic engagement signals.
- Focus on Fundamentals is Crucial: Sustainable deliverability relies on solid sending practices and a strong sender reputation, not shortcuts.
- Inconsistent Results: Some users report short-term gains, but these are often followed by a decline in deliverability if underlying issues aren't addressed.
Key considerations
- Legality: Carefully evaluate the legality of using these services and avoid tactics associated with spamming.
- Sender Reputation: Prioritize building a positive sender reputation by earning genuine engagement from subscribers.
- List Hygiene: Maintain a clean and engaged email list through regular cleaning and confirmed opt-in practices.
- Authentication: Implement proper email authentication protocols (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) to verify your sending identity.
- Content Quality: Focus on creating valuable and relevant content that recipients will find engaging.
- Long-Term Goals: Consider the long-term consequences of using these services on your sender reputation and avoid short-sighted strategies.
- Foundational Setup: Address the underlying deliverability issues that are causing problems instead of relying on quick fixes. Warming services will not help if your foundations are bad.
What email marketers say
17 marketer opinions
The majority of email marketing experts and community members advise caution when considering inbox placement platforms (including email warming services) as a deliverability strategy. While some acknowledge potential short-term benefits, there's a strong consensus that these platforms are not a sustainable solution for long-term deliverability. Many believe they can be risky, bordering on unethical or even fraudulent, and that mailbox providers are increasingly adept at detecting and penalizing such tactics. The overriding recommendation is to focus on building a strong email marketing foundation based on genuine engagement, high-quality content, list hygiene, proper authentication, and consistent sending practices.
Key opinions
- Limited Long-Term Benefit: Inbox placement platforms offer temporary boosts but don't address underlying deliverability issues.
- Ethical Concerns: Many consider these platforms to be 'gaming the system,' potentially crossing into fraudulent territory.
- Risk of Detection: Mailbox providers are actively working to identify and penalize platforms attempting to manipulate engagement signals.
- Focus on Fundamentals: Sustainable deliverability relies on good sending practices, not shortcuts.
Key considerations
- Sender Reputation: Prioritize building a strong sender reputation through authentic engagement and valuable content.
- List Hygiene: Regularly clean your email list to remove invalid or unengaged subscribers.
- Authentication: Implement proper email authentication protocols (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) to verify your identity.
- Engagement: Use double opt-in to confirm subscribers want to receive messages. This reduces spam complaints and ensures better engagement.
- Long-Term Strategy: Ask yourself: is this strategy a quick fix to a long term problem? Using this type of platform may be a 'crutch' for a weak email foundation.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks suggests that even if inbox placement platforms work as advertised, any benefits will be temporary unless the sender's practices are already good.
13 Feb 2023 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Email marketer from ZeroBounce suggests the foundation for email success starts with email verification of your list to remove invalid or risky email addresses. This combined with good sending practices will lead to better inbox placement.
22 Jan 2024 - ZeroBounce
What the experts say
4 expert opinions
Experts across various platforms strongly advise against using inbox placement platforms (including engagement farms) for email deliverability. They raise concerns about legality, sustainability, and the risk of detection by mailbox providers. These services offer no long-term benefit and can actively harm sender reputation by mimicking spam tactics rather than fostering genuine engagement.
Key opinions
- Legality Questionable: Inbox placement platforms bear resemblance to tactics used in spam lawsuits.
- Unsustainable Results: The benefits are temporary and disappear once you switch to your own audience.
- Detection Risk: Mailbox providers can identify and penalize these services.
- Reputation Damage: Inauthentic engagement does more harm than good in the long run.
Key considerations
- Legality: Be aware of potential legal ramifications and avoid tactics associated with spamming.
- Authenticity: Focus on earning genuine engagement through valuable content and permission-based marketing.
- Long-Term Impact: Consider the long-term consequences of using these services on your sender reputation.
- Underlying Issues: Rather than relying on quick fixes, address the root causes of deliverability problems, such as poor list hygiene or unengaging content.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks argues that inbox placement platforms will not provide a lasting benefit, as changing to your own audience changes what you're doing.
23 Dec 2021 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from SpamResource states that mailbox providers are very effective at detecting inauthentic engagement, and using services to generate fake positive engagement signals will, in the long run, do more harm than good to your sending reputation. They highlight the importance of earning genuine engagement through valuable content and permission-based marketing.
27 Jan 2024 - SpamResource
What the documentation says
5 technical articles
Email deliverability documentation from major providers like Google, Microsoft, SparkPost, Sendgrid and Mailchimp emphasizes the importance of building a strong sender reputation through consistent sending of valuable emails, proper authentication, list hygiene, and recipient engagement. While warming IP addresses may have a limited role, the documentation consistently recommends focusing on fundamental best practices as the key to long-term deliverability success, with no provider recommending email warming services or inbox placement platforms.
Key findings
- Sender Reputation is Key: A positive sender reputation is crucial for avoiding spam filters and achieving good deliverability.
- Value Content is Required: Consistently sending emails that recipients find valuable is essential for building a positive reputation.
- Authentication is Critical: Proper email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) is vital for verifying your identity and ensuring deliverability.
- Engagement Matters: Engaged recipients and consistent sending volume are essential for maintaining good deliverability.
- Hygiene is a must: Consistent cleaning of lists and segmentation of audiences help to keep email deliverability high.
Key considerations
- Authentication: Implement SPF, DKIM, and DMARC to authenticate your emails and prevent spoofing.
- List Management: Maintain a clean and engaged email list by removing inactive subscribers and acquiring new subscribers through confirmed opt-in.
- Content Quality: Focus on creating valuable and relevant content that recipients will find useful and engaging.
- Sending Practices: Maintain a consistent sending volume and avoid sending unsolicited emails.
- Avoid Shortcuts: Prioritize fundamental best practices over quick fixes like warming services.
Technical article
Documentation from Mailchimp recommends that ensuring your email is properly authenticated, using a familiar 'From' address, segmenting your lists, and cleaning your audience regularly are all key components of a good deliverability strategy. Mailchimp does not recommend or mention warming services.
7 Jul 2022 - Mailchimp
Technical article
Documentation from Google Postmaster Tools explains that sender reputation is a key factor in deliverability. Consistently sending emails that recipients find valuable is crucial for building a positive reputation and avoiding spam filters. This cannot be bypassed by warming services.
1 Dec 2021 - Google Postmaster Tools
Besides Spamhaus, what blocklists are important for email marketers to monitor?
How accurate are email spam testing tools and what are the alternatives?
How accurate are seed lists for email deliverability testing?
How accurate are seedlists in deliverability platforms like Everest and Glockapps?
How accurate is SNDS and Google Postmaster Tools reputation data?
How can I accurately test and measure email deliverability and sender reputation?
How do I set up Braze with Validity/Everest seed lists?
How reliable are GlockApps deliverability placement reports and what are the alternatives?
What are the best inbox placement testing tools?
