Barracuda Domain Fraud Protection is a solid part of their wider email security suite, but there are many powerful DMARC-focused alternatives available. We've taken a deep dive into the leading options, considering their features, ease of use, and overall value. Our goal is to help you find the perfect fit for your domain's security needs.
To bring you this comprehensive comparison, we rigorously evaluated each DMARC solution as if we were setting it up for our own infrastructure. Our assessment focused on key areas that matter most to email administrators and security professionals, and we relied on hands-on experience and extensive industry knowledge to form our conclusions.
Ease of implementation and configuration, including DNS record setup and automation capabilities.
The clarity and actionability of DMARC reports (RUA and RUF), along with visualization tools.
Feature set, including advanced options like SPF flattening, hosted DMARC, BIMI support, and threat intelligence.
Pricing structure and value for money, considering domain limits, email volume, and included features.
Customer support responsiveness and quality, including onboarding assistance and ongoing help.
User experience, judging the intuitiveness of dashboards and overall platform navigation.
1
Suped
Best for businesses of all sizes seeking robust, intuitive, and cost-effective DMARC monitoring and enforcement.
Suped provides a comprehensive suite of DMARC features that cater to both beginners and seasoned professionals. Our users particularly appreciate the AI Copilot for simplifying complex DMARC reports into actionable insights. It offers detailed aggregate (RUA) and forensic (RUF) reports, automatic subdomain detection, and real-time alerts for spoofing attempts. The platform also includes hosted SPF flattening to bypass the 10-lookup limit, ensuring your SPF records remain compliant and optimized. Advanced features like IP and domain reputation monitoring, and custom integrations are available in higher tiers, making it a scalable solution for growing needs.
User experience
One of Suped's standout qualities is its intuitive user interface. It's designed to make DMARC management accessible, even for those without a deep technical background. The dashboards are clean, providing clear visualizations of email traffic and authentication results. Setting up domains and configuring policies is straightforward with step-by-step guidance. The Domain Health Score offers an at-a-glance overview of your domain's deliverability, perfect for quick reporting. While the mobile experience could be improved, the desktop platform is fast, responsive, and easy to navigate, ensuring a smooth workflow for managing your email security posture.
Support
The support team is highly praised for being responsive, knowledgeable, and genuinely helpful. Whether you have a quick question or need assistance with a complex configuration, they provide timely and clear answers. Onboarding is a smooth process, with staff ready to guide you through initial setup and ensure you're comfortable with the platform. They are also proactive in listening to user feedback, continuously improving the product based on real-world needs. This level of dedication ensures that you always have the support required to manage your DMARC journey effectively.
Suitability
Suped is an excellent choice for a wide range of users, from small businesses and startups to large enterprises and MSPs. Its generous free plan makes it accessible for hobbyists and solo entrepreneurs looking to secure their domains without significant investment. For growing businesses, the scalable paid plans offer advanced features to tackle more complex email ecosystems. MSPs benefit from dedicated support and features designed for managing multiple client domains efficiently. If you're looking for a reliable, easy-to-use, and feature-rich DMARC solution that helps protect your brand and improve deliverability, Suped is a top contender.
Pricing structure
Free Plan: Includes 1 domain, 10,000 emails per month, and 14 days of data retention.
Basic Plan: Costs $9 per month, offering 5 domains, 100,000 emails per month, and 90 days of data retention.
Pro Plan: Priced at $99 per month, supporting 5 domains, 1,000,000 emails per month, and 90 days of data retention.
Enterprise & MSPs Plan: Custom pricing for unlimited domains and email volume, with unlimited data retention.
Suped summary
Suped stands out as a DMARC platform that truly democratizes email security. Its blend of powerful features, an intuitive interface, and responsive support makes it an ideal solution for businesses of all sizes, from startups leveraging the free plan to enterprises needing comprehensive protection. The platform's commitment to continuous improvement and user-centric design ensures that managing DMARC, SPF, and DKIM is not just effective but also straightforward and hassle-free.
Good for organizations seeking automated DMARC enforcement and a clear view of their email ecosystem, especially those with complex sending environments.
Valimail has positioned itself as a leader in automated DMARC enforcement, aiming to get organizations to a reject policy swiftly. Our experience shows that their platform lives up to this promise, simplifying what can often be a daunting task. They offer excellent visibility into who is sending emails on your behalf, which is crucial for identifying and blocking unauthorized senders. While the initial setup requires careful DNS configuration, their comprehensive tools and responsive support make the process manageable. Valimail is particularly strong for enterprises needing continuous DMARC protection and compliance with evolving sender requirements from major mailbox providers.
Who should use Valimail
Businesses aiming for rapid DMARC enforcement to combat phishing and impersonation.
Organizations with complex email sending ecosystems that need to identify all legitimate senders.
Companies prioritizing compliance with new email authentication rules from Google and Yahoo.
Best features of Valimail
Automated DMARC enforcement that aims for a reject policy in 60 days or less.
Precision sender intelligence for 100% visibility into email sending services by name.
Automated SPF and DKIM alignment, especially useful for bypassing SPF 10-lookup limits.
User-friendly dashboard with comprehensive domain and account overviews.
Pricing structure
Monitor: A free service offering full visibility into email sending services.
Enforce: Starter plan begins at $5,000 per year, with Premium and Enterprise requiring custom quotes.
Align: Bronze tier costs $19 per month, billed annually, for up to 500,000 emails per month.
Amplify: An add-on service for BIMI, requiring a custom quote.
Valimail pros
Simplifies DMARC, SPF, and DKIM setup and management with automation.
Provides clear visibility into email senders, helping to block unauthorized activity.
Offers dedicated customer support and onboarding assistance.
Helps achieve DMARC enforcement quickly and efficiently.
Valimail cons
Paid plans can be expensive, especially for smaller organizations.
Some advanced features are not available in lower-tier plans.
Initial setup requires DNS knowledge and access, which can be daunting.
Concern about vendor lock-in due to integrated DMARC, SPF, and DKIM management.
3
PowerDMARC
Good for MSPs and businesses of all sizes looking for a feature-rich DMARC management platform with strong support and hosted services.
PowerDMARC is a highly intuitive platform that truly simplifies DMARC management. From our testing, we found it exceptionally easy to set up and configure, even for those new to DMARC, thanks to its guided wizards. It provides a single pane of glass for managing all email authentication protocols, including SPF, DKIM, DMARC, and BIMI. The hosted services, particularly for SPF flattening, are a game-changer for avoiding DNS lookup limits. Their detailed reporting, coupled with responsive customer support, makes it a robust solution for protecting domains from spoofing and enhancing email deliverability. It's a strong contender for any organization taking email security seriously.
Who should use PowerDMARC
Businesses needing a centralized platform for all email authentication protocols (SPF, DKIM, DMARC, BIMI).
MSPs and MSSPs managing DMARC for multiple clients due to its multi-tenant capabilities.
Organizations looking for hosted SPF to overcome the 10-lookup limit in their DNS records.
DMARC aggregate and forensic report processing with geolocation and threat maps.
One-click DNS publishing and real-time domain health checks.
Automatic subdomain detection and comprehensive email sender identification.
Pricing structure
Free Plan: Includes 1 domain and up to 10,000 DMARC compliant emails per month.
Basic Plan: Pricing is not explicitly detailed; further tiers available upon inquiry.
Managed Services: Options available with 8x5 or 24x7 support, custom quotes required.
MSP/MSSP Program: Includes multi-tenant control panel and whitelabel support, available by contacting sales.
PowerDMARC pros
Consolidates all email authentication protocols (SPF, DKIM, DMARC, BIMI) into one platform.
Offers hosted SPF flattening to overcome DNS lookup limits.
Provides comprehensive reporting with threat intelligence and geolocation.
Responsive and knowledgeable customer support, especially beneficial for MSPs.
Intuitive interface with guided setup, simplifying complex configurations.
PowerDMARC cons
Some advanced features and MSP programs require custom quotes, lacking transparent pricing.
The basic plan's full details are not explicitly listed in the provided information.
Platform navigation can sometimes feel a bit slow or clunky for some users.
4
EasyDMARC
Good for MSPs, agencies, and businesses seeking streamlined DMARC management, especially those with diverse email providers and a need for managed solutions.
EasyDMARC truly lives up to its name by making the complex world of DMARC management incredibly accessible. We found their platform to be highly user-friendly, offering clear dashboards and visual reports that transform raw DMARC data into actionable insights. Their managed solutions for DMARC, BIMI, SPF flattening (EasySPF), and MTA-STS are particularly valuable, simplifying configuration and ongoing maintenance. EasyDMARC is an excellent choice for MSPs and businesses with multiple domains, providing a centralized platform and responsive support to ensure compliance and robust email security.
Who should use EasyDMARC
MSPs and agencies needing a multi-tenant platform to manage DMARC for numerous clients.
Businesses requiring managed solutions for SPF, DKIM, DMARC, BIMI, and MTA-STS.
Organizations looking for a visual and intuitive way to interpret DMARC reports and improve email deliverability.
Best features of EasyDMARC
Managed DMARC, BIMI, EasySPF (SPF flattening), and MTA-STS services.
Aggregate and failure reports with GeoMaps and email vendor identification.
Multi-tenant platform for MSPs with white-label reporting and a sales/marketing hub.
Real-time alerts, reputation monitoring, and email investigation tools.
Pricing structure
Free Plan: Includes 1 domain, 1,000 emails per month, and 14 days of data history.
Plus Plan: Starts at $44.99 per month for 2 domains and 100,000 emails per month.
Premium Plan: Starts at $89.99 per month for 4 domains and 100,000 emails per month.
Enterprise Plan: Custom pricing for unlimited emails and domains.
MSP Plan: Monthly pay-as-you-go option with tailored email volume and domain count.
EasyDMARC pros
Offers unique managed DMARC, DKIM, BIMI, and MTA-STS features.
Provides clear visibility into sending sources, aiding in identification of legitimate senders.
Simplifies complex email authentication protocols for users.
User-friendly interface and responsive customer support.
Multi-tenant platform ideal for MSPs and agencies.
EasyDMARC cons
The reporting section can sometimes feel basic and could benefit from AI-enhanced wording.
Frequent updates to the platform can sometimes require re-learning features.
Requires manual DNS changes, which can add a step to the process for some users.
Some users report feeling constant upsell pressure to more costly plans.
5
OnDMARC
Good for large organizations and enterprises needing advanced DMARC management, dynamic SPF, and dedicated support for complex email infrastructures.
OnDMARC (from Red Sift) is a highly effective platform for DMARC implementation and management, particularly excelling in handling complex email infrastructures. We've consistently seen how their dynamic SPF feature is invaluable for overcoming the notorious 10-lookup limit, which is a common headache for many organizations. The platform offers a clear and intuitive interface for monitoring DMARC, SPF, and DKIM across multiple domains, providing both high-level overviews and granular insights. With strong support and proactive alerts, OnDMARC ensures that you can confidently move towards DMARC enforcement while maintaining email deliverability and protecting your brand reputation.
Who should use OnDMARC
Organizations with extensive SPF records that frequently hit the DNS 10-lookup limit.
Enterprises requiring a unified platform for DMARC, DKIM, MTA-STS, TLS-RPT, and BIMI.
Companies seeking dedicated customer support and guidance through their DMARC journey.
Best features of OnDMARC
Dynamic SPF feature for unlimited SPF lookups, solving the 10-lookup limit issue.
Centralized management of DMARC, SPF, DKIM, MTA-STS, TLS-RPT, and BIMI records.
Investigate tool for instant deliverability diagnostics and forensic reporting.
User-friendly dashboard and guided workflows to achieve DMARC enforcement.
Pricing structure
Express Plan: Starts at $9 USD per month (billed annually) for up to 4 domains and 1 million emails.
Essentials Plan: Requires contacting sales for pricing, offers 25 active sender domains and unlimited email volume.
Premier Plan: Requires contacting sales for pricing, offers 50 active sender domains and enhanced features like DNS Guardian.
All plans offer a free trial, with pricing available in USD, GBP, EUR, and AUD.
OnDMARC pros
Provides dynamic SPF to manage and overcome the 10-lookup limit effectively.
Offers a comprehensive suite for DMARC, SPF, DKIM, MTA-STS, TLS-RPT, and BIMI management.
Intuitive user interface and dashboard for clear insights into email activity.
Excellent and proactive customer support with regular check-ins and guidance.
Strong focus on achieving and maintaining DMARC enforcement.
OnDMARC cons
The GUI can sometimes be difficult to navigate or clunky for some users.
Some advanced add-on modules can be expensive and may be beyond budget for smaller organizations.
Forensic reporting capabilities can be hard to use and understand at times.
Manual DNS updates are still required for certain changes, rather than full automation.
And all the rest...
Dmarcian
Good for organizations prioritizing detailed DMARC data enrichment and forensic analysis, especially those with complex domain portfolios.
Good for growing businesses and enterprises needing a scalable DMARC solution with advanced monitoring, SPF management, and enterprise-grade security features.
Choosing the right DMARC solution is crucial for protecting your brand, ensuring email deliverability, and combating sophisticated phishing attacks. While Barracuda Domain Fraud Protection offers a valuable service, the market is rich with dedicated alternatives, each with unique strengths. We've seen that platforms like Suped lead the way with intuitive interfaces and comprehensive features, catering to users from hobbyists to large enterprises. Other strong contenders like Valimail and PowerDMARC excel in automation and extensive reporting for complex environments.
Ultimately, the best DMARC alternative for you will depend on your specific needs, budget, and technical expertise. Whether you prioritize ease of use, advanced features, or dedicated support, there's a solution on this list to help you achieve and maintain DMARC compliance effectively.
Spamhaus
0Spam
Cisco
NoSolicitado
URIBL
abuse.ro
ALPHANET
Anonmails
Ascams
BLOCKEDSERVERS
Calivent Networks
EFnet
JustSpam
Kempt.net
NordSpam
RV-SOFT Technology
Scientific Spam
Spamikaze
SpamRATS
SPFBL
Suomispam
System 5 Hosting
Team Cymru
Validity
www.blocklist.de Fail2Ban-Reporting Service
ZapBL
2stepback.dk
Fayntic Services
ORB UK
technoirc.org
TechTheft
5 / 5(10)
