Summary
Gmail's Suspicious Link notification can appear even for legitimate HTTPS websites, causing confusion for senders. This often stems from issues beyond basic security, such as domain reputation, URL redirects, or server certificate mismatches in tracking links. Understanding these underlying causes is key to preventing these warnings and ensuring proper email deliverability.
Key findings
- Root cause assessment: The prompt identifies a common issue where a legitimate HTTPS website link in an email triggers a Suspicious Link notification in Gmail, despite the link appearing valid.
- Beyond HTTPS: While HTTPS is fundamental for security, it does not solely guarantee a link's trustworthiness in Gmail's eyes. Other factors play a significant role.
- Associated content: Gmail may flag a link if other content hosted on the same domain (or an associated domain) is deemed malicious or untrustworthy, even if the specific link is benign. This relates to overall domain reputation.
- CNAME and redirect issues: Links using CNAME records for tracking (e.g., from an Email Service Provider, or ESP) can lead to certificate errors if the ESP's certificate does not cover the custom tracking domain. This can cause Gmail to deem the link suspicious.
- Phishing detection: Gmail employs sophisticated phishing detection mechanisms that analyze various link attributes, including the discrepancy between the displayed URL and the actual destination, potential redirects, and general patterns indicative of phishing attempts. Learn more about recognizing phishing scams.
Key considerations
- Investigate link path: Thoroughly inspect the full URL, including any redirects or tracking links, to identify where the Suspicious Link warning might originate. It may not be the final destination URL.
- Check certificate validity: Even with HTTPS, ensure that the SSL/TLS certificate for all domains in the link path (especially tracking domains) is valid and correctly configured.
- Domain reputation monitoring: Actively monitor your sending domain and any linked domains for blacklisting (or blocklisting) or reputation issues, which can trigger warnings. Even if your IP is clean, your domain can be affected.
- Review ESP practices: If using an ESP, confirm their link tracking setup and ensure it aligns with best practices to avoid triggering security alerts. Sometimes ESPs can cause issues with phishing warnings.
What email marketers say
Email marketers frequently encounter Gmail's Suspicious Link warning, even with HTTPS, indicating a broader issue than simple encryption. They often point to shared infrastructure, CNAME configurations, and the dynamic nature of Gmail's filtering as primary culprits.
Key opinions
- Shared hosting impacts: Marketers frequently suspect that shared link redirectors or IP addresses used by ESPs can lead to issues, as malicious content from other users on the same hostname can negatively affect everyone using that infrastructure.
- Google's broad scanning: Some believe that Google's extensive scanning for problematic content across domains can inadvertently flag legitimate links if related (even indirectly) to undesirable material.
- Gmail's evolving algorithms: There's a common sentiment that Gmail's filters are increasingly stringent and sometimes unpredictable, making it challenging for marketers to pinpoint exact causes of warnings without specific feedback from Google. This often contributes to inconsistent warnings.
- Certificate chain issues: Marketers have observed that issues with SSL certificates on tracking subdomains, particularly when HSTS (HTTP Strict Transport Security) is in use, can lead to these warnings.
Key considerations
- Thorough link review: Always verify both the displayed link text and the actual destination URL, especially with tracking redirects. Any mismatch can trigger flags.
- ESP configuration: If using an ESP, investigate their link tracking and custom domain setup. Ensure that SSL certificates for custom tracking domains are correctly implemented and valid.
- Reputation management: Regularly check your domain's reputation with tools like Google Postmaster Tools. A low reputation, even if unrelated to the specific link, can contribute to warnings.
- HSTS awareness: If your main domain uses HSTS, ensure all subdomains, including those for link tracking, have valid SSL certificates to avoid certificate errors. This is crucial for maintaining deliverability when using HTTPS.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks suggests that the Suspicious Link notification might appear if Google dislikes other content hosted on the same site, indicating broader content or domain reputation issues.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks indicates that malicious content hosted on a link under the same hostname is a common reason for such warnings. This is particularly true if one is using a shared link redirector from an ESP.
What the experts say
Experts emphasize that while HTTPS is essential, it does not prevent Gmail's Suspicious Link warnings if underlying issues like certificate mismatches on tracking domains or shared infrastructure with poor reputation exist. They advise a nuanced approach to link configuration and security.
Key opinions
- CNAME misconfiguration: Experts point out that a CNAME record redirecting to an ESP's domain (e.g., links.yourdomain.com to links.esp.com) can lead to certificate validation failures if the certificate is not properly managed by the ESP for your custom domain.
- Certificate errors are key: The core issue is often a certificate error where the requested domain name (your custom tracking domain) does not match the server's certificate (the ESP's domain certificate). This is not necessarily a red herring but a direct cause for the warning.
- HTTP vs. HTTPS for tracking: Some experts suggest using HTTP (insecure) links for tracking domains within emails, and then allowing the final landing page to upgrade to HTTPS. This can circumvent certificate validation issues on the tracking link itself.
- Sender reputation is paramount: Beyond technical configuration, sender reputation (both domain and IP) significantly influences how Gmail treats your links. Poor reputation can trigger warnings regardless of SSL status. This connects to Gmail's dangerous message alerts.
Key considerations
- Custom tracking domain SSL: Ensure your ESP can provide a custom SSL certificate for your tracking domain (the CNAME). This is the ideal solution for HTTPS tracking links.
- Consider HTTP for tracking: If a custom SSL certificate for tracking links is not feasible, evaluate the risks and benefits of using HTTP tracking links that redirect to an HTTPS landing page.
- Proactive reputation monitoring: Regularly use tools like Google Postmaster Tools to monitor your domain's reputation. A sudden drop can indicate issues that lead to link warnings.
- DMARC, SPF, and DKIM: Proper implementation of email authentication protocols like DMARC, SPF, and DKIM strengthens your sender reputation and reduces the likelihood of links being flagged as suspicious. Read more in our guide to DMARC, SPF, and DKIM.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks explains that the CERT failure seen on a CNAME redirect link is a critical issue, not a 'red herring.' It means the ESP's certificate doesn't cover the custom domain, leading to the security warning.
Expert view
Expert from SpamResource states that domain reputation is a significant factor in how email providers, including Gmail, assess link trustworthiness. Even if the link itself is secure, a poor domain reputation can trigger warnings.
What the documentation says
Official documentation and security advisories consistently highlight that while HTTPS encrypts data in transit, it doesn't guarantee a site's legitimacy or safety from all threats. Phishing, malware, and other deceptive practices can still occur on HTTPS sites. Mailbox providers, including Gmail, use sophisticated algorithms that look beyond encryption to assess overall link and sender trustworthiness.
Key findings
- HTTPS is not a silver bullet: Documentation from security bodies (e.g., FTC Consumer Advice) clarifies that HTTPS merely encrypts the connection. It does not certify the content or the sender's intent. Malicious sites can and do use HTTPS.
- Multi-layered security: Email services like Gmail employ a multi-layered approach to security, including scanning for malware, detecting phishing patterns, analyzing sender reputation, and scrutinizing URL redirects. This goes beyond simple SSL/TLS validation.
- Phishing indicators: Official guides on phishing detection (e.g., from IT Governance) describe how scammers manipulate link appearance (display URL vs. actual URL) or use deceptive redirects, which can trigger warnings even if the final site is HTTPS.
- Domain reputation and trust: Google's own documentation on Gmail security highlights that domain reputation is critical. If a domain is associated with spam or abuse, even secure links from it can be flagged. See more on how Gmail flags suspicious links.
Key considerations
- Verify redirects: Ensure that all redirect paths, especially those created by ESPs for tracking, are secure and do not involve any intermediate domains with poor reputations or expired certificates.
- Content and context review: Beyond the link itself, the content of the email and the overall context (e.g., sender behavior, past complaints) contribute to Gmail's assessment. Avoid anything that might appear to be a phishing attempt or dangerous.
- Secure domain registration: Maintain up-to-date and secure domain registrations, including DNS settings. Any vulnerabilities can be exploited, leading to your domain being flagged.
- Adhere to best practices: Continuously follow email best practices for authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) and sending behavior to maintain a strong sender reputation and minimize security warnings.
Technical article
Documentation from Consumer Advice (FTC) cautions that scammers widely use email or text messages to trick users into revealing personal information. This underscores the need for robust email provider security features, even if they sometimes err on the side of caution.
Technical article
Documentation from Google Workspace (Gmail) asserts that Gmail keeps accounts and emails encrypted, private, and under user control. This implies that any Suspicious Link warning is part of a broader security effort to maintain this trust and privacy.
Related resources
6 resources
Related pages
What does the Gmail 'This message seems dangerous' alert mean for email deliverability?
Why do emails get a phishing warning in Gmail and how to prevent it?
Why do legitimate emails sometimes trigger inconsistent suspicious link warnings in Gmail?
Does using HTTPS/SSL for email links and images improve deliverability or performance?
Why is Google flagging my CDN or email content as malicious?
A simple guide to DMARC, SPF, and DKIM
Ultimate guide to Google Postmaster Tools V2
What happens when your domain is on an email blacklist?
Why your emails are going to spam in 2024 and how to fix it
A practical guide to understanding your email domain reputation
