Summary
The Microsoft domain error '452 4.3.1 Insufficient system resources' signifies a temporary issue on the receiving (Microsoft) server, often stemming from overload or resource constraints such as insufficient disk space. This error can also be a result of Microsoft enacting throttling measures, especially for new or unproven IPs, IPs sending too high a volume too quickly, or those exhibiting suspicious sending patterns resembling spam. While documentation confirms its transient nature requiring retries, consistent occurrences can harm sender reputation. Resolving the issue involves adjusting sending practices (slowing down, warming IPs, segmenting), monitoring sending patterns and bounce rates, checking server logs, and potentially engaging with the ESP and recipient's administrator for further investigation. Delays in message delivery can also be associated with this error.
Key findings
- Temporary Server Issue: The primary cause is a temporary server overload or resource constraint on the Microsoft side, including insufficient disk space.
- Microsoft Throttling: Microsoft utilizes this error as a method of throttling senders, especially those with new IPs, high sending volumes, or suspicious activity.
- Transient Nature: The error code indicates a transient issue, suggesting that retrying delivery is the appropriate first step.
- Reputation Impact: Persistent errors of this type can negatively affect sender reputation if retries are repeatedly unsuccessful.
- Delays in Delivery: Experiencing delays with client seeds can be an early sign of the problem.
- Greylisting can be a factor: Greylisting is a factor where retries may be delayed temporarily.
Key considerations
- Retry Delivery: Ensure sending systems are configured to automatically retry message delivery after a delay.
- Adjust Sending Practices: If encountering this error, reduce sending speeds, warm up new IPs, and segment sending lists to avoid triggering throttling.
- Monitor Sending Metrics: Closely monitor sending patterns, bounce rates, and server logs to identify potential causes and impacts on reputation.
- Engage with ESP: Work with your ESP to investigate persistent issues and pinpoint the underlying cause of the errors.
- Contact Recipient Admin: For persistent errors affecting specific recipients, consider contacting their email administrator for more details.
- Dial Back Connections: Consider dialing back connections
What email marketers say
9 marketer opinions
The Microsoft domain error '452 4.3.1 Insufficient system resources' generally indicates a temporary issue, most commonly related to server overload or resource constraints on the receiving (Microsoft) end. This can be triggered by exceeding sending volume limits, especially with new IPs or domains, or by sending patterns resembling spam activity. While typically a transient error requiring automatic retries, persistent occurrences can negatively impact sender reputation, necessitating careful monitoring, adjustments to sending practices (e.g., dialing back connections, warming up IPs, segmenting lists, adjusting sending speed), and communication with the ESP to identify root causes.
Key opinions
- Temporary Issue: The error usually signifies a temporary server overload or resource constraint on Microsoft's side.
- Throttling: Microsoft might use this error code to implement rate limiting, particularly for new or unproven IPs, or IPs with suspicious sending patterns.
- Sender Reputation Impact: Repeatedly encountering this error can negatively affect sender reputation if excessive retries fail.
- Soft Bounce: The error is classified as a soft bounce, suggesting a temporary problem rather than a permanent delivery failure.
Key considerations
- Monitor and Adjust: Carefully monitor bounce rates and sending patterns to identify and address potential causes of the error.
- Adjust Sending Practices: Consider dialing back connections, warming up IPs, segmenting lists, and adjusting sending speeds to avoid triggering rate limits.
- Investigate with ESP: Work with your Email Service Provider (ESP) to investigate the root cause of persistent errors.
- Retry Delivery: Ensure your sending system automatically retries delivery of messages that initially receive this error code.
- Check Server Logs: Checking server logs might provide extra information.
- Contact Admin: Contacting the recipient email administrator might also provide more context to the error.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Mailjet Blog responds that '452 4.3.1' is a soft bounce, suggesting temporary problems with the recipient's server. It's important to monitor bounce rates and avoid sending to addresses that generate persistent soft bounces.
3 Sep 2024 - Mailjet Blog
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Deliverability Service shares that Microsoft uses this error code to implement rate limiting, especially if it detects unusual sending patterns or spam-like activity. Adjusting sending speed and segmenting lists can help.
12 Jun 2023 - Email Deliverability Service
What the experts say
3 expert opinions
The Microsoft domain error '452 4.3.1 Insufficient system resources' indicates a temporary issue on the receiving end. Observed delays in email delivery suggest a wider problem possibly affecting multiple platforms. The error often signifies Microsoft employing throttling measures, especially for new or unproven IPs sending high volumes. The root cause can range from a busy server or insufficient disk space to greylisting, necessitating retry attempts for message delivery and careful sending practices to avoid triggering throttling.
Key opinions
- Temporary Failure: The 452 4.3.1 error signifies a transient failure that requires retry attempts.
- Throttling Mechanism: Microsoft uses this error code as a throttling mechanism, limiting connections and message rates for certain IPs.
- Delays Observed: There are observed delays in email delivery due to the 452 4.3.1 errors
Key considerations
- Retry Delivery: Implement retry mechanisms for failed deliveries due to the 452 4.3.1 error.
- Adjust Sending Speed: Reduce sending speed and spread messages over time, particularly for new or unproven IPs.
- Monitor Sending Reputation: Monitor your IPs reputation and sending patterns to identify and avoid triggering throttling measures.
Expert view
Expert from Spam Resource responds that the 452 4.3.1 error is often used by Microsoft as a form of throttling. Microsoft can limit the number of connections that an IP can make within a given period and also the message rate. The cause of the throttling might be because your IPs are either new, unproven, or sending too high a message volume too quickly. The recommended action is to slow down your sending speed and try to spread the messages out over a longer period.
22 Apr 2025 - Spam Resource
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks shares that they are seeing delays of around 15 minutes in some client seed sends and that Mailchimp is also affected.
27 May 2024 - Email Geeks
What the documentation says
5 technical articles
The Microsoft domain error '452 4.3.1 Insufficient system resources' signals a temporary issue, generally related to resource constraints or overload on the recipient's server. Official documentation and technical resources uniformly suggest that the sending server should retry delivery after a delay. The error falls under the 4xx category, indicating that the command was accepted but not executed due to a transient problem, and re-requesting the command is appropriate.
Key findings
- Temporary Overload: The error indicates a temporary server overload or resource constraint on the recipient's side.
- Transient Issue: The error is categorized as a transient issue, suggesting a temporary problem rather than a permanent failure.
- Automatic Requeueing: Systems like Postfix automatically requeue messages with these errors for later delivery attempts.
Key considerations
- Retry Delivery: Implement mechanisms for retrying delivery of messages that initially receive this error code.
- Delay Before Retrying: Retry delivery after a delay to allow the recipient's server to recover from the resource constraints.
- Transient Nature: Understand that the error is temporary, so persistent intervention might not be necessary if retries are successful.
Technical article
Documentation from MXToolbox notes that a '452 4.3.1' error may occur if the recipient's mail server is temporarily unable to accept messages due to resource constraints. Retrying delivery after a delay is the recommended approach.
3 Dec 2022 - MXToolbox
Technical article
Documentation from Cisco explains the 4xx status codes in general terms as meaning: The command was accepted, but the requested action did not occur. However, the error is temporary, and the command may be re-requested. For example, this situation can occur if the server is temporarily unable to provide service.
26 Mar 2022 - Cisco
Are there specific pixel width or SL line character limits that cause Microsoft to mark emails as spam?
How can I improve email deliverability with Microsoft and avoid spam filters?
How can I improve my sender reputation and inbox placement with Microsoft?
How can I resolve Microsoft Outlook S3140 errors blocking my transactional emails?
How do I contact Microsoft about email deliverability issues for B2B clients?
What should I do if Microsoft blocks my IP address during IP warming?
