Suped

Summary

When a Gmail warmup goes awry, the immediate instinct might be to halt all email sending. However, the deliverability landscape, especially with Gmail, often suggests a more nuanced approach. While a pause might seem logical, it can sometimes be more detrimental than maintaining a controlled sending strategy. This page synthesizes insights from industry experts, email marketers, and official documentation to provide a comprehensive view on how to navigate a Gmail warmup issue and determine the best course of action.

What email marketers say

Email marketers, often on the front lines of deliverability challenges, frequently share practical advice derived from real-world scenarios. Their perspectives often highlight the immediate impact of sending issues and the need for agile adjustments, balancing ideal deliverability practices with campaign objectives. The consensus leans towards cautious continuation rather than a complete standstill.

Marketer view

Marketer from Email Geeks observes that a client's significant warmup misstep led to a stark contrast in opens: 0.5% on Gmail versus 20% on other providers. This clearly indicated a severe issue specifically with Gmail's filtering.

20 Aug 2020 - Email Geeks

Marketer view

Marketer from Email Geeks explains that the initial send bypassed the intended warmup process, directing all volume to new IPs. This is a critical error as it prevents the necessary gradual reputation building.

20 Aug 2020 - Email Geeks

What the experts say

Deliverability experts bring a deep understanding of ISP algorithms, sender reputation mechanisms, and the intricate dynamics of email ecosystems. Their advice often prioritizes long-term sender health over short-term fixes, emphasizing consistent, high-quality sending and data-driven decisions.

Expert view

Expert (Deliverability Specialist) from Email Geeks firmly advises against stopping email sending completely, even after facing deliverability challenges during the warmup phase. They explain that continued sending, albeit carefully managed, is essential for reputation.

20 Aug 2020 - Email Geeks

Expert view

Expert (Deliverability Consultant) from Email Geeks recommends that if stopping sending is absolutely unavoidable, a minimum pause of three weeks is advisable before attempting to resume. This allows some time for reputation systems to clear recent negative signals.

20 Aug 2020 - Email Geeks

What the documentation says

Official documentation from major mailbox providers and industry bodies offers foundational guidelines for email sending and reputation management. These resources consistently emphasize the importance of compliance, authenticity, and user engagement as cornerstones of good deliverability.

Technical article

Documentation from Twilio SendGrid states that most email reputation systems will only retain data for a maximum of 30 days, which implies that extended breaks in sending can effectively reset your IP's reputation, requiring a full re-warmup.

01 Jan 2024 - Twilio SendGrid

Technical article

Google's official sender guidelines specify that senders should aim for consistent sending patterns and high user engagement to build and maintain a positive sender reputation with Gmail. Erratic sending can be detrimental.

01 Nov 2023 - Google

5 resources

Start improving your email deliverability today

Get started