Summary
Interpreting 'Rejected' errors in Gmail Postmaster Tools can be a puzzling experience for email senders. These errors indicate that Gmail has permanently refused delivery of your messages. Unlike temporary failures (TempFails), which often resolve themselves, rejections signify a more serious issue that requires immediate attention to prevent further damage to your sender reputation and email deliverability. Understanding why your emails are rejected is crucial for maintaining healthy email sending practices and ensuring your messages reach their intended recipients.
Key findings
- Permanent refusal: A 'Rejected' status in Gmail Postmaster Tools means that Gmail has permanently blocked the delivery of your emails, indicating a critical issue rather than a temporary deferral.
- Content and reputation: While Postmaster Tools might not explicitly state the cause, rejections are often linked to your email content, sender reputation (both domain and IP), or authentication failures.
- Detailed error messages: For precise troubleshooting, you need to consult your own email service provider's bounce logs. These logs contain specific SMTP error codes and messages from Gmail, which provide vital clues beyond what Postmaster Tools displays.
- Bounce types: Common reasons for rejections, even when overall bounce rates are not high, include invalid mailboxes (e.g., typos in email addresses) or recipients' mailboxes being permanently unavailable.
Key considerations
- Inspect bounce logs: Always dig deeper into your bounce logs. Your email service provider (ESP) should provide detailed bounce messages from Gmail, which are more granular than the aggregated data in Postmaster Tools.
- Verify recipient lists: If bounces indicate invalid mailboxes or mailbox unavailability, clean your email lists immediately. Continuing to send to non-existent addresses can severely damage your sender reputation, leading to more rejections. This is critical for improving your Gmail domain reputation.
- Monitor delivery errors dashboard: While Postmaster Tools provides a high-level view, keep a close eye on the Delivery Errors dashboard. It highlights trends that might indicate underlying issues with content or sending practices. For a comprehensive overview of what to monitor, refer to this guide on Google Postmaster Tools.
- Authentication check: Ensure your authentication records (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) are correctly configured. Rejections can sometimes stem from authentication failures that prevent Gmail from verifying your sending legitimacy. Issues such as DKIM success rate dips or SPF failures can contribute to rejections.
What email marketers say
Email marketers often face frustration when trying to decipher 'Rejected' errors in Google Postmaster Tools. While the tool provides high-level aggregation, it frequently lacks the granular detail needed for effective troubleshooting. Marketers highlight the importance of cross-referencing Postmaster Tools data with their internal bounce logs to gain a clearer picture of rejection causes, especially when overall bounce rates appear stable.
Key opinions
- Data granularity: Marketers frequently find that Postmaster Tools lacks sufficient detail. The delivery errors report in GPT shows 'Rejected' as a category, but not the specific reasons for those rejections.
- Reliance on ESP logs: Many marketers emphasize the necessity of checking bounce logs from their own ESP (email service provider). These logs contain the actual SMTP error codes and messages from Gmail, which are crucial for diagnostics.
- Common rejection causes: Typical reasons for rejections, even without a significant overall bounce increase, include invalid email addresses (typos) or mailboxes that are permanently unavailable. These indicate list hygiene issues.
- Temporary deferrals: Sometimes, 'Rejected' spikes in Postmaster Tools can be attributed to temporary deferrals (TempFails) that didn't convert into hard bounces, but still impacted delivery rates for a short period. Your ESP's logging of these can be vital.
Key considerations
- Deep dive into logs: When you see 'Rejected' in Postmaster Tools, the first step is always to examine your raw bounce logs for Gmail recipients. Look for specific SMTP error codes (e.g., 550, 554) and accompanying messages.
- Audience segmenting: If Postmaster Tools shows rejections, but your general bounce rate is steady, narrow your bounce analysis to only @gmail.com inboxes. This helps pinpoint Gmail-specific issues.
- List hygiene importance: If rejections are due to invalid or unavailable mailboxes, prioritize list cleaning. Regularly removing invalid addresses helps improve overall domain reputation and reduce future rejections.
- Content review: Even without drastic changes, a gradual shift in content or sending patterns (e.g., increased frequency or new content types) can trigger rejections. It's wise to review recent campaign content for potential spam triggers or policy violations, as detailed in this guide on monitoring email deliverability.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks suggests always diving deeper than what Postmaster Tools shows. While Postmaster Tools indicates 'Rejected' as a general error type, it does not provide the specific reason for the rejection, such as a particular SMTP error code or message from Gmail. Without this additional detail, troubleshooting becomes nearly impossible, as the root cause remains unknown.The aggregated view in Postmaster Tools is useful for identifying trends, but for actionable insights, it is essential to access the raw bounce logs provided by your ESP. These logs will contain the exact bounce messages, which are the key to understanding why Gmail specifically rejected a message.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Iterable explains that the Delivery Errors dashboard in Google Postmaster Tools provides a percentage of all email messages that were either rejected or temporarily failed by Gmail. This high-level overview helps identify potential issues with overall email delivery performance.However, to truly understand the nature of these errors, senders need to examine the detailed list of error types and reasons that Gmail provides within the tool, which typically appears below the main graph when a data point is clicked.
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts emphasize that 'Rejected' errors in Gmail Postmaster Tools often signify more than simple bounces; they can indicate serious underlying issues with sender reputation or content quality. Experts advise against solely relying on the aggregated view in Postmaster Tools, stressing the critical need to consult granular bounce logs provided by email service providers (ESPs).They suggest that what appears as a 'Rejected' spike in Postmaster Tools could sometimes be a surge in temporary deferrals (TempFails) that did not result in immediate hard bounces. Understanding the distinction and investigating detailed error messages are paramount for effective troubleshooting and maintaining a healthy sending domain.
Key opinions
- Beyond the summary: Experts agree that Postmaster Tools only provides a high-level summary. To truly interpret 'Rejected' errors, you must go beyond the general graph and examine the specific error messages associated with those data points, usually found below the graph in a detailed chart.
- TempFails versus rejections: A sudden increase in 'Rejected' volume in Postmaster Tools could often be a spike in temporary failures (TempFails), not necessarily hard rejections. These deferrals might clear up on their own or persist long enough to become hard bounces if the issue isn't resolved.
- Importance of ESP logs: The definitive source for understanding specific rejection reasons lies in your ESP's bounce logs. These logs capture the exact SMTP reply codes and messages from Gmail, which detail why a message was deferred or rejected.
- Content and reputation signals: While Postmaster Tools won't explicitly state 'bad content,' a rise in rejections, especially without other clear causes like invalid addresses, often points to content filtering or a deteriorating sender reputation from Gmail's perspective. For insights on potential causes for email rejections, refer to SocketLabs' guide on Google Postmaster Tools.
Key considerations
- Drill down in Postmaster Tools: Always click on the data points in the Postmaster Tools graph to reveal any additional charts or tables below, which might provide specific error categories even if not the full SMTP message.
- Cross-reference with ESP data: If Postmaster Tools shows a rejection spike but your ESP logs don't show a corresponding hard bounce increase, investigate if your ESP is logging deferrals (TempFails) separately. This can indicate a short-lived issue that resolved itself.
- Content and sending pattern review: Even subtle changes in content, subject lines, or sending volume/frequency can trigger Gmail filters. Conduct a thorough review of campaigns sent during the period of 'Rejected' errors for any potential red flags.
- Authentication health check: Ensure your SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records are correctly set up and aligned. Authentication failures can directly lead to rejections, as Gmail prioritizes authenticated mail. Use a deliverability tester to confirm proper setup and alignment, and review DMARC reports from Google.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks indicates that it's often difficult to interpret Postmaster Tools results directly, suggesting that more granular information is usually available when you click on the data points. This interactivity is intended to help senders understand the nature of the errors they are encountering.The expert believes that this drill-down functionality should provide helpful details for determining the specific reasons for rejections or temporary failures, which are crucial for deciding on any necessary actions.
Expert view
Expert from SpamResource emphasizes that reputation is the single most important factor determining whether an email is accepted or rejected by an ISP like Gmail. A poor reputation, built over time through sending unwanted mail, will lead to increasingly frequent rejections, often without specific error codes initially.They note that ISPs rely heavily on historical sending patterns and user engagement to assign reputation scores. If the 'Rejected' errors persist and are not tied to obvious invalid addresses, it's highly likely that your sender reputation (IP or domain) is suffering, signaling a need for comprehensive deliverability remediation.
What the documentation says
Official documentation for Gmail Postmaster Tools clearly states that the Delivery Errors dashboard shows the percentage of all email messages rejected or temporarily failed by Gmail. This tool is designed to give senders an overview of their delivery performance and potential issues with Gmail, though it often requires deeper investigation using other data sources.Documentation also highlights that 'Bad' sender reputation explicitly means a history of sending enormously high volumes of spam, and mail from such entities will almost always be rejected at the SMTP level or marked as spam upon arrival. This underlines the severity of consistently poor sending practices as a cause for rejections.
Key findings
- Delivery errors dashboard: Google's documentation confirms that the Delivery Errors dashboard in Postmaster Tools displays the percentage of emails that Gmail either completely rejected or temporarily deferred. This is the primary place to observe 'Rejected' trends.
- Reputation correlation: A 'Bad' sender reputation indicates a history of sending high volumes of spam, leading to mail being almost certainly rejected at SMTP or marked as spam. This directly links rejections to a severely compromised reputation.
- API error information: The Gmail API returns HTTP error codes and messages in the header, along with a JSON object in the response body for more detailed error information. While Postmaster Tools aggregates, the underlying API provides the specifics. More details can be found in the Gmail API error handling guide.
- Temporary vs. permanent: Documentation implicitly distinguishes between 'rejected' (permanent refusal) and 'temporarily failed' (deferral/TempFail), though both contribute to the overall delivery error percentage shown in the dashboard.
Key considerations
- Understand categories: Familiarize yourself with the various error categories and reputation statuses that Gmail Postmaster Tools reports. A 'Rejected' status can stem from a 'Bad' or 'Low' reputation, indicating severe deliverability issues.
- Align with policies: Ensure your sending practices comply with Gmail's bulk sender guidelines. Violations of these policies can lead to emails being rejected, even if they aren't explicitly spam. Non-compliance often results in automatic blocking.
- Implement authentication: Gmail heavily relies on SPF, DKIM, and DMARC for authentication. Incomplete or incorrect setup of these protocols can cause emails to be rejected by Gmail's servers. Proper authentication boosts trust and deliverability. Consult our guides on DMARC, SPF, and DKIM.
- Monitor spam complaints: While not directly a rejection cause, high spam complaint rates (viewable in Postmaster Tools) significantly degrade sender reputation, which then leads to increased rejections. Actively using Feedback Loops to identify high complaint volumes is advised for senders. Amazon Web Services' blog provides further insight.
Technical article
Google for Developers documentation explains that the Gmail API returns two levels of error information when a message is processed: HTTP error codes and messages in the header, and a JSON object in the response body. This layered approach provides both a general status and specific details about the error encountered.Understanding these granular error messages, which are typically found in your ESP's logs or directly if you integrate with the API, is essential for diagnosing why an email was 'Rejected' by Gmail. The aggregated data in Postmaster Tools is a high-level summary of these underlying API responses.
Technical article
Gmail Postmaster Tools documentation states that the Delivery Errors dashboard shows the percentage of all email messages that were rejected or temporarily failed by Gmail. This dashboard is a key metric for senders to gauge their overall deliverability performance to Gmail inboxes.The documentation implies that a high percentage of rejected messages indicates a significant problem with sender reputation or content, necessitating immediate investigation into sending practices and email authentication protocols like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC.
Related resources
7 resources
Related pages
Why are emails suddenly rejected by Gmail?
What email deliverability metrics to monitor in Google Postmaster Tools?
How to resolve a low Gmail domain reputation?
What causes 4003 and 4004 Gmail soft bounce errors and how to resolve them?
Troubleshooting dips in DKIM success rate in Google Postmaster Tools
Ultimate Guide to Google Postmaster Tools V2
How to Improve Domain Reputation Using Google Postmaster Tools [2025 Guide]
A simple guide to DMARC, SPF, and DKIM
How email blacklists actually work: a simple guide
What happens when your domain is on an email blacklist?
