Summary
Linking to PDF files in emails generally does not cause bounces in itself. However, the *method* of linking, and the nature of the server hosting the PDF, can trigger security filters like Mimecast. Filters may block emails if the linked content is deemed suspicious, hosted on an unverified domain, or if the link's behavior (e.g., redirecting or being unreachable) suggests malicious intent. The generic 554 Email rejected due to security policies error from Mimecast often indicates a broader issue with the link's security posture or the hosting environment, rather than the file type itself. Always ensure your links are stable, reputable, and accessible from various geographical locations.
Key findings
- File type is secondary: PDF file format itself rarely causes bounces. The primary concern for security filters is often the domain hosting the file or the link's characteristics.
- Hosting domain reputation: Links to public storage buckets (e.g., Google Storage) can be flagged if they are commonly associated with spam or malware, or if their security posture is ambiguous.
- Link accessibility: If a link is not reachable from all locations or by security scanners, it can trigger filters. This behavior can mimic malicious content trying to evade detection.
- Generic error codes: Bounce messages like 554 Email rejected due to security policies from Mimecast are often broad and require deeper investigation into the specific link or sender behavior.
- Filter behavior: Email security gateways actively follow and analyze links. If the link's destination or the link itself presents any red flags, the email may be blocked. Understanding why email filters modify links can help.
Key considerations
- Validate hosting: Ensure any third-party links used are from reputable sources. Consider hosting PDFs on your own domain or a trusted content delivery network (CDN) to maintain control over reputation.
- Link structure: Avoid excessively long or complex links that might be perceived as suspicious. Learn more about how multiple or long links affect deliverability.
- Review bounce messages: The full bounce message (MTA rejection) provides the most precise information about why an email was rejected. Consult resources like the Mimecast SMTP Error Codes for specific details.
- Security scanner compatibility: Ensure your linked content is accessible by security scanning gateways from various global IP addresses without restriction.
- Sender reputation: A strong sender reputation can help mitigate some risks associated with link content. Conversely, a poor reputation will amplify them.
What email marketers say
Email marketers often encounter deliverability challenges when linking to external resources, and PDF files are no exception. While the PDF format itself is usually not the direct cause of bounces, the platform where the PDF is hosted and the way the link behaves can significantly influence how security filters, such as Mimecast, react. Marketers highlight that issues often arise from using public cloud storage links, which can be perceived as less secure or untrustworthy by some aggressive filters.
Key opinions
- Link source matters: Many marketers believe the problem isn't the PDF, but rather the type of link being used, especially if it points to generic or public cloud storage domains.
- Perceived risk: Certain hosting solutions might be flagged by security filters due to past misuse or a lack of clear reputation signals, leading to bounces.
- Bounce message is key: Without the specific bounce message, diagnosing the exact cause of rejection (e.g., by Mimecast) is difficult. It usually contains clues.
- Link behavior: Unreachable links or links that behave unexpectedly when scanned can trigger security policies, regardless of the file type. This also relates to how direct download links affect deliverability.
Key considerations
- Host on your domain: Whenever possible, host PDFs and other static content on your own domain or a subdomain. This gives you more control over the link's reputation and trust.
- Test accessibility: Verify that your linked content is accessible from various networks and geographic locations, mirroring how security filters might scan them.
- Monitor deliverability: Regularly check your email deliverability rates and investigate any sudden drops or increased bounce rates. Tools can help determine if third-party links affect deliverability.
- Review security policies: Understand that email security gateways use complex policies. Spambrella notes that outbound email filters protect from data breaches, including those originating from suspicious links.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks suggests that the problem likely isn't the PDF itself, but rather the hosting location of the PDF. The specific issue in their case might be that the links point directly to a Google storage bucket, which can sometimes be viewed with suspicion by certain email security filters.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks states that after further investigation, the root cause seemed to be that some of the links within the email were not reachable from certain geographic locations or by automated scanning systems. This inaccessibility likely triggered Mimecast's security policies, leading to the email being blocked.
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts agree that while PDF links themselves are not inherently problematic, the context and characteristics of the link are paramount. They emphasize that security gateways, including Mimecast, employ sophisticated scanning techniques that go beyond mere file type. Issues arise when links lead to untrustworthy domains, exhibit suspicious behavior (like unreachability), or are part of emails from senders with poor reputations. The goal of these filters is to prevent phishing, malware, and other threats.
Key opinions
- Behavior over content: Experts stress that security filters are less concerned with the PDF format and more with the behavior of the link and its destination. A link that isn't always reachable by scanners, for example, is a red flag.
- Malware mimicry: Blocking content analysis gateways from seeing hostile content while letting recipients see it is a common tactic used by malware, making such link behavior suspicious.
- Generic bounces need investigation: A generic rejection message like Mimecast's '554 Email rejected due to security policies' provides little direct insight, requiring the sender to investigate potential link issues or sender reputation problems.
- Domain reputation is key: The reputation of the domain hosting the PDF is a critical factor for email deliverability. A poor reputation can lead to emails being sent to the spam folder or outright blocked.
- Authentication matters: Proper email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) can help establish trust. Learn about a simple guide to DMARC, SPF, and DKIM.
Key considerations
- Robust hosting: Always host content, especially PDFs, on reliable servers with high uptime and consistent availability for scanning by security filters. This impacts the impact on deliverability of direct PDF download links.
- Proactive monitoring: Utilize tools to monitor your domain and IP reputation regularly. This helps detect if you're on a blocklist or if your sender score is declining.
- Understand filter logic: Familiarize yourself with how corporate filters, like Mimecast, assess links and content. Many corporate filters follow links in emails.
- Detailed logging: Maintain comprehensive logs of bounce messages and delivery failures. This data is crucial for troubleshooting specific rejection reasons.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks notes that it is plausible that the issue originates from the link pointing directly to a Google storage bucket. They emphasize that receiving the full rejection message is crucial for diagnosing the exact problem, as general observations can be misleading.
Expert view
Expert from Spam Resource highlights that email filtering systems are designed to detect evasive tactics. If a link is only accessible to a recipient but not to the scanning gateway (e.g., due to geo-blocking or IP restrictions), it is immediately flagged as suspicious, typical of malware attempting to bypass security. This is regardless of whether it's a PDF or another file type.
What the documentation says
Official documentation from email security providers like Mimecast often details the various policies and heuristics used to filter inbound and outbound email. These documents typically confirm that their systems analyze URLs for a multitude of factors, including the domain's reputation, the link's accessibility, and any suspicious redirection or cloaking. The file type at the end of the link (e.g., PDF) is generally less critical than the security posture of the host and the overall behavior of the URL.
Key findings
- URL scanning depth: Email security gateways perform deep URL scanning, evaluating not just the top-level domain but also the full path, query parameters, and redirection behavior.
- Reputation-based filtering: Domains and IP addresses hosting linked content are assessed against internal and external threat intelligence feeds, including blocklists, to determine trustworthiness.
- Behavioral analysis: Links that display inconsistent availability to different IP addresses, or those that change their destination based on the accessing entity (e.g., scanner vs. user), are highly suspicious.
- Policy enforcement: Email rejections with codes like 554 security policies indicate that the email violated an established security rule, which can relate to links.
- Anti-spoofing and brand protection: Filters are designed to protect users from phishing attempts where malicious links may mimic legitimate ones. This ties into why Mimecast blocks emails with anti-spoofing policies.
Key considerations
- Official guidance: Always refer to the specific documentation provided by your email security gateway (e.g., Mimecast) for detailed explanations of error codes and policy configurations.
- Infrastructure integrity: Ensure your web servers and hosting environments for linked content are secure, consistently available, and not associated with known vulnerabilities or malicious activity.
- Content delivery networks (CDNs): Using reputable CDNs for hosting large files like PDFs can improve both deliverability and user experience by ensuring global accessibility and consistent performance.
- Regular audits: Periodically audit all links embedded in your emails to ensure they are still valid, accessible, and not redirecting to unexpected destinations.
- Compliance standards: Adhere to general email sending best practices and industry compliance standards to maintain a strong sender reputation, which indirectly benefits linked content deliverability.
Technical article
Mimecast documentation on SMTP error codes explains that a 554 Email rejected due to security policies error indicates that the email failed one or more internal security checks. This could be due to a variety of factors including suspicious URLs, content, or sender reputation, requiring the sender to investigate which specific policy was triggered.
Technical article
Spambrella's documentation on outbound email filtering emphasizes that filters perform deep analysis, including URL scanning, to prevent data loss and outbound threats. This process ensures that links, regardless of their file type, are safe before reaching the recipient.
Related resources
3 resources
Related pages
Why do email filters modify or break links?
What is the impact on email deliverability of providing direct PDF download links in emails?
Do PDF attachments negatively impact email deliverability?
Why are emails bouncing with Mimecast anti-spoofing policy?
Which corporate filter appliances or software follow links in emails?
Are spam trigger words, PDF attachments, and links bad?
Why is Mimecast blocking emails containing Calendly links?
How email blacklists actually work: a simple guide
Why your emails are going to spam in 2024?
Email deliverability issues: getting your messages to the inbox
