Suped

What are popular email deliverability testing tools and their features?

Summary

Understanding and utilizing email deliverability testing tools is crucial for ensuring your messages reach the inbox effectively. These tools offer various functionalities, from basic authentication checks to advanced spam filter analysis and inbox placement testing across different mailbox providers. While some tools provide quick, simple scores, others offer in-depth reports requiring careful interpretation. The choice of tool often depends on the specific needs and technical proficiency of the user, whether they are a marketing professional or a seasoned email deliverability expert. The goal is always to diagnose potential issues and optimize email performance for better sender reputation and higher engagement.

What email marketers say

Email marketers often seek practical, actionable insights from deliverability testing tools that directly impact their campaign performance. Their perspectives typically revolve around ease of use, clear reporting, and the ability to quickly identify and resolve issues that might prevent emails from reaching the inbox. For marketers, a tool's value often lies in its ability to streamline testing and provide results that can be easily understood and acted upon, without requiring deep technical knowledge. This helps them focus on campaign strategy and content, confident that their messages have the best chance of being delivered.

Marketer view

Marketer from Email Geeks notes using mail tester frequently as a consultant, appreciating its affordability. It's particularly effective for validating basic authentication and link integrity.Furthermore, it offers valuable spam assassin checks, which are essential for preempting common spam filter issues. The tool's ability to perform these core checks makes it a reliable option for routine email deliverability assessments.

26 Jul 2019 - Email Geeks

Marketer view

Marketer from Email Marketing Blog suggests that while some tools appear confusing, a structured approach to initial testing can simplify the process. They suggest focusing on fundamental steps to generate a first report.The initial focus should be on copying seedlist addresses and sending a regular email, then reviewing the basic report. This helps users become familiar with the tool's interface before diving into advanced features.

18 Aug 2023 - Email Marketing Blog

What the experts say

Email deliverability experts approach testing tools with a critical eye, seeking precision, comprehensive data, and advanced diagnostic capabilities. Their opinions often highlight the nuances of interpreting results, the importance of seedlist diversity, and the strategic value of integrating testing with broader deliverability monitoring efforts. For experts, tools are not just for basic checks, but for uncovering complex issues, identifying patterns, and guiding sophisticated optimization strategies to maintain high sender reputation and consistent inbox placement.

Expert view

Expert from Spam Resource highlights the critical role of maintaining a clean sender IP reputation, noting that even perfectly formatted emails will fail if the IP is tainted. They emphasize the continuous monitoring of blocklists (or blacklists) as a fundamental aspect of deliverability.Proactive reputation management, including consistent testing and swift action on warnings, is more effective than reactive troubleshooting after a block has occurred.

10 Jan 2025 - Spam Resource

Expert view

Expert from Word to the Wise suggests that reliance solely on a single deliverability testing tool can lead to incomplete insights. They advocate for using multiple tools to gain a more comprehensive view of how emails are perceived by different ISPs.Varying tools often have different seedlists and testing methodologies, offering a broader perspective on potential inbox placement challenges and successes across the diverse email ecosystem.

15 Nov 2024 - Word to the Wise

What the documentation says

Technical documentation and research papers provide the foundational principles behind email deliverability, outlining protocols, standards, and the mechanisms used by mailbox providers to filter email. This perspective focuses on the 'how' and 'why' behind email delivery and spam filtering, offering the context necessary to fully understand what deliverability testing tools are measuring. Documentation often covers the specifications for authentication methods, the criteria for spam detection, and recommended best practices from an architectural and compliance standpoint, which helps in building robust email sending systems.

Technical article

Documentation from RFC 7489 (DMARC) outlines the mechanism for domain owners to indicate whether their emails are protected by SPF and/or DKIM, and to specify how receiving mail servers should handle failures. It notes that DMARC enables senders to gain insight into email authentication results and protects against fraudulent use of their domains.This framework is critical for testing tools to verify proper DMARC implementation and ensure compliance for improved deliverability and security.

10 Mar 2015 - RFC 7489

Technical article

Documentation from Microsoft 365 Exchange Online Protection (EOP) specifies that EOP uses multiple anti-spam engines and real-time blocklists (blacklists) to filter inbound email. It details that sender reputation, IP reputation, and content analysis are key factors in determining whether an email is delivered to the inbox, junk folder, or blocked entirely.Testing tools must therefore simulate these multi-layered checks to provide accurate deliverability assessments for emails sent to Microsoft recipients.

05 Sep 2024 - Microsoft Docs

13 resources

Start improving your email deliverability today

Get started