Summary
The external label in Google Workspace (formerly G Suite) emails is a security feature designed to enhance awareness and protect users from potential phishing attempts and Business Email Compromise (BEC) scams. It visually flags email threads and conversations that include recipients outside a user's organizational domain. This helps recipients identify emails that are not internal, prompting them to exercise caution before interacting with the content or sharing sensitive information. While primarily a security measure, its implementation can have subtle implications for email deliverability and how recipients perceive messages.
Key findings
- Security enhancement: The primary purpose of the external label is to boost security by making users aware when an email originates from outside their Google Workspace organization. This is especially crucial for preventing phishing and BEC attacks where attackers impersonate internal contacts. This aligns with Google's efforts to improve email security, as outlined in their official announcement.
- User awareness: The label serves as a visual reminder, encouraging users to apply a higher level of scrutiny to messages from outside their trusted domain. This is a direct response to previous attempts by spammers to copy in-body warning banners.
- Gradual rollout: The feature was rolled out gradually across Google Workspace accounts, explaining why some users noticed it later than others.
- Impact on deliverability: While not directly affecting technical email deliverability (like SPF, DKIM, DMARC validation), it can indirectly influence inbox placement by changing user behavior. Users might be more hesitant to open or interact with emails flagged as external, potentially affecting engagement metrics.
- Administrator control: Google Workspace administrators have the ability to manage or disable this feature within their domain settings, as detailed in Google's support documentation.
Key considerations
- Sender perception: Senders must acknowledge that their emails might be visually marked as external by Google Workspace users. This could lead to a subconscious bias that affects open rates or engagement if recipients are highly security-conscious or have internal policies.
- Mitigating impact: To counteract any potential negative perception, ensure your sender reputation is strong and your emails consistently provide value. Learn more about how external domains can affect sender reputation.
- Internal communication strategy: For organizations, it's essential to educate employees on the purpose of this label and how to differentiate legitimate external communication from potential threats. This also applies to understanding Gmail's 'This message seems dangerous' alerts.
- User experience: Some users find the constant presence of the label distracting, especially when they regularly communicate with external parties. This points to a tension between enhanced security and potential user interface clutter.
What email marketers say
Email marketers have mixed reactions to Google Workspace's external label. While some recognize its security benefits, others express concern about its potential impact on user engagement and the overall recipient experience. The visual prominence of the label raises questions about how it might influence recipient trust and interaction with legitimate external emails, including marketing communications.
Key opinions
- Gradual feature adoption: Marketers noted that the rollout of the external label was not immediate for all users, indicating a phased deployment by Google. This meant the impact was not felt uniformly at first.
- Potential for reduced engagement: A key concern is whether the label might lead to a decrease in open rates or click-through rates, as recipients may be more cautious about interacting with emails explicitly marked as external. This is a common concern when Gmail categorizes emails in a way that impacts visibility.
- User interface impact: Some marketers highlighted that the banner associated with the external label takes up significant screen real estate, especially on smaller displays, which can detract from the email content itself.
- Perceived nuisance: For domains that frequently send legitimate external emails, some users found the persistent external label annoying, as it redundantly flags what is known external communication.
Key considerations
- Monitoring engagement: Marketers should closely monitor their open and click rates for Google Workspace recipients to detect any changes after the external label becomes prominent. This vigilance helps in understanding the real-world impact on their campaigns.
- Content and trust: Focus on building strong sender trust through transparent, valuable content. Even with an external label, a recognizable and reputable sender can maintain engagement. This is critical for preventing emails from going to spam.
- Educating recipients: If sending to an organization you have direct contact with, consider communicating about this label proactively if it's causing confusion or concern among recipients. This applies to notifications in platforms like Office 365 regarding external emails as well.
- Adaptation, not panic: Rather than fearing the label, marketers should adapt their strategies to acknowledge its presence. Focus on strong branding, clear subject lines, and compelling content to ensure messages stand out despite the warning.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks observes that the external label has been rolling out gradually. This implies that not all Google Workspace users received the feature simultaneously, which might explain inconsistencies in user experiences.The marketer suggests this phased deployment is typical for large-scale Google feature updates, allowing for monitoring and adjustments before full release.
Marketer view
A marketer from Email Geeks expressed frustration, noting that the external banner takes up too much space on a laptop screen. They found it particularly annoying when sending legitimate emails to known external recipients, as it leaves very little room for actual message content.This highlights a trade-off between security visibility and user interface efficiency, especially for users who frequently interact with external contacts.
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts largely view Google Workspace's external label as a positive step for email security, particularly in combating sophisticated phishing and Business Email Compromise (BEC) attacks. They acknowledge that while it may cause minor user interface friction, its benefits in improving user awareness of potential threats outweigh these drawbacks. Experts also highlight the evolving landscape of inbox security features and the continued importance of strong email authentication standards like DMARC, SPF, and DKIM.
Key opinions
- Phishing prevention: Experts agree that the label significantly aids in preventing Business Email Compromise (BEC) by visually indicating when an email comes from outside the organizational domain, making it harder for attackers to impersonate internal figures.
- Improved user awareness: The label forces recipients to pause and consider the legitimacy of an email, rather than blindly trusting the sender name, especially if it's a first-time contact from an unassociated domain.
- Resistance to spoofing: Unlike previous in-body warning banners that could be copied by spammers, this native label is integrated into the Gmail interface, making it significantly harder for malicious actors to fake.
- Evolution of security features: This feature is seen as part of a broader trend where email service providers like Google are introducing more sophisticated, native security warnings to protect users from evolving threat landscapes.
Key considerations
- Reinforcing authentication: The presence of the external label underscores the critical importance of robust email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) for legitimate senders to build trust and avoid further negative flagging. A simple guide to DMARC, SPF, and DKIM can help.
- Managing user experience: While beneficial for security, organizations should be mindful of the potential for user fatigue if too many legitimate emails are flagged as external. Similar warnings in Office 365 present similar considerations.
- Monitoring impact on engagement: Deliverability experts advise senders to closely monitor their engagement metrics with Google Workspace recipients to assess any indirect impact on open rates or click-throughs, even if direct deliverability remains unaffected. This requires using tools like Google Postmaster Tools.
- Internal policies: Organizations should establish clear internal policies and provide training for employees on how to interpret the external label and respond appropriately to external communications.
Expert view
Deliverability expert from Email Geeks explains that the external label acts as a visual cue for recipients, indicating that the sender is outside their Google Workspace organization. This is especially relevant when a recipient communicates with a new or previously uncontacted individual.The expert emphasized that this feature is a direct effort to combat Business Email Compromise, preventing scenarios where a user might mistakenly trust an email impersonating an internal CEO from a suspicious external domain like a Hotmail account.
Expert view
An expert from Email Geeks highlighted Google's previous attempts to warn users with in-body banners, which spammers quickly learned to copy. They pointed out that the new external label is significantly harder for spammers to fake because it's integrated into the Gmail interface itself.This shows an evolution in Google's security measures, moving from easily circumvented warnings to more robust, native indicators, which is a positive development for phishing deterrence.
What the documentation says
Official Google documentation and related technical resources confirm that the external label in Google Workspace is a security feature designed to warn users about emails originating from outside their organization. It is presented as a measure to mitigate phishing and Business Email Compromise by increasing recipient vigilance. The documentation also provides guidance for administrators on how to manage this feature, indicating a level of control over its implementation within an organizational domain.
Key findings
- Explicit purpose: Google's official stance is that the external label is intended to provide a visual warning for messages that include external recipients. This is detailed in their Workspace Updates Blog.
- Security objective: The label is a key component in Google's efforts to enhance email security, specifically targeting sophisticated phishing and impersonation attempts, such as those seen in BEC schemes.
- Administrator configurability: Google Workspace administrators have controls to turn these external recipient warnings on or off, allowing organizations to tailor security settings to their specific needs. This functionality is outlined in Google Workspace Admin Help.
- Scope of application: The label applies to email threads or conversations where at least one recipient is from outside the user's Google Workspace organization.
Key considerations
- Complementary to authentication: While the external label provides a visual warning, it works in conjunction with underlying email authentication protocols like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC to establish sender legitimacy. Proper DMARC configuration is especially crucial, as discussed in DMARC policy for G Suite aliases.
- Administrative deployment: Organizations should review their Google Workspace settings to ensure the external label is configured in a way that balances security with the operational needs of their users who regularly communicate externally.
- User training: Documentation suggests that organizations should train their users on how to interpret and respond to the external label effectively, integrating it into broader security awareness programs. This helps prevent issues like Gmail phishing warnings for internal emails.
Technical article
The Google Workspace Updates Blog announced in April 2021 that email threads with external recipients would display an External label and a reply warning banner. The blog states these features serve as helpful reminders for users to approach external messages with appropriate caution.This official statement directly addresses the feature's primary goal: enhancing security by visually distinguishing external communications to prevent misinterpretation or malicious exploitation.
Technical article
Google's Admin Help documentation provides instructions for administrators on how to turn external recipients warnings on or off in Gmail. It explains that as an administrator, one can configure these alerts for messages received from external email addresses and for messages composed to external recipients.This highlights the administrative control available, allowing organizations to decide the level of warning appropriate for their users and security policies.
Related resources
5 resources
.png)
Related pages
What does the gmail 'this message seems dangerous' alert mean for email deliverability?
How do multiple or external domains in an email affect sender reputation and deliverability?
Will a stricter DMARC policy impact internal email deliverability when using g suite aliases and email forwarding?
How to interpret office 365 notifications for emails sent outside the organization?
How to prevent gmail phishing warnings for internal emails with shortened links or shared sender names?
A simple guide to DMARC, SPF, and DKIM
Why your emails are going to spam in 2024 and how to fix it
Ultimate guide to Google postmaster tools v2
How your email address ends up on a blacklist
