Suped

What impact does malformed HTML have on email deliverability and spam filtering?

Summary

Malformed HTML in emails can have a subtle yet impactful effect on email deliverability and how spam filters process your messages. While major mailbox providers prioritize sender reputation over minor formatting quirks, the cumulative effect of poor coding can contribute to messages being flagged as spam or rendering incorrectly. Email code quality is one of many factors influencing whether your email reaches the inbox. Email clients, particularly Outlook, are known to be less forgiving of HTML errors, which can severely impact the recipient's experience.

What email marketers say

Email marketers often find themselves grappling with the balance between creative email design and the technical integrity of HTML. While the focus is usually on engaging content and effective calls to action, the underlying code plays a role in how recipients perceive and interact with an email. Many marketers report that while slight HTML imperfections might not immediately land an email in a spam folder, they can lead to poor rendering, especially in challenging email clients like Outlook. This can degrade the user experience and indirectly impact engagement metrics, which are crucial for deliverability.

Marketer view

Email marketer from Email Geeks indicates that the primary factor in deliverability for malformed HTML is the sender's existing reputation. Larger mailbox providers often overlook minor HTML issues from established good senders. However, certain email clients, like Outlook, may behave differently and display errors.

04 Dec 2020 - Email Geeks

Marketer view

Email marketer from Reddit suggests that while strict HTML validation is ideal, in practice, many emails with minor errors still land in the inbox if the sender has a good reputation. The biggest headache is often how different email clients render the imperfect code.

15 Jan 2023 - Reddit

What the experts say

Experts in email deliverability acknowledge that while content and HTML validation are important, the landscape of spam filtering has evolved significantly. Modern filters are less reliant on simplistic content analysis and more focused on sender reputation and engagement signals. However, this doesn't mean malformed HTML is harmless. It contributes to a complex scoring system, where even minor errors can tilt the balance if other negative signals are present. They emphasize that while direct content-based filtering has decreased, the overall quality and user experience facilitated by proper HTML remain vital for positive recipient interaction, which in turn feeds into deliverability algorithms.

Expert view

Expert from Email Geeks notes that most HTML errors in emails are minor, such as missing alt image tags, unclosed tags, or missing <title> and <!DOCTYPE html>. These issues are generally quick to fix and while their impact might be marginal, they can make a difference.

05 Dec 2020 - Email Geeks

Expert view

Expert from SpamResource.com states that spam scanning should be viewed as a system with many variables, each assigned a positive or negative value. Malformed HTML might be a small negative, but it adds up with other issues like spam complaints or invalid DKIM signatures.

10 Mar 2023 - SpamResource.com

What the documentation says

Official documentation from various email providers and industry standards bodies often provides strict guidelines for HTML best practices, even if they don't explicitly state the deliverability impact of malformed code. These guidelines are primarily aimed at ensuring consistent rendering across diverse email clients and upholding web standards, rather than directly preventing spam. However, adherence to these standards can indirectly support deliverability by improving the user experience and reducing the likelihood of rendering anomalies that might trigger negative user responses or contribute to a lower engagement rate. While specific documentation might not detail spam filter penalties for missing HTML tags, the emphasis on robust and accessible code underpins the foundation of positive email communication.

Technical article

W3C HTML standards documentation emphasizes that all HTML documents should begin with a valid DOCTYPE declaration to ensure proper rendering in standards-compliant browsers and clients. Omitting this can force rendering into quirks mode, leading to inconsistent display.

17 Dec 1999 - W3C HTML 4.01

Technical article

Microsoft's email development guidelines recommend consistent and valid HTML to ensure optimal display in Outlook and other Microsoft mail clients. They highlight that strict adherence to standards reduces rendering issues that can frustrate users.

05 Sep 2022 - Microsoft Learn

5 resources

Start improving your email deliverability today

Get started