Summary
Email addresses containing random numbers before the domain name, such as user@123gmail.com or name@456yahoo.com, are almost always indicators of invalid or fake email accounts. These addresses are not legitimate and sending to them can severely harm your email deliverability and sender reputation. Their presence points to underlying issues in your email acquisition processes, ranging from users intentionally providing false information to automated bots submitting junk data through your forms.
Key findings
- Invalid format: These addresses typically point to non-existent domains or subdomains, making them undeliverable.
- User intent: They often originate from users who wish to access content or a service (like a quote) but prefer not to provide a real email address, so they input easily typed, numeric-laden fakes.
- Automated submissions: Bots and automated scripts frequently generate such addresses when interacting with web forms, indicating a vulnerability in your signup process.
- Data integrity: A high volume of these addresses signals poor data hygiene or issues with the quality of your lead acquisition channels.
Key considerations
- Deliverability impact: Sending to these invalid addresses will result in hard bounces, which ISPs interpret as a sign of poor list management, negatively impacting your sender reputation and increasing the likelihood of legitimate emails landing in the spam folder.
- Source analysis: It is crucial to investigate the lead sources, such as affiliate partners or paid search ads, to identify the root cause of these invalid submissions and address it upstream.
- Prevention over correction: Do not attempt to correct these addresses by removing the numbers, as they are fundamentally invalid and likely tied to an intent to provide fake data.
- Validation tools: Implement real-time email validation at the point of entry on your forms to prevent these addresses from ever entering your list.
- Spam filter evasion: Understanding how to avoid email spam filters involves proactive list hygiene to ensure your emails reach the inbox.
What email marketers say
Email marketers frequently encounter email addresses with numerical prefixes before major domains like Gmail or Yahoo. Their experiences often highlight common sources of these addresses and practical strategies for mitigation, often stemming from user behavior or lead generation practices. The consensus is that while these might not be classic spam traps, they represent poor data quality that impacts overall campaign performance.
Key opinions
- User-generated fakes: Many marketers believe these are fake addresses provided by users who want to access content but avoid further communication. The numbers are often chosen because they are easy to type near the @ symbol.
- Lead generation issues: Some suspect problems with lead generation partners, where incentivized users or even fraudulent actors might submit invalid data to meet quotas.
- Bot activity: A common perspective is that these addresses are generated by bots programmatically filling out subscription or signup forms, emphasizing the need for form security.
- No simple fix: Marketers generally agree that attempts to clean these by simply removing the numbers are ineffective and carry significant risks to sender reputation.
Key considerations
- Offer value upfront: Provide some immediate value (e.g., a partial quote or preview) before asking for a complete email address to incentivize users to provide real data.
- Confirmation email transparency: Clearly state that a confirmation email will be sent during the signup process to deter fake submissions, as people are less likely to provide a fake email if they know it needs to be confirmed.
- Real-time validation: Employ real-time email validation at the point of entry on your forms to filter out obvious fakes and malformed addresses immediately.
- Review lead quality: Critically assess the quality of traffic from paid partners or campaigns if a high volume of incorrect email addresses is observed, as this can indicate fraudulent activity.
- Customer intent: When dealing with services that offer one-time immediate needs, understand that customers are more inclined to provide disposable or fake email addresses.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks suggests that fake email addresses with numbers before the domain are often created by real users. They explain that people tend not to stray too far from what they know when making up addresses, and the numbers are conveniently located near the @ symbol on the keyboard. This behavior, while seemingly problematic, can actually be a kindness, as it makes these fake addresses easier to identify and suppress. They further suggest implementing system logic to immediately stop sending to such domains once a single bounce occurs, to minimize continued attempts to invalid addresses.
Marketer view
Email marketer from WPShout advises on common reasons emails are flagged as spam, emphasizing the need to identify and fix issues that lead to poor deliverability. This includes sending to invalid addresses and maintaining a clean email list to ensure messages reach the intended recipients. They stress that recognizing patterns in bounces and recipient engagement is crucial for improving inbox placement rates.
What the experts say
Deliverability experts highlight that email addresses containing random numbers before the domain (e.g., user@123gmail.com) are strong indicators of poor list hygiene and potential risks to sender reputation. They emphasize that while not always traditional spam traps, these addresses warrant immediate attention due to their negative impact on inbox placement.
Key opinions
- Scraping indicators: These addresses can be a result of automated scraping of websites, where email addresses might be malformed or augmented with numbers during the collection process.
- Not typical spam traps: While undesirable, experts generally agree these are not classic spam traps, which are designed to be hidden. However, some spamtrap networks do acquire and register domains based on common fake address patterns.
- Bot submissions: A significant portion often comes from bots programmatically filling out forms, creating non-existent or clearly invalid email addresses.
- Data import errors: Less frequently, they can be a sign of corrupted data during spreadsheet imports or database migrations.
Key considerations
- List abandonment: For heavily infected lists, experts often advise scrapping or significantly pruning the data rather than attempting to clean it incrementally, as the damage to sender reputation can be severe.
- Automated suppression: Implement automated suppression rules to immediately stop sending to domains that exhibit patterns of invalidity (e.g., first hard bounce on such a domain triggers permanent suppression).
- Form security: Enhance web form security and use tools like CAPTCHAs to prevent bot submissions, thereby reducing the inflow of these addresses and mitigating reasons why emails go to spam.
- Double opt-in: Employ confirmed opt-in (double opt-in) to verify the legitimacy of new sign-ups. While it might slightly reduce initial conversion rates, it drastically improves list quality.
Expert view
Deliverability expert from Email Geeks suggests that sloppy scraping of addresses from websites is a primary cause for seeing email addresses with random numbers. They also consider bad database imports from spreadsheets as a possibility. These types of addresses are generally not obvious spam traps, indicating instead a fundamental issue with data acquisition. If lead sources consistently produce such data, they advise scrapping the entire problematic list, as extensive cleaning efforts may not effectively resolve the underlying issues.
Expert view
Deliverability expert from SpamResource.com advises that maintaining a clean list is paramount to deliverability. They assert that sending to addresses with suspicious numerical patterns will inevitably lead to reputation damage, as internet service providers (ISPs) view high bounce rates as a negative signal. This practice can result in legitimate emails being flagged as spam or even outright blocklisted.
What the documentation says
Official documentation and industry guidelines provide frameworks for preventing unwanted email and maintaining list quality. These sources underscore the importance of accurate data collection, explicit consent, and adherence to regulations to minimize the impact of invalid or suspicious email addresses on email programs and sender reputation.
Key findings
- CAN-SPAM compliance: The CAN-SPAM Act sets requirements for commercial email, emphasizing accurate header information and the recipient's right to opt out. Sending to invalid addresses complicates compliance and can lead to issues.
- Recipient rights: Regulatory bodies stress the importance of respecting recipient choices and ensuring that all email addresses on a list are valid and have provided consent for communication.
- Data accuracy: Guidelines often implicitly or explicitly recommend maintaining high data accuracy to ensure effective communication, avoid wasted resources, and prevent deliverability problems.
- Anti-spam measures: Documentation from ISPs and email providers outlines measures to identify and filter spam, including patterns associated with low-quality or fake email addresses, which can lead to emails being sent to the spam folder.
Key considerations
- Valid consent: Ensure all collected email addresses have explicit, verifiable consent, which is impossible with non-existent or fake addresses like those with random numbers.
- Form best practices: Follow recommended best practices for web forms to prevent bot submissions and encourage users to provide legitimate contact information during signup.
- Bounce management: Implement robust bounce management systems to promptly remove invalid addresses from your lists, protecting your sender reputation and improving overall email deliverability.
- Compliance with regulations: Adhere to anti-spam laws and regulations, as sending to invalid addresses can indicate non-compliance if not properly managed, potentially leading to legal repercussions or being blocklisted.
Technical article
Official documentation from the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) states that the CAN-SPAM Act requires commercial emails to include accurate header information and a valid physical postal address. This regulation underscores the importance of having legitimate recipient data, as invalid addresses complicate compliance and undermine the purpose of such laws. It also highlights the need for clear opt-out mechanisms.
Technical article
A guide from Mailjet emphasizes that emails can be flagged as spam due to various factors, including high bounce rates resulting from sending to invalid addresses. This highlights the critical importance of regular list hygiene and validation practices to ensure that email campaigns maintain optimal deliverability and avoid reputation damage. They suggest continuous monitoring of email list health.
Related resources
11 resources
Related pages
How to identify and prevent fake or generated email addresses?
How to identify and handle suspicious email addresses like @123gmail.com?
Spam traps: what they are and how they work
Why am I receiving bounce messages for emails I didn't send from my domain?
Why your emails are going to spam in 2024 and how to fix it
How to run an email deliverability test: a proven checklist
What are the different types of spam traps and how do they work?
Will using a randomly generated customer ID in the visible FROM address domain cause deliverability issues or negative subscriber reactions?
Why are orders being placed with @dummy.email addresses?
Email Deliverability Issues: Getting Your Messages to the Inbox in 2025
