Summary
Identifying and preventing suspicious or bot-generated email addresses is crucial for maintaining a healthy email list and strong sender reputation. These unwanted entries can lead to decreased deliverability, higher bounce rates, and potential listing on email blocklists (also known as blacklists). It is essential to implement robust protective measures at the point of data collection and regularly clean your existing lists.
Key findings
- Gibberish usernames: Email addresses with random strings of characters, often combined with legitimate-looking corporate domains, are strong indicators of bot activity or privacy features masking the real address.
- Click tracking anomalies: Suspicious clicks from these addresses, especially if they are not legitimate sign-ups in your database, suggest automated link following by corporate security systems or bots.
- List bombing: Bots may attempt to flood your subscription forms with fake addresses as a form of attack or to test vulnerabilities.
- Privacy features: Some addresses with gibberish usernames, particularly at corporate domains, might be a result of privacy features (like Apple's 'Hide My Email') or other encoding to prevent leaking the user's actual address.
Key considerations
- Implement strong form protection: Use CAPTCHAs, honeypot fields, and fraud detection services on your signup forms to deter bot submissions. Learn more about how to protect email list signup forms from bots.
- Utilize double opt-in: Always use a confirmed opt-in (COI) process. This ensures that only legitimate subscribers who confirm their email address are added to your list, mitigating the impact of list bombing.
- Monitor email engagement: Keep an eye on unusual click patterns or complaint rates, which can signal bot activity or list poisoning.
- Regular list cleaning: Periodically clean your email lists to remove inactive, invalid, or suspicious addresses to maintain good email list hygiene. A comprehensive guide to email list cleaning can provide further insights.
What email marketers say
Email marketers frequently encounter suspicious email addresses that can compromise their sender reputation and campaign performance. Many observe gibberish email prefixes combined with legitimate domains, suspecting bot activity or advanced privacy features. While confirmed opt-in (COI) is a primary defense, it may not completely stop malicious sign-ups or bot-generated clicks on tracking links. Marketers often resort to technical checks and external services to identify and mitigate these issues.
Key opinions
- Bot-generated content: Many marketers believe that gibberish email addresses are 100% bot-related, even when associated with corporate-looking domains.
- Beyond sign-ups: Suspicious activity isn't limited to sign-ups; bot-generated clicks on email links, often from corporate security systems or botnets, are also a significant concern.
- COI limitations: While COI is essential for validating subscribers, it may not prevent the initial influx of bot-generated addresses or bot clicks on confirmation links.
- Privacy features: Some addresses could be privacy-enabled email aliases rather than outright bots, though discerning the difference can be challenging without further investigation.
Key considerations
- Monitor FBLs and complaints: Complaint feedback loops (FBLs) can alert you to issues, even when using COI, indicating that something unusual is happening with your list.
- IP address analysis: Investigating the IP addresses from which suspicious sign-ups or clicks originate can help identify patterns, such as TOR outputs, known VPNs, or botnets. This can help identify and filter bot email addresses.
- Implement CAPTCHA: Adding CAPTCHA to all signup forms is a standard recommendation to prevent automated submissions. While not a magic bullet, it significantly reduces bot traffic.
- Email validation services: Utilize email validation services to detect and remove fake or harmful email addresses from your list, as highlighted by CHEQ's recommendations for fighting spam sign-ups.
Marketer view
Email Geeks Marketer from Email Geeks suggests that marketers should look at the connecting IP address for suspicious sign-ups or clicks to identify patterns, such as whether they originate from TOR outputs, known VPNs, or share the same IP addresses. This analysis can reveal if the activity is truly bot-driven or an attempt to poison the email list. They also suggest implementing CAPTCHA on signup forms as a preventative measure.
Marketer view
Email Geeks Marketer from Email Geeks notes that suspicious email addresses are often bot-generated. These entries are characterized by gibberish usernames and legitimate-looking corporate domains. The marketer emphasizes the importance of using confirmed opt-in (COI) processes to filter out these unwanted addresses, even if it doesn't prevent their initial attempt to sign up.
What the experts say
Experts in email deliverability emphasize that suspicious email addresses, particularly those with randomized user portions at corporate domains, are rarely hide my email features. Instead, they are more likely indicators of sophisticated bot activity or attempts at list poisoning. They highlight the importance of not mailing to such addresses without confirmed opt-in, as well as analyzing the source of these addresses and implementing advanced form protection measures.
Key opinions
- Likely bot activity: Experts generally agree that random character strings in email usernames, especially at corporate domains, are almost certainly bot-generated or part of a list poisoning attempt.
- Privacy feature rarity: It is considered highly unlikely for hide my email features to be used with corporate domains.
- Threat of mail bombing: Bots may be trying to exploit web forms to initiate mail bombing attacks on email addresses.
- Beyond sign-ups: Suspicious activity isn't confined to sign-ups. Bot clicks on tracking links, potentially from corporate security systems or email filtering services, can also generate unusual email addresses in click data.
Key considerations
- Don't mail without COI: As a minimum, avoid sending emails to addresses that appear suspicious without a confirmed opt-in process.
- Analyze source IPs: Routinely examine the connecting IP addresses of sign-ups. Look for traffic from known VPNs, TOR exit nodes, or consistent patterns across different IPs, which can indicate botnets or other malicious sources. This is key to identifying and preventing spambot traffic.
- Deploy CAPTCHA or fraud detection: Implement effective CAPTCHA solutions or fraud detection services on your signup forms to block suspicious or bad traffic at the entry point. This helps in preventing fake email registrations and list bombing.
- Consider advanced header analysis: For form submissions, examine headers like X-Originating-IP which Microsoft has previously used for identification. While the Form-Sub header proposal was intended for this purpose, its adoption isn't widespread, so rely on direct IP analysis.
Expert view
Expert from SpamResource highlights that bots can exploit weak web forms to initiate mail bombs. This type of attack aims to flood a target's inbox with subscription confirmation requests, often using forged email addresses. Preventing such attacks requires robust form security, including advanced bot detection and validation methods to ensure that signup attempts are legitimate. It's crucial to protect forms to avoid being an unwitting participant in a denial-of-service attack on a recipient's inbox.
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise notes that unexpected clicks on email links, particularly those attributed to unusual or random-looking email addresses, often stem from corporate security scanning systems. These systems automatically click links to detect malware or phishing attempts before the email reaches the user. While a protective measure, this can complicate email campaign analytics and potentially flag legitimate campaigns as suspicious if not properly accounted for.
What the documentation says
Technical documentation and research shed light on the mechanisms behind suspicious email addresses and bot activity. These sources often detail how bots are designed to interact with web forms, click tracking links, and methods for mitigating such automated traffic. Understanding these technical underpinnings is vital for developing effective defense strategies, from implementing advanced CAPTCHAs to analyzing mail headers and IP characteristics.
Key findings
- Bot behavior patterns: Bots commonly engage in automated form submissions and link clicking, often from rotating IP addresses or botnets, designed to appear as legitimate user activity. Some are even designed to explore and prevent links to malware.
- List bombing mechanism: List bombing attacks flood accounts with subscription requests, exploiting web forms to generate large volumes of unwanted emails, as described by Klaviyo's support documentation on understanding list bombing.
- Header analysis: Headers like X-Originating-IP can provide insights into the source of form submissions, though their reliability varies.
- Email validation techniques: Email hygiene services use various methods to identify and remove harmful, active, and deliverable email addresses that may be hiding in your data.
Key considerations
- Implement double opt-in and CAPTCHA: Technical documentation consistently recommends these as foundational layers of defense against bots and fraudulent sign-ups. OOPSpam emphasizes these methods.
- Advanced fraud detection: Beyond basic CAPTCHAs, services offering comprehensive fraud detection can analyze user behavior, IP reputation, and device fingerprints to block or redirect suspicious interactions before they impact your lists.
- Utilize email validation services: Integrate third-party email validation APIs at the point of entry (forms) and periodically run full list validation to identify and remove invalid, risky, or bot-generated email addresses. This process is key to accurately verifying your email list.
- Regular database review: Periodically search your database for patterns like gibberish usernames coupled with corporate domains, even if they show legitimate character counts, to flag potential privacy-masked or suspicious entries.
Technical article
Technical documentation from Klaviyo Help Center clarifies that list bombing attacks flood a user's account with numerous fake profiles and email addresses. The primary goal is to overwhelm the target's inbox, causing disruption and making it difficult for them to identify legitimate emails. Marketers need to understand these attacks to protect their email lists by removing fake profiles and preventing future infiltrations.
Technical article
RFC documentation for the Form-Sub header (draft-levine-mailbomb-header-02) proposes a message header designed to identify mail sent in response to web forms. The purpose of this header is to allow recipient mail systems to better recognize and mitigate mail floods resulting from malicious bulk form submissions using forged addresses. While a proposed standard, its widespread adoption remains limited.
Related resources
7 resources
Related pages
How to prevent bot sign-ups and suspicious contacts on email lists?
How to identify and remove bot-generated spam email addresses from contact lists and prevent future bot sign-ups?
What are strategies for email list validation, preventing bad signups, and handling malformed or temporary email addresses?
How can I identify and handle suspicious bot clicks in email marketing campaigns?
How to Identify Email Spam Traps?
Spam traps: what they are and how they work
What are the different types of spam traps and how do they work?
Why Your Emails Are Going to Spam in 2024 and How to Fix It
Email Deliverability Issues: Getting Your Messages to the Inbox in 2025
