Summary
When transitioning to a new email service provider (ESP) and moving to a new dedicated IP address, it is common to experience a drop in domain reputation. This occurs primarily because a new IP address starts with a neutral, or unknown, sending history. Internet service providers (ISPs) rely heavily on historical data to assess sender trustworthiness. While your domain carries some established reputation, the new IP address has no prior engagement signals, leading to a period of re-evaluation. This re-evaluation often manifests as reduced inbox placement and lower open rates, even if your content and list quality remain consistent. This process, known as IP warming, is a necessary step to build a positive sending reputation for the new IP.
Key findings
- New IP reputation: A new dedicated IP address starts with no inherent reputation. ISPs will treat it with caution until sufficient positive sending history is established, which can lead to initial deliverability challenges.
- Domain vs. IP reputation: While your domain reputation is carried over, the new IP's lack of history can temporarily overshadow it, causing filters to be more stringent. The IP's reputation directly influences the domain's perceived trustworthiness during the warming phase.
- ISP machine learning: ISPs employ sophisticated machine learning algorithms that are sensitive to changes in sending patterns and infrastructure. A sudden switch to a new IP triggers a re-evaluation process, which can lead to temporary reputation fluctuations.
- Prefetching behavior: For new or unestablished IPs, mail clients like Gmail might not prefetch emails as readily. This can lead to artificially lower open rates, as users might not see the email preview in their inbox, even if it's not landing in spam.
- Warmup is crucial: A structured IP warming plan is essential to gradually build a positive reputation with ISPs, demonstrating consistent sending behavior and positive engagement.
Key considerations
- Slow and steady: Rushing the IP warming process can be detrimental, as it can trigger spam filters due to an uncharacteristically high volume from a new IP. Gradual volume increases are key.
- Engaged segments first: Start warming by sending to your most engaged subscribers who are highly likely to open and click. This sends strong positive signals to ISPs.
- Consistency is vital: Maintain consistent sending volumes and frequencies during the warmup period. Erratic sending can confuse ISP filters.
- Monitor actively: Continuously monitor your deliverability metrics, including open rates, spam complaint rates, and bounce rates. Adjust your sending strategy based on these indicators. Checking email reputation guides can provide valuable insights.
- Transfer suppression lists: Ensure all unsubscribes and hard bounces from your previous ESP are transferred and suppressed in your new system to avoid sending to problematic addresses.
What email marketers say
Email marketers often face unexpected challenges when migrating to a new ESP and initiating sending from a new dedicated IP. Despite maintaining consistent campaign content, audience, and list hygiene, they frequently observe a significant drop in metrics like open rates and an increase in perceived spam placement. This can be particularly frustrating given the effort put into existing domain reputation. Many marketers report feeling 'stuck' or confused by the sudden change, highlighting the counter-intuitive nature of email reputation during transition periods, where established practices might not yield expected results on a fresh IP.
Key opinions
- Initial confusion: Many marketers are surprised by the dramatic drop in reputation, even when everything else remains unchanged, leading to a sense of frustration and confusion.
- Warmup is critical: Marketers recognize that IP warmup is a necessary evil, often describing it as a painful process with unpredictable ups and downs. The initial reputation drop is viewed as a normal, albeit unwelcome, part of this process.
- Impact on open rates: A common observation is halved open rates, leading to concerns that emails are being marked as spam, even if direct spam complaint rates remain low.
- DNS settings and list hygiene: Marketers emphasize the importance of correctly configured DNS settings and sending to the most active segments of their list during warmup.
- Patience is key: Despite the challenges, marketers advise patience, acknowledging that building a new IP reputation takes time and sustained effort.
Key considerations
- Follow ESP guidance: Adhering strictly to the new ESP's IP warmup plan is often recommended, as they have experience navigating these transitions.
- Segment by engagement: Start sending to the most engaged subscribers (those who consistently open emails) and gradually expand to less active segments.
- Parallel sending: Splitting traffic between the old and new ESPs initially can help manage the transition, gradually shifting volume to the new dedicated IP.
- Leverage welcome series: Incorporating highly engaging welcome series emails for new sign-ups into the warmup strategy can provide consistent positive engagement signals.
- Be patient: Understand that IP warming is a long-term process, and significant improvements may take several weeks, not just a few days. You can find more details about email warm-up strategies.
Marketer view
A marketer from Email Geeks explains they are experiencing severe reputation drops when moving to a new ESP and a dedicated IP, despite sending identical campaigns to the same engaged users. They note that open rates have halved within a week, strongly suggesting emails are being filtered to spam even though spam complaint rates remain low. This scenario is particularly confusing given prior good domain reputation.They find it strange that the reputation is decreasing and are questioning the effectiveness of their current IP warmup strategy, which involves sending to previously opened contacts. The marketer is following their ESP's plan but feels that something is fundamentally amiss with the observed reputation decline.
Marketer view
An email marketer from EngageBay advises that maintaining a healthy domain reputation is crucial, but it's important to understand that IP reputation also plays a significant role. When switching ESPs, even if the domain has a strong history, the new IP needs to build its own credibility from scratch. They suggest that consistent engagement and proper authentication are key to this rebuilding process.They highlight that positive interactions, such as opens and clicks, significantly contribute to the new IP's score, helping it overcome the initial skepticism from ISPs. Conversely, low engagement or spam complaints on the new IP can severely hinder its progress, impacting overall deliverability.
What the experts say
Deliverability experts consistently highlight that a drop in domain reputation during an ESP migration, especially to a new dedicated IP, is a normal and expected part of the IP warming process. They clarify that this isn't necessarily a sign of a fundamental problem, but rather the natural consequence of ISPs treating a new IP address with initial skepticism due to its lack of historical sending data. Experts emphasize that while the domain reputation provides a baseline of trust, the IP must build its own credibility through consistent, positive sending behavior. The challenges faced during this period are largely attributable to how machine learning filters react to changes in sending infrastructure, which they inherently distrust until new patterns are established.
Key opinions
- Normal warmup behavior: The reputation drop is not anomalous, but rather a typical phase in the IP warming process, where a new IP begins with no established trust.
- Machine learning's role: ISP machine learning filters are highly sensitive to infrastructure changes and will react to a new IP address by initially treating it with more scrutiny, causing reputation to fluctuate.
- IP affects domain: Although domain reputation is persistent, the new IP's unknown status can temporarily depress the domain's perceived reputation as ISPs evaluate the new sending source.
- Prefetching impact on opens: Lower open rates might not always indicate spam filtering. For new IPs, emails might not be prefetched by clients like Gmail, leading to fewer perceived opens even if mail reaches the inbox.
- Limited value of short-term reputation metrics: Some experts caution against over-interpreting short-term reputation shifts, particularly on platforms like Google Postmaster Tools. They suggest these tools are more useful for long-term trending rather than daily fluctuations during warmup.
Key considerations
- Prioritize active users: During warmup, focus sending to the most engaged subscribers. This helps generate positive engagement signals, which are crucial for building IP trust.
- Monitor inbox placement: While open rates might fluctuate, the primary goal is consistent inbox placement. Experts advise focusing on whether mail is actually hitting the inbox, even if other metrics seem down initially.
- Patience and persistence: Warmup is an iterative process. It's often described as painful and full of ups and downs, requiring sustained effort over several weeks or even months. Learn how to maintain dedicated IP reputation.
- Transfer suppression lists: Ensure that all unsubscribes and hard bounces from your previous ESP are migrated to the new platform to avoid sending to problematic addresses that can harm your new IP's reputation.
- Understand ISP policies: Familiarize yourself with how ISPs assess email reputation, as their unique algorithms can cause different impacts during warming.
Expert view
A deliverability expert from Email Geeks explains that the reputation drop during warmup is not strange, but rather a normal part of the process. They state that a new IP starts with no reputation, which naturally leads to initial deliverability challenges as ISPs evaluate its trustworthiness. This period is characterized by the IP building its history from zero.They emphasize that machine learning filters, which are fundamental to ISP anti-spam systems, are inherently averse to change. Introducing a new IP represents a significant change, causing these filters to react cautiously and leading to temporary fluctuations in reputation until new, consistent sending patterns are established.
Expert view
An expert from Word to the Wise suggests that a gradual IP warming schedule is paramount. They explain that sudden spikes in volume from a new IP are red flags for ISPs, which can lead to immediate blacklisting (or blocklisting) or severe throttling. Building a consistent sending pattern is more important than achieving high volume quickly.They also advise monitoring feedback loops and bounce rates meticulously. High rates of either indicate underlying list quality issues or aggressive sending, which can rapidly damage a nascent IP's reputation before it has a chance to establish trust.
What the documentation says
Official documentation from major mailbox providers and industry best practices guides consistently emphasize that a new IP address carries a neutral reputation at its inception. This means it lacks the positive or negative history necessary for ISPs to fully trust it, regardless of the associated domain's existing reputation. The initial cautious filtering is a protective measure against potential spam. Documentation stresses that senders must systematically build a positive history for the new IP through a disciplined warming process, which involves gradually increasing sending volume to highly engaged recipients while meticulously monitoring performance metrics. Compliance with email authentication standards (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) is also highlighted as foundational for any new sending infrastructure.
Key findings
- Neutral starting point: New IPs begin with no established reputation, requiring senders to build trust from scratch through consistent, positive sending behavior.
- Engagement-driven reputation: Positive user engagement (opens, clicks, replies) is the primary driver for building a good reputation on a new IP. Conversely, negative engagement (spam complaints, unsubscribes) can quickly damage it.
- Authentication is foundational: Proper configuration of SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records is critical for a new IP. Without strong authentication, even legitimate mail may be treated with suspicion, and the domain reputation can be impacted. Check your email deliverability for setup issues.
- Gradual volume increase: Documentation recommends a gradual increase in sending volume to allow ISPs to assess the new IP's behavior and avoid triggering spam thresholds.
- Monitoring deliverability metrics: Mailbox providers often provide tools (like Google Postmaster Tools) to monitor IP and domain reputation, which are essential for tracking progress during warmup. Consider a blocklist monitoring tool as well.
Key considerations
- Validate all DNS records: Ensure SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records are correctly set up and aligned for the new sending domain and IP before initiating sending. Any misconfiguration can severely impact deliverability.
- Segment your audience strategically: Begin warming by sending to your most engaged and active subscribers. These users are more likely to open and click, providing positive signals to ISPs.
- Adhere to sending limits: Follow recommended daily sending limits and gradual increases for the new IP. Over-sending too quickly is a common cause of reputation damage during warmup.
- Monitor feedback loops and bounces: Enroll in ISP feedback loops to receive complaints and promptly remove affected users. High bounce rates indicate poor list hygiene and should be addressed immediately.
- Be consistent and patient: Building a new IP's reputation is a marathon, not a sprint. Consistency in sending practices and patience are crucial for long-term deliverability success. Refer to AWS SES documentation on IP and domain warming for detailed guidance.
Technical article
Amazon SES documentation states that IP and domain warming is a crucial process for any new sender. It outlines that a new IP address starts with a neutral reputation, meaning Internet Service Providers (ISPs) have no historical data to evaluate its trustworthiness. This necessitates a gradual increase in sending volume to build a positive sending history with each recipient domain.The documentation emphasizes that this process helps establish a good relationship with ISPs, ensuring that legitimate emails are delivered to the inbox rather than being filtered as spam. Adherence to a structured warming schedule and monitoring key metrics are highlighted as essential for success.
Technical article
Google Postmaster Tools documentation indicates that IP reputation is a measure of the trustworthiness of mail coming from an IP address. It explains that new IPs have an 'unknown' reputation, and this can change to 'low' or 'bad' if poor sending practices (like high spam rates or frequent blacklisting) are detected early on. A new IP needs time and consistent good behavior to move towards 'medium' or 'high' reputation.The documentation suggests that monitoring IP reputation within Postmaster Tools is vital during a migration or warming period to identify and address any issues promptly. It also implies that sudden increases in volume from an unestablished IP are viewed negatively.
Related resources
6 resources
Related pages
What are common email deliverability issues during new IP and subdomain warmup after ESP migration?
How does email reputation transfer during IP warming with a new ESP, and how to resolve deliverability issues?
What causes emails to go to spam when migrating to a new ESP and warming an IP?
Why are emails from new dedicated IPs and domains landing in spam?
How to diagnose email deliverability drops after migrating to a new ESP?
How to maintain dedicated IP reputation with ISPs for email sending?
A practical guide to understanding your email domain reputation
Why your emails are going to spam in 2024 and how to fix it
Google Postmaster Tools Domain Reputation: The Ultimate Guide for Email Marketers
How does existing domain reputation impact new dedicated IP warming?
