Summary
Changing your domain name for email marketing is a significant undertaking that extends beyond simply updating your website address. It directly impacts your sender reputation and email deliverability. While it might seem like a straightforward rebrand, the technical intricacies and the need to manage recipient perception are crucial for maintaining email program effectiveness. A strategic approach is vital to minimize disruption and ensure your messages continue to reach the inbox.
Key findings
- Reduced Capacity: New domains often experience significantly reduced sending volume capacity from most mailbox providers for at least the first six months after purchase.
- Domain Warming: A warming process, similar to IP warming, is essential for a new domain. This involves sending to highly engaged users in small, gradually increasing batches.
- Subscriber Notification: Proactively informing your subscribers about the domain change is critical to prevent confusion and minimize spam complaints. As noted by an expert from Inbox Collective, this is a crucial first step.
- Gradual Transition: Running both the old and new domains concurrently and slowly shifting volume from one to the other helps maintain existing reach and operations.
- IP Consistency: If you can maintain the same dedicated IP address, many deliverability issues associated with a domain switch can be mitigated, as the IP often carries more weight for reputation.
Key considerations
- Domain Age: Be aware of the inherent mistrust mailbox providers have for new domains and plan for a period of restricted sending.
- Warming Strategy: Develop a meticulous domain warm-up strategy that prioritizes engagement and slowly scales volume.
- Authentication Setup: Ensure all email authentication protocols, including SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, are correctly configured for the new domain before sending.
- DNS Management: Properly update DNS records to point to your new sending infrastructure. This includes MX records and any custom DNS entries.
- SEO Implications: While an email deliverability concern, remember that a domain change also has significant SEO implications that need separate management.
What email marketers say
Email marketers often emphasize the practical, audience-facing aspects of a domain change. Their focus is typically on minimizing disruption to campaigns and preserving engagement by managing recipient expectations and behavior. They also discuss strategic operational shifts to accommodate the new domain without a sudden drop in performance.
Key opinions
- Dual Operation: It's generally recommended to run both the old and new domains simultaneously for a period, slowly migrating email volume to the new one.
- Pre-notification: Inform your audience about the domain change in advance to avoid surprising them, which can lead to increased spam complaints. As Foster Web Marketing suggests, communicating early is key.
- Engagement First: When beginning to send from the new domain, target your most engaged users first in small volumes to build a positive reputation.
- Add to Contacts: Encourage recipients to add the new email address to their contact list to ensure continuity of delivery.
- Minimizing Impact: The goal is to transition smoothly without negatively impacting existing reach, daily email volumes, or fundraising efforts.
Key considerations
- Recipient Awareness: Prioritize clear and consistent communication with your audience about the impending domain change to prevent confusion and reduce the likelihood of spam complaints.
- Phased Rollout: Implement a phased rollout of your new domain, allowing time for both your systems and your audience to adapt.
- Initial Volume: Start with very small volumes to your most active subscribers when warming the new domain, as detailed in our guide on warming a new domain for 6k contacts.
- Monitoring: Closely monitor deliverability metrics and feedback loops for the new domain to quickly address any issues.
- Internal Use: Consider whether internal staff should also immediately switch to the new domain for daily email, weighing the low volume against the age factor.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks suggests that running both domains in email at the same time and slowly moving volume from the old to the new over time is a good strategy to avoid impacting existing reach and daily operations.
Marketer view
Marketer from Inbox Collective emphasizes that notifying your subscribers is a crucial first step when considering a domain change, ensuring they are aware of the upcoming shift.
What the experts say
Deliverability experts provide deeper insights into the technical implications and mailbox provider behavior when a domain name changes. They stress the importance of domain age, warming protocols, and the often-overlooked role of the IP address in maintaining sender reputation during such a transition.
Key opinions
- Domain Age: New domains are typically treated with suspicion and have significantly reduced sending capacity for up to six months.
- Rest Period: A new domain should ideally be 'rested' for at least 30 days before being used for email sending to build initial trust.
- IP Importance: The IP address is often more critical for deliverability reputation than the domain name. Keeping the same IP can significantly ease a domain transition.
- Domain Warming: While similar to IP warming, domain warming is essential for new domains, focusing on building positive engagement from the outset.
- SEO vs. Email: Experts highlight that SEO challenges related to a new domain are often much greater than the email deliverability concerns, especially if the IP remains constant.
Key considerations
- Initial Distrust: Understand that new domains begin with a neutral or slightly negative reputation and must earn trust over time with mailbox providers.
- Strategic Delay: Consider a 'rest period' for your new domain, as suggested by experts, to allow it to age naturally before high-volume email use.
- IP Strategy: Assess whether your IP address will change. If it remains the same, your domain warming process may be less arduous. If you're moving to a new IP, then a full IP warm-up is necessary, as discussed in migrating email sending domains.
- Reputation Management: Actively manage and monitor your new domain's sender reputation through consistent, high-quality sending to engaged audiences.
- Monitor Postmaster Tools: Leverage tools like Google Postmaster Tools for your new domain to gain insights into deliverability and reputation.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks notes that any new domain is likely to have its volume capacity significantly reduced at most mailbox providers until it is at least six months old.
Expert view
Expert from SpamResource explains that maintaining good email sender reputation involves consistent positive sending behavior, which essentially resets when a new domain is introduced.
What the documentation says
Official documentation from email service providers and industry bodies typically outlines the foundational technical steps required for a new email sending domain. This includes specific DNS configurations for authentication and best practices for domain usage, emphasizing the need for robust identity verification to ensure email delivery.
Key findings
- Authentication Setup: Setting up proper email authentication, including SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, is a fundamental requirement for any new sending domain. Mailchimp documentation provides examples of required records.
- DNS Records: Domain authentication often involves adding specific CNAME and TXT records to your domain's DNS records to verify your ownership and authorization.
- Sender Identity: Using a custom domain for email helps to verify your identity as an email sender and can significantly improve deliverability rates.
- Platform Guidance: Most ESPs provide detailed guides and steps for configuring or changing sending domains within their specific platforms.
- User Credentials: Consider the need to establish new user credentials and email addresses under the new domain, starting with primary accounts.
Key considerations
- DNS Accuracy: Ensure that all necessary DNS records for SPF, DKIM, and DMARC are precisely configured for the new domain. Our guide on DMARC, SPF, and DKIM can assist with this.
- ESP Documentation: Always consult your specific Email Service Provider's documentation for their recommended domain change procedures, as steps can vary.
- Subdomain Strategy: Evaluate if using a subdomain for marketing emails might be a better strategy to protect your main domain's reputation.
- Web Redirects: Implement 301 redirects for any web traffic from the old domain to the new one to ensure seamless user experience and preserve SEO value.
- Comprehensive Update: Plan for updating all existing email addresses and credentials across your organization to reflect the new domain.
Technical article
Documentation from Mailchimp states that email domain authentication requires adding specific CNAME and TXT records to your domain's DNS records for proper setup.
Technical article
Documentation from Kinsta explains that to create a professional custom email domain, the first step is to register a domain name, followed by securing premium web hosting with DNS support.
Related resources
14 resources
Related pages
What are the best practices for email domain authentication across corporate and marketing mail?
What are the best practices for switching to a new sending domain?
How to warm up a new domain for 6k active contacts when moving from a shared domain to a private domain?
When switching to a new subdomain for email, what warm-up process is required?
Should I use a subdomain or my main domain for marketing emails?
How does a domain change affect email deliverability and what steps should be taken to prevent issues like Gmail warnings?
What steps should I take to resolve deliverability issues after rebranding with a new domain and ESP?
A simple guide to DMARC, SPF, and DKIM
A practical guide to understanding your email domain reputation
How long does it take to recover domain reputation from Bad/Low to High
