Summary
The decision of whether to use a subdomain or a completely separate domain for prospecting outreach emails is a common dilemma for businesses concerned about their sender reputation. While both strategies aim to compartmentalize risk, the effectiveness and implications can vary based on sending volume, cadence, and the nature of the outreach.
Key findings
- Reputation isolation: Using a separate domain or a subdomain for cold outreach helps protect your primary domain's reputation from the negative impacts of recipient complaints or blocklistings. This is crucial for safeguarding your transactional and marketing emails.
- Recipient perception: Some mailbox providers (MBPs) may view cousin domains (domains similar to your primary but used for different purposes) with suspicion, requiring recipients to guess legitimacy. Subdomains, however, can inherit the age and initial trust of the main domain, as noted by Sopro.
- Volume and cadence: Low-volume, infrequent outreach to warm leads might not significantly impact a primary domain, but higher volumes or colder lists inherently carry greater risk.
- Mailbox provider variability: How domain reputation data rolls up (or doesn't) to the second-level domain (SLD) differs across various MBPs.
- Spam perception: Regardless of domain choice, unsolicited outreach is often perceived as spam, which can lead to high complaint rates and blocklistings (blacklistings).
Key considerations
- Separate domain for safety: For growing sales lists or any cold email activities, a separate domain is generally the safest approach to prevent adverse effects on your core brand reputation and primary email communications.
- Subdomain as a minimum: If a separate domain isn't feasible, using a dedicated subdomain (e.g., outreach.yourdomain.com) is the bare minimum to segment risk. Learn more about how subdomains affect reputation.
- Corporate vs. consumer filters: Outreach to corporate domains might behave differently than to consumer email providers, but even a single annoyed recipient can cause lasting blockages. Understand how email blocklists operate.
- Strategic vendor choice: Consider using a separate email sending vendor for outreach emails to further isolate any potential deliverability issues.
- Engagement levels: Ensure your opt-in email volume is high enough to 'obscure' any complaints from outreach emails if you use the same domain (which is not recommended).
What email marketers say
Email marketers often grapple with the practical implications of outreach emails on their brand's overall email deliverability. Their experiences highlight a strong inclination towards segregating different email streams to mitigate risks, though the degree of separation can vary based on perceived outreach aggressiveness and volume.
Key opinions
- Risk of main domain: There is a significant concern that using the same domain for both marketing and sales outreach could negatively impact the main domain's reputation.
- Separate domain preference: Many marketers lean towards using a completely separate domain for prospecting emails as the safest approach, especially with anticipated growth in sales lists, even if they aim to keep leads warm.
- Subdomain as a compromise: Some marketers find a subdomain to be an acceptable compromise for isolating risk, particularly for controlled, warm outreach campaigns. This is often seen as a minimal safeguard.
- Volume sensitivity: Small volumes of outreach (e.g., 80-100 emails per campaign) might be considered acceptable from the main domain, but larger scales necessitate greater separation. Learn more about improving deliverability with subdomains.
Key considerations
- Protecting primary brand: The paramount concern is to avoid any negative impact on the primary domain, which is essential for critical business communications.
- Scalability: As outreach efforts grow, the risk of using a shared domain increases, making early separation a proactive measure.
- Internal communication: It is important for internal teams, like sales, to understand the implications of their email practices on overall deliverability.
- Strategic decision: The choice between a subdomain and a separate domain should be a strategic decision based on the perceived risk tolerance and the nature of the outreach program. Consider the pros and cons of using the same domain.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks expresses concern that using the same domain for marketing and sales outreach might negatively impact reputation, questioning if a subdomain offers sufficient protection.
Marketer view
Marketer from Dripify advises that to protect your primary domain's reputation, establishing a separate domain for cold email outreach and redirecting emails from it to the main one is a recommended strategy.
What the experts say
Deliverability experts generally agree that aggressive or unsolicited outreach carries inherent risks to sender reputation. They advocate for stringent separation of email streams and emphasize that even with isolation, the fundamental principles of good sending practices and recipient engagement remain paramount.
Key opinions
- Avoid cousin domains: Domains that look similar to your main one but are used for high-risk sending can confuse recipients and negatively impact trust.
- Outreach as spam: Sales outreach is frequently categorized as spam by recipients, which can damage reputation and affect the deliverability of legitimate opt-in emails if sent from the same domain.
- Corporate vs. consumer impact: While sending to warm corporate leads might not directly affect consumer filters, some providers do share reputation data, and corporate recipients can block you permanently.
- Isolation is best: If a company insists on aggressive outreach, isolating those efforts onto a completely separate domain is the only reliable way to protect corporate and opt-in mail streams.
- Volume sensitivity: Low volumes and infrequent cadences for outreach might be acceptable, but this is merely a probability, not a guarantee. Higher volumes, especially from multiple senders, increase risk.
Key considerations
- Permanent damage risk: A single intensely annoyed recipient from a corporate domain can lead to your mail being undeliverable to that domain indefinitely, regardless of your overall volume.
- Beyond domain separation: Separating domains or subdomains is a risk mitigation tactic, but it does not make "spamming" (unsolicited outreach) safe. The fundamental issue of unwanted mail remains. Fixing emails going to spam requires a holistic approach.
- Vendor isolation: Consider isolating high-risk outreach to its own domain and possibly its own sending vendor to maximize protection for core email streams.
- Monitoring is key: Regardless of the domain strategy, continuous monitoring of your sender reputation and deliverability metrics is crucial to identify and address issues promptly. A practical guide to understanding email domain reputation can help.
Expert view
Deliverability expert from Email Geeks emphasizes that cold outreach is often viewed negatively by spam filters and could be perceived as unethical email use.
Expert view
Deliverability expert from SpamResource emphasizes that separating different email streams, especially high-risk outreach, onto unique subdomains helps prevent negative reputation spillover to your core domain.
What the documentation says
Official documentation and guides consistently advise against mixing different types of email traffic, particularly separating high-risk outreach from core business communications. The general consensus reinforces the importance of domain reputation and the strategic use of subdomains or entirely separate domains to maintain deliverability and trust.
Key findings
- Domain reputation protection: Many sources explicitly state that using a separate domain or subdomain for cold email is to prevent harm to your main domain's reputation. This is a foundational best practice.
- Subdomain benefits: Subdomains are recognized for inheriting some age and reputation from the main domain, which can be advantageous compared to entirely new, unknown domains. However, their own sending patterns will quickly establish a new reputation.
- Legitimacy signalling: Using a custom email domain, whether separate or a subdomain, is seen as increasing your legitimacy as a sender, which can improve open rates and overall deliverability.
- Experimentation safety: For activities like cold emailing that often involve experimentation and higher risk, documentation suggests using a separate subdomain to shield the primary domain's deliverability.
Key considerations
- Primary domain protection: The core recommendation is to protect the primary domain from activities that could generate complaints or lead to blocklistings (blacklistings). Learn what happens when your domain is blacklisted.
- Strategic implementation: Decide on a separate domain or subdomain based on the scale and risk profile of your outreach. This includes setting up proper authentication like DMARC, SPF, and DKIM.
- Consistent sender identity: Even with separate domains, ensure consistent branding and clear sender identification to maintain trust with recipients.
Technical article
Documentation from Dripify recommends setting up a separate domain for cold email to avoid harming your primary domain's reputation, suggesting emails from this domain can be redirected to the main one.
Technical article
Documentation from Sopro highlights that a subdomain benefits from inheriting the age and reputation of the main domain, a critical factor since many email providers view newer domains with suspicion.
Related resources
14 resources
Related pages
Will using a subdomain for different email types affect my primary domain's reputation?
Should I move promotional email campaigns to a dedicated subdomain?
Should I use a subdomain or my main domain for marketing emails?
What are the pros and cons of using the same domain or subdomain for both cold outreach and regular email sending?
Should I use subdomains for outbound email delivery to improve deliverability?
How email blacklists actually work: a simple guide
What happens when your domain is on an email blacklist?
Why your emails are going to spam in 2024 and how to fix it
A practical guide to understanding your email domain reputation
A simple guide to DMARC, SPF, and DKIM
