Summary
When transitioning to a new email sending domain while maintaining an already warmed IP address, the common assumption might be that no additional warm-up is required due to the established IP reputation. However, this is largely incorrect. While a warmed IP provides a stable foundation, mailbox providers like Gmail increasingly scrutinize domain reputation independently. Therefore, a strategic domain warm-up is indeed necessary to build trust and ensure optimal inbox placement for your new domain.
Key findings
- Domain reputation matters: Even with a warmed IP, a new domain starts with no history, requiring a warm-up to establish its own positive sending reputation with Internet Service Providers (ISPs).
- Gradual migration: A gradual increase in email volume from the new domain is essential, mirroring the principles of IP warming, though potentially less painstaking.
- Engagement signals: Initial sends should target your most engaged subscribers to generate positive interactions, which are crucial signals for ISPs.
- Monitoring metrics: Closely monitor engagement rates, bounce rates, and spam complaints. Adjust your sending volume based on these metrics to avoid reputation damage.
Key considerations
- ISP emphasis: Many major email providers, particularly Gmail (which accounts for a significant portion of many audiences), heavily rely on domain reputation for filtering and inbox placement decisions.
- Expedited process: While a full IP warm-up process isn't typically needed, the domain warm-up can still take weeks. It might be expedited compared to a cold IP and domain, but requires careful execution.
- Audience notification: Informing your audience about the domain change can help reduce confusion, minimize spam complaints, and ensure a smoother transition.
- Volume scaling: Begin with a very small volume (e.g., 200-500 messages) and gradually increase, potentially doubling daily or with each send, for at least a week. For more information, see Twilio SendGrid's email guide to IP warm up.
What email marketers say
Email marketers widely agree that changing a sending domain, even on a pre-warmed IP address, necessitates a strategic warm-up period. While the process may not be as extensive as a full IP warm-up, it is critical to build the new domain's reputation with various mailbox providers. They emphasize the importance of gradual volume increases, targeting engaged users, and vigilant monitoring of key performance indicators.
Key opinions
- Domain warm-up is essential: Regardless of IP status, a new domain needs warming because ISPs heavily consider domain reputation.
- Gradual ramp-up: Marketers recommend starting small and slowly increasing sending volume, often doubling daily for an initial period.
- Engagement is key: Prioritizing engaged subscribers for initial sends helps build a positive reputation quickly for the new domain.
- Monitor metrics: It is crucial to watch bounces, spam complaints, and unsubscribe rates. If these metrics rise, pause or slow down the ramp-up.
Key considerations
- Not as painstaking: While necessary, the domain warm-up on a warmed IP generally isn't as arduous as a complete IP warm-up from scratch.
- Audience size matters: For very large audiences (e.g., 700k), even a seemingly small start (e.g., 25-500 emails) is a cautious and effective approach.
- Pre-notification: Sending a message from the old domain to inform the audience about the upcoming brand and domain change can prevent confusion and reduce spam complaints.
- Pacing: Maintain engagement stats between the old and new domains. If the new domain's engagement lags, pause the ramp-up until it catches up. Learn more about domain warm-up strategy and duration.
Marketer view
Email Marketer from Email Geeks indicates that any shift involving the domain or IP combination must be executed gradually. They advise that while the domain changes on an already warmed IP, the warm-up generally won't be as painstaking as a full IP warm-up. They suggest a gradual migration of the sending domain.
Marketer view
Email Marketer from Email Geeks strongly agrees that domain warming is essential because many email providers now place significant trust in domain reputation for filtering and deliverability.
What the experts say
Deliverability experts universally advocate for domain warm-up when switching to a new domain, even if the underlying IP address is already warmed. They highlight that domain reputation is a distinct and increasingly vital factor for inbox placement. Experts provide nuanced advice on the process, emphasizing careful planning, coordination with ESPs, and proactive communication with the audience.
Key opinions
- Domain reputation is distinct: Experts confirm that domain warming is a necessity because mailbox providers increasingly focus on domain reputation independent of IP reputation.
- Ease into the new domain: While not as complex as IP warming, a gradual approach is still required to introduce the new domain to ISPs.
- Pre-warning recipients: Notifying your audience about upcoming brand and domain changes significantly reduces confusion and minimizes spam complaints, leading to smoother transitions.
- Strategic sending: Beginning sends to highly engaged segments of your audience helps establish a positive reputation quickly for the new domain.
Key considerations
- ESP coordination: Coordinate with your Email Service Provider's (ESP) deliverability team, especially for a full Sender Authentication Package (SAP) domain change, to ensure both old and new domains can be active simultaneously.
- Return-path alignment: Ensure that the return-path (SPF) domain aligns with the 'from' domain for both old and new sending domains. This is critical for authentication and reputation. For more details, see our guide on DMARC, SPF, and DKIM.
- Metrics monitoring: Vigilantly monitor bounce rates (aim below 2%), and spam complaints (ideally at or below 0.1%). Skyrocketing unsubscribe rates could signal recipient confusion about the change.
- Long-term reputation: A smooth domain transition contributes to long-term positive sender reputation, preventing potential deliverability issues in the future. Check our article on why your emails fail for more.
Expert view
Deliverability Expert from Email Geeks confirms that domain warming is indeed a current requirement. They advise that while it does not need to be as intricate as an IP warming process, it is still prudent to gradually introduce the new domain to ensure optimal performance.
Expert view
Deliverability Expert from Spam Resource highlights the importance of matching domain reputation with IP reputation, advising senders to treat new domains similarly to new IP addresses for deliverability.
What the documentation says
Official documentation from leading email service providers and industry guides consistently emphasizes that domain reputation is a critical factor for email deliverability, often as important as IP reputation. They advise that even if you're using a pre-warmed IP, a new domain needs a dedicated warm-up period to establish its own trustworthiness with mailbox providers. This process involves gradually increasing sending volume to engaged recipients and meticulously monitoring performance metrics.
Key findings
- Independent reputation: Domain reputation is tracked separately from IP reputation by mailbox providers, making domain warm-up necessary regardless of the IP's history.
- Trust building: A new domain requires a warm-up phase to prove its legitimacy and build trust with ISPs, demonstrating consistent, positive sending behavior.
- Engagement signals: Documentation recommends starting with engaged recipients to generate positive interactions, which are crucial signals for the new domain's reputation.
- Gradual ramp-up: The process involves slowly increasing email volume over time, a method commonly referred to in guides to IP and domain warming.
Key considerations
- ISPs' focus: Mailbox providers are increasingly using domain reputation as a primary indicator for filtering, making domain warm-up a non-negotiable step for optimal inbox placement.
- Monitoring: Continuous monitoring of deliverability metrics (e.g., open rates, click-through rates, bounce rates, spam complaints) is essential to guide the warm-up process and adjust sending volumes.
- Consistency: Consistent sending patterns and content quality during the warm-up period help solidify the new domain's positive reputation.
- Proactive communication: Some documentation suggests informing subscribers about domain changes to minimize confusion and maintain engagement. You might want to consider how to warm up a new sending domain on an existing warmed IP address.
Technical article
Amazon Web Services documentation states that even when migrating to an already warmed IP, a new domain requires its own warm-up to build sender reputation with mailbox providers, as reputation is tied to both IP and domain independently.
Technical article
The AWS guide emphasizes that domain warming is crucial for establishing trust, especially with major ISPs like Gmail, which heavily weigh domain reputation in their filtering decisions for email placement.
Related resources
11 resources
Related pages
How do you warm up a new sending domain on an existing warmed IP address?
What is the best strategy and duration for warming up a domain?
When switching to a new subdomain for email, what warm-up process is required?
How to warm up a new domain for 6k active contacts when moving from a shared domain to a private domain?
What are the best practices for warming up new email domains with Yahoo and Microsoft?
What is a good strategy for aggressively warming a new email domain?
Why Your Emails Are Going to Spam in 2024 and How to Fix It
A practical guide to understanding your email domain reputation
Email Deliverability Issues: Getting Your Messages to the Inbox in 2025
A simple guide to DMARC, SPF, and DKIM
