How do I avoid SURBL CT blacklisting for a 100% opt-in list?
Matthew Whittaker
Co-founder & CTO, Suped
Published 5 Aug 2025
Updated 17 Aug 2025
6 min read
Getting listed on any email blacklist can be frustrating, but finding your supposedly 100% opt-in list on the SURBL CT (Click Tracker) blocklist can be particularly confusing. SURBL CT specifically targets domains used for tracking clicks in emails, and it's known for having a lower threshold for listings, meaning even seemingly good senders can get caught.
The key here is understanding that opt-in doesn't always equal engaged or valid. This blocklist (or blacklist) often catches domains associated with stale lists or poor list management practices, even if initial consent was given. We'll explore why this happens and what practical steps you can take to avoid this common pitfall.
Understanding how these blacklists operate is the first step toward preventing future issues. If you're concerned about how SURBL impacts email deliverability, this guide will provide actionable advice.
SURBL is a real-time blacklist (RBL) that specifically lists domains found in spam messages, rather than IP addresses. Its various lists target different types of problematic domains, and the CT list, in particular, focuses on click tracking domains. While your subscribers may have opted in, if the domain used for click tracking in your emails is associated with patterns of spam or low engagement, it can lead to a SURBL CT listing.
One common reason for listings, even with an opt-in list, is spam traps. These are email addresses specifically designed to identify spammers. Even if a spam trap address was once a legitimate email address that opted in, if it has become dormant or converted into a trap, sending to it can trigger a blacklist. SURBL's lists, including CT, are documented on the official SURBL website, which clarifies their purpose: listing domains in emails.
Another factor is the overall quality and engagement of your list. A 100% opt-in list can still degrade over time if recipients stop engaging with your emails or if email addresses become invalid. This leads to low engagement, high bounces, and eventually, a higher likelihood of hitting spam traps or being reported by recipients who no longer want your mail, even if they initially opted in.
This highlights the importance of not just acquiring opt-in consent, but continuously nurturing that consent through relevant content and regular list hygiene. For more on what happens when your domain is on an email blacklist, read our guide on the topic.
Proactive prevention strategies
Preventing a SURBL CT blacklist listing, especially with an opt-in list, hinges on proactive management and understanding how email service providers (ESPs) and blacklists view sender behavior. It's not just about initial consent, but ongoing list health and engagement. Regular monitoring for listings, using a blocklist checker, is also a good practice.
To avoid being caught, even with an opt-in list, you need to maintain impeccable list hygiene. This means actively removing unengaged subscribers and ensuring your list doesn't contain spam traps or invalid addresses. Double opt-in is a foundational step, but ongoing validation and segmentation are equally crucial. Neglecting these can lead to listings, as discussed in our article about managing Wi-Fi generated email lists.
Preventative measures
Implement double opt-in: Always use a double opt-in process to confirm subscriber intent and reduce the chance of invalid or spam trap addresses entering your list. This adds an extra layer of verification.
Regularly clean your lists: Remove unengaged subscribers (those who haven't opened or clicked in a long time, say, 6-12 months). This helps avoid dormant accounts turning into spam traps.
Monitor engagement metrics: Pay attention to your click-through rates and open rates (where reliable). Low engagement signals may indicate a problem with list quality or content relevance.
Authenticate your emails: Ensure your emails are properly authenticated with SPF, DKIM, and DMARC. While SURBL focuses on domains, strong authentication helps maintain overall sender reputation. You can also monitor your DMARC reports.
Handling a SURBL CT listing
Identifying the source of a SURBL CT blacklist listing can be challenging, especially when your internal records show 100% opt-in. The issue might stem from how your click-tracking domains are perceived, rather than direct spamming. The SURBL blacklist removal guide suggests checking for existing listings first.
If you find your domain listed, it's crucial to immediately review your list acquisition methods and email sending patterns. Even if the initial opt-in was legitimate, a lack of consistent engagement or the presence of very old, inactive subscribers can lead to problems. Consider re-engagement campaigns or sunsetting inactive segments of your list.
SURBL has a lower tolerance for certain signals, so quick action is often necessary. Understanding how to contact SURBL and their delisting policies is important, though prevention is always preferred.
Engagement strategies
Segment your audience: Send targeted content to different segments based on their interests and engagement levels. This can improve relevance and reduce complaints.
Implement re-engagement campaigns: For subscribers who haven't engaged in a while, send a specific re-engagement campaign. If they don't respond, consider removing them from your active mailing list to protect your sender reputation.
Provide easy unsubscribe options: Make it simple for recipients to unsubscribe. This reduces the likelihood of them marking your emails as spam, which negatively impacts your reputation.
Monitor complaint rates: Keep an eye on complaint rates through Google Postmaster Tools and other postmaster tools. High complaint rates, even from an opt-in list, signal problems.
Maintaining list health and engagement
Healthy list
A healthy list is actively engaged, with recent interactions like clicks or opens (where measurable). Subscribers regularly open your emails and click your links. This demonstrates continued interest and reduces the risk of hitting spam traps. The focus is on quality over quantity, even for an opt-in list.
High engagement: Consistent opens and clicks indicate active subscribers.
Recent activity: Subscribers have interacted with your emails within the last 3-6 months.
Clean data: No known invalid addresses or spam traps are present.
Stale list
A stale list, even if 100% opt-in, is one where subscribers have not engaged in a long time. These addresses are more likely to have become dormant, abandoned, or converted into spam traps. Sending to stale lists can severely damage your sender reputation and lead to listings on blocklists (blacklists) like SURBL CT, as it signals poor list management.
Low engagement: Infrequent or no opens and clicks, despite previous opt-in.
Dormant accounts: Subscribers haven't opened or clicked in 12 months or more.
Increased bounce rates:Microsoft, Yahoo, or Gmail begin to reject mail to these addresses.
The distinction between a healthy, engaged opt-in list and a stale one is critical. Even with initial consent, a lack of continued interaction diminishes the value of the opt-in. This is why filtering out inactive subscribers is a vital step in preventing your emails from going to spam or getting listed on blocklists.
Remember, a 100% opt-in list is a great start, but it's not a set-and-forget solution. Ongoing list management, re-engagement efforts, and regular pruning of disengaged subscribers are necessary to maintain strong email deliverability and avoid unwanted listings. This proactive approach ensures your mailing practices align with the expectations of blocklists like SURBL CT, which prioritize active engagement and valid subscriber bases.
Views from the trenches
Best practices
Maintain a rigorous double opt-in process for all new subscribers to confirm their intent.
Regularly segment your email list and identify unengaged subscribers for re-engagement campaigns or removal.
Monitor your complaint rates and bounce rates closely through ESP analytics and postmaster tools.
Ensure all your email authentication records (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) are correctly configured and valid.
Common pitfalls
Failing to regularly clean your email list, allowing old, unengaged, or invalid addresses to remain.
Sending emails to subscribers who haven't engaged (clicked) in 12 months or more, increasing spam trap risk.
Ignoring complaint feedback loops, leading to continued sending to recipients who marked mail as spam.
Relying solely on
Expert tips
If your list is hitting reputable spam traps despite being opt-in, it's often a sign of list staleness.
SURBL CT has a lower listing threshold and can catch even average senders without other obvious issues.
Focus on subscribers who have clicked within the last year, especially with Apple Mail Privacy Protection limiting open data.
SURBL uses diverse methods to identify problematic domains, so a holistic approach to list hygiene is essential.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks says that if a 100% opt-in list is hitting traps on a reputable RBL, it's often due to the list being stale. They advised interrogating the specifics of the mail program when this occurs, suggesting the subscribers may have opted in ages ago but haven't been successfully mailed in 12 months.
2024-03-13 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks says that many RBLs do not accept outside sources for listings, requiring trust. They noted that SURBL employs numerous methods for identifying problematic domains and accounts, highlighting its comprehensive approach to detection.
2024-03-13 - Email Geeks
Key takeaways for continued success
Avoiding SURBL CT blocklisting, even with a 100% opt-in list, requires a shift in focus from mere consent to ongoing engagement and rigorous list hygiene. While gaining initial consent is vital, it's only the first step in a long-term strategy for maintaining optimal email deliverability. The dynamic nature of blocklists (or blacklists) means that static lists, even if legitimately acquired, can become problematic over time.
By proactively removing unengaged subscribers, implementing re-engagement campaigns, and ensuring strong email authentication, you can significantly reduce the risk of your click-tracking domains appearing on blacklists like SURBL CT. This continuous effort helps protect your sender reputation and ensures your emails reach the inbox effectively.
Ultimately, the goal is to send desired emails to an active and responsive audience. Regular vigilance and adaptive list management are your best defenses against unwelcome blocklist entries and are crucial for boosting your email deliverability rates.
Spamhaus
0Spam
Cisco
NoSolicitado
URIBL
abuse.ro
ALPHANET
Anonmails
Ascams
BLOCKEDSERVERS
Calivent Networks
EFnet
JustSpam
Kempt.net
NordSpam
RV-SOFT Technology
Scientific Spam
Spamikaze
SpamRATS
SPFBL
Suomispam
System 5 Hosting
Team Cymru
Validity
www.blocklist.de Fail2Ban-Reporting Service
ZapBL
2stepback.dk
Fayntic Services
ORB UK
technoirc.org
TechTheft
Microsoft, Yahoo, or 
Gmail begin to reject mail to these addresses.
