Summary
When facing the prospect of sending emails to a large contact list, such as 100,000 contacts, a common question arises: is a warming-up process necessary? The general consensus among deliverability experts and marketers is nuanced. While email warm-up is crucial for new sending infrastructure (like a new IP or domain), its necessity for an existing contact list largely depends on the list's quality, engagement, and recency. Sending to an unengaged or old list without proper precautions can severely harm your sender reputation, regardless of the sender's established infrastructure. Conversely, a well-maintained, consent-based, and regularly engaged list may not require a traditional list warm-up, although a gradual ramp-up is still advisable for any significant volume increase.
Key findings
- IP/domain warm-up is primary: The concept of warm-up primarily applies to building a sender reputation for new IPs or domains, not typically for existing, engaged contact lists. This distinction is crucial for understanding deliverability strategies.
- List quality is paramount: The main risk with a large list, regardless of its size, stems from its quality. Old, unengaged, or non-permissioned lists pose a significant threat to your sender reputation due to high bounces, spam complaints, and spam traps.
- Gradual ramp-up for volume: Even with an established sender reputation, a sudden, massive increase in email volume (like 100k contacts) can trigger ISP spam filters. A controlled, gradual increase is always a safer approach.
- Engagement dictates strategy: If your 100k contacts are highly engaged and receive emails regularly, a specific warm-up for the list itself might be less critical than if it's an old, dormant, or cold list.
Key considerations
- Assess list source and age: Before sending, analyze how the 100k contacts were acquired and their last engagement. Old or purchased lists are high-risk and may require re-engagement campaigns or aggressive cleaning.
- Monitor initial sends closely: Start with a small segment of your most engaged contacts (e.g., 1,000 to 10,000). Monitor deliverability metrics like bounce rates, spam complaints, and open rates. Be prepared to pause or adjust if issues arise.
- Leverage ESP auto-warm-up: If using a platform like HubSpot with dedicated IPs, understand their auto-warm-up features, which are designed to build IP reputation. Even with these, manual caution on list selection is prudent for very large sends.
- Focus on deliverability fundamentals: Ensure your email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) is correctly configured and that your content is relevant and valuable to avoid spam filtering. Remember, emails landing in the promotions tab are not necessarily a deliverability failure if they are, in fact, promotional.
What email marketers say
Email marketers often approach large sends with a blend of caution and practicality. While warming up a dedicated IP or a new domain is a widely accepted practice, the necessity of warming up an email list of 100,000 contacts depends heavily on its origin and activity. Marketers emphasize that lists composed of engaged, consent-based subscribers who receive frequent communication are less likely to require a specific warm-up. Conversely, old, unengaged, or purchased lists are seen as significant risks, warranting careful segmentation and a cautious sending approach to protect sender reputation.
Key opinions
- Context is key for warm-up: The need for a list warm-up is often tied to underlying issues like a new IP/domain, or old, risky, and unknown data within the list itself.
- Gradual sending is prudent: Regardless of other factors, starting with smaller sends and gradually increasing volume for a large contact list is a recommended strategy to gauge recipient reaction and mitigate risks.
- Cold lists require warming: For cold email lists, a warm-up process is considered essential to build sender reputation and ensure email effectiveness.
- Promotions tab is not an issue: If the email content is promotional, landing in the promotions tab is not a sign of a broken deliverability strategy.
- Established ESPs have features: ESPs like HubSpot offer auto-warm-up features for dedicated IPs, which can help manage volume ramp-up.
Key considerations
- Evaluate list consent and recency: Confirm that your 100k contacts are consent-based and have been mailed with some frequency. If not, consider a list warm-up or re-engagement strategy.
- Segment and test initially: For new or very large sends, split testing with smaller segments (e.g., 1k or 10k) first allows you to assess performance and identify potential issues before a full deployment.
- Be cautious with volume jumps: A significant jump in volume, even with auto-warm-up, requires caution. It's important to have a strategy to manage potential deliverability issues if things go wrong.
- Understand risks of unengaged lists: Sending to purchased or old lists carries higher costs than benefits due to the risk of damaging sender reputation and getting blocklisted.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks recommends a phased approach to sending, suggesting an initial send to 1,000 contacts, then to 10,000, to assess recipient reaction before a full list deployment. This strategy helps to identify potential issues like high complaints or low engagement early on.
Marketer view
Marketer from Clickback.com states that while cold email lists can be powerful marketing tools, their effectiveness hinges on a proper warm-up process. Without it, even good cold lists may underperform.
What the experts say
Deliverability experts largely agree that the concept of email warm-up is foundational for building or maintaining sender reputation, particularly for new or significantly altered sending patterns. They emphasize that while IP and domain warm-up are critical, the need to warm up a list of 100,000 contacts depends less on its size and more on its engagement history and how it was acquired. Sending to unengaged or questionable lists, even with a warmed IP, is a high-risk endeavor that can lead to severe deliverability issues, including blacklisting.
Key opinions
- Warm-up for sender reputation: The primary goal of warming up is to establish trust with ISPs by demonstrating consistent, positive sending behavior.
- List warm-up vs. infrastructure warm-up: List warm-up is generally not needed for active, permission-based lists, but is crucial for new sending infrastructure.
- Risks of old/unengaged lists: Sending to an old or unengaged list without prior re-engagement can lead to high bounces, spam complaints, and hitting spam traps.
- Engagement as a warm-up proxy: Starting sends with highly engaged segments can simulate a warm-up by generating positive signals to ISPs.
- Consistency is vital: Consistent sending frequency to an engaged audience is more important for maintaining good sender reputation than large, infrequent bursts.
Key considerations
- Gradual ramp-up is key: When migrating to new IPs or ESPs, a gradual increase in sending volume is essential for ISPs to build trust in your sending patterns.
- Avoid sending to old, uncleaned lists: Such lists are prone to containing spam traps and invalid addresses, which can severely damage sender reputation and lead to blocklisting.
- Monitor complaint rates: High complaint rates on initial sends are an immediate red flag for ISPs and can lead to immediate filtering or blacklisting. Close monitoring is crucial.
- Assess engagement: The true quality of a list is measured by its engagement. A lack of recent engagement strongly suggests a need for re-engagement efforts or list hygiene before sending large volumes.
- Sudden volume increases are scrutinized: Any sudden, significant increase in sending volume from a previously low-volume sender will attract immediate scrutiny from ISPs, potentially leading to deliverability issues.
Expert view
Deliverability Expert from Email Geeks states that the primary purpose of warming up is to establish or re-establish a positive sender reputation with internet service providers (ISPs). This foundational step ensures that emails are consistently delivered to the inbox.
Expert view
Deliverability Expert from SpamResource.com recommends that when migrating ESPs or IPs, a gradual ramp-up of sending volume helps ISPs learn and trust your sending patterns. This prevents flagging your email as suspicious due to sudden volume changes.
What the documentation says
Official documentation and research on email deliverability consistently highlight the importance of reputation and a gradual approach to sending. While the term warm-up is often associated with new IPs or domains, the underlying principles apply to any significant change in sending volume or list quality. ISPs and email service providers (ESPs) monitor sending patterns closely, and sudden, large bursts of email can negatively impact sender reputation, leading to filtering or blocklisting. Therefore, a strategic ramp-up, combined with diligent list hygiene and content relevance, is universally recommended.
Key findings
- Gradual volume increase: Building a positive sender reputation requires a consistent and gradual increase in sending volume, allowing ISPs to learn and trust your sending patterns over time.
- Sender reputation preservation: A strategic warm-up is crucial to prevent damage to your sender reputation, which can otherwise lead to low open rates, increased spam filtering, and delivery failures.
- IP/domain warm-up for large campaigns: Warming up IP addresses and domains is a strategic prerequisite for large-scale marketing email campaigns to ensure positive deliverability outcomes.
- Sudden spikes are red flags: ISPs view sudden spikes in email volume, especially to unengaged or unknown recipients, as indicators of potential spamming activity.
- Authentication is foundational: Proper email authentication, including SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, forms the technical backbone of deliverability and complements any volume warm-up strategy.
Key considerations
- Prioritize audience engagement: Focusing on delivering valuable content to engaged recipients is more impactful for inbox placement than simply trying to avoid the promotions tab.
- Adhere to sending limits: New mailboxes are often subject to daily sending limits, necessitating a warm-up period of several weeks before attempting high-volume sends.
- Implement a warm-up schedule: For significant volume increases, a structured warm-up plan that gradually escalates daily sending volume is recommended to build trust with ISPs.
- Clean and segment your list: Regardless of warm-up, maintaining a clean and segmented list, sending to the most engaged first, helps mitigate risks and maximize positive signals.
Technical article
Documentation from Validity.com suggests that focusing on audience engagement and the quality of your content is more impactful for achieving inbox placement than solely obsessing over whether emails land in the promotions tab. The promotions tab is a categorization, not necessarily a penalty.
Technical article
Documentation from Clickback.com outlines that a cold email list warm-up involves a methodical, gradual sending approach. This process aims to build sender reputation and foster trust with both recipients and internet service providers (ISPs).
Related resources
11 resources
Related pages
How do you warm up a new email sender address?
How to consolidate email sending platforms and warm up a new IP for improved deliverability?
How to send to a large, unengaged email list with no existing reputation?
How to warm up an old email list that hasn't been used in a while?
How to manage email deliverability for large sends without sufficient IP warmup?
Why Your Emails Are Going to Spam in 2024 and How to Fix It
How email blacklists actually work: a simple guide
A simple guide to DMARC, SPF, and DKIM
Email Deliverability Issues: Getting Your Messages to the Inbox in 2025
